civus

Committee Hearing, April 2, 2003

Minutes from Philadelphia City Council Committee Hearings, Apr 2, 2003

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

Councilwoman Tasco

What does that mean? COMMISSIONER DECKER: It means that the data base -- an automated system has a number of components. One of them is a data base, and customer software. Licenses have to be purchased for that software. We are under a contractual obligation for the system. We work with vendors who provide the data base services. In order for us to -- and all of those licenses are based on cost. Most typical setup is, the license cost is based on the number of users. We right now do not have the unlimited license capacity to support open internet access from all members -- from anyone who wants to access this information. The second issue that's of concern is network capacity. We simply are not positioned to accept all of that traffic coming in to the system. So they are two -- two issues that at this point make us unable to open this up on a wider basis. 00062 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilwoman Tasco

If you opened it up and put it on the internet, then you would no longer have the fees and money coming in from the companies, right? Because then they could go on the internet and access it without coming to you to pay a fee; is that true? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I'm sorry?

Councilwoman Tasco

The companies that you have the special program with would no 11 longer have to come and pay a special fee to access the services. They would be able to go in on the internet and get that, right? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Anyone -- in this scenario --

Councilwoman Tasco

Anybody would be able? COMMISSIONER DECKER: -- anyone would be able to come in to access the information, that's correct.

Councilwoman Tasco

Okay. So what is the income from the companies that you receive? COMMISSIONER DECKER: We do not have income from the internet component. Many of the companies purchase our microfilm copies of 00063 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole recorded documents, and also they purchase electronic extracts of -- it's known as the recorders index information.

Councilwoman Tasco

Is that what Mr. Goppelt is asking for? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Mr. Goppelt has asked for a number of things, and those components are part of his request.

Councilwoman Tasco

And so, if he gets that and puts it on the internet on his Hallwatch, it's open to everybody. COMMISSIONER DECKER: I don't know what his intentions are. I can't answer that.

Councilwoman Tasco

But I mean, you can go on and program in Hallwatch and you'd get all kinds of information. So the pilot program would no longer be necessary, because they could log on to Hallwatch and get the information. COMMISSIONER DECKER: I don't know what kind of information and how he would make that available. So, I'm sorry. I'm not in a position to answer that.

Councilwoman Tasco

Okay. Let's forget Mr. Goppelt. Let's just talk about Joe 00064 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Public. I'm with David -- Councilman Cohen in trying to see what information... We don't give access to the channels on T.V. We've been fighting that. We won't give the public access to the government T.V. stations. Now we won't give the public access to the information from the Records Department on the internet. I mean, you know, we're supposed to be a public institution that provides services to taxpayers. They pay for your department. They're not begging. They shouldn't have to come down. I shouldn't have to go down to your office. If I'm in my house and I have a computer, I should be able to access whatever information I want, as a taxpayer. And it seems to me, instead of trying to block that, every effort should be made to give public access to the information. And I think it's awful that we're having a lawsuit, spending taxpayers' dollars, to prevent someone getting information who is a citizen and entitled to the information. Whether you get it off the internet 00065 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole or you walk down the street and come into your office and get it, it's just like the old days when we were fighting to get voter registration forms. You know, those days are gone. And we had to fight those days. I thought we had moved into the 20th century. So I think you ought to go back and figure out how you're going to do it. And I think the lawsuit ought to be settled. I don't like paying for my tax dollars on a frivolous suit on something that you all can work out. I think it's a waste of tax dollars. So, I agree with Councilman Cohen. You all better figure it out. Thank you, Madam President.

Council President Verna

You're welcome. The Chair recognizes Councilman Ortiz.

Councilman Ortiz

No, ma'am. I'm fine.

Council President Verna

Councilman Nutter. 00066 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Nutter

Thank you, Madam Chair. Commissioner Decker, let me ask a couple of questions as a follow-up to Councilwoman Tasco. The information that we're talking about -- And if I get the terminology incorrect, you'll tell me. This PHILADOCS, what is it? COMMISSIONER DECKER: PHILADOCS is an automated system. It's used both -- in two ways. It's used to process the documents that come -- land documents that come into our department to be recorded, such as deeds and mortgages. And once that information is processed through a series of work flow steps, a record is stored, and that information is then made available. It becomes public record. So that would include the most recent real estate transactions that have occurred against particular properties and with certain individuals.

Councilman Nutter

At what point does the information become public record, after 00067 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole your department has processed it or while it's still in a processing status? COMMISSIONER DECKER: After -- Immediately after it has become processed.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. And is any of the information within this PHILADOCS system either proprietary or confidential? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The public record component is not proprietary -- it is not proprietary, and it is public information.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. When the companies access PHILADOCS, are they accessing the now processed records that are at that point public information? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. So there's nothing in the system that either the companies or an individual citizen should not see. COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Nutter

Let's talk about the licensing issue, as well as the network capacity issue. 00068 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole In a smaller way -- And you obviously work directly with the Mayor's Office of Information Services. We have a consultant that works with us here in City Council, and they work with Moise. It's my understanding, even for our computers in our offices, in our Council offices, that when you want to put internet access or a variety of other programs on our computers, it only happens after there is a license agreement established either for the entire system in City Council or even for that particular office. Is that the issue that you're dealing with, with regard to licensing? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Nutter

And Councilwoman Tasco's point was very interesting. How did you decide on the 50 companies or 50 users? COMMISSIONER DECKER: It was based on what we -- the funding that was available. That's how much money we had to purchase 50 licenses, that number of licenses.

Councilman Nutter

So the city had 00069 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to buy 50 licenses to allow these 50 companies to have access? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. Now, do you have any knowledge or information with regard to the City's web site, and whether or not there are any licensing issues related to -- I mean, obviously, the general public can access the City's web site. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Mm-hmm.

