civus
Minutes

Stated Meeting, May 11, 2017

Philadelphia City CouncilMay 11, 2017

Properties mentioned in this record

Addresses spoken or written in this record, resolved to their property pages. Mentions with a timestamp jump to the exact moment.

Legislation acted on in this session

From the City of Philadelphia’s legislative record (Legistar). Each file links to its status, roll call, and official documents.

  • Bill 160680READ AND PASSED

    To amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Jackson Street, Broad Street, the Schuylkill Ex…

  • Bill 161108READ AND PASSED

    Amending Chapter 11-600 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Construction, Encroachments and Projections Over, On and Under Streets," to provide additional requirements in connectio…

  • Bill 170002READ AND PASSED

    Authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 269 by relocating the easterly houseline of University Avenue, from a point approximately five-hundred fo…

  • Bill 170015READ AND PASSED

    Amending Section 19-1703 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Refunds," regarding credits and due dates, all under certain terms and conditions.

  • Bill 170016READ AND PASSED

    Amending Title 19 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Finance, Taxes and Collections," to include transfers between stepparents and stepchildren as a transaction excluded from the…

  • Bill 170086READ AND PASSED

    Authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 269 by relocating portions of the houselines and curblines of Convention Avenue, from Thirty-Fourth Stree…

  • Bill 170140-AREAD AND PASSED

    To amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Girard Avenue, 9th Street, Brown Street, 8th St…

  • Bill 170194READ AND PASSED

    To amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by 29th Street, Sedgley Avenue, Ridge Avenue, and…

  • Bill 170201READ AND PASSED

    Amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Zoning and Planning," by amending Section 14-905, entitled "Non Accessory Signs," by authorizing the Director of Finance to cr…

  • Bill 170203READ AND PASSED

    Authorizing the installation of all-way stop signs at the intersection of 57th Street and Wyalusing Avenue.

  • Bill 170205READ AND PASSED

    Amending Section 10-1000 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Fees," to exempt the Land Bank from paying City recording fees in connection with property it acquires; amending Chapte…

  • Bill 170264READ AND PASSED

    Authorizing Owen Kamihira, ("Owner") of Bar Fred LLC, to install, own and maintain an open-air sidewalk café at 1040 North 2nd Street, Philadelphia, PA 19123 ("Property"), under ce…

+40 more substantive items

People mentioned

Names our system found in this transcript. Automatically extracted, so it can include anyone named in the record, not only officials or parties.

Organizations mentioned

Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 COUNCIL OF THE CITY OF PHILADELPHIA STATED MEETING Room 400, City Hall Philadelphia, Pennsylvania Thursday, May 11, 2017 10:46 a.m. PRESENT: COUNCIL PRESIDENT DARRELL L. CLARKE COUNCILWOMAN CINDY BASS COUNCILWOMAN JANNIE L. BLACKWELL COUNCILMAN ALLAN DOMB COUNCILMAN DEREK S. GREEN COUNCILMAN WILLIAM K. GREENLEE COUNCILWOMAN HELEN GYM COUNCILMAN BOBBY HENON COUNCILMAN CURTIS JONES, JR. COUNCILMAN KENYATTA JOHNSON COUNCILMAN DAVID OH COUNCILMAN BRIAN J. O'NEILL COUNCILWOMAN CHERELLE L. PARKER COUNCILWOMAN MARIA D. QUINONES-SANCHEZ COUNCILWOMAN BLONDELL REYNOLDS BROWN COUNCILMAN MARK SQUILLA COUNCILMAN AL TAUBENBERGER MICHAEL A. DECKER, CHIEF CLERK Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Council President Clarke

Morning. Going to get started. The visitors will retire behind the rail. Ask the Members to take their seats. We are going to -- we're going to get started. And thank you for your cooperation. To give our invocation this morning, the Chair recognizes Clerk Joseph Howenstein of the Frankford Monthly Meeting of the Religious Society of Friends. He is here today as the guest of Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez. I would ask that all Members and guests and visitors to please rise. (Councilmembers and guests rise.) CLERK HOWENSTEIN: Thank you, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

You're welcome. CLERK HOWENSTEIN: And I want to thank also my Councilwoman Maria Quinones-Sanchez for the invitation to come and provide this invocation. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 I'm going to speak briefly for about 45 seconds, and then the invocation will be a moment of silent worship that will be about two minutes, a little bit longer than most people are used to being in silence. Quakers are the religion that founded Philadelphia. And our form of relation -of worship always includes some element of silence. And what we do in the silence is we focus on the light of God that exists in each and every one of us and that exists in everyone else. And what that lets us know is that we have a piece of God's truth each individually, and we need to recognize that everyone else also has an element of the truth in them. When we start meetings for business like this, we do take time about two minutes, again, for silent worship. And so, that's what I'm going to do. And one little trick I will give -- and Quakers do have tricks. One little trick I'll give is that in meetings for business for worship, we often think and try to listen and hear the voices Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 of those who are in the meeting with us. And it often, for me, helps me to listen and hear what that person is saying even and almost especially when I don't agree with them. So with that said, I'm going to settle down. We will sit -- everyone can sit for two minutes in silent worship. I will break worship by shaking hands with President Clarke. (Two-minute silent worship.) (Clerk shakes hands with President Clarke.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you so much for those inspiring thoughts. Council be at ease. (Council at ease.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you all. The next order of business is the Approval of the Journal of the meeting on Thursday, May 4, 2017. And the Chair recognizes Greenlee.

Councilman Greenlee

Thank you, Mr. President. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 I move that the Journal of the Meeting of Thursday, May 4, 2017 be approved. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It's been moved and properly seconded that the Journal of the meeting on Thursday, May 4, 2017 stand approved. All those in favor, say aye. (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And the Journal is approved. The next order of business is request for leave of absence. And the Chair recognizes Councilman Henon.

Councilman Henon

Thank you, Mr. President. On behalf of the Majority, there are no requests of leaves of absence today.

Council President Clarke

Chair thanks the gentleman. Chair now recognizes Councilman O'Neill. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Councilman O'Neill

Thank you, Mr. President. On behalf of the Republicans, there are no requests for leave of absence.

Council President Clarke

Chair thanks the gentleman. At this time, I would like to dispense with the regular order of business, and I would like to thank everyone who has taken time out of their busy day to come down and witness their government in action. We really appreciate the fact that you are here. And we also hope that you have a knowledgeable day. But more importantly, we hope that you have a pleasurable day so much so that you come back again. So again, thank you so much for being here. At this time -- folks, I am going to have to ask you all to like -- it's a lot of talking going on. Thank you. At this time, the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell to present a resolution on behalf -- on my behalf, Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Honoring Julia R. Masterman School Students. Would Brett Mandel and those accompanying -hey you guys -- would those accompanying him please join the Councilwoman at the podium. (Councilmembers and guests approach podium.)

Council President Clarke

There they go. And joining the Councilwoman we have Councilman Greenlee and Councilman Johnson and Councilman Squilla.

Councilwoman Blackwell

Thank you, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you.

Councilwoman Blackwell

It is with great pride that we present this resolution on your behalf. Resolution honoring, congratulating and recognizing Julia R. Masterman School students for being crowned World Famous Finalists in the Odyssey of the Mind International Competition. Whereas, Odyssey of the Mind is an international creativity competition that synthesizes science, technology, engineering and the arts; and whereas, Odyssey of the Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Mind has been encouraging students around the world to "think outside the box" and work together as a team to solve challenging problems since 1978; and

Councilman Squilla

Whereas, Julia R. Masterman School Odyssey of the Mind Division I team consisting of Emma Chrizmer -- Chrismer, Havana Covington, Az. (Students: Azalea)

Councilman Squilla

Azaleah Derrickson. (Students: Azalea)

Councilman Squilla

Azaleah? (Students: Azalea)

Councilman Squilla

Azalea. (Students: Yes.)

Councilman Squilla

All right. Michael Fenerty, Amelia Hoffman, Sidney Mandel, Lancelan -(Students: Lachlan)

Councilman Squilla

Lachlan Pepersack. (Laughter)

Councilman Squilla

Is that right, Pepersack? (Students: Yes.) Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Councilman Squilla

All right. All in 5th grade and coached by Chris Hoffman and Brett Mandel won second place overall. First place in spontaneous problem solving at the Pennsylvania State Finals Tournament on April 1, 2017; and. Whereas, the Division I teams winning performance consisted of famous ghosts trying to avoid the Ghostbusters by traveling in a hovercraft taxi, a battery magnet shuttle that traveled through a coiled copper wire, and a fan-powered car; and

Councilman Johnson

Whereas, the Julia R. Masterman School's Odyssey of the Mind Division II team, consisting of Drew Brown in the 8th grade, William -- Willem Cousineau in the 8th grade, Abiona Flora in the 8th grade, Samuel -(Students: Njiru)

Councilman Johnson

Njiru, 7th grade; Julia Powers, 6th grade; Rory McDonald, 8th grade and Ariel Weinbaum, 8th grade and coached by Chris Powers, a Powel Elementary Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 School teacher and the one and only Brett Mandel won Second Place in addition to the Renatra Fusca Award -(Students: Ranatra Fusca)

Councilman Johnson

Ranatra Fusca Award for Ultimate Creativity at the Pennsylvania State Finals Tournament on April 12, 2017; and Whereas, the Division II team competed in the "Catch Us If You Can" problem solving problem by creating vehicles that travel from a multi-level parking garage to a secret meeting place while also performing and acting to avoid being followed; and

Councilman Greenlee

Whereas, the Division II Team won their Ranantra Fusca -(Students: Ranatra Fusca.)

Councilman Greenlee

You know what, come on up here with me and help me out, will you please. (Laughter)

Councilman Greenlee

For Ultimate Creativity, the highest award in Odyssey by creating a performance about the inner Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 working of the human body that included a train-of-thought fan car, a blood-vessel boat that traveled in a blood stream -really -- and a walking neuron; and Whereas, the Julia R. Masterman School, the Philadelphia Public School, will for the fourth straight year compete in the Odyssey of the Mind World Finals. Approximately, 6,000 students from across the United States and around the world will represent the best of young creative minds and compete at Michigan State University in East Lansing on May 24, 2017 through May 17, 2017; and

Councilwoman Blackwell

Now therefore be it resolved, that the Council of the City of Philadelphia does hereby honor, congratulate and recognize the Julia R. Masterman School's Odyssey of the Mind Team on their success in the state competition, and wish them success in the World Finals competition; and Further, be it resolved that an engrossed copy of this resolution be presented to the Julia R. Masterman School's Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Odyssey of the Mind Team as evidence of the sincere sentiments of our legislative body. And certainly, this is a sign it was introduced by President Clarke, agreed to and signed and cosponsorred by all Members of Council. (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

And the Chair recognizes Mr. Mandel.

Councilwoman Blackwell

Our friend.

Mr. Mandel

Thank you so, so much for this honor, Mr. President. And seems like there are fewer people worthy of that title every day in the country. But, Mr. President, thank you so, so much for having us. It's an incredible little streak that we have been on. With apologies to Walt Whitman, the school that is great, is the one with the great students. The best part about this run has been watching all of the well-funded and well-healed suburban private and public school standing and cheering for our students as they beat them year after year. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 It is a wonderful trip. It is a wonderful program. I am thrilled to have been a participant honored by this Council when I was but a kid in school. These guys are going to have a great time. And it is wonderful that you guys have been our good luck charm sending us off each time. Hear from the students very briefly what they like the most about this program. AMELIA HOFFMAN: Thank you. I really love Odyssey of the Mind. It's one of my favorite programs to do. But my most favorite part about it is thinking outside the box and being creative and really getting to show things that we wouldn't usually do in the 5th grade. So, I really love that.

Mr. Mandel

That was Amelia Hoffman. Say your name before you speak. (Applause.) SIDNEY MANDEL: My name is Sidney Mandel. And my favorite part of Odyssey of the Mind World Finals is getting to trade pins with people from all over the world and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 get to meet them and watching him get all emotional. That was fun. We all love that. ARIEL WEINBAUM: My name is Ariel Weinbaum. My favorite part of Odyssey of the Mind World Finals is meeting new people from all around the world and creating friendships that last me a lifetime. STUDENTS: My name is Drew Brown. My favorite part of Odyssey of the Mind is getting to see the different creations and being inspired and amazed by what other teams and kids have done; however. STUDENTS: We can't get to Worlds Finals in Michigan without "your help." (Applause.) STUDENT: We have a Go Fund Me Page. I don't know exactly what the link is.

Mr. Mandel

The Council President will chair the link, I'm sure. STUDENT: Yeah. So, we have a Go Fund Me page. If you'd like to donate, you can also you can write checks out to Masterman HSA if you would like to help us. Thank you. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Council will be at ease. (Council at ease.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Thank you. At this time, the Chair recognizes Councilman Henon who will present a resolution honoring Father Judge High School Students, Jack Flynn and Dylan Feby. Would Jack Flynn and Dylan Feby, Ed Harrington and those companying him, please, join the Councilman at the podium. And we also have Councilman Greenlee, Councilman Domb, Councilwoman Gym and Councilman Taubenberger and Councilman Green. (Councilmembers and guests approach the podium.)

Councilman Henon

Well, good evening -good morning, everybody. And before we start with the presentation and the folks are joining us here, I have to tell you this is a -- an impressive story that deserves the accolations and the recognition that it Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 deserves. You know, you will hear in the resolution the story behind why we are here and why we are honoring these two young men. You have a freshman and a senior who acted instinctively, instinctively where most people would just walk by. And you see on some of these reality TV shows and some of these prank shows where you have, you know, the setups for response of people. And normally, people ignore situations. These two young men saved a person's life by instinctively jumping in while the rest of the bus that they were on sat there, while people out front walking the street kept walking by. And it is quite remarkable that these kids who were -- get up, go to school doing their normal routine, go to catch a bus, SEPTA bus, public transportation to go home. And an individual who attempted suicide who, you know, obviously, had some -- some deep issues that they were dealing with or could not deal with ran into the bus. Ran into the bus. These two kids were on the bus and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 they were off the bus as quick as he hit the bus. And you know, the measures that they took without having any knowledge of being a paramedic, an EMT or CPR, all right, they quickly took off the clothes that they were wearing off of their sweater and applied the tourniquet on the laceration on the neck. And noticed the scene as they were -- in seconds. Noticed that there were wrist lacerations and a neck laceration bleeding profusely. And they were told upon the arrival from our emergency medical responders that if it wasn't for their quick actions, as quick as they did and the actions that they took to stop the bleeding to keep the man alive and coherent until the medics responded, that gentleman would not be here with us today. So, it is an amazing, an amazing, amazing story. So today, we are honoring Father Judge High School students Jack Flynn and Dylan Feby for their heroic actions on February 7, Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 2017.

