civus

Committee Hearing, December 15, 2009

Minutes from Philadelphia City Council Committee Hearings, Dec 15, 2009

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

Ms. Lyons

Hi name is Regina Lyons. I'm an adoptive mother of two and a foster parent of one, and I also have a 18-year-old daughter sitting right back there, whose name is Charmaine. Okay. As I said, my name is Regina Lyons. I was blessed with one 82 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 biological child; her name is Charmaine. Charmaine is years old. I also have 4 two children whom I adopted in 2008. 5 Nysara is three and Kala is two. 6 I would like to thank you, 7 Councilman Kenney and members of City 8 Council, for this opportunity to tell you 9 about problems that have occurred with 10 DHS and the adoption of Shanna who is 18 11 months old. 12 I had Shanna in my home for 13 almost nine months, and my goal for 14 Shanna is adoption. Shanna is Kala's 15 birth sister, and we would like them to 16 grow up together. Shanna is presently a 17 foster child. 18 I have had very little contact with Shanna's DHS adoption worker. I am not informed by DHS about what is going on about the adoption.

Councilman Kenney

Excuse me. I don't want to interrupt but I want to make sure we're clear. Are your interactions with DHS or with the agency 83 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 that DHS contracts with?

Ms. Lyons

It's DHS.

Councilman Kenney

Okay, thank you.

Ms. Lyons

Mm-hmm. When I call the adoption social worker, she does not return my phones. I have to go through the supervisor or the administrator for her to return my calls. There was a desired need to change Shanna's daycare because she was continuously being infected with viral infections, ring worm -- which she had twice -- and pink eye on three occasions. Arrangements for the daycare transfer had to be made by the DHS worker. After three long months, Shanna finally started her new daycare on this Monday. Now my husband and I are waiting to adopt Shanna, and it's moving very slowly. It is very frustrating. We are already adoptive parents and don't understand why this process has to take so long. 84 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 There is a need for the agency, the DHS social worker, adoption worker, the foster parent, and adoptive parent to be able to communicate; and without communication, there is no hope for the kids in need.

Councilman Kenney

Let me ask you a question about the daycare issue.

Councilman Kenney

Why were you not permitted to just take her to another daycare; was there a reimbursement issue or --

Ms. Lyons

No, 'cause DHS was paying for her daycare.

Councilman Kenney

Right.

Ms. Lyons

I applied to CCIS.

Councilman Kenney

What is CCIS?

Ms. Lyons

Um... It's subsidized daycare.

Councilman Kenney

Okay.

Ms. Lyons

And they had paid for her daycare until this CCIS kicks in, 85 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 which didn't kick in yet. So they was paying for it, and in order for her to be transferred, they had to do the paperwork.

Councilman Kenney

How did she wind up initially in the daycare she was in, where you were having the problems?

Ms. Lyons

There is a list, they have a list of daycares that they will pay for.

Councilman Kenney

All right.

Ms. Lyons

So that was one of the daycares that was on the list.

Councilman Kenney

Was it near your home?

Councilman Kenney

And the new one is also near your home?

Councilman Kenney

Okay, fine. Again, part of this process is to try to hear from you and address those issues and try to fix those problems so that you, in the future, and others like 86 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 you will not go through that. And I just want to echo what I talked about there with the earlier witnesses, that your unselfishness is just astounding. You have, again, another grown. Mine are and 16, and 8 I'm like, you know, let's go. 9 (Laughter.) 10 And it takes a special person 11 to want to bring an 18-month-old back 12 into your life. 13

Ms. Lyons

Mm-hmm. 14

Councilman Kenney

But thank 15 you for being here and thank you for your 16 testimony. 17

Ms. Lyons

Thank you. 18

Councilman Kenney

Please 19 identify yourself for the record. 20

Ms. Murphy

Good morning.

Councilman Kenney

Good morning.

Ms. Murphy

My name is Kathy Murphy. Councilman Kenney and members of City Council, thank you for this 87 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 opportunity to testify and hopefully expand the chances for Philadelphia children to find permanent adoptive families. I am most grateful for the level of concern that is evident from what I've heard so far. I'm here to talk to you as a board member of the National Adoption Center and as an adoptive parent. The center believes that adoption is in the best interests of the child when his or her own parents are not able to make a home for him. The foster care system, while promoting the reunification with the biological family, treats adoption as a last resort. Safety, stability, love, and permanency are what these children need. While my husband and I did not adopt from Philadelphia and would have, had Philadelphia children been made available to us, our experiences, frustrations, and challenges mirror those 88 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 of potential adopters that come through the National Adoption Center. John and I began our search to adopt children out of the foster care system in 2003. We wanted to provide a permanent home and family to older children who did not have one. The first challenge that we encountered was a lack of information on the process. We had no idea where to start. Many of our calls to lawyers, private agencies, and state agencies went unanswered. We received no response to many inquiries via websites as we continued our search for children. The unresponsiveness was particularly troubling. We felt as though we were the only ones out there who desired what we did -- to adopt a child from the foster care system. State and city agencies were focused on finding foster parents, not adoptive parents. Even with good agencies, the 89 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 information we were given on waiting children was too vague. We would receive reports listing only children's first name, age, sex, race, and special needs or challenges. There was no photo, no 7 bio information. It is very difficult to search for a child with this little information. We found our first daughter through a lawyer's online network. She was placed with us in August of 2005. Finalization was in March of 2006. Autumn is now 12. We found our second daughter on a state website, which is no longer available due to lack of funding. She was placed with us this past June. Our finalization is January 5. Desiraya is eight. We've had five home studies in six years. In the last six years, we were never once presented with an opportunity for a child from Philadelphia. 90 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Lack of information and unresponsiveness is a deterrent for finding permanent families for the many children who are in the foster care system and are available for adoption. Many people give up in frustration because it takes too long, or they can't figure out what they have to do or whom they need to contact. There are many things that need improvement. I'm asking you today to focus first on three key areas to help the children of Philadelphia find permanent homes. 1. Streamline the process and reduce the time that children are in foster care when parental rights have been terminated or are certain to be. Begin with concurrent plans for biological parents and the children at initiation into the system to reduce the time involved in terminating parental rights when it becomes clear that they will not be able to resume care of their 91 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 children. 2. Make home studies valid for longer than one year. This timing does not match the timeline of the search, identification, placement, and finalization process. Home studies should be valid for at least months. 9 3. Raise awareness via the 10 Internet. Provide a resource in the 11 format that most people use today for 12 research -- the Internet.

Ms. Murphy

13 I encourage you to engage the 14 National Adoption Center to create and 15 maintain a website of Philadelphia 16 children who need to be adopted, along 17 with their photos and short bios, as well 18 as instructions of what to do and who to contact. The center has worked with Philadelphia's Department of Human Services almost since its inception in 1972. These are different times and call for more aggressive efforts. The waiting children are older and present more 92 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 challenges. Prospective adopters, while more savvy, still need guidance through this process. And resources to reach these families must include, in addition to traditional media, the opportunities available through the Internet. So many children count on us. We must not let them down. Help us be accountable to them.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you for your testimony. Where did your adoptive children come from?

Ms. Murphy

Our daughter Autumn came from Iowa, and our daughter Desiraya came from Ohio.

Councilman Kenney

And what was your experience and what -- I guess you dealt with the agencies in those states?

Ms. Murphy

At certain points in time, we actually worked through a local agency in New Jersey as our local 93 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 representative.

