civus

Committee Hearing, December 15, 2009

Minutes from Philadelphia City Council Committee Hearings, Dec 15, 2009

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA JOINT COMMITTEES ON PUBLIC HEALTH and HUMAN SERVICES and LEGISLATIVE OVERSIGHT - - - Room 400, City Hall Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Tuesday, December 15, 2009, 10:10 a.m. - - - RES. 090753 - Authorizing the Joint Committees on Public Health and Human Services and Legislative Oversight to hold public hearings on adoption and foster care policies and programs in the City of Philadelphia and to explore ways to improve the process by decreasing wait times, implementing strategies to reduce the number of children that age out of the system, and address concerns that discourage people from considering adoption. COMMITTEE MEMBERS PRESENT: James F. Kenney, Chair Marian B. Tasco, Co-Chair William K. Greenlee Curtis Jones, Jr. Donna Reed Miller Brian J. O'Neill - - - V A R A L L O Incorporated Litigation Support Specialists 1835 Market Street, Suite 600 Philadelphia, Pennsylvania 19103 215.561.2220 215.567.2670 2 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Good morning, ladies and gentlemen. The committee is now in session. There's no 5 need for a quorum; there will be no 6 legislation that's coming out of committee today. This is a joint committee on Public Health and Human Services and Legislative Oversight. I'd first like to make a few comments relative to our work here today. I want to thank you all for being here today, and this hearing aims to expand the understanding of the foster care and adoption system and discuss ways to decrease wait times for adoption, implement new strategies that will reduce the number of children that age out of the system, and address concerns that discourage people from considering adoption. This issue is certainly sensitive and involves thousands of personal unique stories. Commissioner Ambrose and her staff are to be commended 3 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 for their hard work, dedication, and advocacy for all of the children here, in Philadelphia, who are waiting for permanent families. However, given the complicated situations and unfortunate circumstances that many of these young people come from, it is not surprising that there are also criticisms and suggestions for improvement. Today's hearing will focus on having an open and honest conversation on the issues that plague DHS, additional improvements that the department can make, and enhance coordination that can occur to improve the overall experience for everyone involved. In addition to focusing on constructive feedback, today's hearing will also recognize the significant improvements that Commissioner Ambrose and her staff have made at DHS to increase adoptions and permanent legal custodianship and decrease the number of 4 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 children in placement. So with that, we would ask Commissioner Ambrose to please come forward and begin her testimony. (Witnesses come forward.)

Councilman Kenney

Are there any members of the panel who have any comments at this time? (No response.)

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much. Good morning. Please identify yourself for the record. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Good morning. Anne Marie Ambrose, Commissioner of the Department of Human Services.

Councilman Kenney

Please procede.

Mr. Meriweather

Del Meriweather, Deputy Commission for Children and Youth.

Councilman Kenney

Good morning. Please proceed with your 5 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 testimony. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Good morning, Councilman Kenney and members of City Council and staff. I am Anne Marie Ambrose, Commissioner of the Philadelphia Department of Human Services. I welcome the opportunity to testify on Resolution 9 090753 and to share with you the tremendous strides that DHS is making to assist Philadelphia's children. Since I became commissioner 13 months ago, I have been dedicated to 14 working with my leadership team at DHS to 15 create a sense of urgency for better 16 outcomes for Philadelphia's children. 17 And I am proud to report that there are 18 measurable positive results of these efforts. Among our many accomplishments: We are decreasing the number of children in placement; Decreasing wait times for children in DHS's care to achieve permanency; And implementing strategies to 6 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 increase permanency and/or life connections and other supports for older youth. We have dramatically increased the numbers of adoptions and permanent legal custodianships. One of the major measures our success is the outcomes of performance- based contracting. That demonstrates DHS's commitment to permanency for children. Permanency can be either reunification, which is our preferred permanency result, with a parent or guardian, or adoption or permanent custodianship. PBC has resulted in record numbers of children moving to permanency as well as reducing the length of stay and care. For those who are unfamiliar with PBC, it began to be implemented in March of 2003 and changed the structure of foster care contracts, creating incentives for providers to achieve more timely permanencies. 7 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Since PBC's implementation, a record number of children have been moved to permanency: 8,073 have achieved permanent living situations over the last six fiscal years; Permanency for both foster care and kinship care have more than doubled across the system; And the instability rate has decreased by one-third. 9 months between 2002 and 2009; For children who were adopted, the average length of stay decreased five 8 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 months between 2002 and 2009; And in collaboration with Family Court and our system and community partners, in the last two years alone, we have had a 27 percent increase in adoptions and a percent increase in 8 permanent legal custodianships. 9 Currently, there are 659 10 children in DHS's care who have been 11 legally freed for adoption. It is 12 important to note that the vast majority 13 of children who are adopted from DHS care 14 are adopted from either existing foster 15 or kinship families. 16 For example, in Fiscal Year 17 2009, of the 449 children adopted, 188 18 children were adopted from kinship care 19 and 259 were adopted from foster homes. 20 Of all of the children with the goal of 21 adoption, there are currently only 32 22 children for whom DHS is seeking to 23 identify a resource family. 24 With regard to these children, 25 as I will discuss in greater detail in my 9 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 testimony, DHS is working diligently with providers and others partners, such as the National Adoption Center, to identify pre-adoptive homes for these children's. We will continue to explore ways to remove barriers to the adoption process, as we understand that any delay in achieving permanency can be painful for the children and families involved. Because child safety is of paramount concern for DHS, DHS has implemented the safety model of practice, which incorporates a safety assessment into all aspects of decision-making throughout the life of a family's interaction.

