civus
Minutes

Stated Meeting, October 8, 2020

Philadelphia City CouncilOct 8, 2020

Legislation acted on in this session

From the City of Philadelphia’s legislative record (Legistar). Each file links to its status, roll call, and official documents.

  • Bill 200349SUSPEND THE RULES OF THE COUNCIL

    Amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled “Zoning and Planning,” to amend certain provisions of Chapter 14-500, entitled “Overlay Zoning Districts,” by creating the “/AM…

  • Bill 200349ORDERED PLACED ON THIS DAY`S FIRST READING CALENDAR

    Amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled “Zoning and Planning,” to amend certain provisions of Chapter 14-500, entitled “Overlay Zoning Districts,” by creating the “/AM…

  • Bill 200349READ AND ORDERED PLACED ON NEXT WEEK'S SECOND READING CALENDAR

    Amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled “Zoning and Planning,” to amend certain provisions of Chapter 14-500, entitled “Overlay Zoning Districts,” by creating the “/AM…

  • Bill 200374SUSPEND THE RULES OF THE COUNCIL

    Renaming and designating Chalfont Playground in Northeast Philadelphia as the "Corporal Jimmy O’Connor Memorial Playground".

  • Bill 200374ORDERED PLACED ON THIS DAY`S FIRST READING CALENDAR

    Renaming and designating Chalfont Playground in Northeast Philadelphia as the "Corporal Jimmy O’Connor Memorial Playground".

  • Bill 200374READ AND ORDERED PLACED ON NEXT WEEK'S SECOND READING CALENDAR

    Renaming and designating Chalfont Playground in Northeast Philadelphia as the "Corporal Jimmy O’Connor Memorial Playground".

  • Bill 200424SUSPEND THE RULES OF THE COUNCIL

    Renaming and designating the property commonly referred to as the 30th and Jefferson Playground, located at the corner of 30th and Jefferson Streets, as the “Howard McCall, Sr. Pla…

  • Bill 200424ORDERED PLACED ON THIS DAY`S FIRST READING CALENDAR

    Renaming and designating the property commonly referred to as the 30th and Jefferson Playground, located at the corner of 30th and Jefferson Streets, as the “Howard McCall, Sr. Pla…

  • Bill 200424READ AND ORDERED PLACED ON NEXT WEEK'S SECOND READING CALENDAR

    Renaming and designating the property commonly referred to as the 30th and Jefferson Playground, located at the corner of 30th and Jefferson Streets, as the “Howard McCall, Sr. Pla…

  • Bill 200537Introduced and Referred

    Amending Section 2 of an Ordinance (Bill No. 180560) approved July 10, 2018, entitled “An Ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 250 b…

  • Bill 200538Introduced and Referred

    Amending Title 10 of The Philadelphia Code to create a new Chapter 10-2500, entitled “Less Lethal Devices,” to regulate the use of less lethal devices in specific situations; all u…

  • Bill 200539Introduced and Referred

    Authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 299 by striking from the City Plan Parker Avenue from a point approximately one-hundred fifty-six feet so…

+6 more substantive items

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA STATED MEETING Via Microsoft Teams Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Thursday, October 8, 2020 10:10 a.m. PRESENT: COUNCIL PRESIDENT DARRELL L. CLARKE COUNCILWOMAN CINDY BASS COUNCILWOMAN KENDRA BROOKS COUNCILMAN ALLAN DOMB COUNCILWOMAN JAMIE GAUTHIER COUNCILWOMAN KATHERINE GILMORE RICHARDSON COUNCILMAN DEREK S. GREEN COUNCILWOMAN HELEN GYM COUNCILMAN BOBBY HENON COUNCILMAN KENYATTA JOHNSON COUNCILMAN CURTIS JONES, JR. COUNCILMAN DAVID OH COUNCILMAN BRIAN J. O'NEILL COUNCILWOMAN CHERELLE L. PARKER COUNCILWOMAN MARIA D. QUINONES-SANCHEZ COUNCILMAN MARK SQUILLA COUNCILMAN ISAIAH THOMAS MICHAEL A. DECKER, CHIEF CLERK Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Council President Clarke

Good morning. We're going to get started. I understand that the state law currently requires that the following announcement be made at the beginning of every remote Council session: Due to the current public health emergency, City Council is currently meeting remotely. We are using Microsoft Teams to make this remote meeting possible. Instructions for how the public may view the meeting and offer public comment are included in the Stated Meeting notice that was published in the Daily News, Inquirer, and Legal Intelligencer prior to the meeting, and can also be found on PHLCouncil.com. I now note that the hour has come. The Clerk will please call the roll to take attendance. And, members, just please remember to say a couple of words to make sure that your photo is displayed. Mr. Decker, please proceed. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Bass.

Councilwoman Bass

Good morning. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you to everyone for being here and caring about the people's business. Thank you.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Brooks.

Councilwoman Brooks

Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Domb.

Councilman Domb

Good morning, Council President and colleagues and the listening public.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Gauthier. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Councilwoman Gauthier

Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues. Good morning, everyone. Happy to be here today.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Gilmore Richardson.

Councilwoman Richardson

Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Green.

Councilman Green

Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues. Good morning, public. Good to be here for another session of City Council.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Gym.

Councilwoman Gym

Good morning, Council President. Good Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 morning, colleagues.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Henon. (No response.)

Councilwoman Parker

Councilman Henon is having technical difficulties. It's noted in the Chat box. We can come back to him.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Johnson.

Councilman Johnson

Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues. Still screaming justice for Breonna Taylor.

Council President Clarke

Good morning, Councilman.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Jones.

Councilman Jones

Good morning, Mr. President. Good morning, colleagues. Good morning, viewing public.

Council President Clarke

Good morning. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Chief Clerk

Councilman Oh.

Councilman Oh

Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilman O'Neill. (No response.)

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Parker.

Councilwoman Parker

Good morning, Mr. President. Good morning, colleagues.

Council President Clarke

Good morning, Councilwoman.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

Councilwoman Sanchez

Buenos dias. Buenos dias to my colleagues. Thank you.

Council President Clarke

Buenos dias.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Councilman Squilla

Good morning, Mr. President, and good morning, colleagues.

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Thomas.

Councilman Thomas

Good morning, Council President. Good morning, colleagues. Happy to be here this morning.

Council President Clarke

Good morning, Councilman.

Chief Clerk

Council President Clarke.

Council President Clarke

Good morning. Thank you. We've established a quorum and we will now come to order. Despite the great need, there will be no invocation today. We will, however, observe a very brief moment of silent prayer for our city, its leaders, Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 during the current public health crisis. We will now observe a brief moment of silence. (Moment of silence.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much. Our next order of business is the approval of the Journal of the meeting of Thursday, October 1, 2020, and the Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.

Councilman Squilla

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the approval of the Journal for Thursday, October 1st, 2020. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It has been moved and properly approved the meeting of October 1st, 2020. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 & COMMUNICATIONS Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that Journal is approved. And our next order of business is requests for leave of absence, and the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.

Councilwoman Parker

Thank you, Mr. President. On behalf of the members of Council, there are no requests for leaves of absence today.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair thanks the Councilwoman. Our next order of business is communications. And, Mr. Decker, would you please read the messages from the Mayor and any other communications that you may have in your possession.

Chief Clerk

To the President and members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia, I respectfully request and submit for the consideration of your Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property to execute and deliver to the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority deeds conveying fee simple title to certain City-owned lots or pieces of ground with the buildings and improvements thereon, situate in the Second Councilmanic District of the City of Philadelphia; and A resolution approving the appointment of Ismail Shahid as a member of the Board of Commissioners of the Philadelphia Housing Authority; and An ordinance amending Section 2 of an Ordinance (Bill No. 180560) approved July 10, 2018, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 250 by striking from the City Plan and vacating the legally open portion of Montour Street from Adams Avenue to Foulkrod Street," by extending the period for compliance with the terms and conditions stated therein; and Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 299 by striking from the City Plan Parker Avenue from a point approximately one-hundred fifty-six feet southwest of Matthias Street to its terminus southwestwardly therefrom and reserving and placing on the City Plan a right-of-way for various utility purposes within a portion of Parker Avenue being stricken and authorizing the acceptance of the grant to the City of the said right-of-way, all under certain terms and conditions.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much, Mr. Decker. And our next order of business is the introduction of bills and resolutions. And by way of a reminder, we are asking that all resolutions, including privileged resolutions, be placed on the Final Passage Calendar for the next session of Council, unless they are being referred to committee. In our Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 current remote environment, this procedure will provide an appropriate opportunity for public comment. And I just want to thank you very much in advance for your cooperation. Mr. Decker, would you please read the titles of the legislation that is being offered today by the members.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Parker offers one bill, entitled "An ordinance amending Section 2 of an ordinance (Bill No. 180560) approved July 10, 2018, entitled 'An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 250 by striking from the City Plan and vacating the legally open portion of Montour Street from Adams Avenue to Foulkrod Street,' by extending the period for compliance with the terms and conditions stated therein."

Council President Clarke

Referred to committee.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 Gilmore Richardson offers one resolution, entitled a "Resolution authorizing City Council's Committee of the Whole to hold all hearings required pursuant to Bill No. 200364-A, which established a requirement that the Council hold hearings in connection with anticipated collective bargaining agreements between the City and Police Employees in the Philadelphia Police Department represented by the Fraternal Order of Police."

Council President Clarke

Referred to committee.

Chief Clerk

That's authorizing a hearing, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Oh, okay. Today's Calendar. Sorry.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Gym offers one bill, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 10 of The Philadelphia Code to create a new Chapter 10-2500, entitled 'Less Lethal Devices,' to regulate the use of less lethal devices Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 in specific situations."

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Councilwoman, did you want to be recognized at this point?

Councilwoman Gym

Yes, please. Thank you very much.

Council President Clarke

Councilwoman Gym.

Councilwoman Gym

Thank you very much, Mr. President. First of all, I would like to thank all my colleagues, especially those on the Public Safety Committee. Eight of us are submitting a bill that would require the Police Department to make permanent its current moratorium on the use of tear gas, rubber bullets, and less lethal ammunitions in clearly First Amendment-related activities. Last night we had a chance with our Public Safety Committee and many others -- thank you, Councilmember Gilmore Richardson and others for joining Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 us -- to hear from residents who were impacted by the events of May and June in the aftermath of the killing of George Floyd, Breonna Taylor, and many others. We heard three hours of testimony of people who talked about how they took to the streets to demand justice, to talk for -- to see a better tomorrow, and they were met with a show of force that had not been deployed on such a scale in our city in decades. Militarized vehicles rolled down 52nd Street. Tear gas, pepper spray, agrichemicals filled the air. Individuals held up sizable tear gas canisters that had been shot at them. Without warning, rubber bullets and other objects tore through West Philadelphia and on I-676, forcing families to evacuate and leaving many with no place to retreat. The targeting was clear. It was indiscriminate. It was young people. It was journalists. It was observers, demonstrators, longtime residents, and Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 those calling out for assistance. Many of us had witnessed videos and maybe social media posts that documented the chaos and terror, but few of us on the ground had heard directly from the people who experienced it. Last night we had a chance to hear from many of those people, and I think that their stories were loud and clear. I want to express my gratitude to those who shared. I know they did so from a place of anger that was palpable and, let's be honest, justified. But they also did it with an urgent call for us to change. And the courageous words of ordinary Philadelphians demand more of us. The retelling and reliving of those stories was extremely hard, and I firmly want to reiterate again before our full City Council that every single person who stepped forward last night or who submitted their written testimonies and took the time to talk with us and Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 engaged with Council over the last few months did the City and their communities a profound public service. There are multiple investigations that are going on. We are not pretending to do that. City Council wanted to hold space to recognize that the voices of our residents have to guide the work that we do and that their courage calls us to task to build a better Philadelphia. So I'm proud, along with my colleagues and especially our Public Safety Chairman, Councilmember Jones, to submit this bill. I know it will go through a rigorous review, and I know that we face difficult times ahead, including the fact that in the next couple of weeks we also will continue over the next couple of weeks and months, we will continue to be tested about what our commitment to civil liberties are, what First Amendment freedoms are, and how we intend to fully uphold the Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 constitutional right to voting, to walk freely through our city, to make sure that we are safe in our communities as well. I hope that this bill will be part of that conversation. So thank you.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Referred to committee.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Jones offers one bill, entitled "An ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 299 by striking from the City Plan Parker Avenue from a point approximately one-hundred fifty-six feet southwest of Matthias Street to its terminus southwestwardly therefrom and reserving and placing on the City Plan a right-of-way for various utility purposes within a portion of Parker Avenue being stricken and authorizing acceptance of the grant to the City of the said right-of-way." Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Council President Clarke

Referred to committee.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Johnson offers four bills and one resolution. On behalf of Council President, Councilman Johnson offers an ordinance authorizing transfers in appropriations for Fiscal Year 2021 from the General Fund, the Council to the General Fund, the Department of Planning and Development. On his own behalf, Councilman Johnson offers an ordinance amending Chapter 21-1500 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Boards and Commissions - Public Deliberations," to require recording or transcription of certain meetings and provision to the public of access to such recordings and transcriptions; and An ordinance authorizing DSW1, LLC doing business as Nifty Fifty's to install, own, and maintain a proposed sidewalk cafe at 2700 South 10th Street; and Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 An ordinance authorizing Stephen Garafolo to construct, own, and maintain a proposed exterior stairway at 3000 South 15th Street.