Councilman Kenney

You're a New Jersey resident?

Councilman Kenney

Okay. And you had made an effort, or efforts, to adopt a child from Philadelphia?

Ms. Murphy

From Pennsylvania. We reached out to swan.

Councilman Kenney

What is that?

Ms. Murphy

SWAN? Statewide Adoption Network.

Councilman Kenney

Okay, okay.

Ms. Murphy

We also had reached out to DHS, or DYFS in New Jersey. Finally selected -- finally found an agency who was representative of both Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, Delaware, and New Jersey.

Councilman Kenney

Now, your home inspection or home -- what is it?

Ms. Murphy

The home study?

Councilman Kenney

The home 94 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 study. That's done every year?

Ms. Murphy

It's valid for one year.

Councilman Kenney

And that's a New Jersey requirement?

Ms. Murphy

And it's also, I think, Pennsylvania and Philadelphia.

Councilman Kenney

But annually you need to do this as a result of New Jersey regulations?

Ms. Murphy

Correct.

Councilman Kenney

But also applies here in Philly?

Ms. Murphy

Well, it applies in other states as well. I don't know if it's national. But I know in Iowa as well as in Ohio it is as well.

Councilman Kenney

Okay, fine. All right. Councilman Greenlee?

Councilman Greenlee

Yeah, thank you. I wonder if I could go back to something that Miss Core said earlier. 95 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 You talked about what wasn't provided to the children when they came. It sounds like they basically just had their clothes on their back kind of thing, right?

Councilman Greenlee

Was there any discussion before they came?

Councilman Greenlee

Or anything even writing that addressed those things? I mean, was there, you know -- or did you just kind of assume -- and I would understand why you would assume there would be more. But, you know...

Ms. Core

Well, I just figured that by them just coming out of the clear blue sky like that, they just call you and tell you they're on their way.

Councilman Greenlee

Right, mm-hmm.

Ms. Core

And I said, "Come on," and they were there. 96 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Greenlee

So you would assume there that they would have been provided with more when they were coming.

Ms. Core

Right, 'cause, listen. The kids I had before them was a baby, and they didn't bring one Pamper with 'em. I had to wake my sister to come from her home on Huntington Park, to come to house to take me to a overnight drugstore so I could get a supply of Pampers and the proper milk, you know, things, because I took the baby in the middle of the night, at 12:30 at night. So when they come, they just come with the kids, give 'em to you, and walk right out.

Councilman Greenlee

And you don't know what child is coming till then, do you?

Councilman Greenlee

So you don't know what -- (Indiscernible; parties talking 97 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 over each other.)

Councilman Greenlee

... and you don't have the ability to have clothes available 'cause you don't even know if they're eight years old or twelve years old or something.

Ms. Core

Well, this is what we do. The friends that I have that are foster mothers, you know what they did for me? They set me up a little clothes bank. They taught me how to, you know, keep everything on hand. The only thing -- and I keep powdered milk so if they come in the night, I can get the blender out and make the milk.

Councilman Greenlee

Mm-hmm.

Ms. Core

See, 'cause I didn't know. You're very green at first; you don't know what's going on. But now, I'm a pro at it.

Councilman Greenlee

It sounds that way.

Ms. Core

They can bring different sizes, any color; I'm ready. 98 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 (Laughter.)

Ms. Core

I am really ready.

Councilman Greenlee

If we all could be so organized.

Ms. Core

Yes, I'm very organized.

Councilman Greenlee

Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

These children come from DHS? Did DHS bring them?

Ms. Core

DHS brings 'em, but the agency comes; in two to three days, they appear.

Councilman Kenney

Okay. Commissioner -- I want the make sure that the record's clear 'cause the commissioner seems like she wants to... COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I'm just distressed by some of what I'm hearing, obviously. We, actually, in some instances, do bring the children. It's usually the agency that we contract with. 99 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 And unfortunately, they should be giving the children what they need when they come to your house; you shouldn't have to be scrambling in the middle of the night. The agency gets paid to do those things. And there's two resources that I want folks to know about. Number one is, we have a very, very good director who's in charge of provider relations, and we're now promoting accountability around providers as well. If you have circumstance where providers aren't doing what they need to do, you need to call DHS. And I also have a Commissioner's Response Office. If I don't know about the situations that you have to struggle through, I can't help. And so, I really encourage people to call the Commissioner's Action Response Office. And also, complaints about providers, we will deal with them. And this home study issue, if providers aren't doing home studies in 100 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 the prescribed period of time, we're not going to pay them. So if I know about it, we can put in mechanisms to make sure that, number one, you get what you need for the children you're caring for; and number two, that providers are held accountable for delivering the services that we pay them to deliver.

Councilman Kenney

Commissioner, one of the things that occurs to me during this conversation, which was similar to what we had a number of years ago with Behavioral Health, was that the system got unwieldy, and we were spending money for agencies that were supposed to be delivering services that weren't. And Commissioner Richman at the time developed this CBH model. I'm wondering -- I mean, not exactly, but I'm wondering if a model like CBH would make sense in the coordination of these agencies that do this work that we contract with. 101 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 I mean, it's certainly just an idea that I just threw out there now, and it probably needs to be vetted over a period of time. But I know that the CBH, when they first brought it to our attention, I was like, "This is never going to work" and was dead wrong about it and, you know, voted for it, kind of not sure. And as time went on, I think it really has been a major improvement in the delivery of behavioral health services for our folks who live in the city, and it basically squeezes every dime out of, you know, the available resources. So I'm wondering if at some point in time we ought to maybe study a similar model for these agencies. That would be maybe helpful. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yeah. So I'll tell you two things. One is that we have studied other systems that have gone to -- New 102 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 York is the best example. It's called Improving Outcomes for Children, and it's making sure there's not a duplication of effort. And so, we can advise you about where we are in exploring that. The other issue is the creation of the Division of Performance Management and Accountability. We now have a report card for our foster care agencies; I'll share that report card with you. We also have evaluations of the agencies. And we've created a new tool that we're using to evaluate the agencies that really gets to the heart of what we should be doing on behalf of children. And I'm happy to share that information with you as well.

Councilman Kenney

Are you aware -- I was not aware of your hotline or your, I guess, ombudsman phone number. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yes.

Councilman Kenney

Are all of our foster care folks in the city provided with that number? 103 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: I believe we handed out two folks. And frequently, cases that are problematic come to my attention; we investigate those cases. You know, lack of response is certainly something that I hear frequently. So it's something that I will address if I'm aware of the problems.

Councilman Kenney

I'm just wondering whether or not we should require our contracted agencies to give someone a brochure of something with kind of tips of where to call and what to do; and when the child is brought, whether it's in the middle of the night or during the day, that they get something in their hands so that if they have a problem, they know where to call. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yes. I think that's a great idea. The ideas that I've heard around using the Internet in a different way -- I mean, there's 104 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 lots of things that I'm taking notes on and certainly will take back and implement at DHS.

Councilman Kenney

Okay, thank you very much. Thank you. Councilman Greenlee?

Councilman Greenlee

Commissioner, while you're there, can I just ask one just to kind of follow up, sorry. Just so I'm clear -- again, my question to Miss Core -- when you have some kind of agreement or contract with these agencies, and it says pretty much what they're supposed to provide, okay? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yes.

Councilman Greenlee

Could you provide to the Chair a copy of that? COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Sure, sure.