Councilman Kenney

Within this framework, DHS is deeply committed to identifying and implementing placement reduction strategies to decrease the number of children in care, because, as evidence shows, with the right supports, children are best served with their own families. We have a vast continuum of 10 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 in-home services in place in order to keep children safe in their own homes whenever possible. In all of these efforts, we are working in conjunction with our essentials partners Judge Dougherty and Family Court. However, as the resolution 9 acknowledges, in some instance, placement may be necessary to ensure child safety and the well-being while DHS works with the family to build upon the family's existing strengths and addresses concerns before a child is reunified with the family. Reuniting children with their birth parents is a preferred form of permanency. In the past year, DHS has identified and implemented family-group decision-making as a strategy to engage and empower families to make decisions that develop plans and protect and nurture their children in an effort to reduce the need for placement in the first place or to expedite reunification 11 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 or permanency. As a result of these efforts, there are fewer children in placement with DHS. 8 percent from 5,754 cases to 5,075. And with increased collaboration with our system partners, private providers, Community Behavioral Health, and Family Court, we have reduced the number of children in out-of-state placement by 56 percent in the past year alone, from 144 children to 46, resulting in children being placed closer to home and family connections. One major challenge facing DHS is that although the overall number of children in care has decreased, the population for older youth in DHS's care has grown by 2 percent. These older youth are at risk for aging out of the system without achieving permanency or identifying or developing supportive adults in their lives and with little 12 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 preparation to live on their own. DHS has multiple strategies and initiatives to address the needs of older youth as they prepare to transition to adulthood. Given our understanding of the importance of supporting older youth as they transition out of care, especially for those who are not achieving permanency, DHS makes many efforts to keep older youth in care until they are 21. In fact, DHS has the largest number in the Commonwealth of youth on board extensions. These are youth 16 years or older and who are in school or 17 receiving treatment, who can remain in 18 care until they are 21 years old. Yet, achieving permanency for these youth as well as all children in care continues to be our priority. We recognize that outreach in public awareness is essential in order to generate interest in providing foster care and adoption. 13 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Philadelphia was selected by Casey Family Programs to collaborate with Community Partners, and we have launched "Raise Me Up," a powerful, multi-media campaign designed to heighten awareness about the needs of children in foster care and child-related services and to recruit volunteers. The campaign was launched in September of 2009 at a press conference at the Lincoln Financial Field, with Mayor Nutter, Supreme Court Justice Max Baer, and Eagles Player Jeremy Maclin as the campaign spokesperson, and it features a series of television ads, which aired on network and cable stations. And we just wanted to show those ads very briefly. ) * * * COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Those are some of the reasons why the work that DHS does is so important. I think you'll 14 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 hear more about it from some of the community partners who are going to be testifying today.

Councilman Kenney

But, as you can see, sadly, there remain youth whose parents' parental rights have been terminated, and yet, no adopted or permanent legal custodian resource has been identified and who, therefore, have a goal of another permanent-plan living arrangement. Our adoption unit is creating a pilot project that we hope to start in January of 2010, which will work specifically with these youth to identify permanency resources, assist with development of transition plans, and referrals to services. All of these youths are eligible to receive services from DHS's Achieving Independence Center, which is designed to assist youth 16 years and older to prepare them for independence. AIC is designed to help young people 15 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 achieve their future goals of self-sufficiency. Offering non-traditional hours, flexible scheduling, and onsite job training, the AIC is dedicated to providing support and real life tools for youth, including housing and education services. Other services and programs focus on education, hands-on job-training and employment, and life-skills training. DHS believes that every child has the right to a loving, nurturing, and permanent family, and that people from a variety of life experiences offer strengths for these children. DHS has a nondiscrimination policy, which prohibits a discrimination based on sexual orientation and gender identity, as well as all of the other protected categories such as race, sex, ethnicity, and national origin. With the existence of the added youth center, new DHS staff receive training to ensure that they are 16 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 sensitive to the needs of this population. Existing staff are also offered training, and we have sponsored several brown-bag lunches on topics relevant to serving LGBT population. In addition, our adoption unit has consulted with the national rights campaign All Children All Families Project. In collaboration with NAC, some DHS receive training to engage LGBT families as possible resources. While we know anecdotally that there are many members of the LGBT community who adopt children who are in DHS's care, DHS does not currently collect data on the number of LGBT families that adopt children, nor do we collect other demographic data on adoptive families. Going forward, we plan to collect this data to measure our progress in this area. Finally, we want to ensure that those families who do adopt are aware of resources that support their efforts. We 17 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 encourage adoptive parents to attain the resources that may be available to them if they adopt children, including the adoption tax credit, which is now referenced in our adoption subsidy agreement. Our community partner Tap Link has also developed educational materials about the adoption tax credit that have been distributed at community events cosponsored by DHS, such as National Adoption Day. Despite the tremendous progress that DHS has made, we know that there is a long way to go. We have increased accountability by creating the Division of Performance Management and Accountability, which measures and monitors outcomes for children served by DHS. We are using data-driven and evidence-based measures to track the efficiency and effectiveness of our services, both internal and external. 18 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 And we have implemented Child Stat, while randomly selected cases are reviewed in-depth by a cross section of DHS management and staff to target and correct impediments to progress and continually improve performance. We have also developed a five-year strategic plan aimed at establishing realistic goals and objectives consistent with our mission and core values. Of course, permanency for youth in our care is one of our key goals.

Councilman Kenney

We are eager to continue to improve our performance and welcome your suggestions on how to achieve better outcomes for children in our care. Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much. (Addressing Mr. Meriweather.) Are you going to offer testimony? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: No, just help me answer the questions. 19 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Okay. Just for information sake, what age does the child attain when they are considered an older youth? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: We look at them as and older. And we 8 considered older youth and start working 9 on some of the efforts to engage them in 10 life skills and those kinds of things. 11

Councilman Kenney

And that's 12 currently now 12 to 21? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Correct.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. How many children are in that category in Philadelphia County?

Mr. Meriweather

Approximately 45 percent of our children are within the ages of 12 and older.

Councilman Kenney

And what is the aggregate number?

Mr. Meriweather

5,075, I believe, today.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. And they're in various stages of either in 20 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 foster care or kinship care, and the goal is for their adoption, the ultimate goal. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Correct, permanency, which can take the form of adoption, reunification, or permanent legal custodianship.

Councilman Kenney

Okay, okay. Are there any questions for the witnesses? Councilwoman Miller.

Councilwoman Miller

Good morning. Good morning. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Good morning.

