Well, you present very interesting arguments. It's a typical problem that we have in cities that are trying to avoid urban sprawl, protect free land; and, at the same time, promote economic development. It's a classic controversy.
We are certainly not against development, and we have never taken that position as a blanket position, never.
Thank you very much for your testimony. Is there anyone here from the Law Department to clarify the issue on the description of the property so that the record's clear. There was a question raised by Mr. Plaxton relative to 61 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980780 the description of the property as southeasterly corner of 21st Street and Hamilton Street. His contention is that it's not the southeasterly but the southwesterly corner, and that that is a fatal flaw or a serious flaw in the legislation. Could you please identify yourself for the record and respond.
Good afternoon. My name is Henry Schwartz. I'm the Divisional Deputy City Solicitor for Real Estate and Economic Development. It was brought to my attention that there is a mistake in the title to the bill. It is, in fact, the southwesterly corner, and not the southeasterly corner. However, the intent of the charter in the short title is to provide notice that there is a matter pending before Council. It is the corner of 21st and Hamilton, so it was posted and it was advertised so that anybody with an interest would realize that it was the corner of 21st and Hamilton. The substance of the bill, which is the text of the bill, is correct, and so it would be my opinion that it is not a fatal flaw because 62 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980780 there was adequate notice to the surrounding area that the bill would be concerning 21st and Hamilton, but the substance of the bill is correct, as far as legal position.
Respectfully, I would have to disagree. I believe that the purpose of titles and the advertising is to give people notice. Conceivably, people might have a different view if it's on the southeast or in the southwest. It would seem to me that it would be in everybody's interest that whatever action Council takes, that it be immune from attack. The feelings on both sides seem to be very strong, and under those circumstances, I would clearly say I believe it quite dangerous to enact a bill, if that's what Council would do, in its in its present form. There's no serious lost time at all, but it may save a lot of time in the future. So it would be my feeling that this is a fatal flaw in the bill if, in fact, the land is on the southwest and not the southeast side. Thank you very much. 63 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980780
Good morning. Thank you for the opportunity. I think I'm inclined to agree with you, Mr. Schwartz, that this is, at worst, a (unintelligible) error. In every other respect, is the description of the same accurate in this bill.
Containing frontage along 21st Street approximately 298 feet; and along Hamilton Street, approximately 320 feet. Is that correct?
Okay. So if you looked at the entire paragraph below the term and ordinance, every word in it is correct except the term "southeasterly," which should have read "southwesterly."
Mr. Chairman, I think it is a stretch to say that (unintelligible) 64 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980780 error is such a fatal flaw. Now, I understand that it is our intention to hold bill over, and in that period, I think we should correct it, but I think the record should be clear that this is a fatal flaw.
The short title cannot be amended without republishing it; as compared to the bill, which can be amended as part of the legislative process.
Well, I mean we have two lawyers here -- three lawyers here that are expressing two different opinions. And as long as -- what I think Councilmember Cohen did was bring the issue to the fore so that you can make whatever decision you think is appropriate in this regard. Councilmember Clark agrees with you and your position, so to be forewarned is to be forearmed, I would say. 65 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980780
And I don't disagree that we should hold it. And I think, in that intervening period, it should be corrected. But just for the record, I think that is a stretch to say the (unintelligible) error arises to the level of a fatal flaw.
Thank you very much. Thank you very much for your testimony. Is there anyone else here to testify on this bill? (No response.)
As was previously stated by Councilmember Clark, this bill will be held to a date into the future, and all parties will be notified, and we thank you for coming in with your testimony. Bill No. 980750 was originally heard on November 17th but over-advertised for November 17th and for December 1st. So in an effort to accommodate anyone who like to testify based on the December 1, notification, Bill No. 980750 is an ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code relating to zoning and planning by amending 66 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980750 Section 14-1612, entitled "South Street/Head House Square Special Services District Controls," under certain terms and conditions. If there was testimony given on the 17th, there is no need for additional testimony, but I'd like to ask anyone in the room who had not testified on the 17th but is here because of the advertisement for December 1st, if they would like to testify. (No response.)
Seeing no one, we will continue on. Bill No. 980748, an ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zone designations of certain areas of land located in the 26th Ward and within an area bounded by 20th Street, Pattison Avenue, Penrose Avenue, and the Walt Whitman Bridge approach from partly Class "R-10" Residential, partly Class "C-7" Commercial, partly Class "L-5" Limited Industrial, and partly Class "R-9A" to partly Class "R-10" Residential, partly Class "C-7" Commercial, partly Class "L-5" Limited Industrial, and partly Class "R-9A" Residential. 67 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 Please identify yourself for the record and proceed.
Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Richard Lombardo, Chief of Project Planning, Planning Commissioner, here today to speak on behalf of this bill. Although this bill talks about 2.35 acres of land to be rezoned from various classifications, what we're really talking about here is, back in 1995, Bill No. 1240, the City Council approved the rezoning of land from "L-5" industrial to "R-9A" residential to permit a residential subdivision to go ahead in the Packer Park neighborhood of South Philadelphia. Basically, it proposed to take what was various limited industrial uses -- mostly trucking-related -- and to put in new streets and to build new single-family row houses. Subsequent to the passage of that bill 22 and the beginning of construction, the party interested had acquired additional land. And what this bill basically does is redraw that boundary of the zoning to conform to the additional land 68 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 that was acquired by the developer to allow for the -- basically for this to be developed in accordance with the same plan that's been around since 1995 and has been approved by the Planning Commission on several occasions and City Council, on several occasions, in terms of streets, bills, and utility bills and a previous zoning bill and by the Packer Park community. When this is completed -- if this bill 11 is passed, the developer will build 79 attached single-family sales housing, market-rate housing, along a series of new city streets, in accordance with the zoning and subdivision regulations of the City of Philadelphia. For the record, the Planning Commission, in its meeting of October 21, 1998, recommends approval of Bill 980748. Also, the Planning Commission, in various meetings, has approved the streets, bills, and subdivision plans for this development. Are there any questions?
Any questions for these witnesses? Councilmember Verna. 69 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748
I did not, but I believe there have been -- I guess one of our South Philadelphia planners may have attended. I personally was not there. But we have had this before the commission a number of times. We've always been accompanied by letters or comments from Packer Park in support of this. I know I've talked over the phone over the years to individual members of the Packer Park leadership, asking questions about when these bills are going to be passed or when this project was going to move forward.
Thank you very much. Any other questions? (No further questions.)
Would you like to testify? Members of the community? No, yes? (Carl Primavera comes forward.)
Carl Primavera, P-R-I-M-A-V-E-R-A. I'm here representing First Anthony Residential Capital Corporation, Mr. George David, Sr., behind me. They are the anticipated developers for the project. And also with us is Barbara Capozzi, from the Packer Park Civic Association, who has been working very closely with the with the developer to make sure that this proposed development meets the community's needs. We're really here to answer any specific questions and just to confirm that we have been working with the community.
Mr. Primavera, could you please give us, for the record, a description of the developed and what's proposed.
Sorry, this is Bill 23 -- for the committee's sake, this is Bill No. 24 980748.
Yes. As a matter of fact, with me is George David, Sr., and what I will have him do is just describe the development plan as he's devised it and as approved preliminarily by the Planning Commission.
My name is George David, Sr., and I'm the primary stockholder and President of First Anthony Residential Capital Corp.
What we propose to do here in stages is develop 79 row-house configuration homes in modules of or homes, without a break. They will be 3- and 4-bedroom town house configurations. We intend to start the development along the existing street. And then as it progresses to build a new street, a loop street back in to accommodate the balance of the property.
And that street is up before Council next week, I believe, for a street 72 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 ordinance. And could you tell us a little bit about who will be the anticipated residents and what the prices will be?
Well, our sales agent will be Barbara Capozzi's real estate agency, who has done a great deal of preliminary work in offering this property and describing it to the community. And so we really anticipate that the vast majority of the houses will be bought by people from the existing neighborhood or people who formerly were from that neighborhood.
Are these homes -- could you describe these homes. Are they singles, twins, or row houses?
And this would be similar, I guess, to what the existing Packer Park configuration is now?
And my understanding is that the great desire or demand for property in Packer Park would, hopefully, maybe keep some of our younger couples in Philadelphia who may want to move to Washington Township and maybe thing about staying in South Philadelphia, in Packer Park.
Yes, the general price range would be from 175 to about 185 or 190 thousand dollars.
We're now at a point where the weather will be what will be the determining factor. We would be ready in every respect by 74 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 about January 15th.
Well, if our absorption rate projections are correct, it would be about a two-and-a-half-year project to build out.
And I would like Miss Capozzi to come up and state for the record what the position of the Packer Park Civic Association is regarding this bill.
Barbara, could you please identify yourself for the record.
Okay, Barbara Capozzi, C-A-P-O-Z-Z-I. 75 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748
I'm currently the President of the Packer Park Civic Association. And from the beginning, this developer has sought our advice and taken our suggestion when we asked for changes in the home, different design changes, things that we knew would be comparable to our neighborhood. So from the beginning, they have been most willing. And at our request -- this bill was at our request to make this development the same R-9A zoning as Packer Park, to eliminate any duplexes or triplexes. That was at our request. At our request, Councilwoman Verna introduced this bill, so we're very happy about it. Right now, there's a dirty trucking company there, and it could be only -- we know it will be a big improvement.