Council President Clarke

Those four bills just read by the Chief Clerk will be referred to the appropriate committee.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property to execute and deliver to the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority deeds conveying fee simple title to certain City-owned lots or pieces of ground with the buildings and improvements thereon, situate in the Second Councilmanic District.

Council President Clarke

Next week's Calendar.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Green offers one resolution, entitled a "Resolution declaring October as Domestic Violence Awareness Month in the City of Philadelphia." Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Council President Clarke

Next week's Calendar.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Domb offers one bill, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 9 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Regulation of Businesses, Trades and Professions,' by adding a new Chapter entitled 'Residential Property Wholesalers,' to regulate the solicitation of purchases of real property and require certain disclosures by property purchasers to homeowners, and amending Chapter 9-1100 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Fair Practices Ordinance: Protections Against Unlawful Discrimination,' to provide protections to homeowners from solicitation and related problems."

Council President Clarke

Referred to committee.

Councilman Domb

Council President, can I be heard on that?

Council President Clarke

Absolutely. I'm sorry, Councilman. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Councilman Domb

That's okay.

Council President Clarke

The Chair recognizes Councilman Domb.

Councilman Domb

Thank you, Council President. And I really want to thank Community Legal Services and the Greater Philadelphia Association of Realtors for their willingness to work together on this important issue to protect property owners in Philadelphia. I also want to thank the Administration, the Philadelphia Commission on Human Relations, and the Law Department for their countless hours of work and their valuable input on this bill. I also appreciate the level of support I received from many of my colleagues and would like to thank those who co-sponsored this bill, Councilmembers Gilmore Richardson, Squilla, Quinones-Sanchez, Johnson, Gauthier, Parker, Thomas, Green, Brooks, and Councilman Gym. Thank you all very much. Also, I look forward in this Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 bill to helping residents across Philadelphia to better understand their rights as property owners and level the playing field by arming them with important information they need should they wish to sell to a wholesaler or avoid them altogether. Now, we've seen all these Buy Houses or Cash for Homes signs throughout the City. You see them on telephone poles and all over the City, and we've heard the horror stories from so many homeowners who undersold their homes or fought alongside someone to regain ownership of their home, after unknowingly agreeing to what they thought was a fair deal but in many cases was not. Making an offer to buy someone's home is not illegal and it's certainly not illegal to sell your home for any price or for any reason you see fit. However, we have to be sure that everyone at the table is abiding by a Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 shared set of standards and rules we all deem reasonable and responsible. Many wholesalers are currently working in the shadows, with no real oversight, and it's time now that we shed some light on their practices. So it's my hope with this legislation that we will provide more protections for homeowners who are solicited by wholesale buyers and will be able to hold them accountable to the standards we expect of our businesses. Again, I want to thank CLS, Community Legal Services, and the Greater Philadelphia Association of Realtors, GPAR, for their ongoing dedication to this effort, and it was great to see them working together. And I look forward to working with all of my colleagues to educate our residents and set these new standards for wholesalers doing business in our city. Thank you, Council President.

Council President Clarke

Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 Thank you, Councilman.

Councilman Johnson

Council President?

Council President Clarke

The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Councilman Johnson

Council President, I just want to applaud my colleague Councilman Domb for this piece of legislation. Living in a gentrified neighborhood, I have seen and I continue to see the aggressive tactics of individuals coming into their neighborhood soliciting for residents to sell their homes. A lot of individuals in the neighborhood sell their homes way below, under market value, but also going even beyond that, the process has become so disrespectful, because I've had constituents reach out where they have lost loved ones and they will go down to the Register of Wills Office and will pull a person's death certificate and then they will begin to start calling and soliciting that individual to sell their Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 home. There have been text messages. Don't know where they're getting our phone numbers from, but text messages and phone numbers aggressively asking you to sell your homes, and it's primarily happening in areas that are becoming gentrified. And so I thank Allan Domb, who comes from the real estate community, for stepping up to the plate and addressing this issue. Thank you very much, Councilman Domb.

Councilman Domb

Thank you, Councilman Johnson.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Thank you, Councilman. And that will be referred to committee.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Thomas offers one resolution, entitled a "Resolution honoring and congratulating the Northeast High School Football team, on their successful 2019-2020 season and overall 12 to 2 record in the Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 Philadelphia Public Football League."

Council President Clarke

Awesome. That will be on next week's Calendar.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Bass offers one bill and two resolutions, entitled "An ordinance amending Chapter 19-200 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'City Funds - Deposits, Investments, Disbursements,' by revising the list of City depositories."

Council President Clarke

Referred to committee.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution authorizing the Committees on Education and Public Health and Human Services to hold joint hearings examining the School District of Philadelphia's preparedness for public health and environmental emergencies, and to develop best practices that can help the District adequately prepare for these emergencies.

Council President Clarke

This week's Calendar. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Chief Clerk

And a resolution authorizing the Committees on Public Health and Human Services and on Children and Youth to hold joint hearings examining current and best practices to ensure youth have a successful transition from foster care to thriving adulthood.

Council President Clarke

This week's Calendar.

Chief Clerk

There are no other bills or resolutions being offered by the members, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much, Mr. Decker. And our next order of business is reports from committees, and the Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson for a report from the Committee on Rules. (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Councilman Johnson? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Okay. We'll come back. We'll find out Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 going to come back to Councilman Johnson when we find out what's going on. The Chair now recognizes Councilwoman Bass for a report from the Committee on Parks, Recreation and Cultural Affairs.

Councilman Johnson

I'm ready, Council President, when you are. I apologize. I had technical difficulties.

Council President Clarke

Okay. Let's go back to Councilman Johnson. Councilman Johnson, just call on you.

Councilman Johnson

Thank you, Mr. President. The Committee on Rules reports out one bill with a favorable recommendation.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Mr. Decker, please read the report.

Chief Clerk

To the President Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 Council of the City of Philadelphia, the Committee on Rules, to which was referred Bill No. 200349, entitled "An ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled 'Zoning and Planning,' to amend certain provisions of Chapter 14-500, entitled 'Overlay Zoning Districts,' by creating the '/AME, American Street Overlay District,'" respectfully reports it has considered and amended the same and returns the attached bill to Council with a favorable recommendation.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair again recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Councilman Johnson

Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended so to permit first reading of this Bill No. 200349. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It has been moved and Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill No. 200349. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and this bill will be placed on our First Reading Calendar today. The Chair now recognizes Councilwoman Bass for a report from the Committee on Parks, Recreation and Cultural Affairs. (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Another challenge? Councilwoman Bass? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Okay. Someone reach out. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Councilwoman Parker

Mr. President, we'll text her.

Council President Clarke

Okay. She's just saying she's having technical difficulties. Okay. We'll try and get back to her prior to the session ending. That concludes our reports from committee at this time. And our next order of business is consideration of the Calendar, and I note that the bills just reported from committee with a suspension of the rules have been deemed to have had a first reading. These bills will be placed on our Second Reading Calendar and Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. As there are no additional bills on our First Reading Calendar, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker for the purpose of calling up resolutions and bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar today. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 2ND READING

Councilwoman Parker

Thank you, Mr. President. The following resolutions and bills are being called up from the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars today. They are Nos. 200519, 200522, 200523, 200525, 200528, 200529, 200530, 200532, and 200534. All other bills and resolutions are being held.

Council President Clarke

Thank you so much, Councilwoman. Before we proceed with the consideration of the public comment, I will now take a brief five- to ten-minute -- I think it's going to be more like five-minute -- recess to give our technology professionals some time to connect the speakers we have for today's meeting. (Brief pause.)

Council President Clarke

Great. Good morning.

Ms. Harvey

Good morning.

Council President Clarke

Good Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 morning. Just please state your name for the record and proceed with your testimony.

Ms. Harvey

Thank you. Good morning. My name is Karen Harvey. I'm a retired social worker. I am also a lead organizer at TURN, Director of the Philadelphia Rent Control Coalition, and a member of the Philadelphia Tenants Union. I lived at the Penn Wynn House Apartments from March 2010 until June 2017. From December 2016, when I and the other 100-plus tenants of Penn Wynn were informed of the pending mass eviction until June 2017, I applied for 40 different residences in search of a place to live. Myself and numerous other Penn Wynn tenants were erroneous filed against in Landlord-Tenant Court three times for supposed failure to pay rent. Any month for which we were unable to present rent receipts was deemed as our having failed to pay. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 Because of an inept maintenance man, who flooded my apartment when he failed to turn off the bathroom water valve before raising the toilet to repair it, many of my belongings, including the majority of my rent receipts, were destroyed in that flood. Each eviction filing became a stain on my credit report, making it impossible for me to find a decent place to live. Finally, and only thanks to a family friend's willingness to provide me with a character reference, in June 2017 her landlord agreed to rent me a house, where I continue to reside today. I live in West Philadelphia on a block known for illegal activity and gun violence. I don't feel safe in my home. On two separate occasions, young men were shot in front of my door. Just this summer, my next-door neighbor was shot when an errant bullet went through her front door, hitting her as she sat watching television. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 There's virtually no police presence on my street. There is as many abandominiums and vacant lots as there are occupied homes on my street. More than once, young men have followed me from the El stop onto my block, only turning back after a neighbor exiting her home spoke to me. Both times, the sun was still high in the sky. I am a senior, using a cane, ripe for the picking. Rarely am I outside after dark alone. Almost nightly young men lounge on my front steps smoking weed and drinking. Last week, as is their frequent custom, they left their party favors behind for me to pick up. Thinking I've gotten everything, walking down the cement steps, I stepped on an unseen plastic container and fell down the remaining steps. Because of those court filings on my record, I am unable to secure a safe place to live. The resolution Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 presented today by Councilman Thomas represents my only chance of securing safe and decent housing for the remainder of my golden years. I seek nothing more than that which each of you desire for your own parents - a safe and decent place to live. I ask each of you in good conscience is it really fair for me to be denied that right? I thank you for allowing me the opportunity to speak on my truth today.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much, Ms. Harvey.

Ms. Harvey

Thank you. Have a good day.

Council President Clarke

You're welcome. Mr. Decker, do we have anybody else?

Chief Clerk

There are no other speakers on the public comment list, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 We will briefly go back to our reports from committee, and at this time, I would like to recognize Councilwoman Bass for a report from the Committee on Parks, Recreation and Cultural Affairs.

Councilwoman Bass

Thank you, Mr. President. The Committee on Parks, Recreation and Cultural Affairs reports out two bills with a favorable recommendation.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much. Mr. Decker, please read the report.

Chief Clerk

The Committee on Parks, Recreation and Cultural Affairs, to which was referred Bill No. 200374, entitled "An ordinance renaming and designating Chalfont Playground in Northeast Philadelphia as the 'Corporal Jimmy O'Connor Memorial Playground'"; and Bill No. 200424, entitled "An ordinance renaming and designating the Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 as the 30th and Jefferson Playground, located at the corner of 30th and Jefferson Streets, as the 'Howard McCall, Senior Playground' in the City of Philadelphia," respectfully reports it has considered the same and returns the attached bills to Council with a favorable recommendation.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Thank you very much. It's been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council -- I'm sorry. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.

Councilwoman Bass

Thank you, Mr. President. I move that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bill Nos. 200374 and 200424. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the rules of Council be suspended so as to permit first reading this day of Bills No. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 200374 and 200424. All those in favor please say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and these bills will be placed on our First Reading Calendar today.

Councilwoman Parker

Mr. President, Councilmember Thomas had noted he wanted to be recognized.

Council President Clarke

Yes. The Chair recognizes Councilman Thomas.

Councilman Thomas

Thank you, Council President. I just wanted to first thank Ms. Karen for her testimony, but I did want to offer some clarity that the bill that she testified on today has been moved to next week's Calendar. So we will be voting on that bill next week. I did not want her to think that we did Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING not hear her testimony and we did not listen to the important issue that people are facing in Philadelphia as it relates to evictions. Thank you, Council President, for allowing me to clarify.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Thank you so much. Let me get back on our agenda. And we will now move to our Calendar. So, Mr. Decker, will you please read the title of Resolution No. 200519.

Chief Clerk

A resolution recognizing and celebrating the reopening of the historic Philip Jaisohn Memorial House on October 10, 2020, which honors the legacy of Philadelphian Philip Jaisohn, a Korean-American pioneer for democracy, political and religious freedom, and Korean independence.

Council President Clarke

And at this time, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gym for a motion on the Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING resolution.

Councilwoman Gym

Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution 200522.

Chief Clerk

A resolution recognizing October 2020 as Manufacturing Month, and further honoring Oat Foundry for their innovation and dedication to the Manufacturing Industry in the City of Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Philadelphia.

Council President Clarke

The Chair recognizes Councilman Henon.