Councilman Nutter

Do you have any information about that? Is that mixing apples and oranges in this discussion? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes, I believe it is.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. If the public was going to have access to PHILADOCS, how would something like that be handled in the context of the licensing issue? COMMISSIONER DECKER: We would need the resources to be able to purchase additional licenses, assuming the objective is unlimited access to the system. 00070 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole We would need the resources to enable to us purchase an unlimited number of licenses into that system.

Councilman Nutter

How would you know how many licenses to purchase? Because you never really know how many people are going to use the system. COMMISSIONER DECKER: We would look at -- work the data base licensing structure to determine whether they offer a structure, a purchasing structure that would enable unlimited usage.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. So if this were going to be open to the public, what's your estimate on what it would cost, from a licensing standpoint, to allow the entire public access? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I don't have an exact figure, but we're probably talking about tens of thousands of dollars.

Councilman Nutter

For the 50 companies and the 50 licenses that you purchased, how much did each license cost? COMMISSIONER DECKER: I'm sorry, 00071 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Councilman.

Councilman Nutter

You have 50 companies. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes.

Councilman Nutter

You bought 50 licenses. How much did each license cost? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Our total -- I'm sorry, Councilman. I don't have that number at this point, but we do have -- I can get that to you. I can get the annual maintenance cost for the number of licenses that is currently supporting the system.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. You can send that to the Chair, and we'll then have that. But you believe that to open the system to the entire public we're talking tens of thousands of dollars, is that -- COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Nutter

-- is that your belief? COMMISSIONER DECKER: For the licenses. 00072 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Nutter

For the licenses. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Which is one of the issues.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. The second issue is network capacity; is that correct? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Nutter

Now, the City, again, has a server. It has a web site. And I think all of us have had the experience that at certain points in the day when there's particularly heavy traffic within the government, the system either slows down or from time to time stops. Was your system set up to deal with some estimated amount of, quote, unquote, traffic in the system? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes. Yes, it was, Councilman.

Councilman Nutter

Do you know what the capacity is? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes. 50 users. 00073 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Nutter

That's a coincidence. And so, if a decision was made to open this access, there are two things that would have to happen: One, the City would have to purchase enough licenses to allow for the access; and two, it sounds like you will probably need some upgrade in either hardware or software. I'm assuming working either with Moise or through whatever consultant Department of Records utilizes, to allow the system to then function for the possibly thousands of people, additional people to use the system; is that right? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. I'm not sure if you'll be able to answer this question, but is there a particular position of the Administration on this issue of complete and open access by the public to the PHILADOCS system? I mean, if there's not a position, don't try to create one at the moment. COMMISSIONER DECKER: At this point 00074 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole there is not a position.

Councilman Nutter

Okay. So there are actually three things that need to happen: One, the City Administration has to make a decision that they wish to make available this information to the general public, one; two, the City Administration and in conjunction with City Council would have to decide to pay for it, because you need the licenses; and three, the administration would then have to decide to acquire either the necessary software and/or hardware to allow the system -- Because once you make the first decision, and once you make the second decision, you're on your way toward making this happen. But it then makes no sense to buy all the licenses, having made a decision to open the system to the public, and it doesn't then have the capacity to function. So there's a third cost and procedure that you need to go through to open the system to the entire public; is that correct? COMMISSIONER DECKER: That's correct. 00075 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Nutter

All right.

Councilman Cohen

Point of Information.

Councilman Nutter

This is a point of information, not to be confused with a Point of Inquiry.

Councilman Cohen

Well, I understand it. And maybe I have it wrong. And if so, I'd like to be corrected. I understand there's a request by Mr. Goppelt that that would involve a single license. It would not involve everything that's been talked about, about making it available to thousands and thousands of users. It would be made available to Mr. Goppelt who on his own is making it available to the public. Isn't that the fact here, Mr. Goppelt?

Mr. Goppelt

Well, the Commissioner has mentioned problems with network capacity, or cited network capacity and licensing issues as a reason for not making this information available to the public. And I would offer her and this City 00076 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Council, if she gives me the electronic form of the recorders index, I will make that information available to the public tomorrow. If she gives it to me today, I will make it available to the public tomorrow. If she can't do it, for whatever reason, I can.

Councilman Cohen

And without this huge extra cost of licenses?

Mr. Goppelt

Councilman, I've used free software, as opposed to paid software which the City uses. So for me, I don't face a user limit the way that they might do. However, I did want to make one observation about the licensing issue. In my experience, the limit on the number of licenses usually refers to the number of simultaneous users. In other words, the number of people who can access the system at one time --

Councilman Nutter

Mm-hmm.

Mr. Gopelt

-- can't be any higher than a certain number, in this case perhaps 50. I don't know what the details of their license is. But in that particular case, all you need to do is not to say: Okay, these 50 00077 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole companies are permanently assigned licenses. You just buy enough licenses for your peak demand, and just let any member of the public use it. So, I don't know what the details of the licensing are --

Councilman Nutter

But, Mr. Goppelt...

Councilman Nutter

I think that that goes back to item number two, which -- and Councilman, I'm sorry to talk across your Point of Information. I just want to keep track of the traffic. It sounds like Mr. Goppelt is even saying, there will be a need for the City to buy some additional licenses. The question is, how many. And I think his point is, you know, whether you buy 10,000 of them, whether you buy 5,000 of them, maybe -- I mean, from a computer standpoint, you figure out what your peak times are, try to estimate how many licenses you need. But I don't think we get around the discussion or the reality that the City will have 00078 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole to buy some additional number of licenses, the number which we do not know at the moment. Is that a fair statement?

