civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - July 31, 2024

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jul 31, 20246h 45m

All right, so this is our property from a rendering standpoint as an overview, but these are the six single-family homes on Sharp Neck, right?

Similar wording

Those are the ones that have already been approved by way of zoning permit as of right, as well as a building permit, and in the midst of construction.

Similar wording

These are the six single-family homes right behind it.

Similar wording

And, again, all these properties have off-street parking with garages, you know, for the sharp-neck properties in the front with rear parking.

Similar wording

And then we're creating a sense of community with landscaping and such.

Similar wording

And, you know, given the size of the community, obviously there's going to be, like, commercial trash pickup given the amount of size of the units, the amount of units.

Similar wording

And we can agree to that in the form of proviso, but I don't think it's necessary.

Similar wording

but if need be, we can agree to that. And then these are the duplexes here, right? These are

Similar wording

the 16 unit of duplexes here. And then you can see here that we're actually set back,

Similar wording

I believe that is another 20 feet back here. And then this is a rendering of what we hope to be

Similar wording

the completed portion of the Sharknack Street properties. But you can see it's a mix of stone

Similar wording

as well as a mix of brick.

Similar wording

as well as a mix of brick and then here is the actual uh parking uh what's called curb cut

Similar wording

And then here is the actual parking.

Similar wording

where there's gonna be a carriage house here's a two unit but all the other ones are one unit but

Similar wording

you can even see from the architecture what my client trying to mimic was the brick was the stone

Similar wording

and also mixing some mansard roofs throughout and then this is just an interior portion and you can

Similar wording

see this is from if i guess if i was standing back you know my back to upsell which is way above us

Similar wording

because of the slope of the property uh these are the duplexes but you can even see the duplexes

Similar wording

they each have parking as well um and then even the the uh common areas like you know again what

Similar wording

we wanted to do is focus on adequate and nice landscaping but we also wanted to break up the

Similar wording

fact that we do have a dry vial throughout. So even the walkways were thought out with like some

Similar wording

brick in the walkways themselves to provide some definition for residents. And then this is the

Similar wording

site plan for the single families. So you can see there's one, two, three, four, five, six single

Similar wording

families. And here's the carriage house with the curb cut. And that's coming all up a sharp neck.

Similar wording

And then this is, I guess, a more wider view of the site plan, but here's the single families on Sharpneck, and then here's the single families which mimic those just behind us on Sharpneck, one single family, two single families, three single families, four, five, six.

Similar wording

What you can also see is that we do provide open area and a setback for these properties on Sharpneck, which is 10 feet.

Similar wording

But because it's within the easement area of this drive aisle, that's why we received that technical refusal on the notice of refusal.

Similar wording

And then in the back of the property, as you can see, like, you know, these are the duplexes.

Similar wording

There's two sets of building structures for the duplexes.

Similar wording

And then, again, we were very mindful that we're, you know, behind those properties on an upsell, which are way above us.

Similar wording

But, you know, we did also do a setback back here in the rear of the property.

Similar wording

so and then you can just see here from the sloping of of the property um like you know

Similar wording

we definitely have um some sloping from front to back for these from for these building structures

Similar wording

and then this is just again showing the property this is the front part on sharp neck street

Similar wording

again mixed between uh brick as well as stone and again we're set back on the third story

Similar wording

um and this is the uh the properties right behind us the single families on sharp neck as well as

Similar wording

can see they also mimic the properties that actually face sharp neck those single families

Similar wording

and then this is just the rear of these properties as well and you can see there's adequate parking

Similar wording

garages for all the single families and then these are the renderings for the duplexes and

Similar wording

you can see like we didn't change the quality of materials for those duplexes it's a slightly

Similar wording

different look but you have a mix between bricks and stone and lentils and you most importantly

Similar wording

have parking for each of the units and then my client wanted to really go full out here so

Similar wording

they did renderings on the inside of these properties as well so you can see and I have

Similar wording

the traditional floor plans but if you take a look at it this is first essentially these are

Similar wording

single families you know you have two car parking you have a little sunken den area and then if you

Similar wording

go up a flight of steps um you have an open floor area of a kitchen dining room and a living room

Similar wording

and then you also have like a a second and third floor uh with uh with bedrooms each of the single

Similar wording

All families, I believe, are, let me just confirm this, are approximately 2,800 square feet in size.

Similar wording

They're three bedrooms, four baths.

Similar wording

And then this is the traditional floor plans you would see from us in doing a presentation.

Similar wording

But my clients really want to show the quality of the interior and the properties.

Similar wording

but here you see the garage on the first floor the sunken den area behind it and then you can see

Similar wording

on the first first floor is the is the open floor plan of the living room dining room and kitchen

Similar wording

a lot of light and air from front to back and then you can see on the third floor are two bedrooms

Similar wording

And then you can see on the third floor are two bedrooms with a bath and a laundry facility.

Similar wording

with a bat.

Similar wording

And then on the upper floor, obviously, is the master suite.