Councilwoman Miller

Can you further define "permanency"? What is "permanency," particularly for a young person that's aged out? Or what exactly is permanency? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Permanency is finding a permanent, loving, stable resource for that child. And it can manifest itself in a variety of different ways. 21 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Legally, that child can achieve permanency through adoption or permanent legal custodianship or reunification. And traditionally, the system -- and this is a national issue, not just a Philadelphia issue. The system hasn't necessarily focused on permanency for older youth. So this goal that we talked about, the (indiscernible), that is sort of a long-term foster care goal, and we don't have long-term foster care since the adoption of the state Families Act. So the system has had to readjust itself, 'cause when you speak to older youth, they want permanency for themselves; they want a permanent, loving, stable home. And their needs are pretty intense as they grow older.

Councilwoman Miller

Well, don't you think that permanency for youth aging out could help that maybe prevent some of what we saw in this film? And I've seen the commercials 22 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 on TV, and I couldn't figure out whether you wanted families to adopt or whether you just want volunteers and volunteers to do what. But, you know, the first couple times I saw the commercials, I thought they were very interesting, and I thought they were good, but I really didn't know what you wanted. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: So the goal of Raise Me Up, the slogan is, "You don't have to raise a child to raise them up. Just let them know you care." And the goals that Philadelphia has chosen for the Raise Me Up campaign are recruitment of foster and adoptive families, mentoring, and older youth. And so, there's been a series of stories that Channel 6 has done on each of those areas. And some of the assistance to older youth is just volunteering at an after-school program or tutoring, 'cause some people don't want to make a full commitment of being 23 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 an adoptive or foster parent, but there are little things that they can do that contribute to the lives of these older youth, volunteering at the Achieving Independence Center. So Women's Christian Alliance is one of our community partners, and they followed a mentor volunteer who went and worked with some of the children there in an art class. So there's a variety of different community partners that we've selected to assist in all of these goals.

Councilwoman Miller

Okay. I could probably sit here and ask you a million questions, but I won't.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. You had indicated earlier, in answer to my question, that 45 percent of the children in the system are 12 to 21. How many children younger than 12 in the aggregate are in the system? So you said there was 5,000 or so 12 to 21. How many children in the 24 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 system younger than 12?

Mr. Meriweather

That would be about 55 percent of 5,000 children.

Councilman Kenney

Oh, it's 5,000. I'm sorry. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: 5,000.

Councilman Kenney

The universe is 5,000?

Mr. Meriweather

Yes. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Right.

Councilman Kenney

And 45 percent are 12 to 21.

Mr. Meriweather

Yes.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. Part of the reason for this hearing is to kind of understand the process, 'cause a lot of us -- I know I don't, and when we started getting into this, I still have questions of how things actually work. DHS contracts or has relationships with agencies that place or attempt to place children in some permanency? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Correct. 25 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 We have a contract with foster care agencies, and actually, some kids are in different levels of care group, so they might be in a group-home situation, but it's most likely to be a foster-care situation.

Councilman Kenney

Are all of these private agencies or nonprofit agencies, are they all attempting to move the child to permanency, whether it is reunification, whether it is adoption, or a custodianship? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yes. And, in fact, as a part of the performance-based contracting, there are incentives for those private agencies to be successful in getting permanency outcomes.

Councilman Kenney

Financial incentives? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yes, financial incentives in that that they fewer cases for those cases that they move to permanency. So ultimately, they 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 can reinvest the resources for the contract into the work that they do.

Councilman Kenney

And you had indicated in your testimony that your department abides by all the non -- all of the federal laws that are nondiscriminatory relative to who you deal with, who you try to place children with, who you try to get to adopt children. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Correct.

Councilman Kenney

Are all of the agencies that you contract with required to follow the same nondiscriminatory policies? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: They are, and I think there are some providers who do a better job of that. For instance, we have about agencies in 21 our performance-based contracting family foster care.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: About half of those actively recruit the LGBT 27 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 community. So one of them actually goes to a church that has largely LGBT members. Some of them aren't as active in recruiting; although when we did a survey of them and they know they have to follow the federal and state law, they've said that they will assist any of those families who come to their attention in moving towards adoption and permanency.

Councilman Kenney

Even if they're faith-based agencies that perhaps maybe will follow the law but don't necessarily agree with the law? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: They've -- they've claimed that they follow the law.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. Do we have ways of making sure that that's the case? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Absolutely. And this is something that's shined a light on something we need to take a closer look at, and we'll be working more closely with our providers. 28 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Over the years -- I mean, I know you've only been here months, but I know you've been in 5 in this arena or this environment for 6 many years -- have we have been able to 7 track children that age out of the 8 system? 9 I know that the commercials, 10 the PSAs bring that right close to your 11 face and heart as to what happens to 12 folks who sometimes age out of the 13 system. Have we have been able to -- I 14 know it's difficult from a homelessness 15 standpoint, but have we been able to 16 track the children or adults now that 17 have aged out and wound up incarcerated? 18 COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Not very well, although there's new federal legislation that will require the Fostering Connections Act that will require in 2011 for the states to collect that data and report it out to the federal government. So we're really working closely 29 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 with the state and will look for some direction from them on doing it.

Councilman Kenney

I guess of the children who have been in the system, and we know who they are and their names and Social Security numbers and former addresses, I mean, could we possibly do that now by going into our criminal justice system and determining whether or not there -- I mean, I know there is a relationship, you know, a connection, but to be able to quantify it in some way so that we know, as a county in the State of Pennsylvania, just how many of our kids wind up aging out and in jail. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I actually think we could do that through the care system, so I'll defer Dr. Schwarz to help us pull that data together, 'cause I think it would be very telling about --

Councilman Kenney

That would be sadly, sadly interesting. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I that's 30 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 right, I think you're right.

Councilman Kenney

Councilman Greenlee.

Councilman Greenlee

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. Just one question. I'm sorry if you maybe said this in your statement and I missed it. For the youth that attain permanency, what percentage are reunited with their original -- with their parents? How many go to adoption or custodialship? Do you have that? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I do have it.

Councilman Greenlee

Okay. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: About 63 percent -- okay, we're look at kids right now. About 63 percent return to the parent; 16 percent, adoption. These are the goals that we have. So the goals currently are 63 percent are returned to a parent, so that's our preferred permanency goal. 31 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Greenlee

Mm-hmm. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: We haven't actually done as well on reunification as we could.