Councilman Cohen

Well, before they answer, I would like to raise this one question. It seems to me that if you picked 50, go through the 50, get rid of one of them, and have Mr. Goppelt be the 50th, I think that would deal with the situation now. That's as I see it. I'd like Mr. Goppelt, when he answers the... portion of the question, to also answer that.

Councilman Nutter

I appreciate that. Or we just buy one more license. I mean, if you have 50... And this, I think, all goes back to my earlier point of inquiry, which is, it appears that we've identified the three main issues. City has to decide it wants to do it. City has to buy some additional number of licenses which we won't figure out at this --

Councilman Cohen

I don't concede the second point.

Councilman Nutter

I'm sorry, 00079 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Councilman?

Councilman Cohen

I don't concede this second point. I don't concede that the City has to buy any additional licenses.

Councilman Nutter

I understand, Councilman.

Mr. Goppelt

I think that may be true, Councilman Nutter. 50 simultaneous users on a web site is a lot. On my web site, which is visited by 500 people a day, I would say that the maximum number of people who access the web site at any one time is maybe 8 or 10.

Councilman Nutter

Mm-hmm.

Mr. Goppelt

And I think another thing to keep in mind --

Council President Verna

Well, we would probably benefit -- And I don't know that the Commissioner is going to have this at her fingertips. I'm not sure that any of us who are talking about this know how many of the 50 are simultaneously using the system at any one point in time, nor do we know what the general usage of the PHILADOCS system is in general. But I'll go 00080 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole back to my earlier point of inquiry, which is, the City has to decide to open the system up.

Councilman Cohen

I don't think the City has any choice. I think the City's under a legal obligation.

Councilman Nutter

I understand that. I'm not making the City's argument. I'm just trying to identify the issues. Decision on opening the system up; continued discussion about the licensing issue, whether you need any more licenses: one more, ten more, fifty more. Doesn't really matter to me; and three, if there's a traffic issue and a network capacity issue, that has to be dealt with. So I'm going to go back to my original point, which is, somewhere between the Commissioner, Mr. Goppelt, Rob Dubow, Moise, and probably the Managing Director's Office, and possibly the Law Department at City Council, it appears that there can be an answer and a resolution to the public's benefit to this particular issue.

Mr. Goppelt

Well, like you, Councilman, I'm optimistic that a resolution is 00081 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole possible. The B.R.T. has recently substantially improved their web site. I don't think we heard anything from them complaining about insurmountable issues in licensing, and so on.

Councilman Nutter

I understand that. I'm very familiar with their recent upgrade.

Mr. Goppelt

I mean, not that I'm best buddies with the B.R.T., but in this particular case I think they did a good job, and the Records Department would be well to follow their example.

Councilman Nutter

Mr. Dubow, will you take some level of responsibility for making sure that all these parties get together and seek to resolve this issue? Councilman Cohen has raised a very serious matter here this morning, not only with regard to the funding issue for records, but you've heard all of the comments and questions by the Council Members on this particular issue. There needs to be a resolution. The 00082 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole public should have access. I wanted to be sure the information we're talking about here is not private, proprietary, or confidential information; it is all public record and information. You know, if we're not going to be in the 21st century, we can at least be in the later part of the 20th century with this. And, I mean, we don't have to make this into a Federal case before we can get a resolution.

Mr. Dubow

Rob Dubow, the Budget Director. Yes, I will make sure we work on this with Council and make sure the issue is resolved.

Councilman Nutter

But you understand, I mean, because I know you keep track of the budget process.

Mr. Dubow

Yes. Time is of the essence.

Councilman Nutter

There's a timeliness to this.

Councilman Nutter

This is not the 00083 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole general -- I'm not accusing you of this -- This is not the general: We'll work on it; we'll get back to you the second of nowhere. I mean, this is an actual real, live issue.

Mr. Dubow

I don't know what you mean by that.

Councilman Nutter

Yeah. This is a real live issue that needs a resolution as quickly as possible. And we're going to need to hear back from you and from the Commissioner that there's been a resolution. And I'm sure many of the Members are going to want to know formally or informally from Mr. Goppelt or anyone else that's concerned about this, that there is a legitimate, workable resolution to this particular issue.

Mr. Dubow

I understand the time constraints and how it ties into the budget process.

Councilman Nutter

All right. Thank you. Thank you, Madam Chair.

Council President Verna

You're welcome. The chair recognizes Councilman 00084 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Rizzo.

Councilman Rizzo

Thank you, Madam Chair. I'd just like to go back over what I believe we agreed on today. You're going to authorize Mr. Goppelt to be the 51st member of this group. But I'd like to back up a minute and ask about this three-year-long pilot program. I question the appropriateness of providing this service to 50 people with no revenue or no 12 reimbursement at all to the City of Philadelphia. So I'd like you to check with the Law Department to see what the appropriateness of this lengthy -- I can understand, like Mr. Goppelt said, a short pilot program, but to have one that's lasted three years and spend taxpayers money to support the private sector in many cases. And I think also what you need to do is look at these 50 users to see -- And I'm sure the technology people can look at the actual usages of those 50 customers, those free customers, to make sure that they're just, you know, they have it, they don't use it, we're paying something for it. 00085 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole I'd rather see someone have it that's going to use it. So, I think you really need to look at the usages of those 50 to see, just because they're in the deal doesn't mean they should stay in it. I'm sure that there have been other people that have had an interest, that you're saying, well, we have our 50, there's no room for you. But if you have people that have used it once a month or once a day or once a week, I question the need for an organization to have that, especially for free. The other issue that Mr. Goppelt brought up was the fact that you want to charge him. And I'd like to understand that better. Is that a one-time charge of $400, or is this an ongoing charge? And Commissioner, since you've been so gracious to agree Hallwatch to come on, isn't there some accommodation that you could give to make this problem go away, get the lawyer doing something else rather than fooling around with this? 00086 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole I'd really like you to try to, if you're going to go 90 percent here, go the extra little effort, and let's make everybody happy here today. COMMISSIONER DECKER: To answer your two questions: First question, about the pilot being made available to companies at no cost, I would like to point out, the reason that that was done is because we knew that the capacity, the network capacity simply was not there, and we are unable to guarantee performance. So we do experience some down time. And for that reason, we did not establish a charge for that service.