Councilman Greenlee

Whereas, rooted in the spirituality of their patron, St. Francis de Sales, Father Judge High School educates the whole young man, spiritually, intellectually, physically, emotionally and socially in the Catholic tradition; and Whereas, the motto of Father Judge High School is educating the minds and souls of their students in the spirit of the gentleman saint, St. Francis de Sales; and

Councilman Taubenberger

Whereas, on Thursday, February 7, 2017, never were these qualities more evident as Senior Jack Flynn and Freshman Dylan Feby, both students at Judge, began what was and what is normally a routine journey from home from -- to school on their usual SEPTA Route 20 bus; and Whereas, the bus was en route when an unidentified male was spotted running towards the moving bus in an attempt to be deliberately hit; and

Councilman Green

Whereas, the man bounced off the bus and fell to the ground. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 The bus door was open and Jack noticed the man was bleeding from his neck and wrist in an apparent suicide attempt; and Whereas, Jack and Dylan sprang into action using their Judge sweaters to stop the bleeding from the man's neck and wrist, and waited for him until the ambulance arrived; and Whereas, paramedics reached the scene and were very appreciative of the boy's actions in saving and assisting this man's life; and

Councilman Domb

Jack Flynn will be getting ready to graduate in June and is planning to join the United States Navy soon thereafter. It's Jack's dream to follow in his father's footsteps and become a Philadelphia Firefighter. Jack is proud to be a member of the Father Judge ice hockey team and lives with his parents and younger brother; and

Councilwoman Gym

Whereas, Dylan Feby is currently a Freshman at Judge and enjoys playing basketball. Dylan is also Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 interested in astronomy. It is his hope to continue his education after graduating from Judge and major in engineering. He resides with his mother and stepfather, and enjoys hanging out with his father and two younger sisters; and now therefore

Councilman Henon

Therefore, be it resolved by the Council of the City of Philadelphia that we hereby honor and congratulate Father Judge High School students Jack Flynn and Dylan Feby for their heroic actions on February 7, 2017. Resolved further, that an engrossed copy of this resolution be presented to Jack and Dylan further evidencing the grateful appreciation and deep admiration of this legislative body. And I also want to add in closing that, you know, I want to thank the parents of these two young gentleman who have an incredible future, all right, to have instincts like that. They are good people. Good people do good things, and great people who come from good families and have the Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 opportunity to be part of the community. You know, you should be honor -- honored of their heroic actions. Should be honored as fine young men. And to the school Father Judge, I happen to be a product of albeit to St. Francis de Sales. And I have to tell you, Father Judge does a wonderful job in making sure that family and community come together, all right, for the service of good and for all good men and women. So, you should all be proud. And I want to thank you all and congratulations to you. (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

And the -and the Chair recognizes Mr. Harrington for remarks.

Mr. Harrington

Good morning.

Council President Clarke

Morning.

Mr. Harrington

It goes without saying how proud we are, Father Judge, on behalf of the Administration of these two young men. In the world today where a lot of young people kind of maybe get a bad rap or they Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 have their ear buds in on their cell phones, here is two young men that didn't think. They simply saw something happen to them visual, and they just sprang into action. And when they told me the story, I saw the pictures, I was just blown away. Their character development in school, we pride ourselves in character development. Started a long time ago with their parents. The Northeast Philadelphia neighborhoods they grew up in, these are great kids and they have bright futures. And we are so proud of them. And thank you. (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Council be at ease. (Council at ease.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much young men. At this time -- where is the Councilman? Chair again recognizes Councilman Henon who will present a resolution honoring the Community Life Improvement Program, also Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 known as CLIP. Would Tom Conway and those accompanying him please join the Councilman at the podium. (Applause.) (Councilmembers and guests approach the podium.)

Councilman Henon

I hope not everybody has a camera that's coming up here. We do have work today. Well, again, thank you everybody. Welcome CLIP, CLIP Team. Let's hear it for the CLIP team. (Applause.)

Councilman Henon

We are here to celebrate the 15th Year Anniversary of CLIP right here in the Chambers. And for those who have been around, understand and know what went into the creation of CLIP. I see Councilwoman Blackwell and I know Council President Clarke were all a part of it. And Councilman O'Neill were around at the time. CLIP was a -- in conjunction with the creation of the neighborhood Mayor Streets Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Neighborhood Transformation Initiative. And that initiative was bold. It was strong. We still have remnants of that programs and different names today that is -- you know, Council President Clarke and I laugh at times when we see new programs. But there are not actually new programs, are they Council President.

Council President Clarke

Not actually.

Councilman Henon

They were created at one time and have evolved. But the creation of CLIP, which I am proud of and we all should be proud of, originated and started as a pilot in the 6th Councilman District with my predecessor Joan Krajewski. Who -one thing I was taught through her and through other members of this body is we may not all agree on everything, all right, but we agree that, you know, we can fight for the quality of life and the issues, all right, of the District and the people that we represent. And Joan Krajewski did just that. And the creation of CLIP started, and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 the creation of accolades to Tom Conway during every budget hearing, you know, since then has been outstanding. And I remember CLIP going out and doing graffiti and was happy to have as a Committee person and a community organizer in my neighborhood as a young man. I remember, you know, using the tools that they have which started with -- with graffiti. Blight. Destroying our neighborhoods. And now we have a program that is citywide, and there is not one Councilmember, there is not one citizen of the City of Philadelphia who has not benefitted from CLIP. Over a million properties that have been -- had graffiti removed from it; 200,000 vacant lots; three -- 30,000 exteriors of properties that are now in compliance with 69 percent or above with property maintenance. That is all the quality of life issues that we deal with on a daily basis. And CLIP and its team and everybody up here and those who are not up Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 here who are out there remediating, out there who are cleaning up and working, all right, because, you know, the City must move on and they are working and they are doing a fantastic job. They are all a part of that. One thing that I did when I was first elected, I took a little picture from Undercover Boss that you see on TV. I did Undercover Councilman. And I passed by this one house where -- on Welsh Road that I did. And I think they actually probably were just out there recently because it was -- it's cut down. So, I did an undercover with CLIP. And they had me weed whacking. And they had me mowing the lawn. They had me pulling little trees out and bagging and everything like that. I think they hazed me. I think that was my initiation thing. But they do a great job and deserve all the credit, all the credit for expanding its program citywide, making sure that we get the best quality of life that we deserve. Tom, he's up here wearing a peach shirt. And his top, his button is buttoned. So Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 without further ado, all right, I want to thank you, Tom, for growing with this and managing the program here now as we honor the Community of Life Program of the occasion of the 15th Year Anniversary. Whereas, CLIP, Community of Life Program, was created April 2, 2002 in conjunction with Mayor John Streets Neighborhood Transformation Initiative by long time Councilmember Joan Krajewski.

Councilman Squilla

Whereas, originally designed to address quality of life issues in the 6th Councilmanic District, CLIP now can be found on a Citywide level. The Community Life Improvement Program consists of several programs dedicated to improving the appearance of neighborhoods throughout the City of Philadelphia through the eradication of blight. Last year, CLIP cleaned over 15,000 vacant lots and 3,000 exteriors of properties. These programs are designed to maximize effectiveness and efficiency by inspecting and abating entire blocks; and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Whereas, CLIP encourages business and residents of the City of Philadelphia to get involved in their neighborhood and partner with CLIP programs to make a difference. Their Community Partnership Program, CPP assisted over 500 organizations last year and has supplied resources available for neighborhood cleanups to foster sustainable communities; and

Councilman O'Neill

Whereas, CLIP's Graffiti Abatement Teams and rapid response teams dedicated to the quick removal of graffiti, vandalism and has been in existence for over 20 years. Tom started that in Mayor Rendell's second term, 24 hours then. A little different when we were working with the Police. But still, part of CLIP is why it works so well. This division of CLIP has been working with community organizations and business associations since 1996 removing graffiti vandalism from over 1 million properties; and Whereas, CLIP truly appreciates those Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 groups that have partnered with the program and wishes to recognize the efforts and remarkable results that have come through these partnerships. Only through the combined efforts of community organizations, business associations, elected officials, city, state and federal agencies working together can the quality of life truly improve in neighborhoods throughout the City; now therefore

Councilman Henon

Therefore be it resolved that the Council of the City of Philadelphia hereby honor and commend the quality -- Community Life Improvement Program on the occasion of their 15th Year Anniversary. Resolve further, that an engrossed copy of this resolution be presented to the representatives of CLIP as further evidence of their sincere, respect and admiration of this legislative body. And you know, one thing that you learn along the way that when you only have X-amount of years in Council and others have Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 tenure, you get taught a little lesson that it doesn't just start in the 6th District. It was companioned with the 10th District. And I'm sure Brian O'Neill was one of the founders leveraging and champion for the district of the 10th Councilmanic District along with Joan Krajewski and the Mayor to make sure that Northeast was represented in ways that it wasn't before continuing to address the quality of life issues. So, thank you all. And thank you, Brian. (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

And Chair recognizes Tom Conway for remarks.

Mr. Conway

Thank you, Mr. President, Members of City Council for this resolution. Honored of the team at CLIP. I would also like to thank you for being so supportive of CLIP over the last 15 years. Thanks to you and Mayor Kenney, CLIP received additional funding last year to continue our mission of working with businesses and residents in cleaning up Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Philadelphia. I believe standing here with you today are some of the hardest work in public servants in this City's history, employees that truly care about making a difference, not just in our great city but also in society. Is not just a job, it has become a mission to be the most effective, efficient and caring agency in City government. And I believe we are on our way to succeeding. Our biggest accomplishments -- although Councilman Henon mentioned what we have accomplished over the last 15 years. Our biggest accomplishment is our ability to change people's lives by giving people a second chance. CLIP has a very robust hiring practice where we hire people reentering society to work for CLIP. I am extremely proud of this accomplishment and the diversity of our workforce as we truly represent the City and are up there as one of the most diversified organizations in the City. I would like to thank my employees for Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 their dedication, loyalty and commitment and improving the lives and quality of life of Philadelphians across this great city. Those standing here with me today have over ten years of experience working for CLIP. None of this could have been accomplished if it were not for the two old school politicians -- well three: Mayor John Street and the late Councilman Krajewski and Brian O'Neill -- not the late Brian O'Neill. Mayor Streets' Neighborhood trans -(Laughter)

Mr. Conway

Mayor Streets' Neighborhood Transformation Initiative was the right fit at the right time. His vision of transforming neighborhoods lives to this day through CLIP. He wanted to ensure that all Philadelphian neighborhoods received a lasting piece of the NTI Program. And he succeeded. The Councilwoman's unwavering support of this enforcement education arm of the program allowed us to build the foundation to succeed early on. Again, I would like to thank City Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Council, Mayor Kenney and CLIP employees for their strong effort in cleaning up Philadelphia and improving the quality of life on a daily basis in a very meaningful way. Thank you. (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

Council will be at ease. (Council at ease.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much. Thank you. The next order of business is Communications. And the Chair requests that the Sergeant of Arms delivers the messages from the Mayor to the Chief Clerk. (Mayors messages delivered.)

Council President Clarke

And, Mr. Decker, if you will please read those messages.

Chief Clerk

To the President and Members of the Council of the City of Philadelphia, I am pleased to advise you that on May 8, 2017, I signed all the bills Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 which were passed by Council at its session on April 27, 2017. And that on May 5, 2017, I signed the following bill, which was passed by Council at its session on May 4, 2017: Bill No. 170168. And I am submitting herewith for the consideration of your Honorable Body, a resolution authorizing the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority to dispose of certain properties located in the 7th Councilmanic District. They will be transferred by the City to the Authority by conveyance of such properties to the Philadelphia Land Bank. And an ordinance authorizing the Parks and Recreation Commissioner and the Procurement Commissioner on behalf of the City to execute a concession agreement with Tree Top Quest or its wholly owned subsidiary for an aerial adventure park in West Fairmount Park, all under certain terms and conditions.

Council President Clarke

Do you have any additional communications, Mr. Decker? Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Chief Clerk

I have none, Mr. Clerk.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much. And the next order of business is introduction of bills and resolutions. And the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Good morning, I offer one resolution this morning.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilwoman.

Chief Clerk

A privileged resolution recognizing the month of May as National Foster Care Month in the City of Philadelphia.

Council President Clarke

And that will be on this week's Final Passage Calendar. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell.

Councilwoman Blackwell

Thank you, Mr. President. I have one bill and one resolution. I would like to be recognized on the resolution, if possible.

Council President Clarke

After the Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 reading of the resolution, all right. Thank you, Councilwoman.

Councilwoman Blackwell

Thank you.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance authorizing Route 34 Group to install, own and maintain an open-air sidewalk cafe at 5021-23 Baltimore Avenue.

Council President Clarke

Refer to Committee.

Chief Clerk

And a privileged resolution hereby recognizing May 18, 2017 as Haitian Flag Day in Philadelphia.

Council President Clarke

And Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell.

Councilwoman Blackwell

Thank you, Mr. President. This bill is cosponsored by Helen Gym, Allan Domb, Cherelle Parker, Mark Squilla and Derek Green. And let me say, I was pleased to receive it. It was written by Steve Paul who works for Councilwoman Gym and who was Haitian born. Been here since he was a little boy, around six or seven. And he's been to our meetings. And we are Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 very -- and we are very proud of his commitment and interest. As many of you know, Haiti was the first independent Black country in the world who successfully fought French -- the French colonizations. We are very proud that we will be joining them next week in flag raising and being involved in many activities in addition to that. I know that Councilwoman Gym wants to speak, as well.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gym.