Councilman Greenlee

Mm-hmm. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: We're hoping that creating the continuum of in-home services that we've recently created is going to contribute. As I stated in my testimony, DHS believes that supporting families where they are and giving them the services necessary to keep their children is our first option. And, actually, that's what the law tells us we should do.

Councilman Greenlee

Sure, sure. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: And so, while reunification is a goal for us, we haven't done as much as we should to support families.

Councilman Greenlee

Now, have those numbers changed much since you've 32 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 been studying it? You know, gone up, down?

Mr. Meriweather

The reunification rates have actually decreased by about 5 percent over the last two years.

Councilman Greenlee

Mm-hmm. Any rough idea why that would be, or just --

Mr. Meriweather

Probably the intensive focus on adoption.

Councilman Greenlee

Hmm, more focus on adoption.

Mr. Meriweather

And more permanent legal custodianships within a specific time frame, as outlined by the federal (indiscernible) regulations.

Councilman Greenlee

Okay, all right. Thank you. This thank you, Mr. Chairman.

Councilman Kenney

Just a general philosophical question about reunification versus adoption or custodianship. 33 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Although I think, as a goal, it may be wonderful to want children reunified with their parents, but is it always the best thing? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: No. 7

Councilman Kenney

And is it also more traumatic to be reunited and then be unreunited again? And, in some cases, would it be better that the child is adopted or in a different permanent situation? And, I mean, that's kind of a judgment call that you guys have to make or, you know, I guess, ultimately the agency makes or the department makes. And is it a problem? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I think it's a huge problem. I mean, first and foremost, we have to focus on safety. And if children aren't safe in their own homes, we have to remove them. And then we have to work with the parent to try to get them to be able to create an environment where that child can be safe 34 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 and won't be neglected or abused. And philosophically, we believe in that; but ultimately, children need to be safe, and so, removal is necessary. I mean, one of the things that we're really proud of at DHS is the number of children that we have in kinship care. We're leaders, I think nationally, in kinship care; we're certainly leaders in the state.

Councilman Kenney

And kinship care is a relative? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Is a relative.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Right. So if they can't go to their birth parents, we really do search through and look for family resources for them. And the outcomes for children who go to kinship as opposed to family foster care do better.

Councilman Kenney

Is there a limit on the number of reunification and 35 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 then removal situations? Or is there a point where the department says, you know, We've done this two or three times and now we're going to move in a different direction? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: We do that and also the court does, and the federal law guides us there. The Adoption and Safe Families Act says that there's a 15-month time limit on reunification, and then the court usually changes the goal from reunification to a more permanent outcome.

Councilman Kenney

And then finally for me, one of the agencies that -- is one of the agencies that you deal with these older children the Mural Arts Program at all? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: We have a contract with the Mural Arts. They do a lot of terrific work with us, with our kids, both on the juvenile justice side, on the prevention side. And recently, we supported a grant that they're trying to 36 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 get in the Strawberry Mansion section, and we actually want a woman who does some work for us at the Youth Study Center to help identify some kids in the neighborhoods who need some help. So we view Jane and the work that they do at Mural Arts as great partners.

Councilman Kenney

Great. Councilwoman Miller.

Councilwoman Miller

Thank you. I have one more questions. It seems that the numerous placements always appear -- or people always state that they've lived like in numerous homes; it's really negative in terms of outcomes. And I'm looking at outcomes for children, particularly those aging out. What is the main reason or the most common reason that children are placed from home to home? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I think the most common reason, based on the data 37 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 that we collect, is probably behavior issues. That's hard to quantify. And sometimes it's about not working closely enough with our partners in the behavioral health system to make sure that that child and the family get the supports that are necessary to stabilize the environment. But that is the most common --

Councilwoman Miller

So it's the behavior of the person in placement, not the family. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: That's right. And oftentimes, these kids have been so traumatized that sometimes they're testing out the waters and seeing whether this family is really going to stick it -- stick by me throughout the course of this. And sometimes we don't give enough training to foster parrots, and we don't provide enough support to that child to get through the tough times. And so, it's something that we're working 38 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 on.

Councilwoman Miller

So does data show that those children that are placed in maybe less homes or fewer homes are more successful? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Correct. And, actually, stability is one of the factors that we use in working with our PVC agencies; that's something they're measured on. So the number of moves, there's an incentive to not move kids around, and they really try to adhere to that.

Councilwoman Miller

Okay, all right. Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

What is the percentage of foster and kinship placements that ultimately turn into adoptive parents? I mean, is it a common thing or not as common a thing? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yeah, in Philadelphia, almost all of our adoptions, as evidenced from my testimony, turn into adoption, so -- 39 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Placements of foster care turn into adoption? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Correct. Most of kids who are ultimately adopted come from foster or kinship care situations.

Councilman Kenney

No, but I'm saying, how many folks who actually take on a foster child or kinship placement ultimately adopt the child? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I actually don't have that.

Councilman Kenney

And, again, these questions on numbers that you don't have, you know, feel free to provide it when you can get it. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Okay.

Councilman Kenney

I mean, I understand that you're not prepared for every question. Are there any other questions for these witnesses? (No further questions.)

Councilman Kenney

By the way, 40 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 I want to make sure that the record's clear that the committee today consists of Councilman O'Neill, Councilwoman Miller, Councilwoman Tasco, and Councilman Greenlee. So thank you for your testimony. PANEL MEMBERS: Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Mr. Mullner, Ken Mullner, please. (Witnesses come forward.)

Mr. Mullner

Good morning.

Councilman Kenney

Good morning. Please identify yourself for the record.

Mr. Mullner

Ken Mullner, Executive Director, National Adoption Center.

Ms. Hoffman

I'm Gloria Hoffman, Director of Communications for the National Adoption Center.

Councilman Kenney

Good morning.

Ms. Hoffman

Good morning. 41 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Whoever would like to start, please begin.