Councilman Rizzo

Well, you might want to reconsider that. And I would appreciate you providing to the Chair a report for information systems or your own technology people -- I'd like to see a report on exactly in the last three years what the usages have been. And let's come up with a capacity recommendation. And if there's some that haven't been using it, maybe you need to call that list and don't need the 51st license. And that's an interesting subject in 00087 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole itself, being a government. I'm sure -- I hope that we're absolutely required to operate with those constraints to buy licenses, just like the private sector. I would hope the Law Department has looked at that very carefully to see exactly what we're required to do and what we're not doing. I don't know if licensing always applies to the degree that it does in the private sector, for our government. So, I'd like that issue. But I would like to see, when you're providing the names of the 50 organizations, what exactly they're doing, their utilization of this arrangement that they have. And also, I didn't mean to interrupt you, but if you could answer the rest of the questions in the monetary requirement that Hallwatch may have to get this online; and to give it to them in the format that he needs it to make it work, Commissioner; no obstacles here, if you could, please. COMMISSIONER DECKER: I think your second question was about a $400 charge. That was 00088 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole for procuring copies, electronic copies of index information. And there is a calculation that's used. When we establish a fee, it's really based on labor costs, on materials and usage time, computer usage time. So, there are three basic categories of costs that are used in an algorithm to determine fees. The computer usage time is based on each hour of wall clock computer time. And that's a certain fee which is established. The extract comes from a mainframe, and that the fee is based on that particular extract, what is generated by that extract. And the labor cost, if there's any labor involved in monitoring the job, submitting a job, entering variable information. All those charges are also included in that. The other element is the amount of data that someone is requesting. So, there's a difference -- I don't know where $400 is coming from. There's no, in a sense, set fee. The fee is based on the amount of data. Someone may request an extract of 00089 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole the entire data base, which goes back to... The electronic database goes back to 1976. Another requester may request a month's worth of data. Another requester may request a year's worth of data. So the actual cost for... called a job run, really depends on the amount of data that is being requested.

Councilman Rizzo

Commissioner, is Mr. Goppelt asking for anything different than the other 50 people? And if he isn't, then let's give it to him. COMMISSIONER DECKER: Sure.

Councilman Rizzo

Because you're not charging 50 other people for what you just described to me. So I don't understand why we need to be aggressive in this particular case, when you're not being aggressive at all in the other 50 situations here. COMMISSIONER DECKER: We already said we would give Mr. Goppelt online access to the system. He had a number of other requests, and I was merely trying to explain what his other 00090 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole requests were.

Councilman Rizzo

I understand that. And that's my question. Is he asking for anything above and beyond what you're giving the other 50 people? If he is, then that we have to negotiate. COMMISSIONER DECKER: He's asking for extracts of other kinds of data, and for which he does not want to pay a fee, which other individuals and companies are willing to pay.

Councilman Rizzo

Are any of those 50 people paying you for any additional information? COMMISSIONER DECKER: The online system is a different system. We've already agreed to give him access to that.

Councilman Rizzo

Okay. Mr. Goppelt?

Mr. Goppelt

All I want to do is pay a fair price for the data. The Commissioner has cited a price and cited components in the price of labor and computer wall time. I guess my home computer must be really fast, because I was able to do a month's 00091 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole worth of data in under two minutes. So I don't know what the matter with the City mainframe is that, you know, this is going to require hours and hours of wall time. I think what I would like to see from the Records Department is for them to, quote, unquote, come clean about what their costs are. I think it's a positive step forward to talk about labor cost, materials and computer time. And I liked Councilman Nutter's suggestion that all of us get together and talk about these things. I have offered in the past to speak with the Commissioner and the Department about negotiating a fair price. My offers were ignored. So I think that's the way to go, for me to sit down with them and negotiate a fair price with the computer people present so that knowledgeable people are talking about the true costs.

Councilman Rizzo

I agree that since you're providing this as a public service, that the costs should be fair, the costs should be not inflated, there should be -- Especially when 00092 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole we are giving this to 50 people at no cost at this moment. If it's a matter of revenue, then let's start sending the 50 people a bill in the pilot. If they want it, they can keep it. And maybe they need to start paying for it or doing whatever -- whatever is required here. But I just don't understand a three-year pilot with no end in sight. Commissioner, I suggest you end it and come up with a reasonable cost to --

Councilman Cohen

Point of information.

Councilman Rizzo

Point of Information.

Council President Verna

The Chair recognizes Councilman Cohen.

Councilman Cohen

In the public interest, the Zoning Board, after going through the same kind of contortions that I believe the Records Department is going through, agreed to make available to community organizations without charge the cost of transcripts wherever a community organization had opposition to a zoning 00093 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole change and lost before the Board and was appealing it. Because it's in the interests of the public. The City ought to be paying Mr. Goppelt. The nerve of you compelling somebody who's doing a public service to pay for it is outrageous. Why should Mr. Goppelt, who's taking over what the City ought to be doing to make this available, saving the City, but according to your testimony, Commissioner, thousands upon thousands upon thousands of dollars. He's doing it and you're quibbling with him over a few dollars? It makes absolutely no sense whatever to be involved in this situation. There ought to be no need to work out anything. Mr. Goppelt isn't going to be charging the people of Philadelphia a service fee. He's doing it for nothing. So the City doesn't want the taxpayer to know what's going on? The City wants to keep taxpayers from having the benefit of volunteer citizens contribution to their knowledge? You ought to be encouraging 00094 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Mr. Goppelt. You ought to be asking him: What is it costing you, and the City will pay it? It's a tremendous bargain for the City and for the citizens. And I resent deeply your trying to keep my constituents in the 17th Ward, where I'm the Democratic Leader, from getting the necessary information. They pay millions and millions of dollars a year in taxes, yet you want to deny them this information. I just don't understand that kind of public service, Commissioner. I really don't. I think you ought to be negotiating with Mr. Goppelt what are his costs and how can the City make up to him for the wonderful service he's offering the citizens without taxing them, without requiring them to make a payment.