Councilman Greenlee

Just so we can see, you know -- COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Clothing allowances. 105 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Greenlee

Okay. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: All of those things are things we pay for, diapers. I mean, for you to get a child with one article of clothing, the provider agency is paid to do these kinds of things. These are unacceptable circumstances that --

Councilman Greenlee

Okay. So they're getting money and not spending it. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Yes.

Councilman Greenlee

At least on her case, they sound like they might have gotten some funds and not spent it in that -- COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: Well, then we need to investigate that.

Councilman Greenlee

Yeah, right, okay. COMMISSIONER AMBROSE: You know, so actually, we have members of the Commissioner's Action Response Office 106 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 here that I'd like to have at least the two of you so that we can work through whatever issues you're experiencing now and make sure that the children are getting what they need and we're working on your case the way it needs to be worked on.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you for your testimony.

Ms. Core

Okay, thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Councilwoman Tasco, please.

Councilwoman Tasco

Yes. I'd just like to say to those of you who have come down for the hearing today, to apologize for leaving the table. I had a press conference with the Mayor regarding or foreclosure program, so that's why I had to leave. So I apologize for that.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much. Warren Meltzer, Elia Morris, and Phyllis Stevens. 107 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 (Witness comes forward.)

Councilman Kenney

Good morning. Please identify yourself for the record.

Ms. Hoffman

Good morning, Councilman Kenney and members of Council. I do not look like Warren Meltzer.

Councilman Kenney

I thought I saw you before.

Ms. Hoffman

However, he became ill today and asked if I would deliver his testimony for you.

Councilman Kenney

Please.

Ms. Hoffman

So I'm going to read it to you as he's given it to me. Councilman Kenney and members of City Council, thank you for taking the time to listen to my thoughts on this important topic that has become central to my family. I'm Warren Meltzer, an attorney. My partner is Roy Ross, also an attorney, and we have been partnered for 20 years. We happen to have a wonderful 13-year-old foster son for over 108 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 one year. More than two years ago, we decided to go down the path of adopting a child from foster care. We have a loving home and wanted to share our life with a child in need, knowing all the joy a child would bring to us as well. Overall, we had been looking for a boy, any race, ages 7 or 8 or up. We went through the approval process and had our home study done. Then we turned toward finding a child. Then a wall hit. The effort involved in finding a child is huge, and I was met by overwhelmed case workers, recruiters, and a system so intent on checking every box and finding the perfect family that many families like ours may well, and probably do, walk away. One can look at all of the children listed on the Pennsylvania Adoption Exchange. This is the website handled by the statewide adoption network, where many children available 109 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 for adoption in Pennsylvania are listed. There are probably a few hundred on that list at any one time. I screened through all of the children and then started calling the listed contacts, one by one, often two or three or four times, before getting a return phone call. It became a big effort just to keep track of all the calls made. When I spoke with the contacts, some refused to talk with me, saying they would only talk with our case worker. While understandable, I thought to myself, Our case worker won't be raising the child or paying for college, so why not talk to me. When the contact would talk with me, I would try to get basic information about the child and his background. Then I would try to tell my family story. Sadly, after I would tell many of these contacts that we are a same-sex couple, you could hear the 110 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 enthusiasm leave their voices. Of course, nothing would ever been said explicitly, but it was quite obvious by the change in tone. This happened all too often. Overall, we inquired about more than 50 children. We had only one case worker follow up with us as a prospective adoptive family; and that, unfortunately, fell through. Otherwise, the responses we got included: Not a good fit; Johnny would do best with a mom and dad; Billy had issues with his dad, so it would be best not to have two of them. And so on. All the while, I wondered, maybe the person who had issues with potential same-sex adoptive parents was the person I was speaking with or his or her supervisor or the county Family Court judge. Who could know, but what could 111 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 you do. Despite my best efforts, I can't educate the world and eliminate all prejudice. Even after you would talk with the contacts and had sent them to your home study with all your deeply personal information, often the response you would get is nothing. No thanks, but no 10 thanks. No, not a good fit. Just silence. For a while, I would call the contacts to see what happened after we sent out home study, but at some point, you just stop. Why spend your time chasing someone down just to be told no. 17 I will note that one key exception to all of this has been our contacts involving the National Adoption Center. They have at all times advocated for us with the people in the system, and the center always makes sure each inquiry we made has closure, even if negative. Recently, I saw a child on the website who was one of the first I ever 112 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 inquired about.

Ms. Hoffman

As I recall, I was told that his foster family was considering whether to adopt him. I was told a few times to keep checking back; I did a few times and got the same story. Now he is back on the same website, and I can only assume that since his information says he wants to keep in touch with his foster family that that path for him got closed. But if the system is so desperately in need of adoptive parents, why hasn't someone reached out to us to see if we are still available and interested. Process-wise, the system is failing this child if they are starting the search all over again, not looking into the file to see who has already inquired about the child. One other point worth noting: Many times, children available for adoption have not had their parental rights terminated and, therefore, are not yet legally free. For a child who is not legally free, I believe the risk for gay 113 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 and lesbian people trying to adopt a child is even greater. While many relatives of the child may sit by and let the child be adopted by a straight couple or individual, some relatives may object to a child being adopted by a same-sex couple or a gay or lesbian individual, even if it is okay with the child. If adoption is truly about the best interests of the child, DHS needs to enforce with its provider agencies that many kinds of people can be excellent parents, even those whose sexual orientation may not match those of your social workers or administrators. Thank you for your time.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much for reading the testimony. Please identify yourself for the record, whoever is next. And also let the record that Councilman Jones has joined the committee. 114 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Ms. Stevens

Good morning. My name is Phyllis Stevens. I'm executive director of Together as Adopted Parents.

Councilman Kenney

Good morning.

Ms. Stevens

First, I would like to thank you for giving me the opportunity to speak on behalf of the thousands of children and youth that are in foster care who cannot speak for themselves. My name is Phyllis Stevens. I'm an adoptive mom and I have been a foster mom, a kinship mom. All four of my children were adopted out of foster care, and all four of my children have special needs. I am also executive director of Together As Adoptive Parents, TAP. The main purpose of TAP is to keep kids that have been placed in permanent homes from reentering the foster care system. We do this by providing resources, support, trainings to adoptive, foster, and 115 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 kinship families and their children. TAP also hosts monthly parent meeting in Montgomery and Philadelphia. Not only adoptive, foster, and kinship parents attend these meetings, but many pre-adopt families are there as well. These meetings are a safe place for families to vent. Because we are a parent-run organization, we constantly receive calls on our help line from parents who are fed up with the system. We get calls from parents who have been waiting for years to adopt a 12- or 13-year-old youth. I know of two great families who are members of TAP and have dropped out of the adoption process because their wait was over two years to adopt an older youth. I recently received a call from a family that was in the process of adopting a sibling group of four, ages 6 to 17 years. The adoption was stalled because there was a power struggle 116 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 between the case worker and the pre-adoptive mom. I talked with one devastated mom who was told by one case worker that the agency's plans were to change the goal to adoption for the child because the child had been at her home as a foster child for over three years. The agency has changed her case worker three times, and the goal is still -- has still not been changed to adoption. Not all of the news is bad news. We're starting to see changes, and I would like to spend the last few minutes talking about the changes we need. For the past nine years, Together As Adoptive Parents has been working with adoptive, foster, and kinship families in Philadelphia. Under Commissioner Ambrose, I am seeing something that I have not seen in nine years: The commissioner has sent representatives from her office to sit in 117 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 on our parent group meetings, which means a lot to these families. Adoptive foster and kinship families are finally being heard. Their complaints are being taken serious and acted upon. Families have started to feel that they are valued. Children are getting services that they need. I, Phyllis Steven, have been invited to become a member of the Department of Human Services advisory board and have accepted; this will ensure that the voices of the families are heard. We have the power in our hands to save our children's lives -- and we're talking about lives. If we do nothing or if we do not continue to improve our system, shame on us. Time in a child's life is not the same as time in our lives, an adult life. When you tell a child that you will find a home for them soon, they think tomorrow, maybe in two days; but 118 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 certainly not two or three years. Are there problems? Yes. But I believe we are moving in the right direction. Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much for your testimony and for your commitment to children. But also, I'm glad to hear -- and am not surprised, frankly -- that this particular DHS administration is reaching out to folks like yourself and bringing you into the system and hearing what you have to say, 'cause I think, unless we all start talking, or keep talking, to each other, we're probably never going to get where we want to be. So I'm glad you've agreed not only to do what you're doing with our children, but also to spend some of other free time contributing to this process. Thank you.