Councilwoman Gym

Thank you very much, Council President. Thank you so much to Councilwoman Blackwell for her amazing partnership on a host of issues, especially impacting our African and Carribean immigrant nations. In these times as we face the rise of a reactionary and regressive administration that often seeks to turn the clock back on hard-won freedoms. This resolution about the Haitian revolution and Haiti's legacy of Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 revolutionary struggle for a just and equal society is an example for all of us today. The Haitian Revolution was one of most influential uprisings in the Western hemisphere. It sparked slave revolts throughout the Carribean, which forced the eventual end of slavery in the British and French-occupied territories. And additionally, it inspired the three major slave revolts in the United States of America. The African heroes in Hispaniola fought for human rights, liberty, equality and fraternity and went on to establish the first free Black republic in the world, the Republic of Haiti. The first independent nation in Latin America and the first nation to renounce slavery. We must never forget Haiti. We must never forget Haiti's history, its legacy. We must celebrate and hold Haiti up in times like these. We need those historical lessons more than ever. Thank you so much, Councilwoman Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Blackwell.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Council Ladies. And that will be on this week's Final Passage Calendar. (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilman Greenlee.

Councilman Greenlee

Thank you, Mr. President. On your behalf I offer one bill.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance authorizing Boyd's Realty Partnership to install, own and maintain concrete planter encroachments at 1818 Chestnut Street.

Council President Clarke

That bill will be referred to Committee. And Chair recognizes Councilman Henon.

Councilman Henon

Thank you, Council President. Today I offer one bill and two resolutions.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Linden Avenue(extended), Academy Road, Grant Avenue, Frankford Avenue, the Poquessing Creek and the Delaware River.

Council President Clarke

Refer to Committee.

Chief Clerk

And a privileged resolution authorizing the Committee on Public Property and Public Works to hold public hearings on the status of implementation of the cable television franchise renewal agreement between the City of Philadelphia and Comcast of Philadelphia passed by this Council on December 10, 2015.

Council President Clarke

This week's calendar.

Chief Clerk

And a privileged resolution recognizing May 4, 2017 as International Firefighters Day in Philadelphia and further honoring the men and women of the Philadelphia Fire Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Department for their continual dedication and service to the City of Philadelphia.

Council President Clarke

This week's calendar. Chair recognizes Councilman Jones.

Councilman Jones

Thank you, Mr. President. I have two bills and two resolutions. The resolutions cosponsored by Parker, Oh, Brown, Bass, Johnson, Greenlee on both.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman.

Councilman Jones

And Oh.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance authorizing the Parks and Recreation Commissioner and the Procurement Commissioner, on behalf of the City, to execute a Concession Agreement with Treetop Quest, or its wholly-owned subsidiary, for an aerial adventure park in West Fairment Park.

Council President Clarke

Councilman, after Council, I want to ask you what that is. Refer to Committee. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Councilman Jones

Mr. President, I can show you better than tell you.

Council President Clarke

All right. Thank you. I will look forward to seeing that. Refer to committee.

Chief Clerk

And an Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Gates Street, Henry Avenue, Roxborough Avenue, Magdalena Street, Walnut Lane, Henry Avenue, Kingsley Street, Houghton Street, Walnut Lane, Shurs Lane, Tower Street, Levering Street, Silverwood Street, Leverington Avenue, Silverwood Street, Fountain Street and Ridge Avenue.

Council President Clarke

Refer to Committee.

Chief Clerk

And a privileged resolution recognizing and honoring Overbrook High School graduates, Joyce Eli Bevins and Jean Lu Bevins for their recognition by the Cannes Film Festival for Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 the short film "My Dear Arthur."

Council President Clarke

This week's calendar.

Chief Clerk

And a non-privileged resolution also naming the 5800 block of Race Street as Reverend Albert F. Campbell Way.

Council President Clarke

Next weeks' calendar. Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Councilman Johnson

Council President, I have one privileged resolution and one non-privileged resolution and one resolution regarding the renaming of Broad and Christian Street to Carpenter Street to "Boyz II Men Boulevard" as primarily sponsored by my good friend from South Philadelphia, Councilman Mark Squilla and signed by all Members of Council.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman.

Chief Clerk

A privileged resolution honoring Principal Joanne Beaver of Philadelphia High School for the Creative Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 and Performing Arts, a recipient of the 2017 Lindback Award which recognizes distinguished principal leadership.

Council President Clarke

This week's calendar.

Chief Clerk

And A non-privileged resolution also naming Broad Street from Christian Street to Carpenter Street, "Boys II Men Boulevard."

Council President Clarke

And that will be on next week's Final Passage Calendar. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Sanchez.

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez

Thank you, Council President. I have one privileged resolution, one non-privileged and two bills. And I wish to be recognized after the bill has been read.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilwoman.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance establishing a no truck parking regulation on both sides of the 4400-4500 block of Castor Avenue from Wyoming Avenue to E. Cayuga Street.

Council President Clarke

Refer to Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Committee.

Chief Clerk

And an Ordinance amending Title 2 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "City-County Consolidation," by amending the Chief Assessment Officer's authorization to set standards for the valuation of properties for taxation purposes.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez

Thank you, Mr. President. I recently attended a senior event. And I was talking to one of my beloved seniors who was very happy about the shopping mall that we are building on 3rd and Allegheny. She talked to me about how excited she was that she was going to have all of those amenities close to her. And then she asked me is it time for me to sell my property and move to a smaller apartment. And I said why? And she says, because these improvements mean my property taxes are going to go up, and I'm not going to be able to afford the house that I have lived Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 in with my children. This story, Council President, is one that all of us hear time and time again. I recently fixed the sidewalks of my own community of Norris Square in the park. And I got -- sent an email from folks that say Maria, why are you gentrifying my neighborhood, our neighborhood. And I responded that my seniors had actually asked me for those sidewalks because every Friday morning at ten o'clock they do their weekly walk. And in fact, always invite me and I don't get there often to do it with them. We face this every day. People are scared about new development. A couple of weeks ago when OPA was here, I asked Michael Piper over and over how do we ensure that people don't look at development as something that is going to tax them out of where they live. This Council, under your leadership, has been steadfast in their support of AVI, Homestead Exemptions, LOOP, property tax deferrals, our Senior Freeze. We have done just about everything we can to Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 reassure folks that we are building the City and that we really do value and want to protect our working poor. That is why today I introduce a bill to further protect long time homeowners from what could be perceived as artificially inflated tax bills by closing a critical loophole in the way the City is going to assess property values. I am fearful of what this new annual assessment is going to mean for communities like my own neighborhood of Norris Square and Old Kensington. This legislation will authorize the Office of Property Assessment to look at ways of valuing markets, particularly of properties on the ten-year tax abatement when computing neighborhood market values based on recent sales. This mechanism will ensure that both new and long time homeowners share the benefits of our tax relief programs. The sale or purchase of your neighbor's home should not increase your tax bill Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 simply because your new neighbor is entitled to the tax abatement. People deserve a tax bill that really represents the true value of their property, not an artificial value that may be created by our own development strategies. As we move forward toward annual assessments, we must look at ways to calculate values by each neighborhood, block by block, as precisely and as fairly as possible. I look forward to a very robust conversation with everyone in Council about what this potential bill could mean and the critical consequences that we hear all too often in neighborhood to neighborhood about people fearing new development and enhancements, their own community enhancements in their neighborhoods. For me, it hurts me because people believe that we are fixing our neighborhoods for the new ones to come. And I fight every day to convince them that -- and I apologize that it's taken us so long to fix their old neighborhood amenities in every neighborhood Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 for them, those folks who have believed and have raised their families in their neighborhoods. I look forward to the conversation with the Administration. And I ask any of my colleagues who are interested in discussing this with me to be part of a work group as we look at what this potentially can mean. I welcome their input and their advise. Thank you, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilwoman. And that bill will be referred to the appropriate committee.

Chief Clerk

And a privileged resolution recognizing, honoring and celebrating Sharon Lopez on being named the First Latina President of the Pennsylvania Bar Association.

Council President Clarke

This week's calendar.

Chief Clerk

And a non-privileged resolution authorizing the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority to dispose of certain properties located in the 7th Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Councilmanic District that will be transferred by the City to the Authority by conveyance of such properties to the Philadelphia Land Bank.

Council President Clarke

And that will be on next week's calendar. Chair recognizes Councilman Green.

Councilman Green

Thank you, Council President. I have one bill and one non-privileged resolution. Council President, I will request a suspension of the rules for this non-privileged resolution. This resolution replaces the resolution that's on the Final Passage Calendar for today. That would make a motion withdraw that resolution. Today's resolution is a technical change for the legislation that was introduced last week regarding the Tourism Improvement District.

Council President Clarke

Okay. You making a motion now for the suspension -

Councilman Green

Yes.

Council President Clarke

-- to allow today's ruling? Is there a second? Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

All those in favor? (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. That will be on this week's Final Passage Calendar.

Councilman Green

Thank you, Council President.

Council President Clarke

You're welcome.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance establishing a business improvement district encompassing certain existing and future hotel properties within the boundaries of the City of Philadelphia to be known as the Philadelphia Hospitality Improvement Levy District, designating the Philadelphia Hospitality Improvement Levy District Corporation to serve as the Neighborhood Improvement District Management Association for the Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 District.

Council President Clarke

And that will be referred to the appropriate committee.

Chief Clerk

And a non-privileged resolution initiating action to establish a business improvement district encompassing certain existing and future hotel properties within the boundaries of the City of Philadelphia to be known as the Philadelphia Hospitality Improvement Levy District.

Council President Clarke

And that will be on this week's Final Passage Calendar. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.

Councilwoman Parker

Thank you, Mr. President. I have one privileged resolution co-authored by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown, co-sponsored by Members Green, Bass and Taubenberger and supported by all Members of Council.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilwoman.

Chief Clerk

A privileged resolution recognizing and honoring the Members of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Incorporates its Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Quaker City Alumni Chapter Social Action Committee on the occasion of the 14th year of Delta Days at City Council.

Council President Clarke

This week's Final Passage Calendar. And the Chair recognizes Councilman Domb.

Councilman Domb

Morning, Council President.

Council President Clarke

Morning.

Councilman Domb

No bills or resolutions today.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gym.

Councilwoman Gym

Good morning, Council President.

Council President Clarke

Morning.

Councilwoman Gym

One non-privileged resolution co-sponsored by Councilmembers Reynolds Brown, Green, Bass Domb, Sanchez and Parker with gratitude.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilwoman. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Chief Clerk

A non-privileged resolution recognizing the critical role that guidance counselors and counselors play in meeting students' academic, social and emotional needs and urging the School District of Philadelphia to devote additional resources to expanding the number of counselors in high schools with the highest needs.

Council President Clarke

This week's calendar. And the chair recognizes Councilman Taubenberger.

Councilman Taubenberger

Good morning, Council President and Colleagues. I have no bills or resolutions this week.

Council President Clarke

I'm sorry, Councilman?

Councilman Taubenberger

I said good morning, Council President and Colleagues. I have no bills or resolutions this morning. Thank you.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 And the Chair recognizes Councilman O'Neill.

Councilman O'Neill

Thank you, Mr. President. I have no bills or resolutions.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.

Councilman Squilla

Thank you, Council President. I introduce eight bills today.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Front Street, the Delaware Expressway, Laurel Street, Canal Street and Poplar Street. And an Ordinance to amend Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Zoning and Planning," by revising certain provisions of Section 14-500, entitled "Overlay Zoning Districts," for the amendment of the North Delaware Neighborhood Commercial Overlay Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 District. And an Ordinance amending Title 3 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Air Management Code," by amending Chapter 3-200 thereof, entitled "Prohibited Conduct," to add a new section prohibiting the cutting of rubber tires by any person. And an Ordinance amending Section 14-702 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Floor Area and Height Bonuses," and Section 14-704 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Open Space and Natural Resources," by making technical changes relating to the CDO, Central Delaware River Front Overlay District. And an Ordinance authorizing 2732 Donna's Bar to install, own and maintain an open-air sidewalk cafe at 2732 E. Allegheny Avenue. And an Ordinance authorizing B1 Holdings to install, own and maintain an open-air sidewalk cafe at 767 South 9th Street. And an Ordinance authorizing 1338 Incorporated to install, own and maintain an Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 open-air sidewalk cafe at 1338-40 South 10th Street. And an Ordinance authorizing WT Restaurant Holdings to install, own and maintain an open-air sidewalk cafe at 743 South 4th Street.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Those eight bills just read by the Chief Clerk will be referred to the appropriate committees. And the Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.

Councilwoman Bass

Thank you, Mr. President. I offer one privileged resolution cosponsored by Councilmembers Gym, Quinones-Sanchez and Green.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilwoman.

Chief Clerk

A non-privileged resolution supporting House Bill 1302 which would prohibit Pennsylvania law enforcement agencies from using state resources to investigate, interrogate, detain or arrest people for immigration enforcement purposes. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Council President Clarke

And that will be on next week's Final Passage Calendar. Chair recognizes Councilman Oh.

Councilman Oh

Thank you, Council President. I offer no bills or resolutions.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. That concludes our introduction of bills and resolutions. We have no reports from Committee today. And the next order of business is consideration of the Calendar. Mr. Decker, would you please read the bills on the First Reading Calendar.

Chief Clerk

Bill No. 170306, entitled "An Ordinance to Reinstate Bill No. 140309" Amending Section 140-502 of the Zoning Code, entitled "CTR, Center City Overlay," and Section 14-602 of the Zoning Code, entitled "Used Tables," and to amend Section 14-803 Motor Vehicle Parking standards. And Bill No. 170289, entitled an Ordinance Amending Section 12-701 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Bicycle Lanes," Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 by authorizing the Department of Streets to designate bicycle lanes in both directions on American Street, from Jefferson Street, to Lehigh Avenue for the removal of a travel lane on American Street in the same limits, all under certain terms and conditions.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. The Chair agrees, these bills will be placed on our Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. Chair now recognizes Councilman Henon for a motion concerning the bills on the Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar.