Councilman Henon

Thank you, Council President. I'd like to speak prior to making a motion on this resolution. As you well know, October is Manufacturing Month, and manufacturing and industry has always been one of my primary focuses with small businesses in our neighborhoods putting people all throughout our community to work. We live in a region that is home to more than 5,600 manufacturing firms. Over 200,000 workers are employed in the sector right here in the City of Philadelphia. COVID-19 has created so many challenges for Philadelphia area manufacturing and industry firms. In partners with Commerce, PIDC, and the business leaders, we've worked real hard to troubleshoot some of the unique Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING challenges these businesses have faced, just like a lot of businesses, transportation, childcare. But unlike other sectors of the economy, most manufacturing firms were permitted to keep working as essential businesses, but they were faced, as I had stated earlier, with some challenges in their workforce and their supply challenges and their transportation problems, but they adapted rapidly so that we can continue to make products that were critically needed nationally and internationally and right here in the City of Philadelphia with great partners. These firms did a great job, and despite the challenges, we've had some of the most major successes in the sector on the East Coast. For example, earlier this year, AgustaWestland, a helicopter manufacturer in Northeast Philadelphia, was awarded a $176 million contract to build training simulators, and we've seen significant amount of Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING industrial development. In fact, the inventory of available industrial land is at an all-time low. Warehouse distribution is the future of a lot of our manufacturing and product-moving sector. Each year for Manufacturing Month, I highlight a Philadelphia manufacturing firm that deserves extra recognition. This year I selected Oat Foundry. Oat Foundry is a specialty manufacturing firm in the Frankford Arsenal right here in my district, and they all do wonderful things in the Arsenal. They are an award-winning agency of engineers that describe what they do as designing and building electromechanical, measurable, interactive, and other cool stuff. They are from Drexel. They're local. They're pretty smart kids, and they do a fantastic job with the technology, delivering their products and specialty. And it is true, they are a very cool Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING company. I'm coordinating a tour for their facility later this month, and I welcome any member of Council who wishes to participate to join me, and if you're interested, please reach out to my office. And, again, as always, I want to thank you, Council, for recognizing that the people who live in the City of Philadelphia are also working in these manufacturing and specialty industries right here in our neighborhoods. So thank you, Council President. With that, I make a motion to approve. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200523.

Chief Clerk

A resolution honoring and congratulating Lisa Forrest on the occasion of her promotion to Battalion Chief of the Philadelphia Fire Department, and for becoming the first African American woman to earn this prestigious position in the 149-year history of the Philadelphia Fire Department.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Jones.

Councilman Jones

Thank you, Mr. President. Now I move for its adoption. (Duly seconded.) Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200525.

Chief Clerk

A resolution condemning President Donald Trump for making a Supreme Court nomination during his presidential election and calling upon Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell to defer consideration of the nomination until after the presidential inauguration in January.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson for a motion. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING

Councilman Johnson

Thank you, Council President. I enthusiastically move for the adoption of this resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All in favor signify by saying aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed?

Councilman O'Neill

Nay.

Councilman Oh

Opposed.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The ayes have it and the resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200528.

Councilman O'Neill

Council President?

Council President Clarke

Yes, sir.

Councilman O'Neill

Councilman O'Neill. Could I be recorded as voting Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING nay on this resolution.

Council President Clarke

Okay.

Councilman O'Neill

Thank you.

Councilman Oh

Same for me, Council President. I oppose it as well. Thank you.

Council President Clarke

Okay. Let the record reflect that Councilman O'Neill and Councilman Oh voted for nay on Resolution No. 200525. Thank you. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200528.

Chief Clerk

A resolution congratulating Daniel J. Hilferty on his retirement as the President and CEO of Independence Health Group and honoring his contributions to Philadelphia during his career.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Domb. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING

Councilman Domb

Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200529.

Chief Clerk

A resolution honoring and congratulating the Neumann-Goretti boys basketball team, on their successful 2019-2020 season and overall 24 to 4 record in the Philadelphia Catholic League boys basketball championships.

Council President Clarke

The Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Chair recognizes Councilman Thomas.

Councilman Thomas

Thank you, Council President. We're going to just try to continue to introduce different champions throughout the course of the City every week just to continue to boost morale and enthusiasm. So I enthusiastically move for the adoption of the resolution, and I congratulate all of the participants who were able to be victorious last year. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It has been moved and enthusiastically seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is enthusiastically adopted. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Mr. Decker, please read the title of Resolution No. 200530.

Chief Clerk

A resolution authorizing the Committee on Global Opportunities and the Creative/Innovative Economy to establish an advisory Task Force on Disadvantaged Communities, and further authorizing the Task Force to produce a report of findings and strategies for uplifting disadvantaged persons in Philadelphia through access to arts and culture.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Thomas.

Councilman Thomas

Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It has been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor say aye. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, 200532.

Chief Clerk

A resolution authorizing the Commissioner of Public Property to execute and deliver to the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority deeds conveying fee simple title to certain City-owned lots or pieces of ground with the buildings and improvements thereon situate in the First Councilmanic District of the City of Philadelphia and further authorizing the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority to transfer to the Philadelphia Land Bank fee simple title to such properties pursuant to 16-405 of The Philadelphia Code.

Council President Clarke

Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.

Councilman Squilla

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor indicate by saying aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of 200534.

Chief Clerk

A resolution recognizing and celebrating the second annual Latin American Book Fair in Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING Philadelphia for its work in highlighting local Latin-American authors, literature, and culture.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair recognizes Councilman Oh for a motion on the resolution.

Councilman Oh

Thank you very much, Council President. On behalf of myself and Councilmember Maria Quinones-Sanchez, I'd like to move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that the resolution be adopted. All in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING adopted. Mr. Decker, do you have any additional resolutions for today's Calendar?

Chief Clerk

A resolution authorizing City Council's Committee of the Whole to hold all hearings required pursuant to Bill No. 200364-A, which established a requirement that the Council hold hearings in connection with anticipated collective bargaining agreements between the City and Police Employees in the Philadelphia Police Department represented by the Fraternal Order of Police, introduced by Councilwoman Gilmore Richardson.

Council President Clarke

The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gilmore Richardson.

Councilwoman Richardson

Thank you, Mr. President. I move the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed?

Councilman Henon

Council President, this is Bobby Henon. I'd like to be recorded as no, please.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Let the record reflect Councilman Henon -

Councilman O'Neill

Same with Councilman O'Neill.

Council President Clarke

And Councilman O'Neill and Councilman Henon are voting nay. Thank you. The resolution is approved.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution authorizing the Committees on Education and on Public Health and Human Services to hold joint hearings examining the School District of Philadelphia's preparedness for public health and environmental emergencies, and to develop Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING best practices that can help the District adequately prepare for these emergencies, introduced by Councilwoman Bass.

Council President Clarke

The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.

Councilwoman Bass

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution authorizing the Committees on Public Health and Human Services and on Children and Youth to hold joint hearings examining the current and best practices Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 10/8/20 - STATED - 2ND READING to ensure youth have a successful transition from foster care to thriving adulthood, introduced by Councilwoman Bass.

Council President Clarke

The Chair again recognizes Councilwoman Bass.

Councilwoman Bass

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye. (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

There are no other resolutions on the Final Passage Calendar, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 That concludes our Calendar for today. Prior to recognizing members regarding speeches, I will note for the record at this time that we will use the Chat feature available in Microsoft Teams to allow members to signify that they wish to be recognized. In order to comply with the Sunshine Act, the Chat feature must only be used for that purpose. With that said, are there any speeches on the part of the minority? The Chair recognizes Councilman Oh.

Councilman Oh

Thank you very much, Council President. I wanted to recognize Councilmember Isaiah Thomas and the freshmen Councilmembers for adopting and adjusting to being Councilmembers during COVID-19. It is not easy. I recall, as I'm sure all of you do, my first day as a Councilmember. I walked in and I didn't know what to do. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 me what to do. I didn't know where the bathroom was. I didn't know how to do anything, and there was no real guidance on how to do things. And I remember I did ask something and I think it was Councilmember Blackwell who walked over to me and let me know that they had done that like three years ago and other things, and I was getting acclimated to working with my colleagues. And I just wanted to say it's not an easy process, and the new Councilmembers have done a fantastic job of really navigating this very difficult situation where they are quarantined and their staffs are working through everything and doing bills and resolutions and getting out there. And particularly with Councilmember Thomas, he's doing a great thing. He checked with me. We talked. There was a little miscommunication, which will happen because we're quarantined, we're separate, we're working through our staff Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 that, and he just very quickly accommodated kind of what I thought about it and I tried to work with him, and it all worked out fantastic, and I want to thank him for that, and I'm happy to be able to support his great work and I look forward to all the contributions. I also wanted to recognize the Philip Jaisohn Memorial Foundation that Councilmember Gym and I introduced a resolution recognizing what they're doing. Just coincidently, they answered the call for PPE for our sanitation workers, and this past weekend, AFSCME Local 427, President Carrington came by to pick up 6,000 masks, 250 bottles of hand sanitizer, and it just -- you know, there are so many citizens and people who step up to support their community, their neighbors, and our City workers. And hats off to the sanitation workers who are out there dealing with the virus and all that and making sure our city is safe and clean. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 that, thank you very much.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Speeches on behalf of the majority? The Chair recognizes Councilman Thomas.

Councilman Thomas

Thank you, Council President. First and foremost, I just want to say thank you to all of my colleagues for all the support this past week. My wife and I gave birth to a beautiful baby boy, and you guys couldn't be more supportive and more -- I don't know. I'm just excited. So thank you guys. I appreciate that, first and foremost. Councilmember Oh talked a little bit about the Arts and Culture Task Force, and the Arts and Culture Task Force is an initiative directly out of the Disadvantaged Communities Task Force. So, first of all, Council President, I Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 you for your leadership and putting us in a position to be able to listen to the citizens all across the City of Philadelphia. As my Co-Chair and I, Councilmember Katherine Gilmore Richardson, who I'm very grateful to, as we've been listening to citizens of Philadelphia and Councilmembers as a whole, I think almost everyone at this point has either attended or had staff on at least one of the listening sessions. We've heard some consistent narratives and consistent issues that Philadelphians face as it relates to the problems that they see. I applaud all of my colleagues who have stepped up to the plate for different initiatives to combat the gun violence that we see in the City of Philadelphia. Not just you, Council President. I got to recognize Councilman Johnson, who has been a champion for that issue. And we know, putting on my Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 hat, it's a complex problem that's going to require a lot of people to come together to fix this solution. So we have the lawsuit going on. The Arts and Culture Task Force, again, which is a collaborative effort, will specifically look at how we can address that particular area as it relates to people who have been suffering, but today the next initiative out of the Disadvantaged Communities Task Force will be a press conference at 2:00 p.m. Thank you to Councilmember Bass for allowing us to come in your district and launch in your district, but we will be communicating resource hubs, resource hubs for young people between the ages of 14 to 21 where you can go in the evenings and on the weekends and you can participate in free activities that will be safe, that will keep you busy, and that will hopefully put you in the position to build mentors and Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 navigate their way through life. If I wasn't on City Council, this is the work that I would be doing, and so I have to continue to wear that hat. And our goal is to piece together as many different solutions as possible based on what the citizens of Philadelphia are telling us so we can do right what you say, Council President, before this session started and beat this gun violence pandemic just like beating all the other issues that we're facing as a municipality. So if you're free today, please come out and join us at 2:00 p.m. We'll be at Triumph Baptist Church. We'll be announcing the resource hubs. And this is, again, just one step more as it relates to not only listening to citizens of Philadelphia as it relates to how they're suffering because of this Coronavirus pandemic, but also us just taking one more small step in combatting Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 pandemic that we're facing right now as well too. So thank you, Council President. Thank you, colleagues. I know that was a lot. I'm very emotional and sleep deprived right now, but we are in a state of emergency and it requires the maximum amount of time we have for us to put our best foot forward. So I'm here today and ready to fight with you all and continue this battle. Thank you.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Thank you, Councilman. Thank you so much. The Chair recognizes Councilman Green.

Councilman Green

Thank you, Council President. The joy and celebration that you, Councilman Thomas, you and your wife, have is phenomenal. Just hearing your new son's voice as we are in this Council session brings me joy. The fact we have another black boy, Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 our city brings me so much hope and joy, even though we have so many challenging situations that are going in our city. And I have to reflect on yesterday's press conference, that it's the hope of future children doing well in our city, but also we've got to reflect on the challenges we have in our city, and yesterday's press conference was another piece of hope about what we're going to do to address the violence in our city. Council President, for your leadership, we had the Mayor, a number of Councilmembers there, our City Solicitor Marcel Pratt, members of the General Assembly like Senator Street, so many members of this body, Public Interest Law Center, Hogan Lovells, all come together for this class action to address and allow us as a city to be able to regulate guns based on our own gun laws. So this class action -- and I'm sure many other members of Council will Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 conference yesterday, but this class action appropriately named Crawford versus Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, many of us in this body know the story of Stanley Crawford and his son, and so many victims were there at the press conference to really talk about what we need to do in this city and do what we need to do to address violence. But that class action lawsuit could have easily had a different title. It could have easily been Johnson versus the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. We all know the story of our colleague Councilmember Johnson and how the death of his cousin motivated him to get engaged in this work well before he became a member of this body, before he became a State Representative or working for Senator Tony Williams. I first met Councilmember Johnson when I actually had some hair, and he was at Fels and he was working on Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 starting Peace Not Guns. In fact, I still have his Peace Not Guns e-mail address in my phone, because he's been working on this issue all the time that I've known him in this city. And so as I reflect on yesterday's press conference and recently I got my ballot in the mail, and we all know the importance of voting on November 3rd, and Councilmember Johnson has probably been the most staunch anti-violence advocate we have had in the history of this body, not only in reference to crime and anti-violence but also victims and supporting victims in the City of Philadelphia. And so he introduced legislation and we supported his legislation for a ballot question to amend the Home Rule Charter, and I just want to read that ballot question, because all the ballot questions are important on our November 3rd election, but I want to highlight his ballot Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 question, and I'll read it. Shall the Philadelphia Home Rule Charter be amended to create the Office of the Victim Advocate to advocate for crime victims and to work with victim service providers to coordinate, plan, train, educate, and investigate issues relating to crime victims? And I hope that everyone will support all the ballot questions, in particular Ballot Question No. 2. Now, recently I learned, and I was somewhat shocked, that Reclaim Philadelphia is opposing this initiative. I was surprised, because Reclaim is an organization that supports and uplifts Black Lives Matter.