Miss Capozzi, did I understand one of the other witnesses to say that you were doing the sales of it? 76 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748
Yes. I own the property right next door also, so I mean I have multiple interests in seeing this --
My interest in the question is that you are not a disinterested citizen, resident. Are there other residents who do not have a financial interest in the success of the project who would be willing to come forward and say they agree with you, that this is a good thing to do?
Well, we have people 15 on our board. The developers met with our board 16 three times, and it's been unanimous. There's 17 nothing not to like in having new homes in your 18 neighborhood, especially when it's a trucking company now.
Well, I'm in no 21 position to argue that point, I only raise the point that you are not a disinterested party. Your being the head of the civic association is somewhat in conflict with your being the sales agent for the new houses. 77 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 Having said that, that does not mean that you are not a wonderful, wise, and good person. However, you would have to see that there is some confluence of interest, if not conflict. "Confluence" is the term that I've used here.
Let me ask you another question, and we will just that statement hang out there. Are the houses going to be cul-de-sac? What is the configuration of the land use?
There's homes on 20th 15 Street, and then there's one break in that, and it 16 winds around to a very quite cul-de-sac where there's more homes.
From the very beginning, even at our general meetings, I have made my multiple positions known to everybody, and I have heard no opposition. I will be happy to get a 78 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 letter from the rest, signed individually by the rest of the board or whatever you would feel comfortable with.
The point that I have made has been made. If you want to send a letter, we will happily receive it.
However, even when you send the letter, wearing one of your other hats, that does not take away the confluence of interests.
Excuse me, if I may something. I believe that there's been so much interest generated for this particular proposal. How many people do you have on the list who have expressed a desire to purchase one of these properties?
As of yesterday, we have 79 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 232 people on a -- I don't want to say "a waiting list," but an interest list, who have received a brochure, who have seen the home and who know the prices. So once we get these preliminary approvals, we'll bring the people in, you know, and see how many of those 232 people will actually buy a home. But the interest is very high. And I have -- my very, very first buyer is somebody moving back from New Jersey, which I'm very happy to report, and that's a story that we all want to tell.
Thank you. In great respect for Councilwoman Clark's concern over confluence, I just want to say for the record that Miss Capozzi, in addition to their civic functions and volunteerism, represents something that's unique in South Philadelphia and in Philadelphia, and that is a real estate agent who lives in her neighborhood. We have real estate agents by and large in South Philadelphia who have decided that greener pastures may be better in South Jersey and 80 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 Delaware and Montgomery Counties. So I am confident, as a South Philadelphia resident and as someone who has known Barbara and her family for a long time, that their major commitment is making the neighborhood work because they have a stake in it because they live there and are not simply selling people property while they go home to their cul-de-sac in Montgomery County and don't care what the quality of the residents are. And I mean this respectfully, and I do understand Councilwoman Clark's raising the confluence issue, but I just want to say for the record that we're glad you're living with us.
Thank you. Would anyone else like to testify on this bill? (No response.)
The next bill is No. 980749, which an ordinance approving the plan, estimated costs, and proposed method of charges of 81 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980748 the City Avenue Special Services District for and concerning business improvements and administrative services to portions of the City Avenue area of the City of Philadelphia and Township of Lower Merion.
980749. Is there anyone here to testify on this bill, Councilmember? Could those interested parties -- this is City Avenue.
Mr. Chairman, I think my chief staff has talked to John O'Connor in your office. That bill has already been done. That's one of those double-advertising.
Since it was already done, is there anyone else here to testify on this bill advertised for December 1st? (No response.)
Seeing none, we will move again. Bill No. 980761, an ordinance amending 82 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980749 Section 14-1807 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Appeals to the Courts," to provide for the re-posting of the notice of a zoning hearing when the Court of Common Pleas remands to the Zoning Board of Adjustment for a full and complete record.
Good morning, Mr. Chairman and members of the committee. My name is Richard Lombardo, from the Planning Commission, here testify on Bill No. 980761. This bill amends the administrative section of the zoning code deal with the Zoning Board under the section of "Appeals to Courts" by requiring that when a case is remanded back to the Zoning Board for additional testimony by the courts on the case of an appeal of a Zoning Board decision, that the property be re-posted so as to provide notice to the neighbors of the additional testimony being taken before the Zoning Board of adjustment. Basically, the way the posting requirements are is that any requirements for public notice by the Zoning Board requires an ordinance of City Council to require that public 83 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980761 notice. Since there is no requirement today for expanded testimony on something that's already been heard by the Board, if you're an interested neighbor and from some reason you couldn't make the first hearing and therefore didn't put notice in, you would not be notified of the new hearing. This would assure that everyone that lives near a property would be renotified. As a matter of policy, the Planning Commission has always supported the concept of adequate public notice in the posting of public property, so we would support the enactment of this bill.
