civus
Hearing audio

ZBA Hearing - January 21, 2026

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Jan 21, 20266h 17m

is on this map just because it's turned differently on where the the map that i have on right now

Similar wording

correct so it should be right here where my cursor is on the corner of is that 20 23rd and

Similar wording

Passiunk, right? And like Rittner, 23rd Street and Passiunk?

Similar wording

24th and Passiunk, right here.

Similar wording

Okay. So I guess my question about the illumination is, do you know if this is going to have any

Similar wording

impact on the neighbors that are living on the north side of Passiunk? Because there are a number

Similar wording

of residential blocks just north of there.

Similar wording

Which is Dorada State, I think, right?

Similar wording

Yeah, it is. We have the sign vendors also on the phone or on the call if you want him to testify

Similar wording

to any illumination. Directly across is this commercial pad right here. So I can have him

Similar wording

testify to any illumination. I will tell you that at the RCO meeting, we did have a large number of

Similar wording

people that were present for it. And again, received that unanimous letter of support from

Similar wording

those individuals. I just want to make sure because like right now there's less signs. And

Similar wording

even in this photo, I mean like the Blockbuster video sign is no longer illuminated, right? So

Similar wording

i think you've got a sign that has like 10 different stores are all 10 of them illuminated

Similar wording

like have we have we measured the lumens that are going to be coming off of that sign

Similar wording

greg there is more signage visible on that sign than the others that we're looking at in reference

Similar wording

so my sign vendor is on the on the line if he can raise his hand we can have his name his name is

Similar wording

greg greg and i know just from drive like being in cars over there though only illuminated sign

Similar wording

at night is the 711 which is much lower and below the tree level versus this one that's

Similar wording

above the tree level all the others are turned off are not illuminated

Similar wording

greg

Similar wording

target's coming in now okay thank you

Similar wording

what's the blue sign across the street there that's the this right here this would have been

Similar wording

the blockbuster blockbuster okay yeah so i was like that's not on blockbuster that's like like

Similar wording

20 years i don't even think that sign is there in real life right now all we're all about vintage

Similar wording

vintage yeah so that is an antique i mean my goodness it's protected by the art commission

Similar wording

no were there signs on this uh on these uh piles before i don't believe that there were signs on it

Similar wording

um i believe that the pilings were erected in anticipation of erecting this sign

Similar wording

but i can also ask the sign vendor that question as well right is greg on the line

Similar wording

yes greg you're free to speak hello okay greg could you please state your name and spell for

Similar wording

the stenographer name is greg feld g-r-e-g-f-e-l-d do you swear affirm to tell the truth

Similar wording

told truth nothing but the truth i do could you turn to your video one i thought it was where's

Similar wording

yet okay am i on there council council yeah yeah you're good all right greg um can you just state

Similar wording

your name and title real quick greg feld uh permit expediter uh kc sign company all right now

Similar wording

Greg Feld, permit expediter, KC Sign Company.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Now, Greg, I don't know if you heard the question that was asked by Ms. Wynn,

Similar wording

but do you have any information that you can provide to the zoning board with regards to the illumination?

Similar wording

The illumination, each, the entire sign is comprised of individual illuminated cabinets.

Similar wording

There's, I think, probably like three to each one will have separate tenant panels for the tenants in there.

Similar wording

you can see from the drawing that they're all different sizes so um the illumination each

Similar wording

cabinet will be interiorly illuminated with um we used to use fluorescent bulbs all the uh

Similar wording

everything i was used is uh led lights but they're not like the led message board that you see with

Similar wording

anything flashing or scrolling or anything no animation they're all interior upgrades of old

Similar wording

fluorescent bulbs and um they will be acrylic faces white acrylic faces over the illumination

Similar wording

there are strings of leds that are us installed inside the cabinet so there will be acrylic faces

Similar wording

over them and then each individual tenant will have their name and a logo you know whatever else

Similar wording

on each individual face the pen shopping center the tenants um a lot of the panels at least in

Similar wording

old sign uh to answer another question we've brought up there was a previous sign on these

Similar wording

pipelines um it might have come down 10 or so years ago it was a little while ago there was

Similar wording

a sign here before that was um a different configuration but it uh more or less the same

Similar wording

square feet and then that was taken down and the pilings have been uh empty for uh or just

Similar wording

uninhabited for uh several years now i thought there was i thought there were signs they put

Similar wording

was the previous sign also eliminated yes and since these aesthetic bulbs it cannot be dimmed

Similar wording

once installed right so like it's either on or off correct yeah i was a question i guess my

Similar wording

question for the op for the owner is the plan to leave this on overnight is it going to be on 24 7

Similar wording

or what we can say and i don't mean to cut you off is if you want to put in as a condition that