Ms. Stevens

And I would like add just one thing. 119 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Yes, ma'am.

Ms. Stevens

I'd like to take a little bit of responsibility for Shirley and Regina not communicating with DHS, because they are part of our organization, and I was a little bit confused on sort of the chain of command. So I think a lot of their situation would have been taken care of if I kind of would have --

Councilman Kenney

How long have you been on the committee, the advisory committee?

Ms. Stevens

I just joined actually.

Councilman Kenney

I think it will be a real short time before you figure out what the system is. I'm sure it will be a short learning curve. Thank you very much.

Ms. Stevens

Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Please identify yourself for the record.

Ms. Morris

Hi. My name is 120 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Aleah Morris. I'm an adoptive parent and a foster parent as well. My journey for adoption started in 1993, when I adopted my first daughter. I have four adopted children. Now they're all grown and doing quite well. They encouraged me to pursue adoption again. You know, based on their experience, they said, "Mom, you should adopt, you should adopt."

Councilman Kenney

Who is "they"?

Ms. Morris

My daughters.

Councilman Kenney

Oh, okay, your children, okay.

Ms. Morris

My daughter, Carrie, who's 19 a daughter; I have a daughter, Faleeka, who's 22; a daughter, Portia, who's 20; and my daughter Bessie who's 18. They said, "Mom, you should adopt again. You did a great job with us and you should try." I said, "Okay, that 121 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 sounds good." I said, "Well, you know, maybe I'll do foster care. Maybe I'll try that." So I did sign up with the agency that I had previously adopted my daughters from, which was the Juvenile Justice Center, and I was a foster parents with them before as well. And in that process, you know, they placed a child with me once I was approved for a foster parent. And the child had been placed so many times that stability for her was not a answer. So she ran away. Like, after just being with me for two days, she was gone, they never found her. So in April -- that was in February. So in April, I told my permanency adoption social worker that I wanted to do adoption versus foster care, and I asked if they had any children in a agency that needed permanency, and they didn't at the time. So I then pursued to go online and look for children who are up for 122 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 adoption. So my social worker called me and said, "Oh, there's a matching party." It was May the 30th, and I attended. And I met a young lady there who was up for adoption through Jersey, and me and her spoke for a while. She was at the 8 time. And I then did a interest form 9 online, you know, requesting that they 10 send me some information and that I had a 11 home study in the process. 12 And that was back in May. And 13 my home study is actually still not completed because of the agency, you know, not having enough people to work on it; when, in previous times, when I did adoption before, there was, like, a team that kind of worked with you, like, three or four social workers, and they little got things done. Where now, it's just this one person working on permanency in adoption with me. And every week, I'm in contact with her. And every week she says, Oh, I need this; oh, I need that. I'm, like, 123 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Well, three or four months have passed by and I've asked you what else did you need, and you said, Oh, I have everything. And she went down the list, and I said okay, fine. And then she goes down this list again last week and says, Oh, I need this, I need that. And it's been since May, and my home study's still not complete. And I'm very concerned, and she heard the concern in my voice. And, you know, we're trying to rectify some things because now, the child that I had interest in in Jersey, you know, felt as though I was a match, is waiting. And the child has now had still a birthday still in foster care. So, you know, I was very upset about it.

Councilman Kenney

Well, I know there are folks here listening to what you're saying, and I'm sure you will have contact with them before the hearing's over as to what the difficulties are in your home study issue 124 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 or maybe getting it resolved for you so that you can continue to get moving and get this child into your home. I didn't want to interrupt. So if there's anything else you have to add, please feel free.

Ms. Morris

No, that was basically my main concern. And also, there was another issue with my children, once they turned 18. I was never notified that their health insurance was going to end. And within six months, it ended.

Councilman Kenney

Are they in school?

Ms. Morris

They are in school. I have two in college, and one's still in her last year of high school.

Councilman Kenney

Does that end? I mean, I know myself, I have a 20-year-old in college, and he's still on my health-care plan as long as I provide the semester transcripts that he starts school. 125 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

But there's not a similar situation for you?

Ms. Morris

They were receiving medical assistance based on being special needs to adoption.

Councilman Kenney

Right.

Ms. Morris

So that's what they were receiving. And, you know, it was not until I went and took 'em to the doctor that I found out, Oh, she doesn't have any insurance. I mean, at that time, of course, I could have put her on my insurance, but just to be at the doctor's office now with this $400 bill...

Councilman Kenney

Right.

Ms. Morris

And, you know, she has other medical needs, and we couldn't even go to a specialist.

Councilman Kenney

What is your medical coverage?

Ms. Morris

What I have at my particular job, I have Keystone East. 126 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

That's Independence Blue Cross -- Keystone --

Ms. Morris

Yes, Pennsylvania Blue Cross.

Councilman Kenney

All right. Well, actually, after the hearing, if you talk to Sarah, maybe we can figure out a way to have them address that particular issue relative to the break in coverage. Are your children back on -- since they're in school, are they on your coverage now?

Ms. Morris

After a long, long journey since June, we finally got the insurance on, like, I would say about three weeks ago.

Councilman Kenney

So everybody's covered now?

Ms. Morris

Everybody's covered now.

Councilman Kenney

All right. Make sure you talk to Sarah after the hearing and we'll see if we can't make an inquiry over at Keystone. 127 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Ms. Morris

Okay. Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much and thank you for your testimony. Charles Williams? (Witness comes forward.)