Councilman Henon

Mr. President, is this for the Consent Agenda first or -thank you, Mr. President. I move that the Rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of the Consent Agenda to consider the following bills on the Second Reading of Final Passage Calendar. Bill Nos. 170140-A, 160680, 170149, 170201, 170265, 170310, 170331, 170333, Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 170015, 170016, 170308, 170329, 170330, 161108, 170002, 170086, 170203, 170264, 170281, 170283, 170284, 170286, 170292, 170305, 170311 and 170336. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. It's been moved and seconded that the Rules of Council be suspended to permit the use of the Consent Agenda to consider the bills just read by Councilman Henon. All those in favor say aye. (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it. The motion carries. And we will consider the Consent Agenda shortly. Chair again recognizes Councilman Henon for the purpose of calling on bills and resolution on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar.

Councilman Henon

Thank you, Mr. President. In addition to the bills Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 being considered on the Consent Agenda, the following resolution and bill are being called up for a Second Reading and Final Passage Calendars today. Bill Nos. 170443, 170449, 170335, 170205 and 170332. All other bills and resolutions are being held.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much. Before considering our calendar today, we will have our Public Comment session. The Public Comment session will go as follows. If you are interested in testifying on a bill or resolution that is on the Final Passage Calendar, if you have not already signed up, you may do that, the table to my left. When your name is called, you will go to the podium in the middle of the Council chambers. There is a device on that podium. When the light turns green on that device, it will be your time to speak. When the light turns yellow, you will have 30 seconds to conclude your remarks. When the light turns Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 red, we would ask that you please adhere to those guidelines established by Council and conclude your remarks. You will be given three minutes to testify. Thank you very much. Mr. Decker, can you please call the first name.

Chief Clerk

Stan Shapiro, commenting on 170330. (Approaches podium.)

Council President Clarke

Good morning.

Mr. Shapiro

Thank you, Council President, Members of Council. I'm Stan Shapiro. And I'm testifying today on behalf of Philadelphia Neighborhood Networks. We applaud Council for recognizing that the City must attach itself from serial abuser Wells Fargo, but there is no other mega bank that the City can morally substitute for it, certainly not Citizens Bank. In August 2015, three cooperating federal agencies ordered Citizens to pay tens of millions of dollars in restitution Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 and penalties for pocketing money from customers who made mistakes on their deposit slips. In a truly remarkable pattern of grand larceny, if a customer's deposit slip inadvertently understated the amount of their actual deposit, the bank would credit the customer with the mistaken amount and pocket the difference. And it did it over and over and over again. Just last month, the Citizens Bank affiliate was fined for overcharging charitable and retirement plan, mutual fund customers by failing to waive unallowable fees. And of course, just like Wells Fargo, Citizens is a funder of the notorious Dakota Access Pipeline. In addition, it's also a funder of the Mariner East Pipeline, which brings the dangers of breaks, spills and noxious emissions right into our region. Yes, moving the City's money or most of it to Citizens might be a small step up from keeping it at super-predator Wells Fargo. But ultimately, there is only one good way for the City to manage its money, and that's Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 to create its own bank modeled after the Bank of North Dakota. That bank created in 1919 and getting stronger and stronger as it approaches its 100th birthday holds all the funds of the State of North Dakota and then it reinvests them in the students, farmers, school districts, homeowners and small businesses of the state. When it lends to School Districts for construction or reconstruction of school buildings, it frees of tens of millions of dollars for districts to invest in teachers, supplies, equipment and all of the essentials that are in such short supply in our City. And when it invests in small businesses, it is investing in itself by growing the economy and tax ratables that then benefit the entire community through provision of robust services. It's time for the City to go 100 percent renewable energy to boost its stock of affordable housing to let every business have access to local financing to boost the coop sector of the economy to fix its Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 schools. It's time the City had a tool other than zero-sub tax incentives to lure established businesses to the City and to enable start up -- start ups. And it's high time that the City rid itself once and for all that the pernicious impacts of dealing with the Wall Street predators. Let's create the Public Bank of Philadelphia. (Applause.) (Councilwoman Reynolds Brown sitting in as Chair.)

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Thank you.

Chief Clerk

Kelly morton, commenting on 170330. (Approaches podium.)

Ms. Morton

Hi. My name is Kelly Morton. And I'm a member of Reclaim Philadelphia. We applaud the removal of the $2 billion from Wells Fargo Bank. However, we reject the perception that we are chained to big blanks like Wells Fargo and Citizens Bank because they are the only ones that can handle our large account. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 This perception leads us to tolerate criminal practices like those of Wells Fargo for far too long. Practices that have directly harmed Philadelphians, our School District, vulnerable and indigenous minority populations and the environment as others have pointed out here today. We ask City Council to join other progressive cities in exploring a public bank for Philadelphia. Our City faces financial threats from the Federal Government and the State Government over our status as a Sanctuary City. We also face constant threats of budget cuts from the State Legislature. In the face of these threats, the autonomy provided by a public bank is uniquely beneficial to our City. Beyond the initial economic boon of saving millions in fees every year, a public bank ould offer below market rate loans to projects that would foster real economic and community growth. Our City is full of innovators who have Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 real solutions to our problems. Beyond -rather than relying on a partnership program with a big bank who practices undermine its contributions, the City could invest directly in these initiatives via a public bank. The key points here are that a Philadelphia public bank could save the City millions in fees. And all of its revenue would be invested back into the City where it's needed and where we can directly see the results of our investment. Thank you. (Applause.)

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

You're welcome.

Chief Clerk

Susan Saxe, commenting on 170330. (Approaches podium.)

Ms. Saxe

My name is Susan Saxe. And I'm here today as a member of POWER, Philadelphia Organized to Witness, Empower and Rebuild. We're a grass roots organization that advocates for economic Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 environmental racial and social justice. And we are part of the coalition of organizations working toward a public municipal bank for the City of Philadelphia. We applaud the decision of the City to move its payroll business from Wells Fargo and want to thank Councilwoman Bass for taking the initiative to get this done. This is a step in the right direction. But all corporate banks engage in practices that hurt our City, the neighborhoods and the environment. Why should we remain at the mercy of these predatory banks when a much better alternative is possible? We believe that the only acceptable long term solution is for the City to create its own publicly-owned bank modeled after the Bank of North Dakota, the publicly-owned bank that has serve the State of North Dakota since 1919. A Philadelphia public bank would charge the City no fees, engage in no predatory lending or other abuses and invest its fund solely in Philadelphia and its communities at well below market Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 interest rates. All profits would go back into the City's coffers rather than into the hands of distant shareholders and bank executives. The Bank of North Dakota has been doing this for almost 100 years. I have left an article with your staff about the success of the Bank of North Dakota, and a move by the City of Sante Fe to move forward with its own investigation of public banking. As of the spring Of 2010, North Dakota was the only state boasting a major budget surplus. It had one of the best funded school system and the lowest unemployment in default rates in the country. And it had the most community banks per capita, suggesting that the presence of a state-owned bank actually helped the local banks. This is why comparable forward thinking cities like Oakland, Portland, Seattle and Sante Fe are actively exploring the creation of their own municipal banks. We believe that Philadelphia is a natural leader of Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 this movement because we are, in fact, the home of public banking which was first introduced to these shores by the Quakers. We can begin today to take steps toward the development of our Philadelphia public municipal bank. We are asking you to consider two paths of action. First, we ask that the words a publicly -- "bank publicly owned and controlled by the City of Philadelphia" be added to the City depository list so that the commitment of the City to organizing a public bank is clear even while the details are being worked out. Also, we would like City Council to authorize a study to determine best practices for moving forward with the creation of a public municipal bank. We are ready to work with Council to design such a study and to develop the standards and policies that would best benefit our neighborhoods, our school systems and our public institutions. Thank you so much. And we will be happy Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 to answer any questions that you have at any time.

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Thank you. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

Meghna Chandra commenting on 170330. (Approaches podium.)

Ms. Chandra

Hi. My name is Meghna Chandra. And I'm a community organizer with 215 Peoples Alliance, an organization that's fighting for racial and economic justice. I am here today to testify in favor of 170330 and 170329, following up on the testimony of our member Van Fields of the Finance Committee. So when the news broke about the fraudulent account scandal in which Wells Fargo got caught telling their staff to make 2 million fake bank accounts in their customer names, we decided to ask people about their experiences with Wells Fargo. So, I spent the last few months talking to hundreds of people outside of Wells Fargo Bank. And every time we went out, we would Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 meet at least three to four people who told us about ghost charges on their account, hidden fees, discriminatory treatment and unresponsive or disrespectful customer service. We have heard how people on fixed incomes -- from people on fixed incomes, how Wells purposely takes money out of people's bank accounts when they know they don't have money so they can charge them $35 in overdraft fees. We have heard stories of discriminatory treatment. How one of our members was approved for a loan on property in a rapidly gentrifying neighborhood, but was mysteriously denied it several days later, an African-American member. We've heard from former employees who left Wells Fargo because they didn't like pushing products on low income and immigrant communities who didn't know what they were signing up for. We can connect our members' experience to Wells Fargo's predatory business model. They've been found guilty in the Supreme Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Court for the overdraft fees and pushing that on working people. They make one-fourth of their profits, their non-interest related profits in these kind of hidden charges. They are found guilty of discriminatory lending. And they are one of the biggest foreclosures in the City. And also, they are part of consortium of banks that took 161 million from the Philadelphia School District by selling them swap deals, which went back after the Recession which was caused by banks and corrupt banks like Wells Fargo and corporate banks. And they are also one of the top financiers of private prisons, Corsovic an GEO Group. In doing business with Wells Fargo, the City is supporting a known predator of poor and working people. Our members also see the swindling of their bank accounts and foreclosure of their homes as connected with Wells Fargo's funding for Dakota Access Pipeline and the oil refinery. And more people talk about the pipeline. But the refinery is Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 responsible for 72 percent of toxic emissions in Philadelphia. And as Van, one of our members said, Wells Fargo is funding polluters that fund the well being of my family and my community. And the City enables them by doing business with them. So, we just want to say we applaud City Council under Cindy Bass' leadership for responding to community and activist groups to take on Wells Fargo. But we know that Wells Fargo is one of the worst of the bad. And to get to the heart of the problem, we need the City to hold its money in a public bank that will put the people before profits and invest in the community. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

Mabel Egrede commenting on 170330. (Approaches podium.)

Ms. Egrede

Good morning. My name is Mabel Egrede Alfaro. I am member of Philly with Standing Rock and Indigenous 215. I am 29 years resident of the United States and citizen of Chile from Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 South America. I am Estesa, mixed blood which means that median Chile is generically about 44 percent Native American, 51 percent European, and 5 percent of African descent. I come from the lands of various indigenous groups including the Aracanos Armepuces, the people of the Earth who until this day are defending the life, land, waters and biodiversity for expropriations by destructive corporate colonization. Now I stand in front of you on the occupy land Philadelphia. My humble message to you saying to Cindy Bass says thank you for ending some of your financial relationship with Wells Fargo as well as we all know, it is far overdue. However, in moving into the 21st Century we Philadelphians and we need institutions that are going to invest in our future generations. We need institutions that are going to stand up in the defense of our indigenous, black bodies. In defense of our nation's most vulnerable communities from Flint, Michigan to Standing Rock's Sioux Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 territory, in the defense of all native nations. We need institutions who will fight for healthy sustainable equitable future for all peoples. We need cities that are going to bring healthy and healing reparation for the belongings against African-American relations and similarly against Native American relatives. Because as my dear friend Liz Ellis, a Native American from the Peoria Tribe in Oklahoma and residents of Philadelphia denotes, to the indigenous people comes to 5 percent of the world population, but their territories house more than 80 percent of our planet's biodiversity. For centuries, native people have held reciprocal relationship with the lands they inhabit. Most famously de Lakhota Dakota led Pan indigenous movement to stop the Dakota Access Pipeline. Represents the constant battle of native peoples who stop extracted corporate colonialism. The fight seeks not only to protect the community from destruction, but also to defend the water, Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 lands and human relations, all things of an entire planet. As we have seen in recent years in Apache's fight against defense of their sacred lines from copper mining, the Navajo fights against uranian mining and population. We moving forward from Philadelphia. We need financial institutions that are going to defend our shared environments and planning for diversity. So, I urge you to divest from city banks within the year because they also fund the Dakota Access Pipeline. Thank you. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

Priscilla Bell commenting on 170330. (Approaches podium.)

Ms. Bell

Madrica, welcome, good morning Philadelphia City Council. My name is Priscilla Bell. I'm Boriqua born and raised in Philadelphia. I'm also an active member of the Tejano Revitalization Movement Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 which brings aware of my indigenous people who were the first to encounter colonialism in this hemisphere. I lived in Greys Ferry since 2002, which is one of the most effected neighborhoods in the City due to the toxic air emissions coming from the Philadelphia Energy Solutions Oil Refinery. So, I know firsthand how environmental racism can impact our lives. My 15-year-old son developed asthma at two years old when I first moved into the area. But I want to thank you still for divesting some of the City's money from Wells Fargo. But I also urge for you to be cautious on your decision in moving forward because like Citizens Bank, there are other institutions that do not have the best interest of our people Philadelphia and of our environment. But right now I would like to read a really quick letter from my friend who was going to testify, but due to her health related emergency, she wasn't able to be here today. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Dear Mayor Kenney and Philadelphia City Council, (speaks in another language). In English, my name is Jennifer Diapo. I am a citizen of Philadelphia as well as of the Mohawk Nation of Ga Na Wayeh. I apologize for my absence. And as much as I like to -as much as I ask my comrades to read this for me today. This morning, once again, I am sitting in the oncology office at Fox Center -- Fox Chase Center praying this time that my breast cancer has not returned or metastasized. And that I will be here long enough on this earth to see my three-year-old daughter grow up. The realities of what happens to us human beings when oil spills and toxic chemicals are dumped and released has been a reality for our Mohawk people for decades. We have astronomical rates of birth defects in our children, excessively high rates of cancer due to years of proven dumping and leaching of chemicals in our waterways. In my family alone, my grandmother, father, stepmother, sister, one-year-old son, Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 16-year-old daughter, myself have been affected all by cancer. In addition to our illness in the oncology of our land, the wildlife and the water has been destroyed. So in closing, I would like to -- I urge you to consider standing with us, the first nation's people and help us win our battle against the destruction and the dwindling of the sacred lands and clean water. I plead with you to fully divest our City from banks funding the Dakota Access Pipeline. Naiweh. Thank you. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

Celeste Hardester commenting on 170355. (Approaches podium.)