Councilman Green

And so the fact that they would oppose an office that will support victims, like a Stanley Crawford or the other people that were there yesterday, or someone even like our own colleague Councilmember Johnson, because he and his family have been victims of violence in our city. And when you look Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 numbers, if you look at the recent numbers from the Philadelphia Police District, we've had 368 homicide victims in the City of Philadelphia as of last night. That is more than last year. Last year we had 264. So we're already above the number of last year, with a 39 percent increase. And so we need to do all that we can to address the gun violence in our city. Yesterday's announcement of the class action lawsuit is one way to do that, but we also need to support the victims of violence in our city, victims like Mr. Crawford, the other plaintiffs in our class action lawsuit, and even victims like our own Councilmember Kenyatta Johnson, who has been a staunch advocate for victims in the City of Philadelphia who have suffered through crime and violence. So I'm hopeful that this was just a brief lapse in judgment by Reclaim and that they will take a different perspective and support Councilmember Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 Johnson, the victims in the City of Philadelphia by having this office, and encourage everyone to support all of the ballot questions, but in particular Ballot Question No. 2, so we can help the victims of violence in our city that so desperately need our support and help as we deal with the issues of crime and violence in our city. Thank you, Council President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Priorities matter. The Chair recognizes Councilman Jones.

Councilman Jones

Thank you, Mr. President. Since my colleague Member Green is recognizing ballot questions, I'd like to point out No. 2. No. 2 ballot question is, Shall the citizens create a Citizens Police Oversight Commission? And I think equally that is something that we should consider and vote yes for. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 the balance between public safety, there are different chains of public safety. Public safety means that when you get stopped by the Philadelphia Police Department at 2:00 in the morning, that you should be treated like a citizen with respect. Also, if black lives matter as we did on Musgrave, they should matter on Market Street and they should matter on Market Street in Harrisburg, as exhibited by the lawsuit that we put forth yesterday. I want to cite out to give context that in Afghanistan last year, which is a war zone, there were 22 servicemen that lost their lives, 22. As Member Green talked about, we've exceeded last year's number, over 300 murders in the City of Philadelphia alone, just one city. So as we look to get self-governance over gun laws, it just makes sense. It is important that we be Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 of Philadelphia than we would be in the nation of Afghanistan. It's just common sense. So we've been -- this is not our first time at the rodeo. We've gone up against the gun lobbyists. We've gone up against the NRA. We got sued, not only as a body but personally, and here we are again stepping up in 2020 to protect the citizens of the City of Philadelphia. So I want to salute you, Mr. President. I want to salute the Mayor for joining us and spearheading this lawsuit, because it shows to the people, as Member Johnson, myself, other members of Council, Gauthier, every day, well, what are you doing, what are you prepared to do as you want to save our lives. Well, this says in one statement that we will go up against friend or foe. We have a lot of friends in Harrisburg, but some of them in between Harrisburg and Philadelphia, there's Mississippi, Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 step to the plate to deal with them too. Thank you, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. The Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Councilman Johnson

Thank you, Council President. Just a couple of things I wanted to acknowledge. First and foremost, thank you, Councilman Green. Thank you, Councilman Jones, talking about the ballot position creating the Office of Victim Advocate. I want to thank the following individuals for being sponsors of this ballot question: Councilman Thomas, Councilwoman Gym, Councilman Squilla, Councilmember Green, Councilmember Brooks, Councilmember Gilmore, Councilman Jones, Council President Darrell Clarke. I thank you for being supportive of the legislation. And I don't know if it's Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 the state level, there's concern that -- how the state operates, they have taken more of a punitive approach regarding advocating as it relates to the rights of victims, but nevertheless, this ballot question has been the result of a year of work with the Special Committee on Gun Violence, specifically the Subcommittee of Victims and Co-Victims of Gun Violence. And so there are a group of mothers who have lost sons and daughters to gun violence. There are a group of mothers and fathers who will never ever, never ever have that opportunity to have dinner, breakfast or lunch with their children. They will never ever have a chance to spend a holiday, a birthday with their children. And so this is the results of me sitting down, organizing, and working with those mothers to make sure that they have a voice and a seat at the table. A lot of times we talk about the issue of Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 from their mouths. Our interests, our voices are always put to the side, and so we want to make sure they have a seat at the table as it relates to trauma support. We want to make sure they have a seat at the table that when a loved one is lost and they need a place to go for a referral, they can come and feel like they have the necessary support that they need, as well as trying to put their lives back together. , victim service organizations across the City of Philadelphia. This will be a hub that specifically deals with advocacy, policy, legislation, training, and supporting and uplifting other organizations like Mothers in Charge, the National Justice Homicide Alliance, and there are other grassroots, boots-on-the-ground organizations that Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 day to day, assisting and helping families of murdered victims, families of shooting victims or other violent crimes that need our support. So I just wanted to educate everyone, because there's a lot of misinformation about the upcoming ballot question. My office was never consulted, not one time, regarding any recommendations, any suggestions as it relates to how we move forward here in the City of Philadelphia. So I just want to state that for the record. Also, I want to acknowledge the work of Council President Darrell Clarke as it relates to us moving forward with the lawsuit around regulating our own destinies specifically around the issue of gun law. And so I talked to my colleagues early on before we even started the Council session of how there was a group of young men in Bucks County that was running a gun trafficking operation, and what they would do, they Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 store to the next store purchasing guns legally and then distributing them and selling those guns on the street. This lawsuit will enable us to control our own destiny by regulating those type of incidents where illegal guns are flooding the streets of Philadelphia. So I thank all my colleagues for stepping up to the plate to address this issue. We know it has to be comprehensive. There is not going to be one solution that's going to enable us to combat this issue, but we have to address it comprehensively. m.

Councilman Johnson

today, we have a Zoom meeting with the Office of Behavioral Health, an organization called Neighborhood Networks that deals specifically with the issue of trauma. Our communities are hurting. Our communities are hurting. And so we want to figure out how do we address the Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 trauma, how do we address the issue of grief in our neighborhoods. We know, as I always say, hurt people hurt other people, and at the end of the day, if we don't begin getting to the root cause of why these young men are walking around with so much anger, so much anger and pain that they can take a life with no regard for how it's going to have an impact not only on other individuals but also the community as a whole, we have to find out what the root cause of the trauma is coming from. m. today. I just wanted to remind everyone if they want to participate, they are welcome to join. Thank you very much, Council President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Keep up the good work. The Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass. Stated Meeting October 8, 2020

Councilwoman Bass

Well, thank you, Mr. President, and I just wanted to speak very, very briefly. And as we all know, we woke up this morning -- we had the event yesterday in Germantown in which we are proceeding and trying to control our own destiny and saying that we want to have a say in terms of how gun violence is happening in the City of Philadelphia, and that for those who represent the entire Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, whether it's the State Reps in Philadelphia who are very supportive for the most part, just completely on board, to those who are in the hinterlands, as Councilman Jones mentioned, the Mississippi part of Pennsylvania, all of these people ran for public office. All of these people were elected to serve their district but also the entire Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. And so it cannot be taken so lightly that these are Pennsylvanians who are dying. Maybe that will sort of shake their Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 consciousness, if you will, if they think of it as not Philadelphians but as Pennsylvanians. Because they have an obligation and a duty to ensure that we are all protected, that we are all under the best of care and living in the best of circumstances. And so the failure that you see here in Philadelphia with the gun violence is a failure across the Commonwealth in every county, in every State Rep district, in every State Senate district. It's not just a Philadelphia problem. It's not just a state problem. It's a problem throughout the entire country, and so we need to get a handle on it. We all woke up, as I said, this morning to the reports of what happened in Germantown. Council President, as you said, not even a half a mile away from where we were yesterday, and it's absolutely outrageous. I just can't even imagine that this person had an assault Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 weapon, which was laying on the ground on Germantown Avenue in news reports this morning, after he had committed a homicide with that assault weapon and attempted homicide with two others. And so, you know, I'm just flabbergasted and don't know really exactly what to say, except that I thank you, thank you, thank you, Mr. President, and to all the powers to be that really have worked on this piece of legislation -- on this lawsuit to make sure that those in Harrisburg know that they have a responsibility and a duty to all of us. So I just really wanted to put that out there. Thank you, Mr. President. Thank you to all of my colleagues. We're all going through this, and I really appreciate you. And also really quickly, Councilman Johnson, on your ballot initiative, we want to support that. I can't tell you how many homes I've been Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 been killed in the neighborhood and I'm sitting on somebody's sofas, their momma's sofa, their grand-mama's sofa, everybody is mourning, and nobody knows what to do. We need this office. I wish we didn't need it, but we need this office. If we don't need any other office right now, we need this office. And so I'm a thousand percent with you, Councilman. I want all the people in the Eighth District to know how important this is across the City of Philadelphia, and we have to support this ballot initiative undoubtedly. Thank you very much, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Thank you, Councilwoman, and thank all of you for your continued support to make sure that we improve the quality of life for all Philadelphians. As we've seen over the years, this is not a North Philly thing or West Philly Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 thing, a Germantown thing, South Philly.

Councilwoman Bass

Everywhere.

Council President Clarke

It's everywhere. And hopefully we will get to a point where we are successful. And we will make sure we keep everybody abreast as the litigation proceeds. So thank you so much.

Councilman Johnson

Council President?

Council President Clarke

Yes, sir. Yes, Councilman Johnson.

Councilman Johnson

If you don't mind, can I just get a small point of information for clarification? I mentioned that this afternoon at 1 o'clock we will be meeting with -- the organization is called Network of Neighbors. I said something else and there's another organization. So I stand corrected. I want to give the proper organization their props, which is Network of Neighbors. We will be hosting them at 1:00 p.m. That's an organization Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 out and about in the community. Thank you very much, Council President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. That concludes our speeches on behalf of the minority and the majority today. With that, I will recognize Councilman Jones for a motion to adjourn. Councilman.

Councilman Jones

I try to be good with my mic. Thank you, Mr. President. I move that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, October 15th, 2020 at 10:00 a.m. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It has been moved and properly seconded that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, October 15, 2020, 10:00 a.m. All in favor indicate by saying Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it. The motion carries. Thank you all very much. ) Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 CERTIFICATE I HEREBY CERTIFY that the proceedings, evidence and objections are contained fully and accurately in the stenographic notes taken by me upon the foregoing matter, and that this is a true and correct transcript of same. MICHELE L. m 1:7 88:18 adjourned ages 66:19 82:8,8 45:14,16 20:24 31:22 38:6 24:1 25:1 88:24 89:11 88:16,23 aggressive announcem... arts 53:13 Awesome 38:8 39:14 26:1 27:1 abandomin... 89:10 25:12 2:6 73:12 64:21,22 27:4 39:15 59:4 28:12 32:13 36:4 ADJOURN... aggressively announcing 66:7 aye 8:23,24 59:6,7 60:5 32:16,21,24 abiding 23:25 88:1 89:1 26:5 67:19 asking 11:21 31:6,7 40:4 60:7,8 33:1,4,9 able 24:12 adjusting ago 62:9 annual 55:25 26:5 40:5 42:10 66:15 82:25 38:11 39:8 52:12 63:7 61:21 agreed 35:15 answered assault 84:25 42:11 46:23 83:2 87:3 39:25 40:10 65:4 69:22 Administra... agreeing 63:13 85:5 46:24 48:5 bathroom 62:18 abreast 87:7 22:12 23:17 anti-violence Assembly 49:9,10 35:4 62:3 birth 64:14 absence 9:8 adopted agreements 71:2,14,16 69:18 51:8,9 Battalion birthday 9:13 42:17 46:22 13:9 57:13 anticipated assistance 52:18,19 47:12 78:19 absolutely 47:6 48:11 agrichemic... 13:8 57:12 16:2 53:25 54:2 battle 68:12 bit 64:21 21:25 84:24 49:17 51:15 15:14 anybody assisting 80:2 55:13,14 beat 67:12 black 68:25 acceptance 52:17,25 AgustaWes... 37:20 Association 56:19,20 beating 67:13 69:2 72:18 11:12 18:23 53:24 54:8 44:21 apartment 22:8 24:16 58:3,4 beautiful 75:9 access 19:19 55:11,20 ahead 17:18 35:3 attached 59:13,14 64:15 Blackwell 53:12 56:18 57:2 air 15:15 Apartments 30:13 39:8 60:14,15 becoming 62:7 acclimated 59:20 60:21 all-time 45:4 34:13 attempted 89:2,3 26:7 47:13 block 35:18 62:11 adopting Allan 1:11 apologize 85:6 ayes 9:5 beginning 2:6 36:7 accommod... 61:20 26:9 29:11 attendance 31:12 40:10 behalf 9:11 board 10:13 63:3 adoption Alliance applaud 25:8 2:21 42:16 47:5 19:6,13 83:16 accountable 42:5 47:24 79:23 65:18 attended 48:10 49:16 56:10 64:6 Boards 19:16 24:12 49:4 51:4 allow 61:8 applied 34:17 65:12 51:14 52:24 88:9 Bobby 1:14 accurately 52:10 53:20 69:22 apply 90:22 Attorney's 54:7 55:19 Behavioral 58:8 90:5 55:6 56:13 allowing appointment 79:16 56:25 59:19 81:19 body 10:2 acknowledge 57:22 59:8 37:12 41:7 10:12 Authority 60:20 89:8 belongings 69:19 70:6 77:11 80:15 60:9 66:16 appreciate 10:5,14 35:6 70:20 71:15 Act 61:10 adulthood alongside 22:17 64:18 20:13 54:13 B best 27:21 76:9 action 69:21 28:8 60:4 23:15 85:21 54:20 baby 64:15 28:6 59:2 Book 55:25 69:24 70:3 advance 12:6 altogether approach authorizing back 5:10 59:25 68:10 boost 52:7 70:12 73:12 advisory 53:7 23:8 78:5 10:2,18 28:25 29:3 84:7,7 boots-on-th... 73:16 advocacy AME 30:10 appropriate 11:2,12 29:13 32:7 better 15:9 79:25 activities 79:20 amend 30:7 12:3 20:8 12:15 13:3 36:8 38:3 17:12 23:3 bottles 63:17 14:21 66:22 advocate 71:21 appropriat... 13:17 18:13 41:11 79:13 beyond 25:18 box 5:10 activity 35:18 71:14 72:5 amended 70:4 18:23 19:8 balance 75:2 bill 10:16 boy 64:15 Adams 10:22 72:5 73:19 30:12 72:4 appropriati... 19:21 20:2 ballot 71:10 12:11,13 68:25 12:19 77:15 amending 19:9 20:11 27:16 71:20,22,23 13:5,21 boys 51:20,23 adapted advocating 10:15 12:12 approval 8:1 28:3 53:5,9 71:25 72:11 14:16 17:16 breakfast 44:11 78:5 13:22 19:14 8:10,14 54:11,19 72:12 74:5 18:5,12 78:17 adding 21:8 Affairs 29:8 21:6,14 approve 57:7 58:20 74:6,19,21 21:5 22:16 Breonna 5:16 additional 31:18 38:7 27:8 30:5 46:17 59:22 77:14,17 22:20 23:2 15:5 32:20 57:4 38:10,18 Amendment approved authors 56:3 78:7 80:8 27:7 29:19 BRIAN 1:16 address Afghanistan 17:24 8:20 9:6 available 85:23 86:16 30:4,13,22 brief 7:24 8:4 66:10 69:13 75:16 76:3 Amendmen...