We just had a criticism that it was a little tiny notice on a low post that was inside a fence that said "No 22 Trespassing." So how much notice is that?
Well, the Zoning Board -- let me ask you this -- I don't know about -- that was a City Council posting. The Zoning Board 84 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980761 posting requires it to be posted at the street frontage, at the sidewalk poster, and their poster is a bright orange that you can see for blocks away, but it has to be posted at the public sidewalk for the Zoning Board. I don't know what the posting requirements of City Council are in terms of public posting.
Thank you very much. Any other questions for these witnesses? Councilman Nutter.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just very briefly, I have had conversations about this proposal prior to its introduction with Common Pleas Court Judge Steven Levin, who receives the appeals from any zoning cases, which is the next level of appeal, as well as the chair of the Zoning Board, chairman Tom Kelly. The reason this issue arises is when people take their -- when the applicant or 85 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980761 protestants utilize their right to appeal the action of the Zoning Board of Adjustment and the case goes to Common Pleas Court, sometimes judge will accepted the case back without retaining jurisdiction so the case go back to the Zoning Board the judge will send the case back without retaining jurisdiction, and so the case goes back to the Zoning Board. The judge, at that point, considers the case to be a new case. There is, though, as Mr. Lombardo said, no posting requirement, and that process can take some months. And, literally, property can be bought and sold in the intervening time between the first hearing, the appeal, and the remand. And so new neighbors or current neighbors may not know that there is a second hearing for this particular application. Judge Levin and Mr. Kelly, chair of the Zoning Board, are both in agreement with this particular bill, and that is the reason for it; it is only to provide additional notice. There is no 23 additional payment for the new posting to be paid by the applicant. They're not required to post any additional dollars, only to put up the signs 86 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980761 and be in accord with the 12-day posting requirement. Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
Thank you very much. Is there anyone else to testify on this bill? (No response.)
Seeing none, we'll now move to Bill No. 980779, which is an ordinance 12 amending Title of The Philadelphia Code, 13 relating to "Zoning and Planning," by amending 14 Chapter 14-300, entitled "Commercial Districts," by amending Section 14-305, entitled "C-4" Commercial and" C-5" Commercial Districts," and by amending Chapter 14-1600, entitled "Miscellaneous," by amending Section 14-1607, Entitled "Special Controls for the Center City Commercial Area," under certain terms and conditions. Please identify yourself for the record. Before you do that, the City Council Committee on Licenses and Inspections scheduled to 87 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980779 meet at will be meeting immediately following the Rules Committee. Please identify yourself and proceed.
Rich Lombardo, from the 6 City Planning Commission, here to today to speak 7 on behalf of Bill 980779. 8 This bill really is a bit of 9 housecleaning. It comes about because, in the 10 planning for a new Performing Arts Center, one of 11 the streets, basically the street that used to exist between the subject site and the Philadelphia University of the Arts, which are Delancey Street, was stricken a number of years ago as part of site assemblage. Since that street is no longer a City street, it would function and will continue to function like a street. When the Performing Arts Center is built, this street -- we'll call it a "private street," will still provide access for parking and loading and servicing of the new Performing Arts Center. But since it is not a -- since it was stricken as a street, it has become a driveway. It creates a zoning problem. The Zoning Code in Center City does not 88 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980779 allow a curb cut from Broad Street, ingress or egress from Broad Street, without a zoning variance. There is no special exemption, there is now way around it. A site that -- it can meet zoning and every other category. It can be within the height, the width, the frontage, the permitted use, but because it has a curb cut to Broad Street, it would require a zoning variance. Obviously, that was done to encourage continued introductions of left- and right-turns off of Broad Street into various parking garages and accesses. This, however, is a place where a turn has always been permitted but until, recently, there was a street there. The street was just stricken as part of the site assemblage. So what this bill do, it would exempt this block from that prohibition on curb cuts. And since its a publicly controlled block, and the rest of the block is historically certified in the University of the Arts, we know there will never be more than one curb cut, and that curb cut will go where Delancey Street used to be -- or actually, where Delancey Street will still be, though it won't be public street anymore. That's 89 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980779 all the bill does. For the record, I did talk to on the phone with the representative -- I believe she's the attorney, Judith Eden, calling on behalf of that for Center City residents and just asked her that's all this bill will do and I explained it to her, and she said they had no problem with it.
Thank you very much. Any questions for this witness? (No questions.)
My name is Paul Deegan, D-E-E-G-A-N, and I represent PIDC and PAID. We were instrumental in assembling the site for the Regional Performing Arts Center. We also -- we're the sponsor of the bill to strike the street, thereby creating this problem. And so we asked the Planning Commission how to fix it, and this is the bill they 90 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980779 produced. And we respectfully request favorable consideration and report it out at the next session of Council, with a suspension of the rules.