Ms. Hardester

Thank you Councilpeople. Good morning. It's often humbling to hear concerns -- often humbling to hear the concerns expressed in this room. I am here to give testimony on Bill 170335. I'm representing the Chestnut Hill Community Association. We understand a primary goal of this Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 legislation is to enable all RCOs to have a method for obtaining more complete information upon which to base their decisions. We support this intention but have several concerns about the outcome. In our communications with multiple RCOs, we have learned of none that were aware of this legislation until very recently. Because RCOs are generally volunteer based, last minute notifications can be problematic. The Chestnut Hill Community Association did not learn of the bill until April 25, which did not allow adequate time for responding at the April 28 Rules Committee hearing. We feel this legislation as it is currently written will be onerous to all parties involved, including City agencies, developers and RCOs. The project information form within the legislation sets a platform for a tremendous amount of information to be provided far more than RCOs with a bench of professional capacity generally request to see. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 We question the wisdom of this legislation, its potential detrimental impact, and would like the opportunity to have a greater understanding of it before it is voted on. We appreciate that this legislation be held on the calendar pending the opportunity for further discussion. For the record, we want to say that the Chestnut Hill Community Association review process has been mentioned verbally and in writing as being a model for this legislation. For the record, we disagree with this characterization. We have been told that the intention of the legislation is to level the playing field. We are concerned that the invasive nature of some of the information requested on the project information form exceeds leveling of the playing field and instead somewhat changes the game. This form goes well past what is used in Chestnut Hill asking for information about job creation related issues that open an additional dimension that we are not Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 convinced is constructive. We are concerned that in solving one problem, a whole new set of new ones will open up with this legislation. Many find it dense reading and difficult to understand. We feel an interim solution would be to make an information gathering form available through the Planning Commission, perhaps with plans to assess it's use after an appropriate period of time. Thank you.

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

You're welcome. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

Bill James commenting on 170335. (Approaches podium.)

Mr. James

Yes. Hello, everyone. My name is Bill James. I'm a member of the 50th Ward registered community organization, that serves the portions of East Mount Airy and West Oak Lane Community. I am here today to support my -- support Bill No. 170335 introduced by Councilwoman Cherelle Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Parker. This bill is nothing more -- I'm sorry. I'm nervous. The bill is nothing more than a practical educational tool for residents who deserve to know how development projects will impact their neighborhood. All RCOs do not have members who work in the development related industries against their membership. But this does mean -- does not mean that the residents in my community are not interested in how the projects are developed in our neighborhoods and how they will effect us. This legislation provides us, the people who keep the City going, with important information and questions that we need also to be answered. We have the right to access this information just as well as anyone else. The bill corrects a longstanding wrong in the neighborhoods throughout our City. It levels the playing field of -- and having access to information. I thank Councilwoman Parker for her leadership in the community. You asked for feedback from the RCOs while you are Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 drafting this legislation. And we appreciate your providing an opportunity for us to be heard. I want to thank the bill sponsors, Councilwoman Maria Sanchez and Blondell Reynolds Brown, Chairman Bill Greenlee and all the Members of the Rules Committee for supporting this bill. I hope the City Council will pass this bill and make it law. If you do, it will be bold steps making sure that all Philadelphians, regardless of their ZIP code, have access to information they need for strong communities. Thank you, Councible -- Council President Clarke. (Applause)

Chief Clerk

Bernadette Tanksley commenting on 170335. (Approaches podium.)

Ms. Tanksley

Hello. I am Bernadette Tanksley, a member of the OCA, the Oak Lane Community Action Association, registered community organization that serves East Oak Lane, which is situated on the northern Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 border between the City of -- the City and Cheltenham Township on the north, Godfrey Avenue on the south, Broad Street on the West and 5th Street on the east. I am here today to show you my support for Bill No. 170335 introduced by Councilwoman Cherelle Parker. Our RCO has been in existence since the RCO legislation was first implemented. The range of information provided to the RCO from the City and the applicant has varied from a statement of three lines or less that reflects little thought or preparation to full documentation and slide presentations. As the community attempts to review applications, it becomes clear that at the very least an informed recommendation requires significantly more than is currently required. The proposed form addresses an extensive array of highly relevant information. It alerts applicants to items that deserve consideration such as job creation, community impact and community benefit or Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 detriment. As proposed, the City would not require it for small scale projects. It is hard to understand why the City would choose to continue the RCO process without a mechanism for sharing this kind of information with the community reviewing the application. As indicated, the form would only be required for larger projects. It recognizes that some information may not be known at the time of the application. Meanwhile, the form would provide a major support to RCOs attempting to present appropriate information during the community review process. I want to thank Councilwoman Parker for her leadership and engagement in our community. You asked for feedback from RCOs while you were drafting the legislation, and we appreciate you for providing an opportunity for us to be heard. I also want to thank the bill sponsors Councilwoman Maria Sanchez and Blondell Reynolds Brown, Chairman Bill Greenlee and all members of Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 the Rules Committee for supporting this bill. I hope City Council will pass this bill and make it law. If you do it, it's a bold step towards making sure that all Philadelphians, regardless of their Zip code, have access to the information they need to build strong, sustainable communities. Thank you, Council President Clarke. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

Joe Danihel commenting on 170449 and 170205. (Approaches podium.)

Mr. Danihel

Morning. This is an official decree of the people and writ of mandamus quo warranto; and as such, requires immediate action remedy. This Council continues every week to authorize private property be given to RDA, Land Bank and other public agencies. The people are clearly designated beneficiaries of the Constitution, and government is by the people. Why has government refused to Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 investigate and provide immediate remedy, appearing to violate oath of office, Constitution rule of law? Violation of God given 42 USC 1982 property rights appears to violate Miranda B Arizona where rights secured by Constitution are involved, there can be no rule making or legislation which would obligate them. The Council and Mayor claim that when your God-given rights are violated, it's a matter for the courts. Have Council and Mayor forgotten their sworn oaths and their fiduciary duty. Cooper v. Aaron says you cannot violate the Constitution and laws without first violating your oath of office to uphold, obey and defend the constitution and laws. To Council, Mayor and the City opposed my seventh amendment common law trial by jury. Violating your sworn oath laws and constitution is non an option. The constitution requires immediate remedy of this breach of law. Your oath of office requires you to act or face prison. 42 USC Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 1982, 1983, 1985, 1986; 1918 USC 241, 242, 2381, 2384. PA Constitution Article I Section 1 through 11. 26 PA CSA 703, 705, 708, 709, 712, 713, 716 and other all listing SCOTUS 15-8965, 14-1330, 14-4056 appear violated. I call for the federal and commonwealth governments to perform their constitutional obligations to investigate and prosecute all involved in the theft and illegal deed transfer of my home 1038 West Wyoming Avenue, the denial of God-given 42 USC 1982 property rights for 23 years is egregious extraordinary oath violating and requires immediate remedy. A just government must obey the rule of law. The cover of all government must have it's charter government revoked until a constitutionally compliant government is installed. Public servants cannot refuse their sworn duty to act any more than a fireman can refuse to fight a fire. The sovereign people require the constitution laws be enforced. Jail is Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 required for all who would violate oath or law. It takes a lot of cooperation to create and allow monumental corruption. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

Bob Burdge?

Council President Clarke

Not here -there he is. He is here. (Approaches podium.)

Chief Clerk

Commenting on 170289.

Mr. Burdge

Good morning, sirs and ma'am.

Council President Clarke

Morning.

Mr. Burdge

Ma'ams. Two things. That I agree with the bill that's being passed today or voted on today with Wells Fargo, but also I think that we need to look at some of the other banks that are in this country that are good, honest banks. We don't need to perform -- and this is only my opinion, that we don't need to start a bank of Philadelphia because it's a lot of hassle and to get involved with that. And the other thing that -- my biggest thing today is that I know you put this on Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 next week's bill, but thank -- I want to thank the City Council and the Indigo bike people for the job well done. And thank you for keep funding that and making new bike lanes for the City bicycle riders. We appreciate that. And I'm urging that the bicycle people and the car people work together on the streets of Philadelphia because I have seen a couple accidents already since I started riding bikes. My six months going into being in the bicycle world. But -- and I've been in a couple myself because of cars being impatient -impatient with that. So, thank you. And thank you the gentleman and ladies from Indigo Bike Path watching this. Thank you for all your hard work and good job that you maintaining the bikes and keeping our bicycle world alive. Thank you, sirs.

Council President Clarke

Thank you for your testimony. (Applause.)

Chief Clerk

There are no other Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 speakers in the Public Comment list, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much. That concludes our Public Comment. We will now continue with our Calendar.

Ms. Smith

Excuse me. I have a comment. I signed up.

Council President Clarke

You signed up?

Council President Clarke

Just state your name for the record, ma'am.

Ms. Smith

Yes. My name is Trine Smith. I want to say good afternoon to my fellow Philadelphians, President Clarke, City Councilmembers and the public. I am a social and environmental justice activist. And I urge you all to take bold calculated stance against injustice on all fronts. We understand that America can be a much better place if we would all just do that with fervent passion. I want to thank all earth protectors, those of air, land and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 water and all who really fight for equality and justice. May we uncompromisingly in our search for truth -- may we be uncompromising in our search for truth. May we be relentless in our efforts to transform evil into justice. May we learn to imagine ourselves as healing, as thriving through the future and as creating new ways through the complexities of our times so that we are constantly reminded of our power and of our need to constantly evolve with life. Brightest blessings to all who will do. And may those contrary be damned. This is a testimony from Dr. Elizabeth Ellis in favor of Bills 1073300 [sic] and 10733900[sic] May 11, 2017. Since all Wall Street -- excuse me. Since all Wall Street banks engage in the same harmful and predatory practices, the only real remedy is to establish a public bank for the City of Philadelphia. The only ethical action for the City Council is to refuse to invest in either Citizens or Wells Fargo. We must protect Philadelphians from Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 predatory lending practices and exploiting management of our education funds, but we must also be accountable to native people and Americans most vulnerable -- in America's most vulnerable community across the nation. Liz went on to say as a citizen of Philadelphia as well as a citizen of the Peoria Tribe of Indians of Oklahoma, it is encouraging to hear that the plans to move our City money out of Wells Fargo, but city bank is not a solution. Both Citizens and Wells Fargo was among the top funders of Dakota Access Pipeline. The construction of the Dakota Access Pipeline is not only an environmental disastrous as it impacts drinking water of 18 million Americans, but it also clearly violates native sovereignty with funding from both Citizens and Wells Fargo, energy transfer partners violated federal treaties including the Fort Laramie Treaty of 1868, broke legal precedent as the Supreme Court guaranteed Indian nations water rights and that territories in 1908 Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 and circumvented federal regulatory procedures designed to protect Americans and all the environment that we all share. By investing in Wells Fargo and Citizens Philadelphia -- by investing in Wells Fargo and Citizens, Philadelphia taxpayers are thereby financing the violent and illegal assault on native bodies and territories and directly supporting regulatory capture in North Dakota. I urge you to follow and lead the City Councils of Seattle, St. Monica and neighbors in East Orange County, New Jersey to reject both of these banks. Thank you. (Applause.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you for your testimony, ma'am. That concludes our Public Comment for today. We will now -- Chair recognizes Councilman O'Neill.

Councilman O'Neill

Thank you, Mr. President. As I mentioned to you earlier off the sidebar, I asked to be excused from the rest of this session. And Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 be recorded as voting aye on all bills and resolutions.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Thank you, Councilman. The record shall reflect. We will now consider today's bill Consent Agenda. I will ask the Clerk to read the title of all the bills on the Consent Agenda. After teach title is read, any Member may object to the inclusion of the bill on the Consent Agenda. But such an object and without debate, the bill will immediately be removed from the Consent Agenda and placed on our regular Final Passage Calendar. The Clerk will now read the titles of the bills on the Consent Agenda. Mr. Decker.

Chief Clerk

Bill No. 170140-A, entitled: An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Girard Avenue, 9th Street, Brown Street, 8th Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Street, Spring Garden Street and Broad Street; and Bill No. 160680, entitled: An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Jackson Street, Broad Street, the Schuylkill Expressway(I-76), Vare Street, Passyunk Avenue and 24th Street; and Bill No. 1701941 entitled: An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by 29th Street, Sedgley Avenue, Ridge Avenue and Glenwood Avenue; and Bill No. 170201 entitled: An Ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Zoning and Planning," by amending Section 14-905, entitled "Non Accessory Signs," by authorizing the Director of Finance to create a separate fund for revenue collected by the City with respect to advertising on municipal property, authorizing the disposition of such revenue Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 and making conforming amendments to any other applicable Sections of The Philadelphia Code; and Bill No. 170265: An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Devereaux Avenue(extended), Keystone Street, Princeton Avenue, Keystone Street, Cottman Avenue(extended), Milnor Street, Bleigh Avenue(extended) and the Delaware River; and Bill No. 170310 entitled: An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Aramingo Avenue, Cambria Street, Frankford Avenue, the Railroad Right-of-Way, Kensington Avenue and Lehigh Avenue; and Bill No. 170331 entitled: An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Lehigh Avenue, 20th Street, Sedgley Avenue and 22nd Street; and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Bill No. 170333 entitled: An Ordinance to amend the Philadelphia Zoning Maps by changing the zoning designations of certain areas of land located within an area bounded by Roosevelt Boulevard, Adams Avenue, Arrott Street, Oxford Avenue and Oxford Circle; and Bill No. 170015 entitled: An Ordinance amending Section 19-1703 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Refunds," regarding credits and due dates; and Bill No. 170016 entitled: An Ordinance amending Title 19 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Finance, Taxes and Collections," to include transfers between stepparents and stepchildren as a transaction excluded from the realty transfer tax; and Bill No. 170308 entitled: An Ordinance constituting the Sixteenth Supplemental Ordinance to the Amended and Restated General Airport Revenue Bond Ordinance, providing for certain amendments to the Amended and Restated General Airport Revenue Bond Ordinance; and Bill No. 170329 entitled: An Ordinance Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 authorizing the City Treasurer to enter into an amendment agreement with Wells Fargo Bank, for provision of payroll banking services to the City; and Bill No. 170330 entitled: An Ordinance authorizing the City Treasurer to enter into a professional services agreement with Citizens Bank of Pennsylvania for provision of payroll banking services to the City; and Bill No. 161180 entitled: An Ordinance amending Chapter 11-600 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Construction, Encroachments and Projections Over, On and Under Streets," to provide additional requirements in connection with sidewalk closures; and Bill No. 170002 entitled: An Ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No.