Similar wording

it shuts off after a certain time you know it can't be on um during a certain period of time

Similar wording

I don't think my client would have any objection to that uh if that's the one of the conditions

Similar wording

that the zoning board would be inclined to do I have no other question I mean if that should

Similar wording

that yeah I mean the nobody if the neighbors didn't say anything I just these are the questions that

Similar wording

i would have um i don't know what's your thoughts

Similar wording

okay how about midnight to 5a

Similar wording

okay i think that's fine all right other questions from the board questions from our attorney

Similar wording

hillary emerson um no i just uh in terms of crafting that um proviso just um no illumination

Similar wording

between 12 a.m and 5 a.m but thank you uh questions from the virtual audience or this audience

Similar wording

there are no aims um planning commission

Similar wording

amy boyd with the planning commission amy boyd you swear or affirm to tell the truth the whole

Similar wording

truth and nothing but the truth. Yes. Please proceed. The comprehensive plan recommends no

Similar wording

change in zoning at this location to the current CMX3 commercial mixed use. This property is in

Similar wording

harmony with the auto-oriented shopping center of the property. The proposal was previously

Similar wording

approved and the structure for the sign already exists. The Planning Commission recommends that

Similar wording

the board grant their requested variances for sign area and height. So MI 2025-005-378-2350

Similar wording

west pass shotgun no i vote yes proviso no illuminated signage from 12a to 5a johns my

Similar wording

vote is yes with proviso cheryl guest and my vote is yes with proviso tenetta graham my vote is yes

Similar wording

with proviso ryan mcadams my vote is yes with proviso i win my vote is yes with proviso no

Similar wording

all right thank you thank you very much everyone appreciate you number one

Similar wording

MI 2025-001-083, 249 East Cambridge Street.

Similar wording

Vern Anastasio is the attorney.

Similar wording

Vern is coming in as a panelist.

Similar wording

Okay, thank you.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Mr. Chair.

Similar wording

Counsel, just for the record, could you state your name? You've already been sworn.

Similar wording

Counsel, just for the record, could you state your name?

Similar wording

You've already been sworn.

Similar wording

Yes, Vern Anastasia.

Similar wording

Yes, Vern Anastasio on behalf of Ms. Judith Ciceron.

Similar wording

Okay. Our vice chair has a few questions.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, counsel. Have you submitted your documents and exhibits five days in advance of this hearing?

Similar wording

Yes, ma'am.

Similar wording

And do you waive the reading of the refusal and stipulate to its accuracy?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording

Okay. Thank you. You can share your screen and proceed with your case.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Okay, 249 East Cambria is for the legalization of a pre-existing non-conforming two-family dwelling.

Similar wording

We did meet with the 7th Ward RCO. We met this several months ago, and despite my efforts, I do not have any information from Mr. Cruz as of today, but that doesn't mean they haven't sent something over. I just did not receive it.

Similar wording

we have nothing okay I didn't think so it's a legalization of a two-family dwelling and

Similar wording

I have a 75 page exhibit packet that I'm moving into evidence

Similar wording

I'm going to pull out and show you the plans I have

Similar wording

it's a two-story row Mr. Anastasio question who did you say your client was again

Similar wording

Is she part of the Pure Rock Real Estate LLC entity?

Similar wording

That's her.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

All right.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Yeah.

Similar wording

This is what we have here.

Similar wording

this is the existing first floor plan just come through the the front of and then we have a living

Similar wording

room kitchen and a bedroom in the rear we have a full bath between the kitchen and the bedroom

Similar wording

there is a door from the bedroom to the yard. And then the second floor

Similar wording

would be a living room in the front with a kitchen in the center and a bedroom in the rear.

Similar wording

The kitchen already exists. I recommended that they take what was an old bedroom in the front

Similar wording

and turn that into use that as living space but this is existing this kitchen

Similar wording

and then there's a bedroom in the rear

Similar wording

show you some photos

Similar wording

As you can see, there are separate electric meters that came with the house, one for each of the units, plus a common area.

Similar wording

The basement is just storage and utilities.

Similar wording

There's the second kitchen.

Similar wording

two water heaters

Similar wording

there are some aerials

Similar wording

there are several uh two family dwellings in the immediate block area as well as kip street

Similar wording

there's proof of posting

Similar wording

there's the flyer that went to everyone that not only invited everyone to the seventh ward

Similar wording

Registered Community Organization meeting, but also today's hearing of 194 individual households were mailed.

Similar wording

I'm also moving into evidence, the proof of tax compliance, the deed.

Similar wording

And all 75 pages in addition to any additional materials that were sent out here, the listing of the property.