Councilman Rizzo

Commissioner, I would hope that you can work this out, because I can see a hearing on this specific issue coming, maybe even tomorrow, a resolution to ask for a hearing to have everybody in here. I would hope that we don't have to do that. But I would ask my colleague, Councilman 00095 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Cohen and any other Councilman that's interested in this issue to join me. But I would hope, based on your response so far, I believe you're going to work this out. And I think you understand how important this is to your Council. Even though we talk about how pleased the State Legislature is, make this Council happy, make our constituents happy, and do what you need to do to get this thing working, please, or you'll have a hearing.

Councilman Cohen

Madam President, may I suggest that we pick a date no longer than two weeks from today for a report back at open hearing by the Department of Records as to the disposition of this question, earlier if possible, but a date no later. I don't, but you have the calendar, Madam President.

Council President Verna

I'm looking at our calendar. April the 8th, at o'clock. Commissioner, would you be ready by then? COMMISSIONER DECKER: Yes.

Council President Verna

Very well. 00096 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Thank you. Are there any other questions or comments from Members of the Committee? (No response.)

Council President Verna

Thank you very much, Mr. Goppelt. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner.

Council President Verna

The prison system is next. Good morning, Commissioner. COMMISSIONER KING: Good morning, Madam Council President.

Council President Verna

Every member has a copy of your written testimony. We will make certain that the stenographer has it. He will transcribe it in full. I would ask you to please summarize your testimony, if you will. COMMISSIONER KING: I have a little something that I want to read very quickly.

Council President Verna

That would be fine. I'm asking that you summarize rather than read the entire testimony. Thank you. COMMISSIONER KING: Good morning, President Verna and Members of City Council. I'm Leon King, Acting Commissioner of the Philadelphia Prison System. Thank you for 00097 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole this opportunity to present this testimony regarding our fiscal 2004 year operating budget, and to briefly share --

Councilman Cohen

Could you speak a little slower, please.

Council President Verna

Councilman, I'm sorry. We can't hear you. I don't know if your microphone is on. COMMISSIONER KING: He's asking me to slow down.

Council President Verna

Oh, I'm sorry. Okay. Please slow down. COMMISSIONER KING: -- and to briefly share with you the new vision and goals of the Philadelphia Prison System. Sitting here with me at the table is Press Grooms, Deputy Commissioner for Policy and Operations; Dan Rakowski, Director of Administrative Services; and Ed Siemanski, Fiscal Officer. Also present in the room is our General Counsel and three other Deputy Commissioners who assist me in running the system. By way of background, I was appointed Acting Commissioner by Mayor Street on 00098 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole December 9, 2002, with the support of former Managing Director Estelle Richmond, at the recommendation of former Commissioner Thomas Costello, who retired in December after 30 years of service with the system. I began my employment with the City in 1991 as an Assistant City Solicitor in the Claims Division of the Law Department. In 1993 I was recruited to be one of the founding members of the Civil Rights Unit of the Law Department where I was later promoted to Deputy City Solicitor. While still litigating cases on behalf of the prison system, the Police Department, the Sheriff's Department, and the Clerk of Quarter Sessions, I was appointed General Counsel of the prison system in 1997 by then City Solicitor Stephanie Franklin Suber. In that capacity, I became the lead attorney representing the City in the Jackson vs. Hendrick consent decree litigation, and the primary attorney assisting our outside counsel in the Harris litigation. Late in 2001 I negotiated, along 00099 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole with Director Richmond and Commissioner Costello, the final settlement of the Jackson litigation, ending over 30 years of Court supervision over the system. Over the years in my capacity as General Counsel, and from my active involvement in the consent decree cases, I became familiar with almost all areas of prison operations, and have been an integral part of the management team since 1997. For about a year in 2001 I also served as a Deputy City Solicitor in the Labor and Employment Unit of the Law Department, becoming familiar with human resources issues as they relate to the Police Department, the prison system, and other City departments. Since being appointed Acting Commissioner, I, along with Deputy Commissioner Grooms, Deputy Commissioners John Murphy, Elsa Legessa, Allen Appel, and our new General Counsel Michael Resnick, have begun on a mission of accelerating the transformation and transition of the system from one overseen by the courts and not fully able to utilize its substantial internal 00100 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole talent, to one that has learned from the lessons of the past, recognizes that it cannot forgot those lessons, and is highly motivated to stress professionalism, excellence, adherence to the mandates of the United States Constitution, being even more in tune with the needs of our inmate population, and supporting and recognizing the strengths of our staff. At the same time we are sending a message to staff that behavior that does not comport with the system's goals will not be tolerated. We are also, of course, committed to grooming the leaders of the future who will have be to be ready to take on more responsibility in the next three years as we lose all four of our Deputy Commissioners due to the DROP program. With the full support of Deputy Commissioners Grooms, Murphy and Appel, I'm very proud to have acceded in obtaining the appointment of Deputy Commissioner Lagess, shortly after my appointment as acting Commissioner. She is an historic first and strong evidence of the change that has come about in the system. 00101 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole She was the first warden appointed in her own right -- female warden appointed in other own right in the 400-plus years of the system some years ago, and now she is the first female Deputy Commissioner.