Mr. Williams

Good morning, members of City Council, Commissioner Ambrose, Ken Mullner, the Executive Director of the National Adoption Center and other invited guests. My name is Dr. Charles Williams. I am an assistant clinical professor at Drexel University and director of their newly-named Center for the Prevention of School-Aged Violence. And while I'm in this chamber, I'm reminded of the two City citations I've earned from Council for my work with children in preventing violence, one of which came from Councilwoman Tasco from my citywide "Books, Not Guns" campaign. I have a bachelor's degree in psychology and my dual master's degree in 128 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. D. in education and psychology also from Temple University. My credentials, being what they are, don't make me as qualified to speak about these issues as what I'm about to tell you, which is the fact that I am a former foster care child in Philadelphia. I was in foster care from 1987 until 1994. In fact, I was an emergency placement, along with my two brothers and my sister, because of abuse and neglect in my home, which centered around substance abuse, which is not uncommon for a lot of children who are placed in the system, not just here in Philadelphia, but across the country. One of the things that I think is sort of important for all of us who are here, including the members of City Council, the folks who work for the City, foster care parents, and other agencies who care about this issue, and that is 129 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 that even though I was taken from my home because of abuse and neglect and because I was a poor black kid from a struggling neighborhood and family because there were addictions in my family, that I wanted a decent quality of life. I want the same quality of life going back now several years that you would want for your own children. It's not just enough for me to be out of harm's way, as I speak for many foster care children across the country, of which there are about 500,000 and about (indiscernible) languish in foster care indefinitely. I want a decent education, I want decent medical care, I want to thrive and not just exist. One of the things that I wanted to highlight is that instead of just reading all of this, 'cause you have copies of it already in the record, my experience is atypical, which I think most of us would agree. Most kids in foster care -- many kids in foster 130 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. D. and become a college professor, because of the daunting challenges that they face. I also would like to point out that I'm very pleased that recently I was invited to join the board of directors of the National Adoption Center. And I strongly feel that at the end of the day, each child languishing in foster care would rather with be with a permanent family, in a stable and loving home However, given that this is not the case for the overwhelming majority of youth in foster care, we must examine rather closely and as often as we can, without being defensive or pointing fingers, the experiences of youth in foster care and the subsequent impact of those experience. So what do I mean specifically? 131 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 We have children in foster care who deal with various issues -- mental health, behavioral health. And by the way, I worked with CBH as well once as a clinical systems analyst. I worked in behavioral health for a number of years with children who are in the foster care system, dealing with issues of, you know, depression, anxiety, aggression, anger, those sorts of things. Our children in foster care deal with many issues related to self-esteem, they deal with issues of aggression, and -- which is sort of stunning to me, the research shows that many children who are taken out of homes because of abuse and neglect are abused and neglected once they're placed in the foster care system. Research supports that, and I have the references here to back that up.

Mr. Williams

So while child welfare professionals work very hard -- and they should be commended -- at protecting 132 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 children and taking them out of harm's way and ensuring that they are provided for, I think that part of the issue here is that we have to understand that -- as I said, my experiences are atypical, and foster care is the less-than-ideal, in many circumstances, living situations for many children. So we do have to think about permanency, and we do have to think about the quality of life of children who are in foster care. Because many children who are raised in foster care because of abuse and neglect, because they have been exposed to violence, this can lead to things such as pour academic achievement, which I had mentioned earlier, anxiety, post-traumatic stress, and low future expectations. It can also lead to high rates of emotional difficulties and mental illness. So the quality of their lives aren't as good as they could be And Councilman Kenney and, I guess, other folks also on the Council, 133 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 you know, asked some really good questions, some difficult questions, which is, you know, once kids have been placed in the foster care system or even when there's permanency, you know, what are the outcomes? So specifically, how do we address internalizing problems like depression, externalizing problems like aggression? How are they thriving? How are they doing academically? So are they graduating from one grade to the next? Are they going to high school? Is there post-secondary training? Are they going to college? So, what are the outcomes for youth once they're placed? As I said, it's just not enough for them to be placed, but we want, like every child, to have a very good quality of life to the extent that we can make that possible. One of the things I'd like to talk about briefly -- and the commissioner mentioned this and it's been 134 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 highlighted in the Raise Me Up campaign, and it's something that we think is very drill -- is mentoring. Research shows very clearly that the children in the child welfare system specifically and in foster care can benefit from mentoring. In fact, according to the reports supported by the Corporation for National and Community Service, entitled "Mentoring Children in Foster Care," they showed that foster- care youth can benefit immensely from positive role models, and that one of the things that can happen, because kids in foster care have mentors, is that they can work on things such as goal aspirations, which can lead to high academic achievement or college attainment. They can create meaningful and caring relationships with peers, and they can begin to feel safe in their communities. Also, one of the issues that we have to deal with with kids who are in 135 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 foster care, because of issues of abuse and neglect, is delinquency. Mentoring has been demonstrated to address those issues of delinquency and to increase pro-social development and positive behaviors for kids in foster care, including a greater sense of academic competence, a better attitude towards school, reduction in substance abuse, and increased pro-social behaviors and attitudes Moreover, kids in monitoring programs who are in foster care are more likely to attend college. So once again, going back to their quality-of-life issue. So we're looking to have certain things happen with youth who are in foster care when they engage in mentoring problems. And that is allowing them to improve self-esteem, work well with peers, respect adults, avoid violent conflict, refuse drug use, improve academic performance, and develop a 136 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 better future outlook. Also, the research suggests, just briefly, that these kinds of services can benefit parents of the kids that are in foster care.

Mr. Williams

So essentially, without consistent support of trained, helping professionals, some of which can be provided through mentoring, foster care youth will continue to experience greater rates of internalizing problems like depression, externalizing problems like aggression and academic failure, school dropout. Moreover, if we support foster- care youth, we can deal with their issues of feeling isolated and forgotten by the various systems, tasks (indiscernible) providing for them and ensuring that they have more than just a life, but an abundant life filled with great hope and promise. It is my hope that my personal testimony, buttressed with the latest 137 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 research, will shed light on some of the challenges facing foster-care youth as well provide some insight into how these challenges may be addressed Thank you, members of Council.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much for taking the time to come in and discuss with us your experiences and make recommendations for improvement. We appreciate it.

Mr. Williams

Thank you very much.

Councilman Kenney

Well, it is "good afternoon" now. Mr. Ron Spangler and Pat Albright. (Witnesses come forward.)

Councilman Kenney

Good afternoon. Please identify yourself for the record, whoever would like to start first.

Ms. Albright

I'm Pat Albright.

Councilman Kenney

Pat, would 138 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 you please pull the microphone closer to you. Thank you.

Ms. Albright

Sure. Good morning. My name is Pat Albright. I am here to represent the Every Mother Is a Working Mother Network. And I have with me Debra Sealy, who's a mother who's a part of our organization, who has had dealings with the DHS system.

Councilman Kenney

And can you yourself for the record.

Mr. Spangler

Good morning. Ron Spangler, Arbor Education and Training.

Councilman Kenney

And whoever would like to start, please begin.