Mr. Mullner

Good morning, Councilman Kenney and members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia. I'm Ken Mullner, Executive Director of the National Adoption Center and the Adoption Center of Delaware Valley, and I'm also an adoptive dad. I appreciate this opportunity to participate in today's hearing to consider ways to improve adoption opportunities for Philadelphia children. I'd like to tell you about Alma, a 13-year-old who came from a background of abuse and neglect and who very much wanted a family who would love her and give her a good home. The first time I saw Alma was a rollerskating rink, the scene of one of the Adoption Center's semiannual adoption parties. Here potential adopters have a chance to meet and mingle with children who live in foster care, while waiting 42 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 for the permanent families they want so much. I saw a woman looking at Alma as she took her first tentative steps into the rink. It was Alma's first time on skates, and she held tight to the hand of her social worker. The woman couldn't take her eyes off Alma, and I knew that we probably had made a match here. The story has a happy ending: Alma has been living with her new family, a mom and a dad, for more than a year, and she is about to have a sister, a 14-year-old girl who will soon be joining her family. I like this story because it demonstrates what we know to be true: That once families know about the children, once they know that older children, children with emotional challenges, siblings who need homes together, are available to be adopted, they come forth to adopt them. When the Adoption Center opened 43 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 its doors 37 years ago, it didn't know whether anyone would want to adopt a child who was blind or had Down syndrome or who came with brothers and sisters. Now, 22,000 children later, we know that the first step is to let people know that the children are out there. The center has been working with the City of Philadelphia for a significant part of those 37 years, with its offer to provide visibility for its children to give them opportunities where they can be seen and heard by someone who might want to make a home for them. Many of you are probably familiar with "Wednesday's Child" on NBC 10, a twice-weekly show where former Eagle, and now sports anchor, Vai Sikahema spends time with a child waiting to be adopted. Vai goes where the children say. He has taken dance lessons, ridden a horse, and cooked chili at a midtown restaurant as the children have fun following their dreams for a 44 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 day. Some of you might hear Larry Kane of KYW News Radio every Wednesday as he interviews children who hope someone will hear their stories. The children tell Larry things like, "I want a family who will always be there for me" or "I want to wake up in the morning with the same mom and dad" or, sadly, "I want a family that won't hurt me. As all of you who still read newspapers know, the Philadelphia Inquirer has been running a "Monday's Child" column every week for more than 30 years. And the Philadelphia Tribune has been doing the same thing for the past 18 years. 19 These, along with our adoption 20 parties and other media opportunities are among the ways we try to work with Philadelphia's Department of Human Services. Both they and we have the same goals: to find permanent homes for children. And we are heartened that the 45 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 numbers of adoptions in Philadelphia have risen. Many of these children, of course, have been adopted by their foster parents, and we fully support that.

Mr. Mullner

We would like to see the numbers rise even more, especially when it is not foster parents who are able to adopt the children but newly-identified families who learn about them because they heard them on the radio or lost their hearts to them on television or were captivated by their pictures in the newspapers. These are children who might have grown up in foster care and become part of the 25,000 children who, each year, age out of the system and turn into appalling statistics: to 40 percent become 21 homeless; 22 42 percent become parents 23 themselves; 24 Only 20 percent are able to be 25 self-supporting; 46 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Only 46 percent graduate from high school; 47 percent have long periods of unemployment; And 69 percent are incarcerated at least once. In addition to this emotional toll, the financial costs of keeping children in foster care rather than placing them for adoption are staggering. Research shows that the adoption of a child from the foster care system saves, on average, $258,000 in child welfare and human services costs. For a couple of years now, we have done something unique: We have had adoption parties just for teenagers, for those children in foster care who are among the most difficult to place for adoption. We have given these parties in New Jersey, Delaware; and last year, through a grant from Pennsylvania Statewide Adoption Network, had two parties, one in South Philadelphia and 47 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 one in Pittsburgh. This year we'll be doing one in central Pennsylvania. A hundred children attended our Philadelphia party. Only ten were from Philadelphia. We would love to have a party strictly for Philadelphia's teenagers and are awaiting to hear from DHS staff about moving forward with that. We have opportunities for radio and television exposure, all done sensitively and with the children's best interests at heart, that we hope can include more Philadelphia children in the future. We'd like, two, to develop for DHS a website on which Philadelphia's children can be seen quickly and easily by potential adopters. We have developed such a website for the federal government's Department of Health and Human Services, which it believes is responsible for its significantly increased adoptions awaiting children. We are also excited about two 48 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 free opportunities that are our center can provide to DHS. Through our technology expertise, agencies can now list their services on a free online database, where potential adopters can connect with them. And we are able to offer an interactive online course from foster family to forever family to Philadelphia foster parents thinking about making that transition. We made this offer to DHS more than a year ago and keep hoping that they will take advantage of it. But, of course, adoption doesn't begin and end with public awareness and recruitment. Those interested must work with adoption agencies to see make it happen for them. And we are distressed by the complaints we hear from prospective adopters. Perhaps because we are not an adoption placement agency, families feel safe in confiding their frustrations to us. 49 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 We hear a lot about poor customer, service social workers not returning phone calls in a timely way or at all. We hear about adoption studies that take too long, dragging on sometimes for years, while the child, or children, they want linger in the system. We hear about the attitudes of adoption staff toward gay people or single people or disabled people or those interested in adopting across racial lines that effectively nudge them out of the adoption picture. We have a policy at the Adoption Center: Every contact, whether by phone, mail, or e-mail, is responded to within two business days. We think this is a model that should be adopted by every agency working in adoption.

Mr. Mullner

Prospective adopters tell us that they are frustrated about poor communication, not being told what the adoption process involves or being informed clearly of its timetable. They 50 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 don't know why it takes so long to update earlier home studies or why the home study for being a foster parent and an adoptive parent can't be done simultaneously. They don't know why it is so difficult to adopt across state or even county lines. I've heard people tell me that it is easier to adopt internationally than it is from Philadelphia. And mostly, we hear this: "I don't need. You have all of these pictures and all of this publicity saying that children are available, but when we go to agencies, they make the process so difficult, so unwieldily, so unfriendly, that we wonder what is really going on. " I know you'll be hearing from some of those frustrated adopters who will be telling you about their experience. 51 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Meanwhile, I think about Juiara. She's eight. " It affirms for her that everyone can be triumphant even after enduring difficult and trying times. But I just wonder whether that will happen for Juiara. Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much. (Addressing Ms. Hoffman.) Could you please provide your testimony? And then we'll have questions.