Council President Verna

Since my appointment we have also taken direct responsibility for supervising and overseeing health services within the system for the first time since 1979. Taking this responsibility very seriously and utilizing our heretofore largely untapped internal talent, we have taken decisive steps to improve the delivery of health care in the six short weeks since this responsibility was officially turned over to us. I have set the goal in the system to become a national model of health care in the correctional setting. I have instructed that the system move forward immediately to obtain accreditation with the American Correctional Association, and the National Commission on Correctional Health Care. We will also be fully implementing a 00102 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole new Hepatitis C policy within the system in the next week or so to more effectively treat those inmates who are affected by this disease. We have also taken limited steps to explore the feasibility of altering our system of health care by studying the delivery of health care in other jurisdictions. We are also committed to re-evaluating services available to inmates that may affect recidivism and are seeking to make re-entry and discharge planning an organized targeted process to reduce recidivism. Symbolic of our new mission and goals, we have moved our next correctional officer graduating exercises from the inside of the Philadelphia Industrial Correctional Center to a public ceremony which is going to be held at the Convention Center on April 11th. We are going to showcase our new correctional officer graduating class and publicly announce our new goals. The Mayor, the District Attorney, the City Controller, and the Police Commissioner are going to join us as we move forward to the future. 00103 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole We have extended an official invitation to each Member of Council to join us and show your support at our graduation. We would be honored to have all members attend. Our budget request for fiscal year '04 is $185,234,000, and represents a $10 million increase over our fiscal year '03 estimated budget request. This reflects a phase-in of additional full-time staff for our new women's detention facility which will open in the first half of fiscal '04, anticipated increases in the cost of improved medical care for inmates, and increased maintenance costs connected with the opening of the women's detention facility. This concludes my testimony. And I and my staff are available for any questions.

Council President Verna

Thank you very much, Commissioner. Could you please explain how you are able to operate in FY '04 with 102 fewer positions than you were budgeted for in FY '03? Your FY '04 personnel services budget reflects approximately $1.2 million in 00104 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole delay in filling new positions and turnover reductions, which is equivalent to 40 vacancies for the entire year. I ask, is your budget sufficient to maintain a safe and secure environment in the prisons? COMMISSIONER KING: Yes. Our budget is sufficient to maintain a safe and secure environment in the prisons. Our budget is adequate to maintain a safe and secure environment in the prisons. And I'll ask Mr. Siemanski to explain that technical question about the staffing issue in the budget.

Mr. Siemanski

Edward Siemanski, Fiscal Officer. Regarding the question to the number of positions, those positions weren't filled during fiscal '03. And since the population has dropped considerably since the budget was proposed, we're going to reallocate the staff from various facilities. And we expect to be able to provide adequate security with the number in the fiscal 2004 budget.

Council President Verna

You said 00105 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole the population has decreased? What is the population, and what was it last year?

Mr. Siemanski

The current population today is 7,107 inmates. And that's a decrease from back in September about 800 or 900 inmates.

Council President Verna

I'm sorry?

Mr. Siemanski

800 or 900 less inmates than we had in September. This is the lowest population --

Council President Verna

How do we account for it going down?

Mr. Siemanski

There are many --

Council President Verna

That's quite a bit.

Mr. Siemanski

There are many suggestions going around. People have speculated that it may be Operation Safe Streets. It may have been the cold winter. We're not prepared to state on the record what it was. But those are the two things that come to mind that may be different than they were in past years.

Council President Verna

Well, we'll be getting warm weather. 00106 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. Siemanski

Right. And our prediction is that the end of March, we're going to look to see if the population starts to go up, and it looks like it's starting to go back up.

Council President Verna

And you feel comfortable with the budget that you presently have, even if the population increases?

Mr. Siemanski

Well, it depends on how much the population increases.

Council President Verna

Okay.

Mr. Siemanski

If it goes back up, you know, 1500 inmates or something like that, we'd have an issue.

Council President Verna

All right. Commissioner, you are projecting to spend $7.6 million on maintenance contracts for C.F.C.F. and Women's Detention Facility. This represents an increase of almost 30 percent over last year's cost. Would you please tell us: Would it be better to bring the maintenance back in-house? Would it be more cost effective?

Mr. King

I don't think that it would be more cost effective to bring the 00107 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole maintenance in-house. I believe our experience has been that the service we get for the money we pay is pretty good service. And no, I don't think that that would be more cost effective.

Council President Verna

How many people are in the maintenance contract?

Mr. King

For W.D.F. and C.F.C.F., how many people? Okay. Roseanne, could you come up. Do you know what that number is? We don't have that number. We can get it for you.

Council President Verna

You'll provide it to us, please.

Council President Verna

Please explain the dramatic increase in prison health services. I believe on -30 it is now going to be over $42 million. So if we have less inmates, wouldn't that also be affected?

Mr. King

I believe that the increase in the additional funds for medical came 00108 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole about as a re-negotiation of the contract back in FY '03 when the population was higher. And Miss Steiker from the M.D.O.'s office, I believe, handled all of that, and she can answer that question more specifically.

Ms. Steiker

This is Ellen Steiker, Deputy Managing Director. Good morning.

Council President Verna

Good morning.

Ms. Steiker

The major components of the increase are predominantly the opening of W.D.F., which had a significant staffing impact. Now, we'll be looking at that in light of some of the population declines. But when you open a new facility, you have to staff it properly with health workers. So that was one. The second piece is personnel cost, just the cost of living increases for personnel under the collective bargaining agreement. And the third area is malpractice insurance. That has been a real wild card for the prisons, as well as for the rest of Pennsylvania. It's not a problem that's related specifically to the prisons. But from 2002 to 2003 our 00109 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole malpractice premiums have more than doubled. And so, in this budget we're assuming that there will be continued growth of that. If that doesn't materialize, we won't pay it. Again, we only pay the actual costs that are incurred by the provider. We do not pay some fixed price. So if in fact our assumptions are not correct and the costs come down, then we won't have to pay these costs to the provider.