Ms. Albright

Good morning, Councilman Kenney and members of City Council and staff. My name is Pat Albright, as I just said. I live in Germantown and I'm a former welfare recipient and a mother of an 18-year-old black or biracial son, who this year started his freshman at Albright College. 139 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 I'm testifying today on behalf of the Every Mother Is a Working Mother Network, which is a grassroots network of mothers, grandmothers, and other caregivers based at the Crossroads Women's Center in Germantown. We campaign with our sister organization in Los Angeles and other groups to establish that raising children and caring work is work and for the value of this work to be reflected in the right to welfare and other resources and in other social and economic policies. We are testifying today because since 2006, we have coordinated a group called, DHS, Give Us Back Our Children, a multi-racial volunteer support and action group of mothers, other family members and supporters, including adoptive parents and former social workers, working together to end the unjust removal of children from their families by DHS. Much of the time, the reason 140 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 children are originally taken have more to do with poverty and racism than with abuse or neglect. Once in the system, the mothers are presumed guilty, treated like criminals, and are in serious danger of losing their children permanently despite many efforts to get them back. S. cities. 4 in Chicago. Compare removals to total child population, and Philadelphia is similarly out of line. Yet children here are no safer, and perhaps less so. Most studies show children are far better off and safer at home than in foster care. According to the National Coalition of Child Protection Reform, children who have been 141 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 in foster care have twice the rate -- and this was also seen in the video earlier -- have twice the rate of post-traumatic stress disorder of Gulf War veterans, and only percent can be 7 said to be doing well, quote/unquote. 8 All studies show that 9 preserving the maternal bond is a 10 critical factor in determining the health 11 and well-being of a child. 12 Our work has exposed how the 13 child welfare system operates on the 14 ground level, how it is actually lived 15 and experienced by those most impacted as 16 opposed to policies and slogans on 17 posters. 18 This is why we are compelled to 19 testify today, as the voice of mothers 20 whose children have been taken is almost never heard in these policy debates. What is the context of this issue? It is that the poorest and most vulnerable women and children in Philadelphia are the ones subject to DHS 142 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 intervention. The vast majority of children who are removed from their families are children of color, especially African-American. DHS has acknowledged this, consponsoring meetings on the disproportionate placement of African-American and Latino youth, but the problem persists. Statistics tell the story. In Pennsylvania, in 2000, 49 percent of children in foster care were black, whereas black children make up only 13 percent of the population for the same period. In Pennsylvania, black children were reunified with their families only 58 percent of the time, compared with 72 percent for white children. We've been trying to find the statistics for Philadelphia, but they are not readily available; perhaps DHS can provide them. We are concerned about the proposal to improve the process by decreasing wait times. What does this 143 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 mean in practical terms? We fear it means the fast-tracking of primarily poor black children into adoption, often with significant financial support and incentives to adoptive families as well as to agencies.

Ms. Albright

Support that is given to mothers would enable them to obtain decent housing, one of the main reasons children are removed. Already, DHS is spending $35,000 per year per child in foster care. We have pointed out that there are large financial incentives for keeping children in care, but few for reunification. We fear that decreasing waiting times will result in further limiting the ability of parents to reunify with their children and that there will be more termination of parental rights because they will time out. This is already happening and often, because social workers and other professionals are not doing what they are supposed to do. 144 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 In a typical example, a judge ordered family therapy, pending the approval of a mother's and child's therapist. The DHS worker did nothing to implement the order, despite many calls from the mother and from our organization. She said it was not her job but the therapist's; while the therapist said it was not their job but the worker's. This dragged on for months. And by the time of the next hearing five months later, this therapy had still not been set up. The judge reissued the order, but another five months had passed on the ticking clock, not only straining the bond between mother and young child, but also pushing against the time limit for permanency. We fully support timely decisions regarding the lives of children. And, in fact, we are shocked at how cavalierly DHS and the court makes decisions that keep families apart for 145 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 months and years. How they decide that an hour of time in a windowless office is all that is necessary for a child and mother each week. But if the appropriate resources are not made available, pushing for shorter time limits will only increase the problem and result in more children being permanently separated from their families. One of these resources is housing. Thirty percent of foster children would be home right now if their parents had decent housing. Adequate, competent, and accessible legal help is another desperately needed resource. Most mothers cannot afford private attorneys and must rely on court-appointed lawyers who vary greatly in quality and commitment to their client. There are a few notable exceptions, but most court-appointed lawyers will not return calls or meet 146 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 with clients before hearings and often treat their clients with a contempt that is shocking. Councilmembers, are you aware that, in Philadelphia, a court-appointed lawyer in Family Court make $500 per year for representing their client, regardless of how much or how little work they do? In the second year of a case, that figure drops to $250 per year; and in the third, to $125 per year. It's no wonder that many mothers lose their children because of poor legal representation. We are pleased that Commissioner Ambrose shares these concerns, and we look forward to working with her to address them. We urge you to oppose any measures which would result in more children being permanently separated needlessly from their families. Poverty is not a crime, poverty is not neglect and should not be punished 147 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 by taking children away from their families. We urge you to support the practical measures and resources that would make a real difference in enabling families to stay together. These include housing, financial support, child care, family-centered addict treatment, support for people with mental and physical disabilities, and legal help, among others. This also includes removing any financial incentives for agencies to keep children in care. Other cities and states have made changes that have greatly reduced the number of children removed from their families, including in Pittsburgh and Chicago. Philadelphia can do the same. Please do the right thing for our kids.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much for your testimony. Please identify yourself for the record. 148 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Ms. Sealy

My name is Debra Sealy. I have two children. One is 17, and he's home, under supervision of DHS. I have a daughter that's years old, and 6 she's with DHS but PLC. 7

Councilman Kenney

What is 8 PLC? I'm sorry.

Ms. Sealy

Permanent legal custody.

Councilman Kenney

Okay.

Ms. Sealy

And she's been in foster care for, like, three years. And when the court date do come up, they postpone some of the results because they said they couldn't get the statements from the doctor on time, and it just prolong until it got to PLC. I'm asking for support of decent housing. Um, you know, let's see. And, um, well, I'm getting medical treatment and I'm just about overcoming that. But it's just -- it's poor service with DHS, you know. It's like -- it's like they saying that I shouldn't get my 149 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 child back, but I've been a good mother to my child. I'm always there, feeding her, making sure that she have clothes, you know, making sure that she went to school. But it still wasn't enough, you know. And the aim is probably just, you know, the other people getting they satisfaction of seeing a parent get hurt. But, um, you know, as the lord said, don't worry 'cause he had to overcome the world.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you for your testimony, and I wish you best wishes in your efforts to reunify your family stabilize and get back to a regular life. Best wishes.

Ms. Sealy

Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Happy holidays. Please identify yourself for the record.

Mr. Spangler

Good afternoon. Ron Spangler, Arbor Education and Training. 150 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753

Councilman Kenney

Please proceed.

Mr. Spangler

I'd like to take this opportunity to thank Councilman Kenney and the members of City Council for this opportunity. My name is Ron Spangler. I'm representing Arbor Education and Training and Rest Care. Rest Care supports many young adults and children through services such as therapeutic foster care, highly secure placements, sexual offender programs, and academic and vocational development. Through our Arbor Education and Training services, we provide life- changing programs that help prepare young adults, ages 4 through 21, to obtain either meaningful or gainful employment or pursuit of post-secondary education. I worked in the field of workforce development, continuing education, and community and economic development. Prior to joining Arbor, I 151 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 was vice president for workforce and continuing education at ETI International. Previously, I worked as vice president at (indiscernible) Technology and Training. I've also served as deputy executive director of the Mayor's Commission for Literacy and director at the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority. I've worked on several Philadelphia (indiscernible) projects to strengthen economic development. Arbor Education and Training has a clear vision for providing services to youth, to strengthen youth employability by availing community resources while imparting an understanding of the responsibilities associated with becoming a healthy adult and a contributing member of society. Serving low-income, at-risk youth since the early 1980s, Arbor's innovative programs are renowned for establishing best practices. In 1997 152 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 and, again, in 2002 and 2003, one of Arbor's youth programs received the National Promising and Effective Practices Network Award for effective practices in youth employment and development. Arbor was recognized for helping organizations in the field improve and for dispelling the myth that nothing works in youth programming. The (indiscernible) major programs that have demonstrated exemplary performance, model definition, and relations with its collaborative partners. Foster youth transitioning to independent living are heavily concentrated in America's large cities. If their transitions are not successful, these young people will become unemployed, homeless, or find themselves lacking in educational skills and certifications, all issues that the city will have to address. Fortunately, city governments can play a variety of leadership roles in 153 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 promoting and helping achieve successful transitions to independence and adulthood for foster youth. Indeed, cities and their elected officials and appointed officials can and are showing such leadership by convening partners, assembling the necessary human and financial capital, and establishing vision, goals, and accountability systems. It's our concern for young adult that prompts our testimony today regarding solutions and recommendations. Our expertise in foster and transitional care includes the Achieving Independence Center, Passports to Success in New York City, and collaboration with the Department of Labor and the Casey Family Programs and the Bridge in Pittsburgh. We have developed and implemented services to help young people in foster care achieve their goals of self-sufficiency. Going forward, we want to continue that commitment and 154 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 relationship to ensure that most, if not all, youth and those other young Philadelphians are successfully enrolled or re-enrolled in post-secondary education, training, vocational school, or high school this is fall. These students needs significant support to be successful in school, with adequate wraparound services. I witnessed firsthand the dramatic impact in youths' lives that are connected to these centers.