Council President Clarke

10:17 12:13 45:3 61:7 Bank 54:21 31:4,12 33:14,20 69:21 70:11 African 14:20 58:18 Avenue 10:23 Baptist 67:18 38:19,24 73:23 71:5 73:10 47:14 American approving 11:5,11 bargaining 39:18 40:22 briefly 38:3 81:11,15,25 AFSCME 30:10 47:14 10:11 12:19 18:16 13:9 57:12 40:24 57:9 83:4 82:2 63:15 55:25 approxima... 18:22 85:3 based 67:9 bills 11:1,19 brings 68:24 addressing aftermath ammunitions 11:6 18:16 avoid 23:8 69:23 12:1 13:1 69:2 26:11 15:4 14:19 area 43:21 award-win... basketball 14:1 15:1 Brooks 1:11 adequately afternoon amount 66:10 45:16 51:20,24 16:1 17:1 3:12,13 27:23 59:3 87:17 44:25 68:9 areas 26:7 awarded Bass 1:10 3:3 18:1 19:1,5 22:23 77:21 adjourn agency 45:17 and/or 90:24 arming 23:5 44:23 3:4 27:6 20:1,7 21:1 Bucks 80:23 Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 Buenos 6:20 60:3 84:7 challenges 59:21 60:22 clarification 60:12,16,19 30:6 54:24 committee 6:21,24 career 50:21 43:21 44:2 childcare 87:16 60:25 64:4 coincidently 11:25 12:24 build 17:11 caring 3:7 44:9,10,18 44:4 clarify 41:7 68:14 74:12 63:13 13:4,15 44:24 66:25 carries 89:8 69:10 children 28:4 clarity 40:21 77:5,22 collaborative 14:15,23 building Carrington challenging 59:23 69:8 Clarke 1:10 80:16 82:21 66:8 18:10 19:3 45:18 63:16 69:4 78:18,20 2:2 3:9,16 86:19 87:4 colleague 20:9 21:21 buildings cases 23:18 champion Church 3:22 4:6,13 87:12 88:6 25:9 70:16 26:19 27:14 10:8 20:16 Cash 23:10 65:24 67:18 4:21 5:3,17 88:20 89:4 72:23 74:18 28:19 29:7 54:16 Catholic champions CINDY 1:10 5:24 6:6,16 89:7 colleagues 29:18 30:3 bullet 35:23 51:23 52:6 circumstan... 6:23 7:6,14 class 69:21 3:15,20 4:4 31:17 32:10 bullets 14:19 cause 82:7,13 champions... 84:8 7:17,18 8:7 69:24 70:3 4:12,18 5:2 32:14 38:4 15:17 celebrating 51:24 cite 75:15 8:18,25 9:4 70:12 73:12 5:15,22 6:5 38:6,9,17 business 3:7 41:16 55:24 chance 14:22 citizen 75:8 9:14 11:16 73:16 6:15,21 7:5 53:5 57:7 8:9 9:7,17 celebration 16:8 37:3 citizens 8:2 12:23 13:14 clean 63:25 7:12 14:13 78:9 11:18 19:22 68:21 78:19 63:19 65:4 13:18 14:3 clear 15:22 17:14 22:18 committees 24:22 28:16 cement 36:20 change 16:16 65:9 67:9 14:9 18:8 16:10 24:20 62:11 27:16 28:3 32:11 43:24 Center 69:20 chaos 16:5 67:21 74:21 19:2 20:6 clearly 14:20 64:13 65:18 28:17 58:20 businesses CEO 50:18 Chapter 74:22 76:11 20:19 21:2 Clerk 1:20 68:5 80:21 59:22 21:7 24:13 certain 10:6 13:23 19:15 city 1:2 2:9 21:20,24 2:20 3:2,11 81:10 85:20 common 76:4 43:12 44:2 11:14 19:18 21:9,14 4:20 7:25 22:3 24:25 3:18,24 4:8 collective commonly 44:3,7 20:15 21:12 27:8 30:8 9:23 10:10 25:5 26:16 4:15,23 5:5 13:9 57:12 39:2 busy 66:23 30:7 54:15 character 10:19,20 27:3,13,24 5:11,19 6:2 combat 65:20 Commonw... buy 23:9,20 certainly 35:14 11:4,5,9,13 28:9,14,21 6:8,11,18 81:15 70:5,15 buyers 24:11 23:22 Charge 79:22 12:16,17 28:24 29:12 6:25 7:8,16 combatting 83:12,22 certificate Charter 13:3,10 29:21 30:15 9:22 12:10 67:25 84:12 C 25:23 90:2 71:21 72:4 15:12 16:22 30:24 31:8 12:25 13:16 come 2:20 communica... cafe 19:24 certification Chat 5:9 61:7 17:3,7 18:3 31:11,20,24 13:20 18:11 5:10 7:21 66:18 Calendar 90:21 61:10 18:14,15,20 32:4 33:10 19:4 20:8 28:25 29:2 communica...

Council President Clarke

11:23 13:19 CERTIFY checked 18:24 20:24 33:21,25 20:10,21 66:4,16 9:1,18,20 20:20 21:3 90:3 62:21 23:11,12 37:14,18,25 21:4 26:20 67:17 69:20 10:1 27:5,25 certifying CHERELLE 24:23 27:10 38:13 39:10 27:6,15 79:10 communities 28:10 31:13 90:25 1:16 27:12 30:2 39:21 40:6 28:2,11 comes 26:10 17:3 18:4 32:12,17,18 chains 75:4 Chief 1:20 39:6 42:25 40:9,16 29:25 37:22 coming 25:13 53:8 64:24 32:21,25 Chair 8:12 3:2,11,18 43:18 44:15 41:8,23 38:17 41:15 82:14 66:13 81:23 40:11,23 9:9,15 22:4 3:24 4:8,15 46:11 52:7 42:7,12,15 42:18,21 comment 81:24 41:12 57:5 25:6 28:17 4:23 5:5,11 54:18 57:7 43:3 46:19 47:9 48:14 2:14 12:4 community 60:24 61:3 29:5 30:17 5:19 6:2,8 57:13 63:21 46:25 47:4 50:16 51:18 33:13 34:1 22:7 24:15 Calendars 31:15 32:22 6:11,18,25 63:24 65:5 47:18 48:2 53:4 54:10 35:1 36:1 26:10 43:14 33:6 39:13 40:17 7:8,16 9:22 65:21 67:4 48:6,9,22 55:23 57:6 37:1,23 63:20 82:12 call 2:1,20 41:24 43:4 12:10,25 69:2,5,9,10 49:6,11,15 58:19 59:21 Commerce 88:3 3:1 4:1 5:1 47:20 48:24 13:16,20 69:14,16,22 49:22 50:3 60:22 43:23 company 6:1 7:1 50:24 52:2 18:11 19:4 70:10 71:7 50:9,22 CLS 24:14 Commission 46:2 16:15 29:15 53:16 55:3 20:7,10,21 71:18 72:25 51:6,10,13 Co-Chair 22:13 74:23 completely 63:14 56:7 57:19 21:4 26:20 73:5,11,15 51:25 52:14 65:6 Commissio... 83:15 called 33:4 59:6 60:7 27:6,15 73:20 74:2 52:20,23 co-sponsored 10:3 20:11 complex 66:2 81:20 87:19 61:15 64:8 28:2,11 74:7,10 53:14,22 22:20 54:11 compliance calling 16:2 68:17 74:15 29:25 37:22 75:21,22 54:3,6,25 Co-Victims Commissio... 10:24 12:21 25:24 32:23 77:7 82:24 38:17 41:15 76:11 79:18 55:9,15,18 78:11 10:13 comply 61:10 48:17 Chairman 42:18,21 80:13 83:10 56:5,15,21 Coalition Commissions comprehen... calls 17:11 17:15 47:9,12 86:14 56:24 57:18 34:9 19:16 81:13 cane 36:11 Chalfont 48:14 50:16 City-owned 57:25 58:5 Coast 44:20 commitment comprehen... canisters 38:21 51:18 53:4 10:6 20:15 58:10,15 Code 13:23 17:23 81:16 15:16 challenge 54:10 55:23 54:15 59:5,11,15 19:15 21:7 committed concern 78:3 care 28:8 31:21 57:6 58:19 civil 17:23 59:18 60:6 21:15 27:9 85:4 concludes Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 32:9 61:2 contract 27:13,24 87:4,10,12 86:12 87:10 84:12 Darrell 1:10 demonstrat... 88:8 44:24 28:9,14,21 88:4,6,16 87:13,14 couple 2:22 77:22 80:16 15:25 condemning contributions 28:24 29:10 88:20,22 88:7,11,12 17:20,21 daughters denied 37:11 48:15 50:20 63:8 29:12,21 89:4,7 88:13 77:10 78:13 Department conditions control 34:9 30:2,13,15 Council's Councilma... courage DAVID 1:15 13:11 14:17 10:25 11:15 81:6 83:8 30:21,24 13:4 57:7 10:9 20:18 17:11 day 31:4 19:11 22:14 12:22 90:24 31:3,8,11 Councilman 54:18 courageous 37:17 39:18 47:13,17 conference conversation 31:20,24 1:11,13,14 Councilme... 16:16 39:25 61:24 57:15 75:7 66:14 69:7 18:6 32:4,19 1:14,15,15 14:24 17:15 course 52:6 76:18 80:2 deployed 69:11 70:2 conveying 33:10,21,25 1:16,17,18 40:14 56:11 court 34:21 80:2 82:5 15:11 70:8 71:9 10:5 20:14 37:14,18,25 3:18,19 61:19,24 36:23 48:16 deal 23:18 depositories congratulate 54:14 38:13 39:8 4:15,16 5:5 62:7,20 cousin 70:18 74:9 77:3 27:12 52:11 cool 45:20,25 39:10,13,17 5:8,11,13 63:11 64:20 COVID-19 dealing 63:23 Deposits congratulat... cooperation 39:21,24 5:18,19,20 65:7 66:15 43:20 61:22 deals 79:19 27:10 26:22 47:10 12:6 40:6,9,16 6:2,3,8,25 70:17,23 Crawford 81:21 deprived 50:17 51:19 coordinate 40:19 41:6 7:3,8,10,15 71:12 72:23 70:4,7 death 25:23 68:7 connect 72:7 41:8,23 8:12,13 73:18,25 72:20 73:15 70:17 DEREK 1:13 33:18 coordinating 42:4,7,12 18:11 19:4 77:20,20,21 create 13:23 decades describe connection 46:3 42:15 43:3 19:7,13 Councilme... 72:4 74:22 15:12 45:17 13:8 57:11 corner 39:4 43:6 46:5 20:21 21:4 22:20 61:20 created 43:20 December deserves conscience Coronavirus 46:10,15,19 21:22,25 61:21 62:14 creating 30:9 34:14 45:10 37:10 67:24 46:25 47:4 22:2,4,5,24 65:10 69:16 77:15 decent 35:11 designating consciousn... Corporal 47:18 48:2 25:2,3,6,7,9 Councilwo... Creative/In...