The next bill is Bill No. 980781, an ordinance amending an ordinance approved December 15, 1969, as amended, which approved the Redevelopment Proposal, the Urban Renewal Plan, and the Relocation Plan of the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Philadelphia for the redevelopment of the Model Cities Urban Renewal Area by approving the 22nd amendment of the Redevelopment Proposal and the 14th amendment to the Urban Renewal Plan, which provide, inter alia, for certain additional land acquisitions. Redevelopment Authority. (Noel Eisenstat comes forward.) 91 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - 980781
Please identify yourself for the record when you're prepared.
Good morning. My name is Noel Eisenstat, E-I-S-E-N-S-T-A-T. I am the Executive Director of the City's Redevelopment Authority. And as you've read, I'm here to give comments on Bill No. 980781. This is a bill 9 authorizing an amendment to the Model Cities Urban Renewal Area. This bill is actually the 22nd amendment to the Redevelopment Proposal, and the 14th amendment to the Urban Renewal Plan. The maps before you describe -- we are basically here for two reasons today. One is to acquire 38 parcels of land for the African-American Development Corporation. Unfortunately, their president Marwan Kreidie, who's also a member of the City's Civil Service Commission, is conducting business in his capacity as a civil service commissioner and is unable to be with us. But let me explain that this is an area that is adjacent to the Al-Aqsa Islamic Society, and the Society is currently housing space for worship and classroom and a specialty food store. 92 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - 980781 The properties are to be developed into a parking lot to provide approximately 83 parking spaces in an area for modular classrooms -- these are 5 actually double-unit classrooms. The Arab-American Development Corporation will lease the parcels from the Islamic Society. Financing for this project is being provided by the Arab-American Development Corporation. The other development in this urban renewal taking are for two properties on behalf of Community ventures and the Francisville Community Organization. Mr. Steve Kauffman (ph) was here earlier here today; he left just recently. These two properties are for a senior citizen rental development project located at Edwin and Wylie Streets. The project will consist of new construction of affordable rental units 20 for seniors. The rest of the properties for this 21 project were previously acquired during urban 22 renewal taking approved on June 11, 1998, the same 23 calendar year. Funding is to be provided through 24 low-income housing tax credits in a combination of Year 23 Community Development Block Grant Funds. 93 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - 980781 If you have any questions about either of these --
At the beginning of your testimony, we think that you said -- Councilwoman Clark and myself -- "African-American Development Corporation." Do you mean "Arab-American Development Corporation?"
I'm we glad made that change. Thank you. Are there any questions for Mr. Eisenstat? (No questions.)
Is there anyone else here to testify on this bill? (No response.)
Thank you very much. Bill No. 980800 will be held at the request of the sponsor, Councilman DiCicco. The next bill is 980801, which is an ordinance amending an ordinance approved August 15, 1969, as amended, which approved the amended 94 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - 980781 Redevelopment Proposal, the amended Urban Renewal Plan, and the amended Relocation Plan of the Redevelopment Authority of the City of Philadelphia for the redevelopment of Pennsport Urban Renewal Area, by approving the 4th amendment of the Redevelopment Proposal and the 3rd amendment to the Urban Renewal Plan, and by providing for certain changes, namely: certain additional acquisition of a property for rehabilitation with an institutional reuse; certain land use changes from residential to institutional/public; certain expressly designated and provided-for imminence of condemnation; and updating the property rehabilitation standards, all as contained in the amended Redevelopment Proposal and Urban Renewal Plan. Please identify yourself for the record.
My name is Noel Eisenstat. I am the Executive Director of the City's Redevelopment Authority. I'm here to provide comment on Bill No. 980801. This is a revision to the Pennsport Redevelopment Area. I would note that this is the 95 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980801 for the since the early 1970s that the Pennsport Urban Renewal Area has had any activity. The property that's actually in question, that is the cause of this hearing, is 1600 South Second Street, which is adjacent to 1602 South Second Street, the Jokers New Year's Day Association headquarters. Councilman Kenney and I have spent numerous other attempts to attempt to acquire this property through other mechanisms, through buying liens, other types of condemnation vehicles. And ultimately, this is a property that needs to be acquired through the urban renewal process, and this will be used to expand their Mummers Clubhouse. The property is a vacant three-story mixed-use commercial property, and it's a blighting influence along Second Street, in the Pennsport community.
Okay. For the record, I think it's important to make it clear that I am a member of that New Year's association, which is a nonprofit organization. There is no 24 financial interest whatsoever in the organization. And the bill was introduced by 96 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980801 Councilman DiCicco at the request of the organization and the surrounding neighbors, due to the blighted nature of the building and the lack of prospects that the owner, which is no longer the owner, was going to do anything to fix it up. As a matter of fact, there were pieces of bricks that were falling out of the second floor and a dangerous pavement that's resulted in a number of lawsuits. And children and young adults were entering the basement and using it as a kind of hangout, drinking, drug-using activity. So we're hoping that the acquisition by the club will enable the club to rehabilitate it into a useful purpose and less of a blight on the neighborhood. Are there any questions for Mr. Eisenstat?