Similar wording

And I think is important to see as well, and I'd like to now call my client with Judas Ciceron to the stand.

Similar wording

that I think is important to see as well.

Similar wording

Judith Ciceroon has been promoted I could you please state your name is spelled for the

Similar wording

stenographer

Similar wording

hello hi could you please state your name is spelled for the stenographer

Similar wording

Judith Cicero, J-U-D-I-T-H-C-I-C-E-O-N.

Similar wording

Right.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I swear.

Similar wording

Counsel?

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Ms. Cicero, did you hear my presentation to the board today?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Is it true and accurate to the best of your knowledge?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

And do you adopt it as your own testimony?

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

I have no questions from the board.

Similar wording

Yes, I have a question, Vern.

Similar wording

could you pull up the image again of the second floor bathroom second floor bathroom yeah because

Similar wording

you were going through and they weren't labeled i just want to see the second floor bathroom

Similar wording

if we can find it and then um i'm assuming the utilities for both units are in the basement

Similar wording

but only the first unit has access to the basement so what's the management plan

Similar wording

And for if the second floor tenant needs to access meters.

Similar wording

They can contact the owner of the management company for access to the basement.

Similar wording

And then I'm assuming the owner is going to be offsite, that these are both, this is an investment property.

Similar wording

Ms. Cicerron, you're not occupying either of the unit, is that correct?

Similar wording

Correct.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Ms. Cicerron, could you assist in identifying the bathroom on the second floor?

Similar wording

I'm going to scroll, okay?

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

This is it.

Similar wording

That there?

Similar wording

Yep.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Other questions, you know, I always have the issue with having to go through a bedroom to go to the backyard as problematic for me trash, etc.

Similar wording

So that's that's a that's just a nonstarter as far as I'm concerned for this project. What is the goal around trash? What's the process?

Similar wording

Interior storage for both units. They both have plenty of space for storage inside each of the units. The layout was as it was how she found it. This wasn't built out. There's no building permits pulled.

Similar wording

So I understand the preference not to have access from the yard to a bedroom, but that is the way she found the property, and it was purchased that way.

Similar wording

Are there other duplexes on the block?

Similar wording

Yes, more than more than more.

Similar wording

How many?

Similar wording

I can't say that they're all legalized, but I counted half a dozen.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

and the other concern is these these are small houses but not they're not real big houses they

Similar wording

were probably about 1100 square feet maybe if that were two three bedroom house so yeah she

Similar wording

when she bought it i mean it has a second kitchen on the second floor i understand yeah i just

Similar wording

understand i understand how she bought it um but but it's an opportunity for a for uh you know for

Similar wording

someone who may not be able to rent an entire house in order to get some housing.

Similar wording

I hear you. And we hear you, sir. Other questions? Questions from our attorney?

Similar wording

Not at this time, Mr. Chair. Questions or comments from the audience, the virtual audience?

Similar wording

No, Haynes. Planning Commission.

Similar wording

Amy Boyd with the planning commission. The comprehensive plan recommends no change to the RSA 5 residential single family zoning at this location. The property received rental license in 2017 and in October 2024 for one family rental. There is no evidence that the conversion to two family was done.

Similar wording

for one family rental there is no evidence that the conversion to two family was done with the

Similar wording

benefit of permits the planning commission recommends that the board deny the proposed

Similar wording

use variance for two dwelling units thank you council we're going we'll vote on this next week

Similar wording

uh next wednesday we'll vote at 2 pm after we take it to executive session okay thank you

Similar wording

mr chair i just want to for the record i just want to put on the record that my client fully

Similar wording

intends to get a administrative co that will of course uh be subject to an inspection to ensure

Similar wording

that whatever work was done prior to her purchase was in fact uh does in fact meet the international

Similar wording

building code thank you very much thank you all right number two mi2025-005-215-1024 south

Similar wording

6th street al knockamson is the attorney there is a letter of non-opposition from council member

Similar wording

Squill and a letter of non-opposition from Bella Vista Neighbors Association.

Similar wording

Oh boy. I'm trying to get it up and running. Okay.

Similar wording

So here's what we could do. Here's what we could do is I got, I think I have two cases

Similar wording

Then I have two more with you. Try to get, as I do the two cases, try to get it fixed. Then we'll do all yours right in a row. Right. Thank you.

Similar wording

Number three, MI 2025-005-223-1813 Ranstead Street. Andrea Solomon is the attorney.

Similar wording

Good afternoon, counsel. Could you please state your name and spell it for the stenographer?

Similar wording

Good afternoon, Andrea Solomon, A-N-D-R-E-A-S-A-L-O-M-O-N.

Similar wording

Do you swear or affirm to tell the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth?

Similar wording

I do.

Similar wording