Council President Clarke

37:4,7 38:21,25 84:2 38:22 48:6,9,22 26:13,14,15 1:10,11,12 53:6 Decker 1:20 designing consider correct 90:8 49:3,6,11 26:17,20 1:12,13,16 credit 35:10 2:25 9:18 45:18 74:24 corrected 49:15,20,22 28:18,22 1:17 3:2,4 crime 71:16 11:17 12:7 desire 37:6 considerati... 87:22 50:3,7,9,22 29:3,9,13 3:11,13,24 72:6,9 28:15 29:23 desperately 9:25 32:12 Council 1:2 51:3,6,10 29:15,17 4:2,8,10,23 73:21 74:9 37:20 38:15 74:8 33:13 48:19 1:10 2:2,7,9 51:13,25 30:18,19 4:24 5:7 crimes 80:5 41:13 42:18 despite 7:22 considered 3:9,14,16 52:4,14,20 37:2 40:17 6:11,13,17 criminal 79:2 47:7 48:12 44:18 30:12 39:7 3:20,22 4:3 52:23 53:14 40:18 41:9 6:18,20 9:9 crisis 8:3 49:18 50:14 destinies consistent 4:6,11,13 53:19,22 43:4,5 9:10,16 critically 51:16 53:2 80:19 65:14,15 4:17,20,21 54:3,6,25 47:20,22 12:10,25 44:13 54:9 55:21 destiny 81:6 constituents 4:25 5:3,14 55:9,15,18 48:24 49:2 13:20 14:5 Cultural 29:8 57:3 83:8 25:20 5:17,24 6:4 56:5,10,15 49:13,14,20 14:7,10,11 31:18 38:7 declaring destroyed constitutio... 6:6,16,23 56:21,24 49:24,24 27:6 29:6 38:10,18 20:23 35:8 18:2 7:6,11,14 57:11,18,25 50:5,6,11 31:16,22 culture 53:13 dedication develop construct 7:16,18 8:7 58:5,7,10 50:11,24 32:2,22 56:4 64:21 24:17 42:24 27:21 58:25 20:3 8:18,25 9:4 58:15 59:5 51:2 52:2,3 33:2,11 64:22 66:7 deeds 10:5 development consulted 9:12,14,23 59:11,15,18 53:16,18 38:5,8 current 2:8 20:14 54:14 19:12 45:2 80:9 11:16,24 60:6,12,16 55:3,5 56:7 39:14,15 8:2 12:2 deem 24:3 devices 13:25 contained 12:23 13:7 60:19,25 56:9 58:7 40:13 41:25 14:17 28:6 deemed Devices,' 90:5 13:14,18 61:18 64:4 58:12,13,14 42:3 57:17 59:25 32:15 34:24 13:24 container 14:3,9 64:11,25 58:16,16 57:19,21 currently 2:5 defer 48:19 dias 6:21,21 36:21 16:22 17:2 65:22 67:4 61:15,17 59:4,6,7 2:10 24:4 Deliberations 6:24 context 75:16 17:7 18:8 67:11 68:4 64:5,8,10 60:4,7,8 CURTIS 19:17 different continue 19:2,6,10 68:14,20,24 65:23 66:2 77:19 82:25 1:15 deliver 10:4 34:18 52:5 17:20,22 20:6,19 69:14,25 68:15,17,19 83:2 86:20 custom 36:17 20:12 54:12 65:20 67:8 25:11 35:16 21:2,20,22 74:11,12 68:21 74:13 87:3 delivering 70:13 73:24 44:12 52:5 21:24 22:3 76:18 77:5 74:15,17 countless D 45:24 75:4 52:7 67:6 22:6 24:24 77:10,22 77:6,7,9,12 22:15 D 1:17 demand 15:8 difficult 68:12 24:25 25:3 80:16,22 77:13,18,19 country Daily 2:16 16:17 17:18 62:15 continued 25:5,7 82:19,21 77:21 82:22 84:17 Daniel 50:17 democracy difficulties 86:21 26:16 27:3 84:21 86:19 83:17 85:23 county 80:23 dark 36:13 41:21 5:9 29:11 Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 dinner 78:17 Drexel 45:21 emotional events 15:3 fantastic 17:24 30:21 63:10 83:6 84:21 direct 90:24 drinking 68:6 everybody 45:23 62:14 31:4,13 Foundry 85:3 87:2 directly 16:6 36:16 employed 86:5 87:7 63:5 32:15,21 42:23 45:12 getting 26:3 64:23 79:2 DSW1 19:21 43:17 eviction fathers 78:15 39:18,25 45:12 62:10,19 Director 34:8 Due 2:8 Employees 34:16 35:9 favor 8:22 40:11,20 four 19:5 82:6 disadvanta... Duly 8:17 13:10 57:14 evictions 41:5 31:6 40:3 47:13 54:17 20:7 Gilmore 1:12 53:8,11 30:23 39:20 enable 81:5 evidence 90:4 42:9 46:23 61:24 64:11 Frankford 4:9 13:2 64:24 66:13 42:6 46:18 81:14 exactly 85:9 48:4 49:8 64:18,25 45:13 14:25 22:21 Disbursem... 47:25 49:5 encourage examining 51:8 52:18 70:23 76:6 Fraternal 57:17,19 27:11 51:5 52:13 74:4 27:18 28:6 53:25 55:12 77:11 13:12 57:15 65:7 77:21 disclosures 53:21 55:8 engaged 17:2 58:22 59:25 56:19 58:3 Fiscal 19:9 free 66:22 give 33:16 21:12 56:14 57:24 70:19 example 59:13 60:14 fit 23:24 67:16 75:15 87:22 Discrimina... 59:10 60:11 engineers 44:20 88:25 five- 33:14 freedom Global 53:5 21:17 88:19 45:17 exceeded favorable five-minute 41:22 go 17:16 displayed duplicate ensure 28:7 75:19 29:19 30:14 33:16 freedoms 25:21 29:13 2:24 79:14 60:2 84:5 excited 64:17 38:11 39:9 fix 66:4 17:24 38:3 66:20 disrespectful duty 84:5 enthusiasm execute 10:4 favors 36:18 flabbergast... freely 18:3 76:22 79:9 25:19 85:15 52:8 20:12 54:12 feature 61:7 85:8 frequent 81:2 distributing dying 83:24 enthusiasti...

Council President Clarke

exhibited 61:11 flood 35:8 36:17 goal 67:7 81:4 49:3 52:9 75:12 fee 10:6 flooded 35:3 freshmen going 2:3 distribution E 52:16,25 exiting 36:8 20:14 54:14 flooding 81:8 61:20 17:6 25:17 45:5 e-mail 71:4 entire 83:12 expect 24:13 54:22 Floyd 15:5 friend 76:22 29:2,2,4 district 10:10 earlier 44:8 83:22 84:16 experienced feel 35:19 focuses 43:12 friend's 33:15 52:4 20:18 27:19 44:21 entitled 10:17 16:7 79:10 foe 76:22 35:13 66:3,6 69:5 27:22 45:14 early 80:21 12:11,14 express 16:11 feet 11:6 followed 36:6 friends 76:23 69:13 81:13 54:18 58:23 earn 47:14 13:3,21,24 extending 18:17 following 2:5 front 35:21 81:14 82:10 59:2 66:16 easily 70:13 18:12 19:16 10:23 12:20 fell 36:21 33:3 77:16 35:24 36:15 85:20 66:17 73:4 70:14 20:22 21:5 exterior 20:4 Fels 70:25 foot 68:10 full 16:22 golden 37:5 79:16 83:21 East 44:20 21:7,9,15 extra 45:10 field 23:5 Football fully 17:25 good 2:2 3:4 84:13,14 easy 61:22 26:21 27:8 extremely Fifty's 19:22 26:23 27:2 90:5 3:9,13,14 86:13 62:13 27:9 30:5,6 16:20 fifty-six 11:6 force 15:10 Fund 19:10 3:16,19,22 District,' economy 30:8 38:20 18:17 53:8,9 19:11 4:2,3,4,6,10 30:11 44:5 53:7 38:24 F fight 68:11 64:22,23,24 Funds 27:10 4:11,13,16 Districts,' educate environment face 17:18 figure 81:25 66:7,14 further 42:23 4:17,18,19 30:9 24:21 72:8 12:2 65:16 filed 34:20 forcing 15:19 53:9 54:19 4:21,24,25 documented 80:6 environme... faced 44:2,8 filing 35:9 foregoing future 45:5 5:3,13,14 16:5 Education 27:20 58:25 facility 46:4 filings 36:23 90:7,21 69:8 5:17,20,21 doing 19:22 27:16 58:20 equally 74:23 facing 41:4 filled 15:14 foremost 5:22,24 6:3 24:22 62:18 effort 24:18 errant 35:23 67:14 68:3 Final 11:23 64:11,19 G 6:4,6,13,14 62:21 63:13 66:8 erroneous fact 17:19 32:17,24 77:12 Garafolo 6:16 7:3,4,6 67:5 69:8 Eight 14:15 34:20 45:2 68:25 33:5 60:23 Forrest 47:10 20:3 7:10,11,14 76:19 80:2 Eighth 86:13 especially 71:3 72:18 Finally 35:12 forth 75:13 gas 14:18 7:18 33:23 Domb 1:11 either 65:12 14:14 17:14 failed 34:24 find 28:25 forward 15:13,16 33:24,25 3:18,19 El 36:7 essential 44:7 35:4 29:3 35:11 16:23 22:25 Gauthier 34:5 37:9 21:4,22 elected 83:21 establish 53:7 failure 34:22 82:13 24:19 63:8 1:12 3:25 37:17 82:22 22:2,4,5 election established 84:9,11 findings 68:10 80:12 4:2 22:22 88:14 25:9 26:9 48:17 71:24 7:20 13:6 fair 21:15 53:10 80:17 76:18 gotten 36:19 26:13,14 electromec... 57:10 23:18 37:10 Fire 47:12,16 foster 28:8 General GPAR 24:17 50:25 51:2 45:19 estate 26:10 55:25 firm 45:10,13 60:3 19:10,11 grades 10:19 Domestic emergencies evacuate families firmly 16:21 fought 23:15 69:17 11:3 12:16 20:23 27:21,23 15:20 15:19 80:3 firms 43:17 Foulkrod gentrified 18:14 Donald 48:15 58:25 59:3 evenings 80:4 43:22 44:6 10:23 12:20 25:10 26:8 grand-ma... door 35:21 emergency 66:20 family 35:13 44:17 found 2:18 George 15:4 86:5 35:24 2:9 68:8 event 83:6 72:24 first 14:12,20 Foundation Germantown grant 11:13 Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 18:24 happened 50:17 hub 79:19 25:15 77:16 introduction 87:10,13,14 26:3 43:9 grassroots 84:20 hinterlands hubs 66:18 82:11 11:19 join 46:6 61:25 62:3 79:24 happening 83:17 66:19 67:19 industrial inventory 67:17 82:18 62:4,8 grateful 65:8 26:7 83:10 historic 41:17 Human 22:13 45:2,3 45:3 joining 14:25 63:18 64:17 gratitude happy 4:5 history 47:16 27:17 28:4 industries investigate 76:15 65:25 68:6 16:11 7:12 63:6 71:15 58:21 59:23 46:13 72:8 joint 27:18 70:6,16 great 7:22 hard 16:20 hitting 35:24 hurt 82:4,4 industry investigatio... e 79:16,17 informed Isaiah 1:18 66:2 74:16 71:7 4:15,16 37:15,16 holiday 78:19 illegal 23:21 34:16 61:19 74:17 77:13 knows 86:6 20:21 22:23 hat 66:2 67:7 home 23:16 23:22 35:18 initiative Ismail 10:12 77:22 83:17 Korean 41:22 68:18,19 hats 63:22 23:21,22 81:8 64:23 66:12 issue 22:10 88:11,13 Korean-A...