Chief Clerk

269 by relocating the easterly houseline of University Avenue, from a point approximately five-hundred, forty-five feet north of Curie Boulevard to a point approximately two-hundred thirty-six feet further northwardly therefrom; and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Bill No. 170086 entitled: An Ordinance authorizing the revision of lines and grades on a portion of City Plan No. 269 by relocating portions of the houselines and curblines of Convention Avenue, from Thirty-Fourth Street to Health Sciences Drive; and Bill No. 107203 entitled: And Ordinance authorizing the installation of all-way stop signs at the intersection of 57th Street and Wyalusing Avenue; and Bill No. 170264 entitled: An Ordinance authorizing Owen Kamihira of Bar Fred to install, own and maintain an open-air sidewalk cafe at 1040 North 2nd Street; and Bill No. 170281 entitled: An Ordinance regulating the direction of movement of traffic on American Street between Girard Avenue and Thompson Street; and Bill No. 170283 entitled: An Ordinance authorizing Piedmont 1901 Market to construct, own and maintain various right-of-way encroachments at 1901 Market Street; and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Bill No. 170284 entitled: An Ordinance authorizing Brandywine Operating Partnership to construct, own and maintain various right-of-way encroachments at 1900 Market Street; and Bill No. 170286 entitled: An Ordinance established a no truck parking regulation on the 2600 and 2700 blocks of Winchester Avenue both sides; and Bill No. 170292 entitled: An Ordinance establishing a no truck parking regulation on both sides of Ogontz Avenue from Somerville to Belfield Avenue; and Bill No. 170305 entitled: And Ordinance amending Chapter 9-200 of The Philadelphia Code, (entitled "Commercial Activities on Streets") by amending Section 9-213, entitled "Farmers' Markets," to revise certain provisions relating to the permissible location of the farmers' market on South 43rd Street near Clarke Park; and Bill No. 170311 entitled: An Ordinance amending Chapter 11-600 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled, "Construction, Encroachments Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 and Projections Over, On and Under Streets," by adding definitions for "Electric Vehicle" and "Electric Vehicle Charger" and authorizing a new category of encroachment for which building permits may be obtained entitled "Electric Vehicle Chargers"; and Bill No. 170336 entitled: An Ordinance amending Section 12-1131 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Electric Vehicle Parking," to provide for a time limit on the moratorium on new electric vehicle parking spaces, all under certain terms and conditions.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Mr. Decker. These bills have been read on two different days. The question for each bill now is shall the bill pass finally. The clerk will call the role. And upon being called, each Councilmember shall vote aye on each of the bill, nay on each of the bills or indicate those bills for which the member is voting aye and those bills for the Member is voting nay.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Bass? Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Councilwoman Bass

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Blackwell?

Councilwoman Blackwell

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Domb?

Councilman Domb

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Green?

Councilman Green

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Greenlee?

Councilman Greenlee

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Gym?

Councilwoman Gym

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Henon?

Councilman Henon

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Johnson?

Councilman Johnson

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Jones?

Councilman Jones

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman O'Neill is voting aye on all bills. Councilman Oh?

Councilman Oh

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Parker?

Councilwoman Parker

Aye on all bills. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez?

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown?

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Squilla?

Councilman Squilla

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Taubenberger?

Councilman Taubenberger

Aye on all bills.

Chief Clerk

Council President Clarke?

Council President Clarke

Aye on all bills. The majority of all Members having voted in the affirmative for each of these bill, the bills on the Consent Agenda are passed. We now consider -(Applause.)

Council President Clarke

We will now consider the bills and resolutions on the regular Second Reading and Final Passage Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Calendar. Mr. Decker, if you will read the title of 170443.

Chief Clerk

A resolution initiating action to establish a business improvement district encompassing certain taxable (for real estate tax purposes) hotels within the boundaries of the City and County of Philadelphia, to be known as the Philadelphia Hospitality Improvement Levy District, designating the Philadelphia Hospitality and Improvement District Corporation to serve as the Neighborhood Improvement District Management Association, under the Committee and Economic Improvement Act.

Council President Clarke

And the Chair recognizes Councilman Green.

Councilman Green

Thank you, Council President. I move that this bill be withdrawn. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 All those in favor? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. Bill No -- Resolution 170443 is withdrawn. Mr. Decker, 170449.

Chief Clerk

A resolution approving the redevelopment contract of the Philadelphia Redevelopment Authority for the redevelopment and urban renewal of a portion of the Auburn Redevelopment Area identified by house number and street address as 2246 East Cambria Street.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilman Squilla.

Councilman Squilla

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 All those in favor say aye? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And 170449 is adopted. Mr. Decker, please read the title of 170335.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance amending Title 14 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Zoning and Planning," and Title 18 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Commerce," to provide for the preparation and distribution of Project Information Forms with respect to certain development projects.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.

Councilwoman Parker

Thank you, Mr. President. I would like to offer an amendment to Bill No. 170335. A copy of the amendment has been circulated to all Members of Council. And I move for the adoption of the amendment. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor? (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. Bill No. 170335 has been amended. It will be placed on our Second Reading and Final Passage Calendar at our next session of Council. Mr. Decker, 170205.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance amending Section 10-1000 of The Philadelphia Code, entitled "Fees," to exempt the Land Bank from paying City recording fees in connection with property it acquires; amending Chapter 16-700, entitled "Philadelphia Land Back," to provide for the leasing out of Land Bank property; and amending Chapter 19-1400, entitled "Realty Transfer Tax," to exempt the Land Bank, and Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 certain transactions involving the Land Bank, from payment of realty transfer tax.

Council President Clarke

This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is, shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, call the role.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Bass?

Councilwoman Bass

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Blackwell?

Councilwoman Blackwell

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Domb?

Councilman Domb

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Green?

Councilman Green

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Greenlee?

Councilman Greenlee

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Gym?

Councilwoman Gym

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Henon?

Councilman Henon

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Johnson?

Councilman Johnson

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Jones?

Councilman Jones

Aye. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Chief Clerk

Councilman O'Neill is voting aye. Councilman Oh?

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Parker?

Councilwoman Parker

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez?

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown?

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Squilla?

Councilman Squilla

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Taubenberger?

Councilman Taubenberger

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Council President Clarke?

Council President Clarke

Aye. The ayes are 17, the nays are 0. Majority of Members present voting in the affirmative. The bill passes. Mr. Decker, 170332.

Chief Clerk

An Ordinance authorizing transfers and appropriations for Fiscal Year Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 2017 from the General Fund and the Grants Revenue Fund, certain or all City offices, departments, boards and commissions to the General Fund, the Water Fund, and the Community Development Fund, certain of all City offices, departments, boards and commissions.

Council President Clarke

This bill has been heard on two separate days. The question is, shall the bill pass finally. Mr. Decker, call the role.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Bass?

Councilwoman Bass

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Blackwell?

Councilwoman Blackwell

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Domb?

Councilman Domb

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Green?

Councilman Green

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Greenlee?

Councilman Greenlee

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Gym?

Councilwoman Gym

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Henon? Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Councilman Henon

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Johnson?

Councilman Johnson

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Jones?

Councilman Jones

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman O'Neill is voting aye. Councilman Oh?

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Parker?

Councilwoman Parker

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez?

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown?

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Squilla?

Councilman Squilla

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Councilman Taubenberger?

Councilman Taubenberger

Aye.

Chief Clerk

Council President Clarke?

Council President Clarke

Aye. The ayes are 17, the nays are 0. The Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 majority of Members present voting in the affirmative. The bill passes. Mr. Decker, do you have any additional resolutions?

Chief Clerk

A resolution recognizing the month of May is National Foster Care Month in the City of Philadelphia introduced by Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Council President Clarke

Who? Couldn't hear you. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown.

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Chief Clerk

And a resolution hereby recognizing May 18, 2017 as Haitian Flag Day in Philadelphia, introduced by Councilwoman Blackwell.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilwoman Blackwell.

Councilwoman Blackwell

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it, and that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution authorizing the Committee on Public Property and Public Works to hold public hearings on the status of implementation of the Cable Television Franchise Renewal Agreement between the City of Philadelphia and Comcast Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 of Philadelphia passed by this Council on December 10, 2015, introduced by Councilman Henon.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilman Henon.

Councilman Henon

I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

A resolution recognizing May 4, 2017 as International Firefighters Day in Philadelphia, and further honoring the men and women of the Philadelphia Fire Department for their continual dedication and service to the City of Philadelphia, introduced by Councilman Henon. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Council President Clarke

Chair again recognizes Councilman Henon.

Councilman Henon

I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution recognizing and honoring Overbrook High School graduates Joyce Eli Bevins and Jean Lu Bevins for their recognition by the Cannes Film Festival for the short film "My Dear Arthur," introduced by Councilman Jones.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilman Jones.

Councilman Jones

Thank you. With Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Panther pride, I move for the adoption. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution honoring Principal Joanne Beaver of the Philadelphia High School for the Creative and Performing Arts recipient of the 2017 Lindback Award which recognizes distinguished principal leadership, introduced by Councilman Johnson.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilman Johnson.

Councilman Johnson

Council President, I move for the adoption of the resolution, please. (Duly seconded.) Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

A resolution recognizing, honoring and celebrating Sharon Lopez on being named the first Latina President of the Pennsylvania Bar Association, introduced by Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez.

Councilwoman Quinones-Sanchez

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for its adoption. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved an properly seconded. All those in favors say aye? (Ayes.) Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution initiating action to establish a business improvement district encompassing certain existing and future hotel properties within the boundaries of the City of Philadelphia to be known as the Philadelphia Hospitality Improvement Levy District designating Philadelphia Hospitality Improvement Levy District Corporation to serve as the Neighborhood Improvement District Management Association for the District, introduced by Councilman Green.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilman Green.

Councilman Green

Thank you, Council President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

The ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

And a resolution recognizing and honoring Members of Delta Sigma Theta Sorority Incorporated Quaker City Alumni Chapter Social Action Committee on the occasion of the 14th year of Delta Days at City Council, introduced by Councilwoman Parker.

Council President Clarke

Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.

Councilwoman Parker

Thank you, Mr. President. I move for the adoption of the resolution. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

It's been moved and properly seconded. All those in favor say aye? Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 (Ayes.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. And that resolution is adopted.

Chief Clerk

There are no other resolutions on the Final Passage Calendar, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you very much, Mr. Decker. That concludes our calendar for today. Are there any speeches on the part of the Minority and speeches on part of the Majority? Chair recognizes Councilman Jones.

Councilman Jones

Thank you, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Welcome.

Councilman Jones

A couple of words and comments that I've heard you say by way of approaching development in your district and Maria talked about it a bit, Councilwoman Sanchez talked about it a bit today. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Councilman Johnson wrestles with it all the time. Councilwoman Blackwell has had to deal with it because there's an ebb and flow to development. Neighborhoods start, they rise, they have seen better days, sometimes they rise again. But in that rising, all progress isn't forward for all people. Meaning, some people get crushed in the wake of that progress. Yesterday had an opportunity to join the Philadelphia Tenants Union at one of my facilities at Penn Wynn on Lebanon Avenue. If you know anything about Wynnefield, it -that property was built in 1960. 240 units right around the time when that kind of architecture for the Jetsons. It was way cool. Like when you walk by there, you always thought some rich person lived in there. When I delivered orders to there, you felt like you were some place. Well, its seen better days. It was purchased recently by a group of investors. By now, those residents had been disabled Veterans, people have had challenges in Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 their life that wound up on Section 8. And when I went out there -- we had gotten complaints about it before. But when I went out there, the total disrespect to those people to receive a letter saying in 30 days you just got to go. Now some of those people had -- are newbies, had only been there 7 years. Some people had been there 20 years. One lady I met, 32 years. And as important as the longevity, paid her rent on time. Never had rowdy parties. Never had a reason, legitimate reason, to be evicted at all. Find themselves in the wake of that development, property values go up. Investors see it. Come in and say, oh, well. Well, oh well isn't good enough. Oh well isn't good enough. I understand economic development. I have done development. I went to compete with you on shovels, you know. I never catch up, but I can try. But what will not happen, what we cannot abide is a disregard for humans to be Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 given a letter two months before -- oh, no two weeks before the Christmas holidays and told you got 30 days and then you got to go is wrong. These are men and women who served our country. These are men and women who are taxpayers, and only because of economic value are being displaced. And they are going to go somewhere. And we should be concerned about the process by which they do. So, I want to challenge us -- I'm pro development. I have done my share of deals. But there has to be a rule and guide in how you treat tenants and how you do them. And so, we are going take this as a case example and try to look at similar patterns around the City, whether in the First District or the Fifth to see if there's a commonality of what is going on. And Philly is on the rise. But as they say about tides, all boats should rise with that tide. People shouldn't be drowned by it. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Thank you, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Chair recognizes Councilman Green.

Councilman Green

Thank you, Council President. Yesterday during the School District testimony, we heard some good news. We were informed by our colleague Councilwoman Parker that Estelle Richman had been confirmed to the SRC. We also heard some good news from Dr. Hite in his testimony that the School District is committed to negotiating a contract with the teachers union. And I would like to remind our -- my colleagues here today that approximately one year ago, we passed a resolution that urged the School Reform Commission, Superintendent Hite, the School District of Philadelphia to actively negotiate a mutually agreeable new contract with the Philadelphia Federation of teachers that provide adequate staffing of our schools, acknowledges the contributions Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 and sacrifices of teachers and other staff and respects both seniority and traditional payment structure like Step Pay. Now just a few days ago, I believe the Philadelphia Federation of Teachers released a survey that highlighted the impact that this contract impasse has had on both students and teachers in the City. And in this survey they released, they also informed us it's been 1,349 days since the teachers had a contract. From my respect, I believe this impasse impacts not only the students, teachers, but our City as a whole. And as a son of a retired school teacher, I remember the challenging contract negotiation of the '80s. I'm also as a parent of Philadelphia School District student, I'm also concerned how this contract impasse may impact us going forward. So, I urge both the School Reform Commission, Dr. Hite and his staff as well as Philadelphia Federation of Teachers to work together to resolve this contract Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 impasse. Thank you.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Gym.