Council President Verna

Thank you. Commissioner, on -30 of the detail you have $2.3 million for Philadelphia health management for drug treatment programs. Are they a direct provider?

Mr. King

What page is that again?

Council President Verna

45-30.

Mr. King

I believe that is connected with the F.I.R. program. I'd ask Ellen or --

Council President Verna

I'm sorry?

Mr. King

I believe that's funding connected with the F.I.R. program, but I would ask Deputy Commissioner Appel to come up and explain that. 00110 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Council President Verna

I have no 3 idea what the F.I.R. program is.

Mr. King

Forensic Intensive Recovery.

Council President Verna

Okay. All right. Good.

Mr. Appel

Hello. I'm Allen Appel. I'm the Deputy Commissioner for Treatment. The F.I.R. program provides for the early parole of inmates to enter drug treatment in a variety of community agencies. And it removes those inmates directly from the prisons. So it helps to reduce the inmate population, while it also helps to reduce the numbers that come back through the drug treatment successes that it provides.

Council President Verna

Are they community groups that you're referring to? Are they the ones that are outlined on -30?

Mr. Appel

They are a number of those. There are others that make up the F.I.R. network that receive their funding not through the prisons but through other agencies.

Council President Verna

Okay. 00111 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole Well, of the $2.3 million for the Philadelphia health management, what portion of that contract is for administrative purposes?

Mr. Appel

We don't have that information right now, but we will certainly provide it to you.

Council President Verna

You'll provide it to us, please. Thank you. Commissioner, on -31 of the detail, you request $400,000 for Philadelphia Urban Affairs Council for programming female inmates. Would you explain what that is?

Mr. King

I can explain it generally speaking. We have a facility at Cambria Avenue in North Philadelphia where we house 2,000 female inmates. That money goes to --

Council President Verna

How many female inmates do we have?

Mr. King

200. No. 200 I meant. 200.

Council President Verna

That's better. We're going to have to build a new prison.

Mr. King

And these female inmates 00112 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole receive treatment and counseling and other services. And that's what that money is for.

Council President Verna

Okay. And on that same page of the detail, you have $33,981 for G.E.D. and basic skills education. Is this for your staff or is it for inmates?

Mr. King

It's more inmates.

Council President Verna

And why has this program been reduced from its FY '02 level?

Mr. Siemanski

Edward Siemanski. That two payments doubled up in that fiscal year inadvertently. And that's why you see that double amount in fiscal 2002. And it's G.E.D. education for the inmates provided by the School District of Philadelphia. It's not for the Philadelphia prison staff. That money doesn't go to Philadelphia prison staff. It goes to the School District, teachers.

Council President Verna

Fine. Thank you very much. The Chair recognizes Councilman Cohen. 00113 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Councilman Cohen

Yes. Just a couple of questions. When did the population jump from the -- previously figures that I heard about were something like 5,000. And Judge Shapiro was complaining bitterly that that was way over the maximum allowed. When did it jump to 8,000? Was that during Commissioner Timoney's reign? Because there had been dealing in certain circles that arrests were going apace, people were going into jail, and cases were being thrown out of Court because they had -- either the arrests were improper, at least, not supported by the evidence in many cases, and in many cases they were. But there was an enormous increase. Was that when it took place?

Mr. Siemanski

Well, the 5,000 inmate population was back in 1995, 1996. The population jumped to the 8,000 level. Then it was back -- began to climb to that level in 1998. And that was when Commissioner Timoney first came to town.

Councilman Cohen

When did the DROP begin? 00114 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole

Mr. Siemanski

In September of last year.

Councilman Cohen

Was that the same time when the Safe Streets Program was being initiated?

Mr. Siemanski

Shortly thereafter.

Councilman Cohen

Has anybody investigated the percentage of that? The current population is what, 7100?

Councilman Cohen

Do we know how many of that 7100 are in prison because of failure to pay bail, say, that's no higher than $5,000 which would require $500 in cash bail? Do we know how many prisoners are there?

Mr. Siemanski

I couldn't tell you that off the top of my head. I know we looked into that a few months back. I would have to research it again and get you the information.

Councilman Cohen

Is there anybody assigned to the task of determining whether a prisoner is there solely because of the inability to pay bail, and what it costs the City to collect -- to have them put up $503, I think it 00115 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole was, for a $5,000 bail? How much does it cost the City to provide whatever services, you know, are needed for that prisoner? What does it cost the City to hold that person in confinement, and whether it would not in fact be cheaper if the City put up the bail.

Mr. Siemanski

There's no one specifically assigned to that task.

Councilman Cohen

Would it make sense to do that? I believe that probably one-third of the prisoners are there simply because they're too poor to put up minimal bail. And the City spends many many times the amount that it would cost the City to put up the bail and have some control over the person when he's out on bail. And I don't see any purpose in the person staying in jail if the only thing keeping him there is because he's too poor to get $500 for bail.

Mr. Siemanski

No. And I --

Councilman Cohen

I can understand 00116 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole if a judge commits somebody because they're fearful that the person may be a threat to society in one way or the other or presents some kind of a danger. But if the only thing keeping somebody in prison is an inability, say, to come up with something as small, say, as under $1,000, it seems to me to be a terrible waste of money for the City to insist on waiting for bail money while it's costing the City. What does it cost, do you think, per prisoner each day?

Mr. Siemanaski

Well, the per diem cost in fiscal '02, I believe, was $75 a day per inmate.