Council President Clarke

74:19 75:19 health 2:9 8:3 26:2 35:20 imagine 72:15 85:24 26:12 41:3 Journal 8:1 41:20 77:13,20 27:17,20 36:9 43:16 84:25 86:16 65:25 71:6 8:10,15 9:5 grief 82:3 28:4 50:19 71:21 72:3 impact 82:11 initiatives 78:25 80:19 journalists L ground 10:7 58:21,24 homeowners impacted 65:20 71:2 81:12,15,21 15:24 L 1:10,16 16:6 20:16 59:23 81:19 21:13,18 15:3 innovation 82:2,3 joy 68:20,25 90:15 54:16 85:2 hear 15:2 23:14 24:10 importance 42:24 issues 65:15 69:3 land 45:3 group 50:19 16:8 41:2 homes 23:10 71:11 input 22:16 67:14 72:8 JR 1:15 54:21 78:12,14 heard 15:6 23:14 25:15 important Inquirer 2:16 74:9 judgment landlord 80:23 16:6 21:23 25:16 26:6 22:10 23:6 install 19:23 73:23 35:15 guidance 23:13 65:14 36:5 85:25 41:3 71:24 Instructions J July 10:17 Landlord-... 62:5 hearing homicide 75:25 86:14 2:12 J 1:16 50:17 12:13 34:21 guide 17:9 13:17 68:23 73:4 79:23 impossible Intelligencer Jaisohn June 15:3 lapse 73:23 gun 35:19 hearings 13:5 85:5,6 35:11 2:17 41:17,20 34:13,17 Latin 55:25 65:20 67:13 13:8 27:18 honest 16:14 improve intend 17:25 63:10 35:14 Latin-Ame... 68:2 69:23 28:5 57:8 honorable 86:22 interactive JAMIE 1:12 justice 5:16 56:3 73:10 75:23 57:11 58:22 10:2 improveme... 45:20 January 15:8 79:2 launch 66:17 76:7 78:9 59:24 honoring 10:8 20:17 Interest 48:21 79:23 law 2:4 22:14 78:11,14 held 15:15 26:22 42:23 54:17 69:19 Jefferson justified 69:19 80:20 80:20,24 33:9 47:10 50:19 inauguration interested 39:3,4 16:14 laws 69:23 83:9 84:10 HELEN 1:13 51:19 48:21 46:7 Jimmy 38:23 75:23 guns 69:23 helicopter honors 41:18 incidents interests 79:3 job 44:17 K lawsuit 66:6 71:3,4 81:3 44:22 hope 18:5 81:7 internation... 45:23 62:14 Karen 34:6 70:12 73:12 81:4,8 help 27:22 24:8 69:3,8 included 2:14 44:14 Johnson 1:14 40:20 73:17 75:13 guys 64:15,18 59:2 67:2 69:12 72:10 including INTRO 11:1 5:12,13 Katherine 76:16 80:18 Gym 1:13 74:6,8 hopeful 73:22 11:22 17:19 12:1 13:1 19:5,7,14 1:12 65:7 81:5 85:13 4:23,24 helping 23:2 hopefully 35:6 14:1 15:1 22:22 25:3 keep 44:7 laying 85:2 13:20 14:7 80:3 66:24 87:5 increase 73:9 16:1 17:1 25:6,7 66:23 82:22 lead 34:7 14:10,11 Henon 1:14 horror 23:13 independen... 18:1 19:1 26:15 28:18 87:7 Leader 48:18 22:24 41:25 5:5,8 43:4,5 hosting 87:24 41:22 50:19 20:1 21:1 28:22 29:3 KENDRA leaders 7:25 42:3 63:11 58:7,8,12 hour 2:19 indicate 8:22 22:1 23:1 29:9,14,15 1:11 43:24 77:19 58:16 hours 15:6 42:9 55:12 24:1 25:1 29:17 30:18 Kenyatta leadership high 26:23 22:15 88:25 26:1 27:1 30:19 48:25 1:14 73:18 65:3 69:15 H 36:10 house 34:12 indiscrimin...

Council President Clarke

introduce 49:2 65:24 kids 45:22 League 27:2 hair 70:24 highlight 35:15 41:18 15:23 52:5 70:14,17,24 killed 86:2 51:23 half 84:22 45:9 71:25 Houses 23:10 individual introduced 71:12 72:23 killing 15:4 learned 72:13 hand 63:18 highlighting housing 25:25 57:16 59:4 73:18 74:2 kind 63:3 leave 9:8 handle 84:17 56:2 10:14 37:4 individuals 60:4 63:11 76:17 77:8 know 16:12 leaves 9:1,13 happen 62:23 Hilferty Howard 39:5 15:15 25:13 71:19 77:9 85:23 17:16,17 leaving 15:20 Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 left 36:17 56:3 63:16 market 25:17 met 15:10 83:5 84:20 nationally 48:16,20 42:22 43:9 legacy 41:19 located 39:3 75:11,12 70:23 85:4 44:14 North 86:25 88:17,23 Legal 2:16 longtime masks 63:17 mic 88:14 mothers navigate 67:2 Northeast offer 2:13 22:7 24:15 15:25 mass 34:16 MICHAEL 78:13,15,23 navigating 26:23 38:22 23:20 40:21 legally 10:21 look 22:25 matter 72:18 1:20 79:22 62:15 44:22 offered 12:9 12:18 81:3 24:19 63:7 74:14 75:9 MICHELE motion 41:25 nay 49:13 Nos 33:6 28:12 legislation 66:9 72:25 75:10,11 90:15 43:7 46:16 50:2,12 39:18 offers 12:11 12:8 24:9 73:2 75:2 90:7 Microsoft 1:6 48:25 56:8 58:17 note 2:19 13:2,21 25:10 71:19 75:22 Matthias 2:11 61:7 88:11 89:8 necessary 32:13 61:5 18:12 19:5 71:20 77:24 lost 25:21 11:7 18:18 mile 84:22 motivated 79:11 noted 5:9 19:7,14 79:20 85:13 75:18 78:13 maximum Militarized 70:18 need 7:22 40:15 20:22 21:5 let's 16:14 79:8 68:9 15:12 mourning 23:6 70:9 notes 90:6 26:21 27:7 29:13 lot 25:15 44:3 Mayor 9:20 million 44:23 86:6 70:10 73:9 notice 2:15 office 25:22 lethal 13:24 45:5 66:3 69:15 76:15 mind 87:15 mouths 79:3 73:13 74:8 November 46:8 72:5 13:25 14:19 68:6 76:23 McCall 39:5 minority move 8:14 79:9,12 71:11,24 72:19 74:3 level 22:17 78:25 80:7 McConnell 61:14 88:9 30:20 39:16 80:5 84:17 NRA 76:8 77:15 79:14 23:4 78:3 lots 10:7 48:19 miscommu... 41:12 42:4 86:7,8,8,9 number 79:16 80:9 liberties 20:15 36:4 means 75:5 62:23 47:23 49:4 86:10 69:15 73:8 81:19 83:20 17:23 54:15 90:23 misinforma... 51:3 52:9 needed 44:13 75:20 86:7,8,9,10 life 67:3 69:2 loud 16:10 measurable 78:2 80:8 53:19 55:6 neighbor numbers Oh 1:15 6:2,3 82:9 86:23 lounge 36:14 45:19 Mississippi 56:12 57:22 35:22 36:8 26:4,5 73:2 13:18 49:14 light 24:7 loved 25:21 media 16:4 76:25 83:18 59:8 60:9 neighborho... 73:3 50:6,11 lightly 83:23 79:8 meeting 1:3 Mitch 48:18 80:12 88:16 25:11,14,16 numerous 56:8,9 lines 10:19 Lovells 69:20 2:10,12,13 moment 7:24 moved 8:19 81:20 86:3 34:19 61:16,17 11:3 12:15 low 45:4 2:15,17 8:5,6 30:25 39:12 neighborho... 64:20 18:13 lunch 78:17 8:11,20 momma's 39:22 40:23 43:13 46:14 O okay 13:19 Lisa 47:10 33:19 81:18 86:4 42:8 46:20 82:3 o'clock 87:18 22:2 28:25 list 27:11 M 87:18 89:10 month 20:24 48:3 49:7 neighbors O'Connor 29:13 31:25 37:24 mail 71:10 meetings 34:22 42:23 51:7 52:15 63:21 87:20 38:23 32:5,6 50:4 listen 41:3 maintain 19:18 43:10 45:9 53:23 55:10 87:24 O'Neill 1:16 50:10 65:4 19:23 20:4 member 46:4 56:16 58:2 Network 6:9 49:13 once 36:6 listening 3:21 maintenance 10:12 34:10 months 17:3 59:12 60:13 87:19,24 49:20,24,25 one-hundred 65:9,13 35:2 46:5 70:20 17:21 88:21 Networks 50:5,11 11:6 18:17 67:21 major 44:19 74:18 75:19 Montour moving 80:17 81:20 58:13,14,16 ones 25:21 literature majority 35:7 76:17 10:22 12:19 multiple 17:5 Neumann-... Oat 42:23 ongoing 56:3 48:18 64:7 members morale 52:8 municipality 51:20 45:11,12 24:17 litigation 88:9 2:21 9:12 moratorium 67:15 never 78:15 objections open 10:21 87:8 making 23:20 9:23 12:9 14:18 murdered 78:16,18 90:4 12:18 little 62:22 35:10 43:7 28:13 30:2 morning 2:3 80:3 80:9 objects 15:18 operates 78:4 64:21 48:16 63:24 61:4,8 3:5,10,14 murders nevertheless obligation operation live 34:19 man 35:3 69:17,19,25 3:15,17,19 75:20 78:7 84:5 80:25 35:12,17 manufactu... 76:18 3:23 4:3,4,4 MURPHY new 13:23 observe 7:24 Opportunit... 36:25 37:8 44:22 Memorial 4:7,11,12 90:15 21:8 24:21 8:4 53:6 43:15 46:11 manufactu...

Council President Clarke

38:23 41:17 4:14,17,18 Musgrave 62:13 68:23 observers opportunity lived 34:12 42:22,25 63:10 4:18,22,25 75:10 news 2:16 15:24 12:4 37:13 lives 72:18 43:10,10,16 men 35:21 5:2,4,14,15 85:3 occasion 78:16 75:9,18 43:22 44:6 36:6,14 5:18,21,21 N next-door 47:11 oppose 50:7 76:21 79:13 45:6,8,10 80:23 82:7 5:22,25 6:3 name 34:2,6 35:22 occasions 72:19 living 25:10 45:13 46:13 mentioned 6:4,7,14,14 named 70:4 Nifty 19:22 35:20 opposed 9:2 84:7 Marcel 69:17 83:18 87:17 6:17 7:4,4,7 narratives night 14:22 occupied 31:9 40:7 LLC 19:22 March 34:13 mentors 7:11,12,13 65:14 16:8,23 36:5 42:13 47:2 lobbyists Maria 1:17 66:25 7:15,19 nation 76:3 73:6 October 1:7 48:7 49:12 76:7 56:11 messages 33:23,24 National nightly 36:14 8:11,15,20 49:14 51:11 local 45:21 MARK 1:17 9:19 26:2,4 34:2,6 75:7 79:23 nomination 20:23 41:18 52:21 54:4 Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 55:16 56:22 67:13,24 83:19,20 72:15 73:3 30:7 59:2,25 40:6,9,14 pretending 58:6 59:16 68:2 86:13 73:5,20 plastic 36:21 Pratt 69:17 40:16,19 17:7 60:17 89:5 parents 37:7 people's 3:7 74:3 75:6 plate 26:11 prayer 7:25 41:6,8,23 pretty 45:22 opposing Parker 1:16 pepper 15:14 75:21 76:2 65:19 77:2 prepare 42:4,7,12 price 23:23 72:15 5:7 6:12,13 percent 73:9 76:12,25 81:11 27:23 59:3 42:15 43:3 primarily order 7:21 9:9,10 11:5 86:11 79:18 80:13 Playground prepared 43:6 46:16 26:6 8:9 9:7,17 11:11 12:11 period 10:24 81:9 83:11 38:21 39:3 76:20 46:19,25 primary 11:18 13:12 18:15,22 12:20 83:14 84:10 Playground' preparedne... 47:4,18,23 43:12 28:16 32:11 22:23 32:2 permanent 84:14 86:15 38:23 39:5 27:19 58:24 48:2,6,9,15 prior 2:17 57:16 61:9 32:22 33:2 14:17 Philadelphi... playing 23:5 presence 48:22 49:3 32:7 43:7 ordinance 40:13 permit 30:21 27:19 58:23 please 2:20 36:3 49:6,11,15 61:4 10:15,16,18 Parks 29:7 31:3 39:17 Philadelphi... 2:22,25 present 1:9 49:21,22 Priorities 11:2 12:12 31:17 38:7 39:24 41:19 9:19 12:7 34:23 50:3,7,9,18 74:13 12:13,14 38:9,18 permitted Philadelphi... 14:7 29:23 presented 50:22 51:3 privileged 13:21 18:12 part 18:5 44:6 16:17 65:15 34:2 38:15 37:2 51:6,10,13 11:22 19:8,14,21 61:14 83:15 person 16:23 84:3 86:23 40:3 41:13 President 51:25 52:4 probably 20:2 21:5 83:18 84:25 Philip 41:17 42:19 46:7 1:10 2:2 52:14,20,23 71:13 21:16 27:8 participants person's 41:19 63:10 47:7 48:12 3:5,9,14,16 53:14,19,22 problem 66:3 30:5 38:20 52:11 25:23 Philly 86:25 49:18 50:14 3:20,22 4:3 54:3,6,25 84:15,15,16 38:25 participate personally 86:25 87:2 51:16 53:2 4:6,11,13 55:6,9,15 problems ordinary 46:6 66:22 76:9 PHLCounc... 55:21 58:9 4:17,21,25 55:18 56:5 21:19 44:11 16:17 82:17 persons 2:18 67:16 5:3,14,17 56:10,15,21 65:16 organization particular 53:12 phone 26:4,5 point 11:5 5:21,24 6:4 56:24 57:18 procedure 72:17 81:20 66:10 72:12 perspective 71:5 14:6 18:16 6:6,14,16 57:22,25 12:3 87:19,21,23 74:5 73:25 photo 2:23 65:12 74:20 6:23 7:4,6 58:5,8,10 proceed 2:25 87:25 particularly phenomenal pick 36:18 87:6,15 7:11,14,16 58:15 59:5 33:12 34:3 organizatio... 62:20 68:22 63:17 poles 23:12 7:18 8:7,14 59:8,11,15 proceeding 79:17,22,25 partners Philadelphia picking 36:12 police 13:10 8:18,25 9:4 59:18 60:6 83:7 organizer 43:23 44:16 1:2,6 9:24 PIDC 43:23 13:11,13 9:11,14,22 60:9,12,16 proceedings 34:8 party 36:17 10:4,10,14 piece 25:9 14:16 36:2 11:16 12:23 60:19,24,25 90:4 organizing Passage 13:11,22 67:7 69:12 57:13,14,16 13:14,17,18 61:18 63:16 proceeds 78:22 11:23 32:18 15:18 17:12 85:12 73:3 74:22 14:3,9,12 64:4,11,25 87:8 outrageous 32:25 33:5 19:15 20:13 pieces 10:7 75:6 18:8 19:2,7 65:23 67:11 process 25:18 84:24 60:23 20:25 21:6 20:15 54:15 policy 79:20 20:6,19 68:5,14,20 62:13 outside 36:13 pause 33:20 21:15 22:8 pioneer 41:20 political 21:2,20,23 69:14 74:11 produce overall 26:25 pay 34:22,25 22:11,13 place 15:20 41:21 21:24 22:3 74:12,18 53:10 51:22 Peace 71:3,4 23:3 24:16 16:13 34:18 portion 10:19 22:6 24:24 76:14 77:4 product-m...