Councilwoman Gym

Thank you very much, Council President and Colleagues. This week is the week before Mothers Day. And I just want to acknowledge all the mothers in the room of course and fathers, too, but this is our day. And it is also a day that Philadelphia's joining organizations around the country as part of a National Mommas Bail Out Day. And this national day is to recognize the number of incarcerated mothers who are currently spending Mothers Day in jail because they cannot afford to pay bail. Every day an average of 700,000 people who have yet to be convicted of a crime are sitting in jails and separated from their families simply because they cannot afford to pay bill. Women held in local jails represent the fastest growing group of incarcerated people in the United States. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Since 1970, the number of women in U.S. jails has increased by 14 times. And nearly 80 percent of women in jails are mothers. And without our support this Mothers Day, many women and mothers could be languishing in these changes separated from their families and loved ones simply because they cannot afford bail. And I hope that as we enter into this Mothers Day, that we will think about the impact and dehumanization of holding people in prison interminably because of cash bail requirements. I believe and I think the City believes that we have to end this practice. Mothers Day is a reminder of the impact on the broader population, on women in particular, and in the families that suffer. So for those who are interested, the No 215 Jail Coalition is supporting the bailout, and donations that they are raising to help with that. But more importantly, as we look ahead to the future, I hope that we will commit ourselves to making sure that Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 practices like cash bail end in our City. And that we will all work together to make that happen. Thank you.

Council President Clarke

Thank you Councilwoman. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Bass.

Councilwoman Bass

Thank you, Mr. President.

Council President Clarke

Welcome.

Councilwoman Bass

You know, we had a number of schools who were represented today, Father Judge and also Masterman. And I wanted to acknowledge that we have some young people here from my district for North Philadelphia. I know that you, as well, from North Philadelphia. And wanted to recognize North Philadelphia's own Kenderton Elementary School. If we can have our students from Kenderton stand up.

Council President Clarke

Stand up guys. (Applause.) Stated Meeting May 11, 2017

Councilwoman Bass

And they came down. And I am sure they enjoyed themselves and enjoying the pizza that we are providing, as well. Thank you so much for coming down.

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Thank you, Councilwoman. Chair recognizes Councilman Domb.

Councilman Domb

Thank you, Council President. I want to talk about a topic that I haven't talked about in at least two weeks, and that's the Earned Income Tax Credit. But I wanted to give you some results because I think it's some good news. I met with Mary Arthur this morning with Campaign For Working Families. And she tells me that our returns and monies going back to people in Philadelphia are up 10 percent, which is good. But we have a lot of work to do. She also shared with me, I donated some office space at Broad and Sansom for the Campaign For Working Families. And the good news there is that we had almost 2,997 taxpayers filed returns that got them back 4.2 million. But we need Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 three other locations for next year. So, I am going to ask you Council President, Broad and Erie for a location there or Councilwoman Sanchez, we need something on Frankford Avenue and 4300. And for Councilman Squilla we need Broad and Oregon. We need landlords to donate for four months the space. It's not a big deal. And I am happy to work with you to do it. It makes a big difference. Thank you. And thank you very much, Councilman.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilman. A shameless plug for a great business. We can meet in City View Pizza at Broad and Erie. Guarantee a lot of people showing up. Thank you. Chair recognizes Councilwoman Parker.

Councilwoman Parker

Thank you, Mr. President. I want to make just a brief comment about Bill No. 170335. And want to say to my colleagues a special thank you for passing the technical amendments that we just made to the bill. And we will vote on Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 it on Final Passage next week. And while I have, Mr. President, thought that I would reserve from making any comments until we got the final passage, unfortunately, one of the individuals who stood up to testify during Public Comment talked about the prospect that this project information form would preempt an existing RCOs form. I want to just state for the record that this form will not preempt any existing RCOs forms. The purpose of this form is to create a floor, a baseline of information for not just RCOs. And let me just say that for the record, but for Philadelphia residents who may not even be active in RCOs to have information relative to development taking place in their communities. In addition to that, and I won't read the names. And I know my colleagues are about tired of seeing this information. But I just want to remind you on the information packet that was left on your desk, we provide samples of -- sort of sample project Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 information forms that are used by one, two, three, four, five, six other community-based organizations throughout the City of Philadelphia. And I applaud them for the development of their forms. As a matter of fact when I look at them, they make the contents of this project information form look like a marshmallow as one of the community-based organizations told me when we were in the midst of the drafting process. So thank you, Mr. President and colleagues. Thank you for your support.

Council President Clarke

Thank you, Councilwoman. There being no additional speeches, this Chair recognizes Councilwoman Reynolds Brown for a motion to adjourn.

Councilwoman Reynolds Brown

Yes. Thank you, Mr. President. I move that City Council stand adjourned until Thursday, May 18, 2017 at 10:00 a.m. (Duly seconded.)

Council President Clarke

Thank you. Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 It's been moved and properly second that Council stand adjourned until Thursday, May 18, 2017 at 10:00 a.m. All those in favor say aye? (Aye.)

Council President Clarke

Those opposed? (No response.)

Council President Clarke

Ayes have it. Thank you all very much. Motion carried. ) Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 C E R T I F I C A T I O N I, hereby certify that the proceedings and evidence noted are contained fully and accurately in the stenographic notes taken by me in the foregoing matter, and that this is a correct transcript of the same. ANGELA M. m 1:6 71:19 72:9 address 27:12 115:2 36:18 America 67:14 71:4 108:10 135:22 73:20 30:10 afford 45:24 Allegheny 38:11,17 74:16 77:16 approximat... 136:3 accurately 108:15 129:17,21 45:15 56:18 75:1 93:21 80:13 83:14 11:8 101:21 Aaron 89:13 137:5 addresses 130:8 Alliance America's 85:16 88:11 101:23 abatement acknowledge 86:20 affordable 71:10 95:5 91:4 92:23 127:17 28:11 47:17 129:8 adequate 64:22 allow 50:23 American 96:15 April 9:6 10:7 48:2 131:14 81:14 African 37:18 81:13 91:3 59:3,5 75:3 106:21 27:7 34:2 abating 27:24 acknowledg... 127:23 38:12 75:4 allowed 32:22 76:8,10 131:24 81:13,14 abide 125:24 127:24 adhere 62:1 African-A... alternative 102:18 applicable Aracanos ability 31:14 acquires adjourn 72:16 76:7 68:14 Americans 99:2 75:6 Abiona 9:18 110:19 135:18 afternoon Alumni 53:1 95:4,17 applicant Aramingo able 45:24 act 89:24 adjourned 93:15 122:12 96:2 86:11 99:16 78:23 90:21 135:21 agencies 29:7 amazed 14:11 amount 63:5 applicants architecture absence 5:16 107:16 136:2,12 57:22 62:23 amazing 63:7 81:21 86:22 124:16 5:20 6:4 acted 16:5 administrat... 81:18 88:21 17:20,20,20 and/or application area 40:4 79:6 acting 10:14 21:22 37:21 agency 31:9 37:16 137:18 87:7,11 42:10 55:16 abuser 62:18 action 6:11 49:5 Agenda ambulance ANGELA applications 56:10 78:12 abuses 68:22 19:5 22:4 admiration 59:16,20 19:7 137:11 86:16 97:23 98:6 academic 52:5 53:1 20:16 29:20 60:9,18 Amelia 8:17 Anniversary applied 17:7 98:13 99:7 54:4 70:8 85:22 ado 27:1 61:1 97:7,9 13:10,18 23:16 27:5 apply 137:16 99:15,22 Academy 88:18 94:22 adopted 97:11,14,17 amend 40:1 29:16 appreciate 100:4 40:5 107:5 121:7 109:7 106:19 42:7 55:13 annual 47:10 6:12 82:5 108:14 acceptable 122:12 115:24 ago 22:9 55:19 58:20 48:7 85:2 87:20 areas 40:3 68:15 actions 17:15 116:18 46:16 97:20 98:4 answer 71:1 92:6 42:9 55:15 access 63:16 17:16,24 117:17 127:18 98:11 99:4 answered appreciates 97:22 98:6 64:23 73:22 19:11 20:12 118:14 128:4 99:13,20 84:16 28:24 98:13 99:6 76:20 77:14 21:3 119:11 agree 4:4 100:2 Apache's appreciation 99:15,22 80:11 84:16 active 77:23 120:9 121:5 24:18,19 amended 77:4 20:16 100:4 84:21 85:12 134:16 122:8 123:6 91:14 100:19,22 apartment appreciative Ariel 9:23 88:7 95:14 actively 69:22 adoption agreeable 110:10 45:20 19:10 14:3,3 95:15 127:21 108:20 127:21 amending apologies approach 7:5 Arizona 89:5 Accessory activist 74:9 109:23 agreed 12:4 45:2,4 56:2 12:18 15:17 23:6 arm 32:21 98:19 93:19 115:14 agreement 56:4,8 apologize approaches Armepuces accidents activities 37:9 116:8 117:7 34:18 40:15 58:17,23 48:22 79:5 62:10 64:4 75:6 92:9 103:16 118:4 119:1 41:17 101:2 98:17,18 apparent 65:16 67:19 Arms 33:15 accolades actual 63:6 119:22 101:7 100:8,12 19:3 71:7 74:19 array 86:21 25:1 Adams 100:5 120:19 116:23 101:11 appear 90:6 77:19 80:16 arrest 57:23 accolations add 20:18 121:21 agrees 59:8 103:15,17 appearance 83:17 85:19 arrival 17:13 15:24 56:5 122:19 ahead 130:23 103:23 27:17 88:14 91:8 arrived 19:8 accompany... added 70:11 adventure air 56:3 78:6 104:8 appearing approaching Arrott 100:5 7:2,3 23:2 adding 104:2 34:20 41:19 93:24 109:10 89:2 123:22 Arthur 43:1 accomplished addition 10:2 advertising Airport 110:15,20 appears 89:4 appropriate 118:20 31:13 32:7 37:9 60:24 98:23 100:20,22 110:23 applaud 49:13 52:3 132:14 accomplish... 63:16 80:2 advise 33:23 Airy 83:21 amendment 62:16 65:19 57:9 83:9 article 69:7 31:14,20 134:19 49:9 AL 1:17 55:23 89:19 68:5 74:7 87:13 90:2 accomplish... additional advocates albeit 21:6 101:2 135:4 appropriati...

Council President Clarke

105:2,5,7,9 cities 66:9 breast 79:11 16:19,23,24 61:4 CDO 56:13 55:8 57:11 82:13 105:11,13 69:21 76:4 Brett 7:2 9:3 16:24 17:1 call 62:6 90:7 celebrate 58:3 59:8 charge 68:21 105:15,17 citizen 25:13 10:1 17:2 18:18 104:18 23:16 38:21 59:12 60:19 72:10 105:19,23 74:24 79:4 Brian 1:14 18:19,21,24 111:6 celebrating 65:12 96:19 Charger 106:1,5,9 95:7,8 30:4,12 19:1 113:11 49:16 107:17 104:3 106:11,14 Citizens 32:10,10 business 3:17 called 61:3,17 120:11 108:17 Chargers 107:4 62:20,23 brief 133:20 3:23 4:19 104:19 Celeste 80:14 109:17 104:6 108:10 63:10,15,21 briefly 3:1 5:15 6:8 calling 60:20 cell 22:1 115:11 charges 72:2 109:10 65:22 78:17 13:8 28:1,20 Cambria Center 58:18 116:5 117:4 73:5 110:15 94:23 95:12 bright 22:12 29:6 33:13 99:16 79:10,10 118:1,22 charitable 111:7,9,11 95:19 96:4 Brightest 35:4 51:16 108:16 Central 56:14 119:19 63:12 111:13,15 96:6 101:8 94:12 52:6 58:11 camera 23:9 centuries 120:15 charm 13:7 111:17,19 city 1:1,5 bring 76:5 64:22 68:6 Campaign 76:15 121:18 charter 90:18 111:21,23 11:15 20:8 brings 63:18 72:23 73:16 132:15,21 Century 122:16 Chase 79:10 112:1,5,7 25:14 26:3 78:1 74:6 107:5 Campbell 75:17 123:16 checks 14:22 112:10,13 27:18 28:2 British 38:7 121:7 43:6 certain 34:10 127:4 129:4 cheering 112:15,17 29:7,10,12 Canal 55:18 Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 30:17 31:5 78:14 108:3,6,17 49:14,21 26:14 27:6 Collections commit community... 31:9,21,23 City-County 108:23 51:15 52:4 27:13,20 100:13 130:24 135:2,9 32:3,24 45:4 109:3,6,17 52:22 54:1 28:1,4,18 colonialism commitment companioned 33:22 34:12 citywide 110:2,6,9 55:13 57:9 28:19,24 76:22 78:2 32:1 37:2 30:3 34:17 35:15 25:12 26:21 111:3 57:19 58:15 29:19 30:18 colonization 70:12 companying 40:15 41:2 27:14 112:17,18 62:8 65:14 30:20,21 75:10 committed 15:12 41:17 47:1 claim 89:9 113:8 67:17 71:5 31:16,18 colonizations 127:13 comparable 47:8 50:2 Clarke 1:9 114:22,23 74:17 77:17 32:6,17 37:6 committee 69:20 51:18 52:8 2:2,19 4:10 115:9,16,20 80:14 83:15 33:1 combined 25:5 36:9 compete 11:7 53:1,3 4:12,13,17 115:23 85:17 88:12 CLIP's 28:10 29:5 39:18 40:9 11:11 58:18 62:17 5:4,10,13 116:5,10,14 91:5,9 clock 37:22 Comcast 40:11 41:24 125:21 62:19 63:24 5:22 6:5 7:7 116:17 92:24 97:7 close 45:18 40:16 42:6,19 competed 64:15,20 7:13 12:4,8 117:4,9,13 97:16,19 closing 20:18 116:24 45:1 49:13 10:9 65:1,3,5 15:2,5 117:16 104:18,24 47:7 80:5 come 2:23 52:3 53:2 competition 66:8,10,13 21:15,19 118:1,6,10 105:2,5,7,9 closures 6:10,16 58:10 71:15 7:20,22 66:18,24 22:16,19 118:13,22 105:11,13 101:15 10:19 20:24 81:15 85:7 11:19,21 67:4,8,10 23:21 24:5 119:3,7,10 105:15,17 clothes 17:6 21:9 29:3 88:1 107:15 complaints 68:4,5,11 24:9 30:14 119:19 105:19,23 co-authored 48:21 75:5 116:20 125:3 68:16,21 33:8,11,18 120:1,5,8 106:1,5,9 52:16 125:16 122:12 complete 81:2 69:9 70:10 34:23 35:2 120:15,21 106:11,14 co-sponsored comes 76:12 committees complexities 70:11,12,15 35:11,17,24 121:1,4,18 107:4 52:17 53:20 coming 23:9 57:10 94:9 73:7,17 36:8,13 121:24 108:10 coached 9:2 78:7 132:4 common compliance 74:5,7,13 37:12 39:2 122:4,7,16 109:10 9:24 commend 89:19 25:20 77:12,21 39:6,11,17 122:22 110:15 coalition 68:2 29:13 commonality compliant 78:6 79:1 39:23 40:8 123:2,5,10 111:7,9,11 130:20 comment 126:19 90:19 80:10 81:18 40:18 41:3 123:19 111:13,15 code 45:3 61:10,12 commonwe... computing 84:14,20 41:11,21 127:2 129:2 111:17,19 55:20 56:3 93:1,5,8 90:7 47:18 85:8 86:1,1 42:3,18 131:5,10,22 111:21,23 56:4,9,11 96:18 communica...