Mr. Spangler

In numerous instances, except for our staff, these youth did not have the support systems they need at the time of transition. When the appropriate tools are made available, future success is achievable. Of the 496,000 youth in foster care across the nation, each year, about 20,000 reach an age when they are emancipated from the child welfare system and must live independently on their own. In the City of Philadelphia, youth are preparing to leave the child welfare 155 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 system each year. As adults, we remember the challenges that we encountered when we struck out on our own, even with family and supportive networks. Youth who have exited foster care without an opportunity to develop self-sufficiency skills and support often encounter unemployment, homelessness, or become dependent on public assistance. The outlook for foster youth who have aged out is often grim: One in four will be incarcerated within the first two years after leaving the system; Over one-fifth will become homeless at sometime after the age of 18; Approximately 58 percent will earn a high school degree compared with 87 percent of a national comparison group of non-foster youth; Of youth who age out of foster care and are over the age of 25, less than 3 percent earn a college degree, 156 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 compared to 28 percent of the general population. Youth who age out of foster care at age often face unemployment or 6 end in up a series of low-wage, unsteady 7 jobs. 8 Pennsylvania is the fifth top 9 jurisdiction for the number of children 10 in out-of-home care. To improve outcomes 11 for youth leaving in foster care, a new 12 vision and proactive strategy is required 13 that recognizes that key stakeholders 14 cannot do this work in isolation of each 15 other. 16 With guidance and support from 17 local service agencies and visionary 18 leadership people, like you can help build brighter futures. Agendas to retain youth in foster care to the age of 21, working in collaboration with the National Job Core Centers as part of the Older Youth Initiative, and re-engaging disenfranchised children to complete their education can yield substantial 157 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 dividends. The advantages of post- secondary education are well-documented. Young adult with a bachelor's degree earn significantly more than those with less education. It's projected that foster youth with a bachelor's degree, on average, would earn $481,000 more than a foster youth who only has a high school diploma. Even if the young adults who begin college do not obtain their bachelor's degree, they also stand to benefit from the education they complete. Completing any college increases lifetime earnings by $129,000. Yet, so often, when college opportunity knocks, it goes unanswered. A study conducted by Northwestern University Center for Labor Market Studies demonstrates that adults with more than a high school diploma contribute $2,125 in taxes, while those were a bachelor's degree pay $13,630. 158 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 Conversely, individuals with less than years of education required $5,300 annually in supportive services. In this time of is a shrinking budgets and other priorities, how do we improve outcomes for children in foster care? Next year, if we only increase the post-secondary graduation rate to 5 percent for an associate's degree, we will recognize an additional $129 million in increased lifetime earnings for foster youth transitioning to independent level. These increases in lifetime earnings translate to taxable income. Jim Collins, the author of Good to Great, states that the question Why try for greatness? would seem almost tautological. If you're doing something you care that much about and you believe in its purpose deeply enough, then it is impossible to imagine not trying to make it great; it's just a given.

Mr. Spangler

Indeed, the real question is not Why greatness? but what work makes me 159 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 feel compelled to try to create greatness? If you have to ask the question Why should we try the make it great; isn't success enough? then you're probably in the wrong line of work. I know that with your support, we'll be able to retool our procedures and revitalize our concepts. Together, we can create a more successful and effective system. By working together, we will make Philadelphia a leader in the nation. Thank you.

Councilman Kenney

Thank you very much for your testimony and coming in today. Thank you. Barbara Clayton, Debra Young, Christina Farrell. (Witnesses come forward.)

Councilman Kenney

I just want to thank you 'cause you are the last panel and you waited around this long, and I appreciate your patience. And 160 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 someone's got to go last, and it's you. But thank you in advance of your testimony. Please identify yourself for the record.and proceed.

Ms. Clayton

My name is Barbara Clayton.

Ms. Young

Debra young.

Councilman Kenney

Please proceed. Is Christina Farrell here or no? No? Okay. Whoever would like to go first.

Ms. Young

Okay. My name is Debra Young, as I said. Thank you for hearing me today. My children were taken away from me for protecting them from an abusive father. I never lived with this man, I didn't share a home with him. I went to every court system down Center City to get my kids protection. I called the police, did everything, child therapist. Even went to DHS to get help 161 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 for my children. Instead of DHS helping me, they took my kids, okay? Now, they took their kids and put them with his mother that was also abusive to my kids. DHS knew this; they had the records from my child therapist 'cause my kids were in therapy, but they did nothing to help me and my children. Instead of helping me and my children get away from this abuser, they put my kids right with the abuser. Right now, my kids are with a abuser who failed the drug test. He was arrested five times for terroristic threats towards me and my children, stalking and harassment. My children are with this man right, now to this day. DHS gave him custody in June. I've been going through this for two-and-a-half years. I have a organization Justice for Families and Children. I've been to Washington four times to speak about this. People think DHS is there to 162 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 help. And they're supposed to help the families reunify the families; they do not reunify the families, okay? My family -- they've never been to my house in two-and-a-half years; it took a judge for them to come to my house to do a home study. I have passed every psychological test they gave me, I have passed every drug test they gave me, I have passed everything. Me and my kids got diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder because of what we've been through, because our family was destroyed and torn apart. A lot of families in Philadelphia are going through this for no reason. In a one-year period -- it's a known statistic, it's in the Ed Rendell's child abuse report -- in Philadelphia, the Department of Human Services took 8,000 kids away from their families but only investigated 2,073. 163 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 That's a whole lot of kids that are taken away from the families without being properly investigated. If they properly investigated my kids, they would have seen this man has been arrested for terroristic threats, trying to kill me, harassing my children everywhere we went. They did not do the proper job. I have e-mailed them over 200 times since this has happened in 2007. They ignored me. I have called about the abuse after my kids was taken away from me. I have called them 120 times because of the abuse my kids have gone through. I have over 200 pages of evidence of the abuse and what DHS has violated mine and my children's constitutional and God-given rights. I have never beat my children, I don't do drugs, I don't drink. I was a Philadelphia Guardian Angel. I got awarded from the vice president of the United States for my volunteer work. And 164 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 this is who they're taking these children away from. Now, my mother called to get her grandkids. They told her no and as she goes into foster kinship care. Why do our families have to go through kinship foster care, this program, to get their families? In other words, if you don't go through the kinship program for grandparents, you don't get your family. They would rather put 'em out in foster care with people that don't know your kids. Now, Pat Albright said some very good points there. When you go to court and you get represented by a court-appointed attorney -- I met my court-appointed attorney two minutes before I went in there and lost my kids. I have no idea why I lost my kids to this day. I met him two minutes before I went in there. He had -- he didn't know nothing about my case. I lost my kids. 165 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS.