Council President Clarke

Overlay 30:9 pending 27:2,9 30:3 35:11 36:25 10:22 11:3 24:25 25:4 77:5,10,22 45:6 30:10 34:16 30:6 34:9 37:8 79:9 11:11 12:16 25:5,8 80:16 82:20 products oversight Penn 34:12 34:10 35:17 placed 11:23 12:18 18:14 26:16 27:3 82:21 83:3 44:13 45:24 24:6 74:22 34:15,19 38:22 39:6 31:13 32:16 18:22 27:13,24 84:21 85:10 professionals owners 22:11 Pennsylvania 41:4 43:2 40:11 position 28:9,13,14 85:19 86:18 33:17 23:4 1:6 70:5,15 43:19,21 placing 11:9 47:15 65:3 28:21,24 86:19 87:4 Professions,' ownership 83:13,19,22 44:15,23 18:20 66:25 77:14 29:10,12,18 87:11,12 21:8 23:16 Pennsylvan... m 66:15 15:23 16:7 53:12 54:13 11:4,5,9 67:8 31:24 32:3 presidential 47:11 67:17 81:18 16:9 41:3 54:19,20,21 12:16,17 posts 16:4 32:4 33:3 48:17,20 proper 87:22 82:16 87:25 43:13 46:11 54:23 56:2 18:14,15,20 powers 85:11 33:10,21,25 press 66:14 properly 8:20 pain 82:9 63:19 66:4 57:14 65:5 72:7 PPE 63:14 37:14,18,24 69:7,11 31:2 39:12 palpable 66:11,19 65:10,22 Planning practices 37:25 38:9 70:2,8 71:9 39:23 42:8 16:13 72:21 76:17 67:10,22 19:11 21:16 24:7 38:13 39:10 prestigious 46:21 48:3 pandemic 82:4,5 71:18 72:3 Planning,' 27:22 28:6 39:16,21 47:15 49:7 51:7 Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 53:23 55:10 purchases reading 30:17 31:15 regain 23:15 report 28:19 20:10,22,23 results 78:21 56:17 58:2 21:11 30:22 31:4 32:22 39:14 regard 82:10 29:6,24 26:21,22 retelling 59:12 60:13 purchasing 31:13 32:16 40:17 41:24 regarding 31:16 35:10 27:15 28:2 16:19 88:22 81:3 32:17,21,24 43:4 47:20 61:5 78:5 38:6,16 36:25 41:14 retired 34:7 properties purpose 33:1,5 48:24 50:24 80:10 53:10 41:15 42:2 retirement 54:22 32:23 61:12 39:18,25 52:2 53:16 region 43:15 reported 42:5,16,19 50:18 property purposes 40:11 41:1 55:3 56:7 Register 32:13 42:21 43:8 retreat 15:21 10:3 20:12 11:10 18:21 42:1 43:1 57:19 59:6 25:22 reporter 46:21 47:5 returns 30:13 21:9,12,13 pursuant 44:1 45:1 60:7 61:15 regulate 90:25 47:8,9 39:8 22:11 23:4 13:5 54:23 46:1 47:1 64:8 68:17 13:25 21:10 reports 28:1 48:10,13,14 review 17:17 39:2 54:12 57:9 48:1 49:1 74:15 77:7 69:22 28:17 29:1 49:4,17,19 revising proposed put 66:24 50:1 51:1 82:24 regulating 29:19 30:1 50:2,12,15 27:11 19:23 20:4 68:10 75:13 52:1 53:1 recognizing 80:18 81:7 30:11 31:1 50:16 51:14 revision props 87:23 79:4,12 54:1 55:1 41:16 42:22 Regulation 32:1,9 38:1 51:17,18 10:18 11:3 protect 22:11 85:17 56:1 57:1 46:10 55:24 21:7 38:4,10 52:10,17,24 12:15 18:13 76:11 putting 43:13 58:1 59:1 61:4 63:12 reiterate 39:1,7 40:1 53:3,4,20 Richardson protected 65:3,25 60:1 74:19 16:21 84:20 85:3 53:24 54:7 1:12 4:9,10 84:6 ready 29:9 recommen... related 21:19 represent 54:10 55:7 13:2 14:25 protections Q 68:11 29:20 30:14 relates 41:4 83:12 55:11,19,23 22:21 57:17 21:16,18 quality 86:23 real 21:11 38:12 39:9 65:16 66:11 Representa... 56:8,13,17 57:20,21 24:10 quarantined 24:5 26:10 recommen... 67:21,22 70:21 56:25 57:6 65:8 proud 17:13 62:16,24 43:24 62:5 80:11 78:6 79:6 represented 57:23 58:18 right 18:2 provide 12:3 question really 22:6 record 26:25 80:12,17 13:12 57:15 58:19 59:9 37:11 43:18 21:17 24:9 71:20,22 37:10 62:15 34:3 36:24 relating 72:9 represents 59:19,21 44:14 45:14 35:13 72:2,12 70:9 85:8 50:10 51:22 Relations 37:3 60:10,20 46:14 67:11 providers 74:6,21 85:11,17,21 58:11 61:6 22:14 reproduction 63:12 68:3,7 86:9 72:7 77:18 78:7 85:22 80:14 relationships 90:22 resolutions right-of-way provision 80:9 Realtors 22:9 recorded 67:2 Reps 83:13 11:20,21,22 11:10,14 19:19 questions 24:16 49:25 58:9 religious request 9:24 27:7 28:12 18:21,25 provisions 71:23 72:11 reason 23:23 recording 41:21 requests 9:8 32:23 33:4 rights 23:4 30:8 74:5,19 reasonable 19:17 reliving 9:12 33:9 57:4 78:6 public 2:8,13 quickly 63:2 24:3 recordings 16:19 require 14:16 60:23 62:19 rigorous 2:14 3:21 85:22 recall 61:23 19:20 remainder 19:17 21:12 resource 17:17 4:19 5:23 Quinones-S...

Council President Clarke

receipts Recreation 37:4 66:3 66:18,18 ripe 36:12 8:2 10:3 1:17 6:19 34:24 35:7 29:7 31:17 remaining required 13:5 67:19 rodeo 76:6 12:4 14:14 22:22 56:12 received 38:7,10,18 36:22 57:8 respect 75:9 roll 2:1,21 14:23 17:4 quorum 7:20 22:18 Redevelop... remember requirement respectfully 3:1 4:1 5:1 17:14 19:16 recess 33:16 10:5 20:13 2:22 62:6 13:7 57:10 9:24 30:11 6:1 7:1 19:19 20:11 R Reclaim 54:13,20 remind 82:16 requires 2:5 39:6 rolled 15:13 27:2,17,20 raising 35:5 72:14,16 reference reminder 68:8 response 5:6 root 82:6,13 28:3 33:13 ran 83:19 73:23 35:14 71:16 11:20 reserving 6:10 9:3 RPR-Notary 34:1 35:1 rapidly 44:12 recognition referral remote 2:7 11:9 18:19 28:20,23 90:16 36:1 37:1 Rarely 36:13 45:11 79:10 2:11 12:2 reside 35:16 31:10,19,23 rubber 14:18 37:23 54:11 reach 25:20 recognize referred remotely residences 40:8 42:14 15:17 58:21,24 31:25 46:7 17:8 38:5 11:25 12:24 2:10 34:18 47:3 48:8 Rule 71:21 59:22 69:19 read 9:19 61:19 63:9 13:15 18:10 renaming Residential 51:12 52:22 72:4 75:3,4,5 12:8 20:7 65:23 88:10 19:3 20:8 38:20,25 21:9 54:5 55:17 rules 24:2 83:20 90:16 29:23 38:15 recognized 21:21 26:18 rent 34:9,22 residents 56:23 59:17 28:19 29:18 published 41:14 42:19 14:6 40:15 27:14 30:4 34:23 35:7 15:2,25 60:18 89:6 30:3,20 2:15 47:7 48:12 61:9 38:19 39:2 35:15 17:9 23:2 responsibili... 31:2 32:14 pull 25:23 49:18 50:14 recognizes reflect 50:10 reopening 24:21 25:14 85:15 39:13,16,23 punitive 78:5 51:16 53:2 8:12 9:9 58:11 69:6 41:16 resolution responsible running purchasers 55:21 71:22 22:4 25:6 69:9 71:8 Rep 84:13 10:2,11 24:3 80:24 21:13 72:2 28:18 29:5 reform 79:2 repair 35:5 13:2,3 19:6 result 78:8 Stated Meeting October 8, 2020 S 60:13 88:19 shadows 24:5 24:11 74:1 75:1 32:1 33:1 strategies 74:4,8 79:6 S 1:13 88:22 Shahid 10:12 soliciting 76:1 77:1 34:1 35:1 53:11 79:11 80:5 safe 18:4 Section 10:15 shake 83:25 25:14,25 78:1 79:1 36:1 37:1 street 10:22 85:24 86:15 35:19 36:25 12:12 shared 16:12 Solicitor 80:1 81:1 38:1 39:1 10:23 11:7 86:22 37:4,7 sector 43:18 24:2 69:16 82:1 83:1 40:1 41:1 12:19 15:13 supported 63:24 66:23 44:20 45:7 shed 24:6 solution 66:5 84:1 85:1 42:1 43:1 18:18 19:24 71:19 safer 76:2 sectors 44:5 shocked 81:14 86:1 87:1 44:1,8 45:1 20:5 30:10 supporting safety 14:14 secure 36:24 72:14 solutions 88:8 46:1 47:1 36:3,5 71:17 79:21 14:23 17:15 securing 37:3 shooting 80:4 67:8 spend 78:19 48:1 49:1 69:18 75:11 supportive 75:3,4,5 see 15:9 shot 15:16 somebody spoke 36:9 50:1 51:1 75:12 81:5 64:16 77:23 salute 76:13 23:11,23 35:21,23 86:2 sponsors 52:1 53:1 Street,' 12:20 83:14 76:14 24:18 25:12 show 15:10 somebody's 77:17 54:1 55:1 streets 15:8 supports SANCHEZ 65:17,21 shows 76:16 86:4 spray 15:14 56:1 57:1 39:4 76:2 72:17 6:20 84:9 side 79:4 someone's Squilla 1:17 58:1 59:1 81:8 supposed sanitation seek 37:5 sidewalk 23:21 7:2,3 8:12 60:1 61:1 stricken 34:22 63:14,22 seen 23:9 19:24 somewhat 8:13 22:21 62:1 63:1 11:12 18:23 Supreme sanitizer 25:11 44:25 significant 72:14 55:4,5 64:1 65:1 striking 48:16 63:18 86:24 44:25 son 70:7 77:19 66:1 67:1 10:20 11:4 sure 2:23 sat 35:24 selected signify 49:8 son's 68:23 staff 62:25 68:1 69:1 12:17 18:15 18:3 23:24 save 76:20 45:11 61:8 sons 78:13 65:12 70:1 71:1 stuff 45:20 61:23 63:24 saying 8:23 self-govern... signs 23:10 sorry 13:19 staffs 62:17 72:1 73:1 Subcommit... 69:25 78:23 32:5 42:10 75:23 silence 8:5,6 21:25 39:13 stain 35:10 74:1 75:1 78:10 79:5,7 49:8 55:12 sell 23:7,22 silent 7:25 sort 83:25 stairway 20:4 76:1 77:1 submit 9:25 85:14 86:22 83:8 88:25 25:15,16,25 simple 10:6 South 19:24 stand 87:21 78:1 79:1 17:16 87:7 says 76:21 26:6 20:14 54:14 20:5 87:2 88:16,22 80:1 81:1 submitted surprised scale 15:11 selling 81:4 54:22 southwest standards 82:1 83:1 16:24 72:16 School 26:23 Senate 48:18 simulators 11:7 18:17 24:2,13,22 84:1 85:1 submitting suspended 27:18 58:23 84:13 44:24 southwestw...