Anyone else here to testify on this bill? (No response.) 97 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Bill 980801
Seeing none, we will now move to Resolution No. 980112. I think there are four witnesses that have requested to testify. If they could approach the witness table now. This is a resolution. Let me say for the record that this resolution authorizing the Rules Committee to conduct hearings examining the problems that certified minority subcontracting firms experience during the course of their employment on City-funded projects; specifically, their attempts to collect funds due from certain general contractors. Let me say for the record that this resolution deserves and will get a more expanded hearing. Because of the rush of the legislation in the limited days left before our recess, we thought it would be appropriate to allow these individuals to come in to open the record. This record will be extended and expanded at a different time more appropriate to a full-blown hearing on this resolution. But we do thank you for taking time from your work day today. We know you're trying 98 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 to -- considering the resolution, you're out there trying to make a living, and we'd like to give you the opportunity to testify on your concerns today, and then we will recess the hearing to another date and notify you again. So please identify yourself for the record. Thank you for waiting and proceed.
I'm Earl Calloway, and I'm the owner of C.E. Franklin, Incorporated. I'm a certified minority business enterprise with the City of Philadelphia, and we subcontract for plumbing, heating, and air-conditioning work from general contractors. I've been in the business since 1976. All large contracts involving general contractors withhold 10 percent retainage of the total amount of the contract until it's complete. This happens even if the general contractors are only being charged 5 percent retainage themselves. I have a continuing problem with ever collecting this amount and even collecting the final bill. Once we've finished the work for the 99 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 general contractors, the general contractors habitually do not pay the balance for various -- you know, they use various excuses ranging from missing paperwork to erroneous back-charges. They make up the back-charges which consist of work they claim to have done that we were supposed to have done. They do not have to present any proof of this work and often come up with this months after the contract was committed. The only current result I have is to place mechanic liens on the property or sue the general contractor. Both of these involve legal fees, which are very costly. Currently apply all of the retainage for the Sarah Allen Project, Phase IV, which I have completed in December of 1997. This amount is $58,000. I have been back-charged approximately $8,800 of this $58,000, which they're holding until I sign a final waiver. This is a typical ploy by the GCs who can afford to wait, to play the waiting game. So because we, as subcontractors, have limited resources, we must settle for smaller amounts. This problem at Sarah Allen and with 100 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 the Sarah Allen contract is only one of the many examples I could use to demonstrate the payment difficulties I have had and continue to have. I appreciate your interest in the problem. We would like the City to become involved in the process on City-funded jobs. When GCs aren't paying their subs, we would like to see the City step in and enforce payment to the subcontractors. The subcontractors need someone to go to when the authorities -- with the authority to act so that we can get paid. Thank you.
Let me see if I understand it. As a standard practice of doing business, GCs, your own contractors, withhold up to 10 percent of the total value of your contract.
That's correct. 101 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112
And almost always come up with some reason not to pay it over.
So it's a thinly disguised way of stealing percent of the money, 9 isn't it? 10
And if I were to distill your comments, it would be that you need the City to establish an oversight to make sure that this illegal extortion of money is ended. You need some entity in the City that has the authority and the willingness to follow up on that 10 percent hold-back that almost never gets paid over. It's almost like security rent where the landlord figures out some reason that, you know, you either painted the place too dark or you left holes in the wall, something's going to give him a reason not to give you back your security deposit. Is that the same kind of thing?
That's exactly what 102 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 happens to us constantly, and we have many people here today that could testify to the same thing.
Now, specifically, you have 58,000 that is owed to you on a recent project.
Have you any reason to believe that you are going to get any of it back? I know you say that 8,000 is "back-work" or something, that they had to do that you were supposed to do.
That's correct. And at this present moment, they are wait for me to sign the releases so that they will pay me the 58,000, less the 8,500.
And in signing the release, you agree in writing legally sufficient to foreclose any other claim to the $8,000.
Okay. So you, in effect, in order to get the 50, which you desperately need, are complicit in contributing 8,000.
That's correct. 103 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112
Yes, ma'am. When we work basically on a to percent margin, when we're operating out there, that $8,000 basically is all of my profit.
Mr. Chairman, I think that is a reprehensible practice. Thank you for the clarity of your testimony.
That's why we decided to have this hearing and have an additional hearing into the future, to discuss this at length. Councilwoman Verna.
What is your recourse at the present time if you're waiting over a year to be paid?