Similar wording

And there's a roof deck associated with it.

Similar wording

And then this is the rendering, the interior renderings for the, let me just make it a little smaller, but not too small, for the duplexes.

Similar wording

So, I'm just trying to make it small enough so it fits on my screen, but I can't keep doing that.

Similar wording

Hold on.

Similar wording

Let's try it one more time.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So, you have, again, each unit would have its own parking spot within the garage area.

Similar wording

You would walk up a flight of steps, and you'll see this on the floor plans.

Similar wording

unit one is the first floor and the second floor. So unit number one also includes the rear part of

Similar wording

here, which is a bedroom, bathroom, and a storage area. And then on the second floor, when you come

Similar wording

up is where, you know, you can go to the right for unit number one, which includes a kitchen,

Similar wording

a living room, and a bedroom as well. And you go up another flight of steps is unit number two,

Similar wording

which, again, has a living room, a kitchen, and a bedroom.

Similar wording

And then for the fourth floor is multiple bedrooms for that second unit.

Similar wording

And then these are the traditional floor plans you would see as well from, like, you know, perspective of these duplexes.

Similar wording

Again, you have the garage here.

Similar wording

Each unit gets its own parking spot.

Similar wording

You go up to the second floor, and again, you would make a right into unit number one, and you go up another flight of steps for unit number two, which is the third and fourth floors.

Similar wording

So, you know, again, well-attended meeting that took place on July 22nd.

Similar wording

This is our proof of notice.

Similar wording

Our application for appeal that was filed on behalf of the applicant along the notice of refusal.

Similar wording

Our project information form, the deeds of property, and, you know, I think they did a change in the use based on the six single families that are in the front.

Similar wording

And then finally, a certificate showing no taxes are owed for any of these properties.

Similar wording

all right with that being said i'm going to unshare my screen just so everyone can see each

Similar wording

other right and then i can always go back and forth between the drawings but like i said there's

Similar wording

a lot going on here technically from you know from a zoning code perspective i think these are

Similar wording

unique circumstances i think my client did an excellent job of of of responsibly using this

Similar wording

property and shown what they're going to do planning-wise, but more importantly, they've

Similar wording

shown it by action with those six single families that they started construction with, you know,

Similar wording

as of right. I would ask that Mr. Harris virtually raise his hand. I have a few questions for him,

Similar wording

and then myself or Mr. Harris can answer any questions support may have. Thank you. Mr. Harris.

Similar wording

Jonathan Harris, please unmute yourself and wait for the chair.

Similar wording

Hi, Mr. Harris.

Similar wording

Hello, how are you doing?

Similar wording

I'm great. Could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Yes, my name is Jonathan Harris, spelled J-O-N-A-T-H-A-N, last name Harris, spelled H-A-R-R-I-S.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Please proceed, Counselor.

Similar wording

Yes, Mr. Harris, you heard everything I had to state today about your zoning matter.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And is it true and correct?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And do you adopt as your own testimony?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Questions from the board?

Similar wording

I have a couple of questions, but I just want to say that the really appreciate the quality of the architecture that was done for this project, the quality of the materials, the way that it sort of fits in context with the neighbor, I think works.

Similar wording

Right. Thank you.

Similar wording

No question. Two questions. What's happening with the two legs at the end, at the back of the property that extend to either street? Are they just as just going to be horned off or what?

Similar wording

Warren Dolph or what? Two narrow strips, the narrow strip of property that goes from one street to the other.

Similar wording

two narrow strips

Similar wording

the strip

Similar wording

Yeah, coming from Magnolia and going to those driveways, essence you're speaking of, correct?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Okay. If I could, I also would like to bring in a business partner as well as co-owner on this project.

Similar wording

His name is Lenard Gay. He can speak also more in detail on the project as he's been there pretty much every day.

Similar wording

He's seeing this project as well. Would it be possible to have him bring Mr. Gay on, please?

Similar wording

Can we go back to the site plan? Yeah, sure.

Similar wording

Lenard Gay, if you're in the virtual audience, please raise your hand.

Similar wording

the dark gray please unmute yourself and wait for the chair

Similar wording

and mr gay could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer

Similar wording

mr gay

Similar wording

while we're waiting for uh i'm sorry hello

Similar wording

Hi, could you please state your name and spell for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Sure.

Similar wording

Lenard Gay, L-I-N-A-R-D, last name Gay, G-E-Y.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

All right, just stand by and we'll have a few questions.

Similar wording

As far as the, just to reiterate on that question, right now there will just be used as just walkways to the property.

Similar wording

Um, we haven't really, uh, came up with a better plan than that for those driveways, um, as the size doesn't really, uh, commit to much, uh, other than the walkway.

Similar wording

Yeah. John, those are more pedestrian, when you're saying driveway, you mean more pedestrian walkways.

Similar wording

Yes. Pedestrian walkway. I'm sorry.

