civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - May 28, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)May 28, 20257h 56m

The state only allowed, because of the size of the home, a maximum of eight people.

Similar wording

And you have four bedrooms?

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

How many baths?

Similar wording

Three bathrooms.

Similar wording

Okay. And then, but the residents can leave, you say, or go out between 6 a.m. and 8 p.m.?

Similar wording

Yes. They're allowed to come and go as they please. They do have to notify us where they're going, but most of our residents do go to day programs throughout the day, so they're typically not home.

Similar wording

Yes, they're allowed to come and go as they please, not like...

Similar wording

Okay. And then where do you get the referrals from?

Similar wording

for your, the referrals will come from like a placement agency or like social workers at a

Similar wording

hospital or social workers at a nursing home. Or we also get some from, they'll be like, there's a

Similar wording

place called Comar. So they help seniors that may have like anxiety or depression. So we'll get

Similar wording

referrals from them as well. Okay. And how many people are going to be there to provide whatever

Similar wording

services or what services are you going to provide we have three people during

Similar wording

the day and then we have one overnight individual are you asking about the

Similar wording

yeah what would they be doing you said would they be providing medication

Similar wording

providing medication meals they serve three daily meals a day plus a snack

Similar wording

medication any activities or programs that we have running on that day they

Similar wording

will also be participating in that as well okay all right thank you any other

Similar wording

questions yes so i think my question was related to the employees like a lot of the house seems

Similar wording

like it's mostly designed for the residents and is there any space that's sort of restricted

Similar wording

for um any of the employees almost like a like an employee lounge or and then what about parking

Similar wording

for the employees parking there is parking in the front of the building also we do have a sitting

Similar wording

area that is restricted for the employees in the front room

Similar wording

of the home. That's it.

Similar wording

What is the actual ratio for employees

Similar wording

versus patients? One employee for

Similar wording

every six residents. Okay, and then

Similar wording

it should be some kind of office that is utilized for

Similar wording

all of the medication and everything else that is administered

Similar wording

to the patients, correct?

Similar wording

So it's state regulated.

Similar wording

We do not need an office for medication.

Similar wording

We just need a locked cabinet.

Similar wording

And all the medication has to be stored

Similar wording

with the resident's name on it.

Similar wording

Good.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Any other questions?

Similar wording

Questions or comments from our attorney?

Similar wording

Not at this time, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience

Similar wording

or the present audience here?

Similar wording

Mr. Chair, I have Charles Richardson

Similar wording

with the hand up again.

Similar wording

I will promote to the panelists.

Similar wording

They'll be back in shortly.

Similar wording

good afternoon again mr chair mr richardson just for the record state your name and

Similar wording

begin your presentation certainly charles richardson office of councilwoman cindy bass

Similar wording

room 508 city hall uh councilwoman has no opposition uh to granting the variance thank

Similar wording

Thank you very much for taking the time to call us.

Similar wording

Anyone else in the virtual audience?

Similar wording

I do not see any further answers, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan, oh, Amy, we're with the Planning Commission.

Similar wording

The comprehensive plan recommends no change in zoning at this location from the existing RSA 3 residential single family.

Similar wording

The proposed use will have minimal impacts on the surrounding properties and will support the life and safety of community members.

Similar wording

The Planning Commission recommends that the board grant their request of variance for personal care home.

Similar wording

So, Hillary, we have no provisos.

Similar wording

Am I correct?

Similar wording

So, I believe that the RCO had indicated a proviso, but I didn't see anything listed on the letter.

Similar wording

Were you aware of any provisos, Mr. Nockamson?

Similar wording

So, we did not handle the community meeting, so I'm not aware.

Similar wording

So, I believe that Mr. Richardson may have been.

Similar wording

So, I'm unaware of any provisos.

Similar wording

There was a note in the letter, but it did not list actually any provisos.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

MI-2025-000682-1531 Lindley Avenue.

Similar wording

I vote yes.

Similar wording

Michael Johns, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Cheryl Gaston, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Tanada Graham, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

I win, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Ishmael Shahi, my vote is yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Helen, I know you have a couple more cases.

Similar wording

I'm going to go and do a couple, then I'll be back to you.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Thanks.

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

okay here we go number one mi2023006 953-2122 west a stop street

Similar wording

Vern Anastasio is the attorney

Similar wording

they'll be coming back in as a panel

Similar wording

afternoon mr chair members of the board

Similar wording

verne could you please state your name as spelled for the stenographer

Similar wording

sure it's burn anastasio a-n-a-s-t-a-s-i-o this is your first time today no i was here this morning

Similar wording

okay all right um so this is a resumptive hearing i see here where swamp poodle sent in a list of

Similar wording

provisos um where we are today is you're going to give us an update from the applicant including

Similar wording

photos plans for the basement questions from the board public testimony and the recommendation

Similar wording

planning is that correct yes sir okay so why don't you start okay allegheny west however all

Similar wording

also sent over a letter there i believe the uh the corresponding or the coordinating rco

Similar wording

uh letter of support based on certain certain proviso so but i will share

Similar wording

i can i can confirm that we received the letter from allegheny west um previously um and that was

Similar wording

in support of a three three unit proposal that's correct the letter for swamp poodle came since the

Similar wording

last hearing yeah so yeah this is uh this is the allegheny west letter supporting the three unit

Similar wording

proposal. We've been working for well over nine months now with the RCO to get to this place. So

Similar wording

I want to thank them for their support and assistance. And so I have that letter. I'd

Similar wording

like to move into evidence. Also, I have the basement plans. I'll move into evidence. I'll

Similar wording

With the front entrance access to the basement itself, which is separate than the rest of the property,

Similar wording

we're able to put the trash there instead of the shared vestibule area, which was not an ideal space.