Basically, there is no 21 recourse, we have no recourse, and that's why we're coming to Council today, to ask for your support, to kind of step in and help us with our problem. We have no recourse. The only recourse that we have is, 104 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 basically, like I stated earlier, is to basically sue the general contractor, which is very costly, or, you know, put a lien on the properties where we've been working. That is also a costly and drawn-out process.
Yes, I will, thank you very much. My name is Grace Gibson. I am the owner of Quality Heating and Sheet Metal. I'm an HVAC company, which is heating, ventilating, and air-conditioning. The company was incorporated in 1966. I purchased this company in 1983 and became certified WDBE in January of 1995. In 1991 and 1992, I connected connect with a general contractor named Earnest Bach (ph) & Sons and was awarded jobs on seven different Projects for him. Those jobs ranged from jobs outside the city to jobs inside the city. One of the jobs was a City-funded project, 47th, 56th and 105 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 Chestnut Street, 74 apartments. Another was Medical College of Pennsylvania and 2100 Pioneer Road, Tom Bach's personal home. All were completed 100 percent or 95 percent complete. Mr. Bach paid me the 15th of the month until I approximately completed 60 percent of the job, and then the back-charges started. He would state that we did not close and lock doors and windows, we did not lock the gate, we did not clean up. And his favorite was we were not adhering to his schedule. Needless to say, we were not the last ones to leave the job. It was not our responsibility to lock his job; it was his foreman's. We did, in fact, clean up. And as far as the schedule, there never was one, either written or verbal. The total money owed to me at that time from this one contractor was $165,000. I sued Tom Bach for $30,000 and --.
Just one minute, Miss Gibson. Of the $165,000 owed, how much of it is City projects? Recognizing that our 106 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 responsibility is to City projects.
On the one project, I was owed $30,000, which was a federal project, the bulk mail postal service. I won but, another stall tactic is to appeal, which only delays, and we don't still get our money. I had to settle with him for $20,000; I lost $10,000, which he pocketed. The balance of $135,000 was still owing, and I had to file a lawsuit, which is very costly to me. During the time that I was working for Tom Bach, I received threats and false statement made by him in the form of verbally abusive conversation. He sent me three or four faxed letters per day and sent me certified mail two to three times a day. This is each and every day. Tom Bach would state in his letters that I had to be at a job at a specific time, a specific day, and if I was not there, I would be 107 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 removed from the job and back-charged. If I did not install equipment on a specific day, I would be removed from the job, and I would be back-charged. These sordid demands were meant to terrorize me since the job was not ready for me to comply with his demands, as he was well aware of. I nonetheless sent men and equipment to the jobs and lost precious time and money trying to meet his demands. His conversations with me went beyond business issues. He threatened to see me homeless, on the street, and would never pay me a dime. He threatened to punch my 70-year-old father in the mouth the next time he saw him. Tom Bach, at the time, was 32 years old. My father tried to resolve these problems. He did nothing but insult us, call us liars in writing. I pleaded with Mr. Bach to at least pay my subcontractors and my suppliers. He did say in a letter, in writing, that he would, but he never did. My company installed Tom Bach's personal home -- duct work in his personal home, and I billed him for the work at that address. He called me and told me in order to get paid, I had 108 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 to send a new bill and bill it to a City-funded project, and that was the only way I was going to get paid. I did so out of fear of not getting paid. I informed Tom Bach that it was not right to do and his response, "You don't tell me who to bill, I tell you." During these years, we hand-delivered invoices, there were miscellaneous times he said he did not receive the invoice. His pay was supposed to be 45 days from the date of the invoice. According to rules on City-funded projects, we're supposed to receive payment within 5 days after he receives payment. He also holds 10 percent of the money on all City projects, and we never get it; and if we do, it's not all that we all should get because they make up these erroneous back-charges. My husband -- and Tom Bach knew this -- is not well, he's physically handicapped, he has multiple sclerosis for the last 11 years, and he has a very bad heart and has had two major heart. I am the sole support of my family, and if I have these kinds of things that happen with general contractors on City-funded projects, I'll be out 109 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 of business. The problem we face as MBE/WBEs is that we have no contact directly to City agencies; we can only deal with the general contractor or builder. If we have a legitimate complaint, problem, or we're not getting paid, we have no 8 recourse to correct these problems, no one to contact. We also do not, as MBEs, know which general contractor's builders have a good track record and are honest with dealing with their subs. We take a gamble when we work for general contractors do not know. There are at least 15 companies that I am aware of that have this 16 ongoing problem. 17 Any general contractor who abuses their 18 subcontractors to this degree should not be allowed to continue to be awarded City-funded work, but that is currently going on. I respectfully request a solution to our problems and I thank you for your time.
Thank you very much. Sir, would you please identify yourself 110 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 for the record.