Ms. Hoffman

Yeah, I'm just here as a helper to answer questions.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. The criticisms that you outlined in your testimony, are they interactions between potential foster and adoptive parents with the agencies that are -- that we contract with?

Mr. Mullner

Yes. 52 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Or is it from our own employees?

Mr. Mullner

Most of the families, they're prospective families, it's their interactions with the provider organizations.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. In some ways, I do empathize with Commissioner Ambrose because of all the vast amount of responsibilities that department has, not just from this particular area, but in every other area, so I can understand from time to time a little bit of delay in interaction with our own employees. But you're saying that these are agency employees that we contract with to do this work, are not returning phone calls and not --

Mr. Mullner

To the best of my knowledge.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. And is there -- you know, obviously, we don't have a policy against interracial 53 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 adoption. Do you think that that is something that is prevalent within the system?

Mr. Mullner

I can only report what our constituent tells me, and there have been quite a few instances where people, for whatever reason, are -- they're not getting the children they hoped to get, and they're not necessarily given a straight answer as to why.

Councilman Kenney

If you could -- I mean, obviously, we have limits on our ability to change things, you know, quickly or, in some ways, at all. But I'm wondering if you have any suggestions on what we would need to do, or should be doing, either through DHS or with -- or changing the relationship between DHS and the City of Philadelphia and these agencies. What would you recommend to improve the complaints that you're hearing? 54 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Mr. Mullner

Well --

Councilman Kenney

I mean, again, you could you give me some ideas now, but you could also follow up with some issues.

Mr. Mullner

Well, to me -- to us, it comes down to pure customer service a lot of times. And, again, I just can't tell you how many times that I personally have taken calls, or a staff have taken calls, from people that say, you know, "I saw one of the children on Wednesday's Child" or "I went to one of your match parties and I fell in love with this child and I'm ready to go and I filled out all my paperwork, but I can't get anybody from the agency to return my call or respond to my e-mail." And out of that frustration, they just too often drop out of the system.

Councilman Kenney

What role does the National Adoption Center play in this process, if any at all? 55 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Mr. Mullner

Well, we have -- I guess we're a small provider for DHS. We help them deal with recruitment. But, you know, again, what we're saying is what our constituents tell us. We think we can help DHS, and that's why we are here; we want to support DHS and we want more kids adopted. And whether it's cultural competency training or customer service or helping come up with legislation that may help cut down barriers for adopting across state lines.

Councilman Kenney

Are any of these barriers able to be remedied through city legislation, or some of them state and federal laws that need to be abided by, and that delays the process?

Mr. Mullner

Well, certainly, in terms of intrastate and interstate adoptions, it's different from state to state. And, for instance, in the Commonwealth, every single county has a 56 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 different law and a different rule; whereby in New Jersey, it's the same rule that's statewide.

Councilman Kenney

Has there been any efforts in the past to interact with county officials or even state officials that would allow for a more simpler process? 'Cause it seems to me that in Philadelphia -- I mean, certainly there are a number of people in Philadelphia that want to adopt and are capable of adopting and, you know, would be good adoptive parents or foster parents. But also, I would think that in the suburban areas, where maybe their people are wealthier or have more means or their children are getting older themselves and they larger homes, that would be a pretty good match --

Councilman Kenney

-- between those folks who have the wherewithal and who want to do it and some of our kids 57 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 who are, you know, living in poverty and strife.

Mr. Mullner

One of the issues that we've had, Councilman, is, for instance, we did pay a visit to our colleagues in Montgomery County. And the response from them was that there are only eight children in all of Montgomery County that need to be adopted. And we have no way to substantiate these numbers, but we kind of find that hard to believe or fathom. But I don't know what the past may be in terms of intrastate or interstate.

Councilman Kenney

Do the people that you interact with find resistence from county officials outside of Philadelphia relative to taking Philadelphia children or being able to adopt Philadelphia children?

Ms. Hoffman

No, I think that they would allow Philadelphia children to be adopted. It really depends on the 58 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 county because they are all different. But I think you asked earlier what could be done between DHS and these provider agencies. And I think there needs to be more accountability, that agencies, unfortunately, are very different. As Anne Marie pointed out, there's not consistency among agencies in their customer service or their policies toward gay and lesbian families or interracial families. But if they're not held accountable for it, then it's not going to change.

Councilman Kenney

The Commissioner had indicated in her testimony that there are some outcome research and assessment that's being done.

Councilman Kenney

And, again, she's been here 18 months.

Ms. Hoffman

Yes, sure.

Councilman Kenney

And, you 59 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 know, I assume the system is as unwieldy as it is for a long time now and not just, you know, over the last few years.

Ms. Hoffman

Absolutely. I think she's done a really good job in moving things forward; it can't all be done at once. But that's one of the big issues. And if there was a recourse -- if a family that is having a problem had a place they could go, if there was somebody in DHS that they could call and say, This is what's happening to me, and somebody would listen to them and hear them, I think that would go a long way, and I think it would make the provider agencies a little more cognizant that they have to give good service to these people.

Councilman Kenney

'Cause, I mean, obviously, it's very clear through the initial testimony and just anecdotally that there should be an urgency to get these kids adopted in 60 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 place.

Councilman Kenney

Because, down the road, we're going to spend a lot of money, in a sad way, in dealing with the outcome of their broken and shattered lives.

Councilman Kenney

So there should be urgency on the part of the agencies, urgency on the part of DHS, which I sense, you know, that there's a better environment but not yet fixed, to keep our costs down -- just to be coldhearted about it, to keep our costs down as taxpayers, 'cause I'd rather have these young people, you know, working and contributing to our tax bases as opposed to using services through the court, prison system, and, you know, homeless agencies.

Mr. Mullner

One of the things we think needs to be looked at is the 61 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 time it takes for the judicial system commit to terminating parental rights and not just kind of -- how long do you wait for birth parents to, for lack of a better word, get their act together. We think there are many different types of permanency but we also believe adoption is the best.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. What I would like for you to do, going forward, is to kind of continue to be in contact with my office and with Sarah to try to come up with some ideas that we can vet to see what it is we're capable of doing as a legislative body and also who we need to talk to on the county level and on the state level to get them engaged in helping to streamline the system and reform a system that obviously needs some help. Councilman Greenlee?