Similar wording

So there's the trash storage for the front of the basement.

Similar wording

And then beyond that, no living space at all.

Similar wording

Some tenant storage in the rear.

Similar wording

There is a bathroom down there and some bike storage.

Similar wording

So, and every unit will have access to this space, but there will be no, no part of the basement will be part of the three family dwelling that is now part of our proposal as a result of several meetings with the RCOs to get to a unit number that made sense for the community as well as for the property itself.

Similar wording

So that's that there.

Similar wording

And I'll stop sharing that.

Similar wording

What can I show you?

Similar wording

There's some photos, both exterior and interior.

Similar wording

And with the RCO weighing in, with the photos and revised plans,

Similar wording

I think I've given you everything that I can move into evidence.

Similar wording

It's a 72-page binder, plus the letter of support with provisos from the RCO.

Similar wording

I believe that's all.

Similar wording

My client, a member of BK Partners, either Brahim Murray or Kyle Easley, should be in the virtual audience.

Similar wording

I would ask them to raise their hand for recognition.

Similar wording

Can I see photos of the basement of the property again?

Similar wording

I think most of the photos are of the living space areas, not the basement.

Similar wording

I have an exterior shot of the entrance to the basement where the trash and storage will

Similar wording

be.

Similar wording

I'll be happy to show you that.

Similar wording

I'll be happy to show you that.

Similar wording

as the basement

Similar wording

Has the basement already been rehabbed?

Similar wording

No, the four units were not including the basement.

Similar wording

Four units were all the first floor and above.

Similar wording

So nothing's been done inside the basement at all, except the bathroom?

Similar wording

That's my understanding, yes.

Similar wording

If my client were here, they could probably get online to confirm that, but yes.

Similar wording

And I'll zoom in here. This is the entrance to the basement for all the units, as you can see here.

Similar wording

And in the front will be the trash storage, no living space, some bike racks after that, and then storage.

Similar wording

And that'll be for each of the three tenants to use.

Similar wording

So how big is the basement?

Similar wording

It's the entire length of the property.

Similar wording

i'll take it back i could bring back the plan if you'd like on the drawing i'm gonna go back to

Similar wording

the drawing this is the old one but it's still the same length it didn't it didn't shrink in

Similar wording

the new plan oh they didn't move they're where they were before these are the these are the old

Similar wording

plan hold on i'll make it easier for you if i just take so so real quick the so the separation

Similar wording

of all these rooms in the basement is done by what like is it done now or would they have to

Similar wording

put install walls like how are they separating all of the spaces in the basement you got three

Similar wording

different spaces yeah it would have been great burn i'm sorry pictures pictures would have been

Similar wording

great to hear. I know. I'm so sorry. Am I able to clarify? Who is that? Kyle Easley. Oh, there you

Similar wording

go. Okay. Not before you get sworn in, Kyle. Mr. Easley, please state your name and spell

Similar wording

for the stenographer. Hello, everyone. My name is Kyle Easley. It's spelled K-Y-L-E-E-A-S-L-E-Y.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes, sir.

Similar wording

Counsel, please proceed.

Similar wording

Thank you, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

I was wondering where my client was.

Similar wording

Mr. Easley, please answer the questions as I present them to you based on the-

Similar wording

Mr. Easley, can you go on the web, put your picture up, your video?

Similar wording

My photo?

Similar wording

Not your photo, you.

Similar wording

Could you go put yourself on a video?

Similar wording

Put myself on a video?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

Please take up the invitation to become panelists.

Similar wording

Oh, oh.

Similar wording

one second

Similar wording

join us panelists

Similar wording

yeah he didn't

Similar wording

accept it yet

Similar wording

I'll be back in trouble Mr.

Similar wording

one second

Similar wording

there you go

Similar wording

forgive me I just picked the kids up from school

Similar wording

thank you Mr. Easley

Similar wording

Mr. Easley how deep is the yard

Similar wording

is the basement

Similar wording

it's the full length of the property

Similar wording

okay

Similar wording

Okay, so about 95 feet deep, is that right?

Similar wording

Yes, yes, but the basement was the former unit, the unit that we got rid of, and so there are three units upstairs, the basement was the fourth unit, and we haven't rented that out since we bought it in preparation for this.

Similar wording

And in the course of working with the RCO and presenting today, there will be no kitchen down there.

Similar wording

The only thing that will be left is the bathroom. Is that right?

Similar wording

Yes, that's right.

Similar wording

You're going to put bike racks as well?

Similar wording

That's right.

Similar wording

And the partitions that the board member had asked about that separate the trash space from the bike rack space from the storage space.

Similar wording

Are those interior partitions already up?

Similar wording

Yeah, they're already up.

Similar wording

there's a door and a wall thank you so the space is finished yes sir

Similar wording

but there will be no living space there that's right and there and there hasn't

Similar wording

been any limit living space there since we owned it other questions

Similar wording

Questions or comments from our attorney?

Similar wording

Not at this time, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Questions or comments from the virtual audience?

Similar wording

So, Mr. Chair, I have Charles Richardson with the hand raised again.

Similar wording

I'll promote them once more.

Similar wording

I'll promote him once more.

Similar wording

Good afternoon again.

Similar wording

Mr. Richardson, just state your name for the record.

Similar wording

Charles Richardson, Office of Councilwoman Cindy Bass.

Similar wording

Councilwoman has no opposition to granting the variance.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Anyone else in the virtual audience?

Similar wording

Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Yeah, sorry. There was a hand, but it's lower down. Go ahead. Go ahead.

Similar wording

Planning Commission.

Similar wording