I wear two hats. I'm Jihad Ali, wearing the hat of a committee member of the United Minority Enterprise Association, and I'm going to give a statement on the resolution you just --
Pardon me? I'm with the United Minority Enterprise Association, which is a trade organization.
Chairman Kenney and members of the committee, I appreciate the opportunity to appear before you today to discuss this committee's resolution authorizing public hearings and examining the problems that certified minority subcontracting firms experience during the course of their employment on City-funded projects; specifically, their attempts to collect funds due from general contractors. Mr. Chairman, to begin with, I would like to just thank you for considering this 111 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 resolution. When I think of the enormous workload of all the members of City Council are under at these final stages of the year, it is truly exceptional for you and members of this committee to still take the time out of a very active schedule to consider the matters of the disadvantaged. My remarks will be very brief in light of the work burden this Council is under. Our organization, the United Minority Enterprise Association, is a self-supported building trades organization with a decade-longer existence than any City agency that is involved in the black, male, women, disadvantaged and disabled field. We have many members who are here to testify at the planned hearings. Our members are prepared to give anecdotal evidence of many occasions when they were not paid, resulting in some firms experiencing financial difficulty, and in some instances, their firms ruined. It is a necessity for this Council to investigate how millions of dollars are being disbursed and who is benefitting. 112 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 Thank you, members of this committee for initiating this and inquiring into this problem. I'd like to put my other hat on now as one of the members of the subcontractor community that was ruined on several City-funded projects. ) Construction, and I didn't know Mr. Calloway was going to be here today, but we also performed on the Sarah Allen project. My company was a carpentry subcontract company and was composed of a group of young African-American men who were very gifted in their field. The Sarah Allen project that I'm speaking of was the 80-unit old nursing home on 40th and Poplar Streets. And on that project, my subcontract was -- I believe it was $640,000. The fact that the general contractor gave us a contract without a bond indicates our level of expertise and our experience. We completed that job -- it was a 7-story building with 80 units. We did the entire layout on our own. From the initial day that we started our work scope, the architects came over, checked 113 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 our layout, and never came back. We completed all 80 units, we got down to the first floor, we had yet to do our finish coat on our dry wall. We were doing the drywall, the framing, all the interior layout. We got down to the first floor, and the contractor -- we were down to our last 60,000 to build. He owed us 50. There was 130,000 in change orders that he didn't want to pay for, so he refused to pay us. And at that time, we were also doing a project with the Shriners Hospital. I did the entire ninth floor of the Shriners Hospital with another company called "Wyatt," but on that project, we were second-tier, which is another disadvantaged position for subcontractors to be in. The bottom line is that you get stole from twice because you have work that's in place that's complete and you also have that 10 percent. So they're actually stealing. In this case with the contractor on the Sarah Allen, we had 50,000 we were yet to bill for, they took that 50, and then had our other 60,000 that was retainage for what we had already completed. 114 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 But there are solutions. The problems that we have is that the City -- our forefathers that preceded us already laid this out. And part of the problem is today, we just don't have the heads of certain departments taking a strong stand.
They're just denying their responsibilities because most of the money that we're benefitting from is federal money. And most of that money, when the projects are proposed to developers and contractors, they're only by law entitled to receive a certain percentage. So the way to correct problem is to start having the Finance Director or the other appropriate entities do an audit because in those cases where we were replaced or we weren't paid, somebody made that profit, and it wasn't the builder. By law, the builder's not supposed to make that profit. That's just a little known fact. If we could just get some enforcement of the provisions, things would end overnight, and it also would end up benefiting the welfare of our community. Because those of us who are disadvantaged from the inner neighborhood, we 115 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 employ other disadvantaged people. And when you employ youth, you end up putting a dent in crime, and that's what it's all about. All our whole will be better, but what we're going is we're creating modern day titans, and we're standing by while crimes are being committed. But I thank you all for taking the time out of your busy schedule to look into this matter.
Thank you very much for coming in and for your testimony. Councilmember Clark.
Well, Mr. Ali, we really don't have anything that's more important. This is work. I appreciate your kind words, but this is work, this is what you elected us to do, this is what said we would do if you elected us.
Let me ask you about the Sarah Allen project. Is that a City- funded project in any way?
Yes, it was. It was funded by the Redevelopment Authority, and they had 116 12/1/98 COMMITTEE ON RULES - Res. 980112 received HUD funds. Most of the multi-million dollar contracts have some form of HUD money in it. And HUD money, once that one dollar of HUD money comes in, that's really our strongest position because that really has a lot of sanctions attached to that money. There's a lot of rules and regulations that the Council is aware of, like the mayor's executive order, which is his executive order that has no sanctions attached to it. When you put in HUD money, you're triggering Section 3, which has some very stiff sanctions in it.