Councilman Greenlee

Thank you, Mr. Chairman. You mentioned just a minute ago 62 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 about the courts? And I know that the Commissioner had said that, you know, there's good cooperation with Family Court here, in Philadelphia. Have you seen that problem with cases dragging on? Have you looked at Philadelphia particularly; is that a problem in your opinion here or --

Mr. Mullner

It's a problem everywhere.

Councilman Greenlee

Okay. Everywhere.

Mr. Mullner

And it's certainly a problem everywhere. And we have just, again, countless stories there of -- was supposed to be a gentleman here testifying, and he could not be make it, but Gloria's going to be reading his testimony. And, you know, it's a situation where they keep giving the birth parents chance after chance after chance. In fact, the last chance they gave her was when they did a surprise drug test, and 63 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 she came back positive. And they said, Well, you know, we'll give you one more chance. And, you know, that's a dozen chances later.

Councilman Greenlee

Mm-hmm.

Ms. Hoffman

And in this particular case, the child said, "I don't want to go back to my mother. She can't take care of me, she is always on drug or alcohol. If I go back, I'm going to run away."

Councilman Greenlee

How old is that child?

Ms. Hoffman

The child is 13.

Councilman Greenlee

Mm-hmm, yeah, 'cause I know there's always been this sort of, I guess, feeling among some people that the best place is with the parents. But as the chairman said earlier, that's obviously not always the case.

Ms. Hoffman

Right. And you asked about the judiciary.

Councilman Greenlee

Yeah. 64 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Ms. Hoffman

Judges do not like to terminate parental rights --

Councilman Greenlee

Right.

Ms. Hoffman

-- because it's a basic tenet of democracy in this country, is the right to raise your own child.

Councilman Greenlee

Right.

Ms. Hoffman

And judges don't like to do that.

Councilman Greenlee

(Indiscernible.)

Ms. Hoffman

But there are some times when it's necessary.

Councilman Greenlee

And it may be in the best interests of everybody.

Ms. Hoffman

Absolutely.

Councilman Greenlee

'Cause, the parent, if they can't get it together, you know, it doesn't help them either eventually. So, okay. Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Will you please continue to give us some ideas on 65 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 what we can do going forward --

Councilman Kenney

-- in the next year legislatively, and coordinating legislative issues with other levels of government.

Mr. Mullner

Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much.

Ms. Hoffman

Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Shirley Core, Kathy Murphy, and Regina Lyons. (Witnesses come forward.)

Councilman Kenney

Good morning. Please identify yourself for the record.

Ms. Core

Good morning. My name is Shirley Core, and I'm a foster mother.

Councilman Kenney

Miss Core, could you please pull the microphone closer to you.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you. 66 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Please proceed with your testimony.

Ms. Core

I've been a foster mother for months. I have two little 5 girls, and they came to my home one day 6 one day. And I looked at they eyes when 7 they got out of the DHS worker's car, and 8 one of 'em kept their face down, and the 9 other one had a big smile. And she said, 10 "When we was driving down your block, I 11 saw you and all of the neighbors 12 clapping," and she said, "I knew I was 13 coming to the right place." And that made my heart feel good because she had been -- they had been very abused by their parents, and all they was looking for is someplace to be safe, and I was there, waiting for 'em. One of the things I want to tell you about is, when these children come to our home from these agencies, the agency gives 'em to you, and then it's like they step back a little bit to see how you are going to relate to the 67 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 children that they placed in your home. They have no medical, they have no clothes most of the time; they came with one piece, one garment. No school background. And they place 'em there and they just sit there and look at you. This is what they do: They just look and watch and listen to hear what you saying about them since they've been there. Now, the older one, Azariah, she didn't talk for about three months; she's very inward. The baby one was five; she was -- just couldn't wait to tell me all about what happened to her in her parents' home. They didn't get a physical for three months. I kept calling 'em and telling 'em, "They need to be looked at."

Councilman Kenney

I'm sorry, ma'am. You were calling who?

Ms. Core

The agency. They didn't have a physical.

Councilman Kenney

No, I'm saying, you were calling the agency that 68 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 placed them with you?

Councilman Kenney

And what's the name of the agency?

Ms. Core

Children's Choice.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. Please proceed. I'm sorry.

Ms. Core

Yes. And I asked them, you know, when was they going to get a physical? and they said as soon as their insurance kicked in. So I -- my niece had a doctor from Torresdale, and she told me, "Take 'em there. He might just look at 'em." Well, it was a coincidence: The mother had took those children there before. And we he saw 'em, he said, "Is it brothers that go with these kids?" and I told him yes. And he told me he would look at 'em for me and gave 'em a physical. Now they have been in my house three whole months. They didn't bring 'em no clothes, didn't give me any money 69 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 or anything to try to help me get started with 'em. December the 27th of 2009 [sic], that's when I got the check, at the Christmas party; they invited 'em to a -- you know, us to a party. I went out and shot the whole check for 'em, 'cause they didn't have anything -- coats, boots, everything. The main thing was, both of these children needed mental help because they had been in such trauma. They had nightmares; they roughed all night. Just like you hear this chair, this the way they slept -- screaming in the night. I slept on the floor in their room every night for three months because they was traumatized at night. And till this day, they send 'em to this place to have therapy, art therapy; had nothing to do with what they needed to empty out of they heads. And they were -- the oldest one was a abused kid. The therapist would 70 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 grab her and pull her all around and tell her to sit up and listen. The mother and father would sit in this family therapy and curse me and call me all kinds of names because they wanted that older girl to say she wanted to come back. And she said, "My heart tells me to stay with Moms" -- that's me. And this person still have her job in this place.

Councilman Kenney

So they create a therapy situation for the foster children, with the birth parents?

Ms. Core

Yes. And he selected where he wanted 'em to go.

Councilman Kenney

I'm sorry. Who's "he"?

Councilman Kenney

Who is "he"?

Ms. Core

The father.

Councilman Kenney

The father of the children.

Ms. Core

The father picked 71 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 the therapy.

Councilman Kenney

Right.

Ms. Core

And the agency went along with him.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. How are they doing today?