Similar wording

Okay. So that's, that's a walkway that's going to be paved from side to side.

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

What about how are you dealing with the pedestrian walkways out to the main street?

Similar wording

I see pads in front of the entrances into the units, which is a good thing.

Similar wording

I'm concerned about pedestrians who want to walk to the main street through this sort of through the carriage house entrance.

Similar wording

Is there a walkway there?

Similar wording

well we have a 25 foot driveway um which i believe give us we we to be quite honest i i

Similar wording

i haven't even um i i've been doing i've been on construction on that site every day

Similar wording

And I actually, to be quite honest with you, haven't even thought about that walkway as far as the driveway.

Similar wording

okay so so so like the project generally that's always a concern for me as pedestrians or

Similar wording

vehicular traffic and how do they how do they how do you separate them so um there really needs to

Similar wording

be some kind of pedestrians defined walkway out of what is really a parking lot where people are

Similar wording

living on right to get out to the main street if pedestrians or kids want to go in and out we want

Similar wording

to make sure that they're safe that's a that's a concern so and i didn't see it in the plan i know

Similar wording

that the architect here is thoughtful so that's something that yeah should be there if it's not

Similar wording

yeah so i yes that's clearly a you know an oversight on our part and given the size of the

Similar wording

of the driveways 25 feet i i think that's something i'm not the architect but i think that

Similar wording

given my experience i think it's something we could definitely accommodate yeah there's a

Similar wording

got it on uh this call would she be able to she's our architect i'm not sure yeah so i know that she

Similar wording

was traveling for she was traveling today she said that obviously she would try her best to be on so

Similar wording

i don't know if a god is on but you know yeah we we have spoke to her about that and what i

Similar wording

understand is there is like a different color walkway that is going to be um dedicated for

Similar wording

that reason um i'm not just sure exactly how that's going to be laid out on the uh on the

Similar wording

actual plans but um there was conversation of that that way pedestrians are um understand which

Similar wording

is you know what what's available to them to use thank you overall quality

Similar wording

i'm not sure if the board can hear me oh there you go hi could you please could could you please

Similar wording

state your name is spelled for the stenographer um good afternoon agatha reister with landmark

Similar wording

architectural design a-g-a-t-a-r-e-i-s-t-e-r you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

nothing but the truth i do

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Proceed, counsel.

Similar wording

Given the nature of the width of the carriage house, we will implement a differentiation in the pavement materials just so the drivers and the pedestrian can basically see the designation between the walkable area and the drivable area just to keep people a little bit more safe.

Similar wording

safe. And also, we could as well implement any reflective mirrors that could be installed inside

Similar wording

the carriage house walls just to see any oncoming traffic as well, or pedestrians.

Similar wording

And just to piggyback off that, Agata, those are in the renderings somewhere, aren't they?

Similar wording

They were in the renderings for the rear portion, but as the board has noticed,

Similar wording

They were not implemented in the carriage house portion, which that's the area that is very important.

Similar wording

So we will add that to the scope of work.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Got it.

Similar wording

Other questions?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

The size of the duplex units, you said that you gave the square footage and bedrooms and baths for the single family.

Similar wording

What about the duplexes, please?

Similar wording

1500 square feet for the 1500 square feet for the duplexes and they're each three bedroom uh

Similar wording

three bath units oh actually i'm sorry the unit number one the lower level unit is three bedrooms

Similar wording

three baths uh the upper level unit is three bedrooms two baths uh and in the carriage house

Similar wording

Each unit is two-bedroom, one-bath, and they're 1,100 square feet.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

And am I reading this plan correctly that basically this will be – the other buildings are basically going to be landlocked?

Similar wording

It'll be all the time.

Similar wording

Yeah, it's completely landlocked.

Similar wording

And I think that's the issue is we have a 28,000-square-foot lot out – you know,

Similar wording

behind us on the sharp neck that's a magnolia street address with a letter r behind but yes

Similar wording

we completely we're landlocked in the sense of there's you know it's elevated behind us we do

Similar wording

have as mr johns pointed out we do have egress like a walkway to public streets in the rear

Similar wording

for pedestrian access so so my question would be about um what are we doing about uh access for

Similar wording

like emergency and fire vehicles I mean I know that's not necessarily part of what we look at

Similar wording

here but um again has there been thought about that and how that might be handled yeah so like

Similar wording

we have a 25 uh uh our width of our driveway in the front is 25 feet and then as you can see

Similar wording

there's a good flow and let me just uh share my screen again and i think it's just better with

Similar wording

the renderings more so but let me just try to do that but you see here even this this is like

Similar wording

basically there's good flow and even for you know trash pickup you know we created a community

Similar wording

within this community um that's open to the community it's not gated um but like you know

Similar wording

we try to have that flow created and i think maybe it's even better i think it's a rendering

Similar wording

above rendering you can see the amount of of flow here within the heart of that community which

Similar wording

would be more than sufficient for not just trash trucks but god forbid there's an issue with a

Similar wording