Ms. Young

OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 My daughter and son got so upset, they started screaming and ran across the business highway 'cause they have no idea why they were taken away from me until this day. My case worker never returned my phone calls. In fact, in the courtroom, after court, she told me, excuse my language, to F off. We're disrespected as parents. We're treated like garbage. The reunification program, I have no idea what that is. They have never tried to reunify my side kids with me. And thousands of parents are going through this in Philadelphia. Grandparents, my mother? Forget it, she couldn't get the kids; they wouldn't return the calls. Grandparents, fathers, mothers are losing their kids for no reason except because they get paid to do this. The incentive bonus for Philadelphia was just awarded $1,273,000 166 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 in incentive bonuses to social workers for taking our kids. To this day, parents do not know why they have lost their kids. They have gone through psychological evaluations, they have done the drug testing. Everybody has to go through the same thing. Even if you don't do this, you still have to go through this program that you're mortified in. I had to do two years of drug-testing. For what? Their own psychiatrist said I didn't need any drug -- no drug counseling, nothing. I did fine on the evaluations; me and my kids passed with flying colors. I still, to this day, have supervised visits with my kids, for two-and-a-half years. But I've never beaten my kids or hurt my kids. My own children wrote letters stating this. Nobody listened to my kids from the beginning. My children told DHS what their father was doing. They never 167 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 listened. My children are with the abuser who's doing drugs. DHS knew and the judge knew in our first court hearing, and he failed three drug tests; I passed. He got my kids. Now, this is happening more and more in Philadelphia.

Councilman Kenney

How old are your children?

Ms. Young

My children now are 11 and 12.

Councilman Kenney

I don't know the specific details of the case and this is not the forum to go into them now. But if you want to give your name to my staff person, Sarah, we can certainly try to get an answer as to what's going on.

Ms. Young

Okay. My kids are now out of DHS but they're with their father.

Councilman Kenney

No, I hear what you're saying. And, again, I 168 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 don't -- we don't have the time to go through the specifics of the case, but I think it's probably quite personal. So I want to get an answer -- I need your information so I can get an answer for me from DHS as to what went on.

Ms. Young

My point is, you want to try to improve the process of decreasing the wait times in the foster care system, okay? Let the families going through adopting their grandkids without going through the kinship care. Most of these families are good families. She waited over two years, and she still has not got her grandkids and --

Councilman Kenney

Let us take a look at what went on.

Councilman Kenney

And thank you for coming in. Please identify yourself for the record.

Ms. Clayton

Barbara Clayton. Good afternoon, Councilman Kenney. And I 169 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 do want to thank you. I am a grandmother and I am here fighting for my grandson. My grandson has been involved with DHS since '06. We came into the picture in '07 because my stepdaughter was estranged from us, and we did not find out about the situation with my grandson until '07. When we found out about the situation, we attempted to approach DHS to find out how we could work with them to get our grandson out of foster care and bring him home to his family. It's been a lot of heartbreak, it's been a whole lot of heartbreak. DHS refused to speak with us. I had to go up and ask the governor for assistance. I've written multiple letters to different politicians in the State of Pennsylvania and the City of Philadelphia requesting help for grandparents. We're looked at like we are the guilty party. I've had home inspections, I've tried to work with DHS. Our working 170 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 with DHS, we've requested family group decision-making; it never came about. Five days prior to our last hearing, they called us and told us they wanted to have a family preservation meeting. They scheduled it five days prior to a hearing where they talked to us about PLC. Our PLC was talked about from November of '07. It was court-ordered in July of '08. And in September of '09, they terminated my stepdaughter's parental rights. They have now stopped us from having any contact with our grandson. Our goal back in 2007 was to bring our grandson home. We wanted to take custody of the child, we wanted to adopt him. Now they're placing our grandson up for adoption. After our hearing in September of '09, we were told by the social worker from DHS, "Oh, Mrs. " 171 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 At 1801 Vine, we went up to Carol Carson's office at the adoption unit to find out that we can't adopt our grandson, so now, he's going to be adopted out. This makes no sense to me. We have tried to work with DHS. I have no problem with foster care, I have no problem with adoption of children, but I don't understand why families are not considered first. I don't understand why DHS is not forthcoming with the truth and help us. These adoption agencies that have been here today, they're all talking about -- adoptive parents are talking about the problems that they have getting answers. Just imagine being a family member trying to get answers. Everyone is not on the same page. Our foster care agency is Children's Choice; I'm not very thrill with them. We've tried to work with them, we've tried to work with DHS. Everyone's not on the same page because 172 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 there is no family group decision-making. And it's sad right now because we haven't had no contact with my grandson since before -- since the termination of rights, I should say. So since September. I want to know what you told my 5-year-old grandson happened to his grandparents. Did we fall off the face of the earth? did we die? or do we not love you anymore? What kind of traumatic does this do to the child? When you have families that want to be involved and they're not permitted to be involved and DHS is not forthcoming with the truth, because their goal back in September of 2007 was to terminate my stepdaughter's rights and to put the child up for adoption, and they never changed that goal. They continued that going, even though we asked them to help us and to work with us. And if they have all these other agencies that they deal with and 173 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 all these different areas, why could they not have pointed us in the direction. They had us do a psychological evaluation for a bonding with our grandson. Our psychological evaluation was positive. There was an obvious attachment.

Ms. Clayton

The child needed us, that we could be a positive influence in his life, and they just disregarded that. They have disregarded the evaluation that was done by the doctor that they sent us to, to have the bonding evaluation done with. And they've terminated our rights. They've taken us out of our grandson's life. And I want to know what this five-year-old thinks. And I've asked that of Children's Choice and DHS and have not gotten a response.

Councilman Kenney

Well, I hear you, and I feel for your situation, and I will promise to get at least a briefing from them as to what their 174 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 position is on why this situation is what it is.

Ms. Clayton

Mr. Del Meriweather is here. He had a conversation with my husband back in August and told my husband that that child should have been placed with us because we're blood, okay? And then you go to court in September and terminate rights and lock us out of his life?

Councilman Kenney

Well, the earlier testimony from DHS was, in fact -- and I am at the beginning of the hearing somewhat torn either way on the philosophy or the policy of reunification, like how many times -- and I'm not talking about your cases in particular. But how many times do kids get given back and taken away from parents. And that's one issue. Now this other issue that you're raising here I think is also valid is that why -- if the goal is to reunify 175 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753 families, then why are the grandparents in your case cut out? So I will get answers to both, if I am permitted to have the information. That's the other issue too as to whether or not the information that's available is, in fact, available to me, or is it private? is it court-ordered private? is it, by regulation or by law, private? Similar to medical information. So I will do whatever I can to get an answer to your particular questions as to why you're in the situations that you're in.

Ms. Clayton

I'm not here to knock foster care.

Councilman Kenney

No, I don't think you are.

Ms. Clayton

And I'm not here to say anything bad about adoption. I just want to know why families are not considered for adoption.

Councilman Kenney

And -- 176 12/15/09 PUB. HEALTH/LEGIS. OVERSIGHT, RES 090753