Ms. Core

The older one is going to school. She had missed so many days before I got her, but the Philadelphia library system, they work with me, sir. They took this child two hours a day, and I sat in that library with her until she could actually read. Her mind would just go somewhere. And the little one is off the hook. She pretends she's someone else. She has never had no evaluation; the father won't allow it. See, they give the parents a lot of authority with those children; he has to sign for certain things.

Councilman Kenney

I guess I -- I don't need the Commissioner to come 72 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 back, but we can get an answer to the question. I'm a little unsure of what birth parental rights there are relative to children that are placed in foster care. It would seem kind of counterintuitive that the abusive parent who's had the child removed from the home in the foster care would have anything to say about the ongoing disposition of the children's mental health, physical health care, those kind of things. Is that court-ordered?

Councilman Kenney

(Addressing Commissioner Ambrose.) You may have to come back. If you could just pull up a chair on the side and then use the microphone there. Thank you. (Commissioner Ambrose comes back to the witness table.) COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Usually these are court-ordered. The birth families have the right to supervise 73 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 visits; I'm guessing that some of these are supervised visits. And then the family -- until parental rights are terminated, the family actually has to consent to all kinds of treatment. Sometimes the delay is an issue of consent from the birth family 'cause we sometimes can't locate them and get them to cooperate with what we think is best in moving forward with the children.

Councilman Kenney

And so, this is -- the genesis of this particular problem that our witness is explaining is a court-ordered requirement? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: In most circumstances.

Councilman Kenney

Or is it state law that -- if anybody can come up to the -- COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Vanessa Garrett Harley is our city solicitor who handles all the court cases for DHS. (Witness comes forward.) 74 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Ms. Harley

Good morning.

Councilman Kenney

Please identify yourself for the record.

Ms. Harley

Vanessa Garrett Harley; I'm chair of the social services law group for the Philadelphia Law Department. Just to briefly explain, until the time that a parent's parental rights are terminated, while it may be hard to understand, they do retain certain rights. Some of that right is that they have the right to know about what medical treatment and/or mental health or behavioral health treatment that their children receive. They have the right to attend those visits. We keep them informed. Because of confidentiality laws that are state laws as well as some federal laws and other consent laws, even to get the children medical treatment or mental health treatment, we require the consent of the parent. 75 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Now, there are ways around it. If the parent does not consent, we have to go through a full-blown court hearing, and you put in other documents. But some of what they're describing is correct. I know it may seem unfathomable that a person who could have abused a child retains such right, but they do, in the way the court system is structured and the laws of Pennsylvania are structured. So basically, what she's saying is, the family therapy is sort court- ordered therapy, because one of the things that the department does when we remove a child from the home, you try and secure safety and make sure that the child is safe and that all of their physical and mental needs are met. But you're also trying to stabilize that family and trying to determine whether or not this is a family that can be saved and perhaps the child can be returned home. Often, family 76 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 therapy is considered a component of that. So that is the mental health therapy piece where the father and the mother may participate with a licensed clinician or therapist. Hopefully -- if that explains your question.

Councilman Kenney

Yeah. I guess it would be clearer to me that a parent, or parents, who are having the experience of their children being removed by the court would not be the most cooperative people in the ultimate permanent disposition of those children, whether it's adoption or legal custodianship. It would seem that it would be in their twisted interest to try to obstruct any of that activity.

Ms. Harley

Sometimes that goes on. However, sometimes the parents are very cooperative because they want to get their children back. Not every child that is taken from a parent -- many of these parents are rehabilitated, and they 77 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 do appropriately interact, and they do what the court asks them to do, and they get help get, and they get themselves together, and the family is reunited. There are certainly those are -- as you say, are obstructionist and don't agree with anything and will do whatever they can to either sabotage a placement where the child. And that is, I believe, some of what was being testified to, is that the parents may be telling the children very negative things and that kind of thing. We experience those issues as well.

Councilman Kenney

But it's your testimony that we're a bit hamstrung by the court system and, I guess, the state law that puts that in place?

Ms. Harley

Well, there's state law. To court law will actually act based on the information that is presented to them. I don't know this individual or particular case. It is a very troubling 78 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 case to me from what I'm hearing, and it sounds as if there's certain information that may need to have been relayed to a judge; I don't know whether or not it was actually related to the judge because I don't know the specifics of the case certainly. But certainly in a case like this, this is information that some additional things should have taken place. A number of the things stated should not have happened with the appropriate intervention.

Councilman Kenney

And I understand, and I want the people from DHS to understand, I mean, this is not -- this is an effort to try to this legislative body understand the system, whether it's -- what works, what's broken, and what levels need to be addressed in order to make it right. So, I mean, I consider all of us in this together, not competing forces and people -- because it's children 79 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 involved, people get -- are understandably distressed and emotional about their frustrations. And part of, I think, what we want to try to do is let those folks understand that a lot of this frustration frustrates you as much as it frustrates them, but because we have to follow certain regulations that we could hopefully address and change, that maybe we won't have this frustration going forward. But I do thank you for your explanation. (Addressing Ms. Core.) And you can resume your testimony.

Ms. Core

Okay. The children, both of them are very happy in my home. And like you said, a lot of times, the parents, they get very resentful because they're very comfortable and they like it there. They're being fed every day, they're being bathed every day, they go to school every day, they have friends; 80 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 and they didn't have that before. So naturally, they would, like children all, they want to be there. And I'm sorry that I'm a decent person and I believe that this is the way all children should live. My five grew up decent, and I think some more can be raised.

Councilman Kenney

Don't be sorry for being a decent person. Are you by yourself in the home?

Ms. Core

No. My husband works for the City.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. Oh, great.

Ms. Core

Uh-huh. And he's a good dad to our five. And now we trying to get as many healthy in their mind as in their body, and it's a pleasure for me to do it. I'm anxious to have two more. I just fixed another room in my house for two more little girls, because I want 'em to be some princesses and less frogs as 81 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 possible. (Laughter.)

Councilman Kenney

You're a very commendable and wonderful person.

Ms. Core

Okay, thank you.

Councilman Kenney

And they're very lucky to have you. And you're extremely unselfish. And after raising your own and taking on more, that says something about you.

Ms. Core

It's a pleasure.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you. Thank you for your testimony.

Councilman Kenney

Please identify yourself for the record.