Councilman Cohen

On average $75 a day, considering all the costs, including the health and the maintenance, and everything else?

Councilman Cohen

Well, so, in seven days, in one week's confinement, the City pays the cost of bail. And what would be the human purpose, if somebody's being kept in jail simply because he or she cannot make the bail payment -- and I guess 00117 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole generally it's a he rather than a she, more often than not -- what use is being served by keeping that person? We know the dangers of jail confinement. The prisoner might learn new methods of committing a burglary or a theft or may become despondent, may develop health care problems, you know, all the terrible things that can happen. His children may have problems, if he has children. His wife may suffer from problems. What's the use of the cash bail system if the person can't make the cash payment? Is it to maintain a prison staff?

Mr. Siemanski

In answer to your question, that's an issue that's been discussed over the years within the prison system and the criminal justice system.

Councilman Cohen

Well, has the prison system made any...

Mr. Siemanski

And the problem with -- We recognize the fact that it costs a lot of money to keep people there. But on the other hand, we have issues that people get bail because we want them to show up in Court. 00118 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole So if you pay their bail and they're not paying the bail, that means they might not come back. And we want them to come back.

Councilman Cohen

Are there any statistical studies on that?

Mr. Siemanski

I could -- Sure; I could get you numbers from the Warrant Unit of the Court of Common Pleas and other sources about how many people, who even when they pay their bail, don't come back.

Councilman Cohen

You know, the costs for a Prison Commissioner are paid really by the school system. The one -- At the state level, the one cost that keeps climbing indefinitely is the prison cost, while the amount of money appropriated for schools in real income has been declining, the state portion of the income. Seems to me that you all, because you're living the situation, you all have a responsibility to present material to us to help guide us in making the decisions. I think it's a terrible waste of money for the City to spend maybe $10,000 and maybe much more than that to maintain somebody in 00119 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole prison because he couldn't come up with the $500 bail payment.

Mr. Siemanski

Well, Councilman, we have a lot of other things in place to assist inmates to contact people and find different sources of money to come up with the bail.

Councilman Cohen

Could you explain those to us in detail? Could you tell us --

Mr. Siemanski

We have social workers who work with them to try and find sources of money and information and contacts. That's part of the reason we have free phone calls for them when they come into the receiving room. They come in. They can make a phone call. We want them to make phone calls so that they can make contacts and get their bail money and leave the prison system.

Councilman Cohen

Well, why can't the City set up a bail fund and have a few people that maintain contact with the prisoners? It would be so much cheaper.

Mr. Siemanski

I can't really answer that. But I'm not sure that the public would appreciate the fact that we arrest people 00120 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole and then pay for them to leave prison. That doesn't make any sense.

Councilman Cohen

Well, but we're spending so much more money maintaining them.

Mr. Siemanski

I understand. It's a tough issue.

Councilman Cohen

The public, I think, has great difficulty understanding that.

Mr. Siemanski

I agree.

Councilman Cohen

At this point, Madam President, I would like to yield the floor because I know there are many other questions by other Council Members.

Council President Verna

At this time I would like to recognize Councilman Rizzo, whose light's been on for some time.

Councilman Rizzo

Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner. Commissioner, I want to talk about PHILACOR. I want to tell you what experience I had this week. I went to visit a school. And in that particular school kids were sitting in the classroom with the sun beating through the 00121 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole windows, terribly distracted by the sunlight, and just not a good situation to try to educate kids. All the window shades were gone from the classroom. And they've been trying to get window shades -- I hope Mr. Vallas is listening -- for a long time. PHILACOR, because I'm familiar with the work that you do there, seems to be a secret to a lot of people.

Mr. King

A hidden treasure.

Councilman Rizzo

A hidden treasure. I bet that if the School District wanted to have you manufacture window shades that they're spending thousands and thousands of dollars to go out and purchase them -- I'm only suggesting that you send -- or I'd love to be part of the meeting -- I'd like the person that's responsible for maintenance in the School District of the City of Philadelphia where possibly items that need to be made: Book shelves, things that support that School District that they're going out presently and buying at Home Depot, Lowe's, you name it, that they get an education, maybe a 00122 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole little meeting to explain what you do. You know, I'm reading here what you do. You do -- I know that Camp William Penn, you've done some things for them. You do the laundry. There's so many things you do. But for the School District's top people not to be aware of what PHILACOR -- Is that how it's referred to, PHILACOR?

Councilman Rizzo

PHILACOR. I'd like you to, you know, have a meeting, or suggest someone to have a meeting. And I'd love to attend it to see. And Plus, I'd like to get one of those updated catalogs of all the nice things for me.

Mr. King

Absolutely. We'd be he happy to provide that.

Councilman Rizzo

And I had some, I believe, stationery printed up there. And it turned out wonderfully. It was --

Mr. King

We do print, I believe, all the stationery for the City. We probably made all these name plates that you have here in City Council. 00123 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole And we actually are going to be presenting some legislation to City Council to request that you change the way we operate so we can expand our services. And we'd be happy to meet with you and the School District.

Councilman Rizzo

Yeah, I would love for you to call whoever the person that runs the maintenance. Am I off the wall to think that maybe your prison population could manufacture window shades?

Mr. King

I don't know about that specifically, but --

Councilman Rizzo

Well, why not? It's really a simple... Let's look at it, at least, because they're going out and spending a lot of money. They're going to do this one school completely over. It's like 250 different window shades. And what is a window shade? They staple material to a tube that's premanufactured, cut it to length. And if you can make some of the -- do some of the things you do, I think that that's something that maybe you could support. 00124 04/02/03 - Committee of the Whole That's only just one of the probably dozens of things that I think, especially when the School District's up against it financially, that you might be able to save them a few bucks.