Council President Clarke

comrades 86:11 87:1 43:2,8,20 132:5 112:1,5,7 58:17,19,24 133:21 33:14 34:24 79:7 87:3 88:3 44:4,10,18 133:13 112:10,13 85:12 88:7 134:6 81:6 concerned 89:18 92:2 44:24 45:8 135:14,24 112:15,17 98:17 99:3 commenting communities 82:16 83:1 92:5 93:17 49:11,19 136:6,9 112:23 100:9,12 62:8 65:14 28:9 47:11 126:10 94:21,22 50:5,20,23 clean 80:9 113:12,14 101:12 67:17 71:5 68:24 72:20 128:18 95:11,11 51:2,5,8,13 cleaned 27:20 113:16,18 103:16,24 74:17 77:17 75:23 85:13 concerning 96:11 98:22 52:2,11,20 cleaning 26:2 113:20,22 104:9 80:15 83:15 88:9 134:18 59:13 101:1,4,6,9 53:4,10,13 30:24 33:2 113:24 109:11,13 85:18 88:12 community concerns 101:18 53:18,23 cleanups 28:8 114:2,4,6 110:16 91:9 21:1,9 80:19,20 102:3 107:8 54:10,17,23 clear 70:13 114:10,12 coffers 69:2 comments 22:24 25:6 81:5 110:18 55:6,11 86:16 114:15,18 coherent 123:21 27:4,6,15 concession 113:2,6 57:7,17 clearly 88:22 114:20,22 17:18 134:4 28:5,20 34:18 41:17 115:7 58:1,6 59:7 95:18 115:5 116:1 coiled 9:12 Commerce 29:5,14 conclude 116:24 60:6,13,16 clerk 1:19 2:9 116:19 colleague 109:13 46:5 48:17 61:24 62:3 117:23 61:8 62:11 2:17,21 117:18 127:9 Commercial 64:18 66:22 concludes 121:10 85:15 88:10 4:12 33:16 118:15 colleagues 55:24 69:16 71:9 58:8 93:4 122:12,14 91:6,12 33:21 35:1 119:12 49:6 54:15 103:16 74:5,9,15 96:17 126:18 92:21 93:3 35:1,13 120:10 54:20 Commission 76:23 80:22 123:11 128:8,13 93:9,12,16 36:4,10 121:6 122:9 127:17 83:8 127:19 81:12 82:9 concrete 130:14 96:16 97:3 39:13 40:1 123:7 129:6 128:22 83:20,22 39:15 131:1 103:21 40:10,20 CLIP 23:1,12 133:22 Commissio... 84:10,23 conditions 133:15 104:14 41:14 42:7 23:12,13,16 134:20 34:16,17 85:22,23 34:22 59:6 135:3,21 106:14,15 42:20 43:4 23:19,23 135:13 41:15,16 86:15,24,24 104:13 City's 31:3 106:22 43:22 44:6 24:12,24 collected commissions 87:6,14,18 Conduct 56:5 63:20 69:2 107:17,23 44:20 45:2 25:4,15,23 98:22 113:3,7 95:5 113:5 confirmed Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 127:11 89:6,14,16 83:1 29:12,24 106:22 15:19 18:2 114:18,19 57:13,18 conforming 89:21,22 Conway 23:2 30:14,17 107:17,19 18:12,23 114:20,21 65:11,13 99:1 90:2,24 25:1 30:15 33:1,8,8,10 107:23 19:13 20:7 117:2,5,6 67:15 68:7 congratulate constitutional 30:16 32:13 33:11,18,22 108:3,6,17 22:21,22 117:24 71:3 83:12 11:17 20:10 90:8 cool 124:17 34:1,4,23 108:23 23:3,8,15 118:2,3,20 83:24 84:22 congratulat... constitution... coop 64:24 35:2,11,17 109:3,6,17 23:22 24:10 118:23,24 85:4 86:6 7:17 90:19 Cooper 89:13 35:24 36:8 109:23 24:14 26:9 119:17,20 87:16,22 congratulat... construct cooperating 36:13 37:12 110:2,6,9 27:11 28:10 119:21 104:24 21:13 102:22 62:22 37:15 39:2 110:13 29:11 31:12 121:17,19 105:1,2,3 conjunction 103:3 cooperation 39:3,6,11 111:3 32:9 39:7,8 121:20 105:11,12 23:23 27:8 construction 2:7 91:2 39:17,20,23 112:17,18 39:12,19,20 123:16,17 105:23,24 connect 72:21 64:10 95:14 copper 9:12 40:8,17,18 113:8 39:24 41:5 123:20 106:1,3,5,7 connected 101:12 77:5 41:3,11,21 114:22,23 41:6,12,13 124:1 127:3 109:18,19 73:21 103:24 copy 11:23 41:22 42:3 115:9,16,20 41:21 42:1 127:4,5 111:7,8,9 connection constructive 20:13 29:17 42:18 43:2 115:23 43:10,11,18 129:3 132:7 111:10,17 101:15 83:1 109:21 43:8,11,19 116:5,10,14 43:21 50:7 132:8 133:6 111:18 110:19 contained corporate 43:20 44:4 116:17 50:8,22 133:12,14 112:5,6,7,9 Consent 137:5 68:10 73:13 44:10,14,18 117:1,4,9 51:11 53:6 Councilma... 112:10,12 59:16,19 contents 75:10 76:22 44:24 45:8 117:13,16 53:8,11,14 27:13 30:6 113:12,13 60:9,18 135:7 Corporation 46:1,20 118:1,6,10 54:12,14,18 34:11 50:1 113:14,15 61:1 97:7,9 continual 51:22 48:12 49:11 118:13,22 54:19,24 Councilme... 113:22,23 97:11,13,17 41:1 117:22 107:13 49:19 50:5 119:3,7,10 55:1,3,7,8,9 25:13 27:10 114:10,11 106:19 continue 20:2 121:14 50:8,11,20 119:19,21 55:12 58:3 104:19 114:12,14 consequences 30:23 87:4 correct 137:8 50:23 51:2 120:1,5,8 58:4,7 Councilme...

Council President Clarke

114:15,17 48:14 93:6 corrects 51:5,8,11 120:15,21 59:12,15 2:16 7:5 115:8,11,13 consider continues 84:18 51:13 52:2 121:1,4,18 60:10,19,23 15:17 23:6 116:3,6,7 59:20 60:9 88:19 corrupt 73:13 52:11,19,20 121:20,24 96:20,21 53:20 57:15 120:14,16 60:18 70:7 continuing corruption 53:3,4,8,10 122:4,7,14 97:4 105:5 93:17 120:17 80:6 97:6 30:9 91:3 53:13,16,18 122:16,22 105:6,7,8,9 Councilpeo... 122:15,17 106:20,23 contract Corsovic 53:23 54:10 123:2,5,10 105:10,13 80:17 122:18 consideration 108:11 73:15 54:15,17,20 123:19 105:14,15 Councils 123:23 34:7 58:12 127:14,22 cosponsored 54:23 55:6 127:2,5 105:16,17 96:11 124:2 127:9 86:23 128:7,11,15 36:17 41:8 55:9,11 129:2,6 105:18,19 Councilwo... 129:4,5 considered 128:19,24 57:15 57:7,17 131:5,10,22 105:21,22 1:9,10,12 131:6,7,8 61:1 contrary cosponsorred 58:1,4,6 132:5,8 106:9,10,11 1:15,15,16 131:11 considering 94:13 12:5 59:7,11,18 133:2,13 106:12 2:12,22 132:1,6 61:9 contributions Cottman 99:9 60:6,8,13 135:14,21 107:18,19 6:23 7:4,8 133:4,18,19 consisted 9:8 67:4 127:24 Councible 60:16 61:8 135:24 108:18,19 7:11,14 135:15,17 consisting 8:7 control 85:14 61:19 62:2 136:2,6,9 111:11,12 11:14 12:10 135:19 9:16 137:18 Council 1:1,9 62:11,12,13 Councilman 111:13,14 15:15 19:22 Councilwo... consists 27:15 controlled 2:2,19 4:13 62:16 66:8 1:10,11,11 111:15,16 23:20 35:6 32:20 Consolidati... 70:10 4:15,16,17 70:15,19 1:12,13,13 111:19,20 35:8,12,19 counselors 45:4 Convention 5:4,10,13 74:8 77:21 1:14,14,16 111:21,22 35:20 36:2 54:3,3,8 consortium 102:5 5:22 6:5 7:7 79:2 85:8 1:17 4:23 111:23,24 36:3,14,15 country 73:8 conversation 7:13 11:15 85:14 88:3 5:17,18,24 112:1,3,4 36:21 37:10 12:14 37:4 constant 48:12 49:4 12:6,8 13:3 88:10,19 6:1 7:9,9,10 112:13,14 37:13,14,16 69:15 91:18 66:14 76:20 conveyance 14:18 15:2 89:9,11,18 8:5,10,12 112:15,16 38:24 44:12 126:6 constantly 34:13 50:3 15:3,4,5 91:6,12 8:14,16,20 113:16,17 44:13,19 129:12 94:10,11 convicted 20:8 21:15 92:2,21 8:22 9:1,14 113:18,19 45:9,10 County 96:12 constituting 129:19 21:19 22:16 93:3,9,12 9:21 10:5 113:20,21 49:12 52:13 107:8 100:18 convince 22:17,18,19 94:22 96:16 10:15,18,22 113:24 52:14,16,21 couple 46:15 constitution 48:22 23:20 24:5 97:3 104:14 15:8,13,14 114:1,2,3,4 53:15,16,19 92:9,12 88:23 89:3 convinced 24:8,9 106:14,15 15:14,15,16 114:5,6,8,9 53:24 57:11 123:20 Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 129:9 Curie 101:22 104:16 defending designating devote 54:6 district 24:14 donations Court 73:1 currently 111:4 113:9 75:8 51:21 Diapo 79:3 24:21 27:13 130:21 95:23 19:23 81:17 122:14 defense 75:21 107:11 difference 30:2,3,6,6 Donna's 137:12 86:19 124:5,21 75:22 76:1 121:12 28:4 31:5 34:11 50:1 56:17 courts 89:11 129:16 125:5 126:3 77:4 designations 63:8 133:10 50:19 51:16 door 19:1 Cousineau CURTIS 1:13 128:4,10 deferrals 40:3 42:9 different 51:20,22,24 Dr 94:14 9:18 customer de 18:4,11 46:23 55:15 97:22 14:10 24:4 52:1,6,10 127:12 cover 90:17 63:7 71:20 21:6 76:18 definitions 98:5,12 28:16 54:6 56:1 128:22 Covington 72:4 deal 16:23 104:2 99:6,14,21 104:16 56:15 66:5 drafting 85:1 8:8 customer's 25:22 124:3 dehumaniz...

Council President Clarke

100:3 difficult 83:5 73:10 107:6 87:19 CPP 28:5 63:4 133:8 130:11 designed dimension 107:11,12 135:11 CPR 17:5 customers dealing 16:22 Delaware 27:12,22 82:24 107:14 dream 19:16 create 64:1 63:2,13 65:6 40:7 55:17 96:2 direct 137:18 121:8,12,14 Drew 9:16 65:8 68:16 cut 26:13 deals 73:11 55:24 56:14 desk 134:23 direction 68:9 121:15,16 14:8 91:3 98:21 cuts 66:14 126:13 99:11 destroyed 102:17 123:22 drinking 134:13 cutting 56:6 dear 43:1 deliberately 80:4 directions 126:18 95:17 created 24:10 76:9 79:1 18:22 Destroying 59:2 127:7,13,20 Drive 102:7 27:7 48:5 D 118:20 delivered 25:10 directly 66:4 128:17 drowned 64:2 D 1:15 debate 97:12 33:17 destruction 67:5,11 131:15 126:23 creating daily 25:23 decades 124:19 76:24 80:8 96:9 districts due 78:6,22 10:11,24 33:4 79:18 delivers destructive Director 55:23 64:7 79:21 14:6 94:8 Dakota 63:15 December 33:15 75:10 98:20 64:9,12 100:10 creation 64:2,5 40:17 117:2 Delta 52:24 details 70:13 disabled diversified Duly 5:3 51:1 23:19,24 68:18,20 decided 71:20 53:3 122:10 detain 57:23 124:23 31:22 60:5 107:22 24:11,24 69:5,8,11 decision 68:5 122:13 determine disagree diversity 108:22 25:1 69:22 73:22 76:18 78:16 denial 90:12 70:16 82:12 31:20 77:11 110:1 70:18 82:23 76:19 77:14 decisions 81:4 denied 72:15 detriment disastrous divest 77:12 115:15 86:23 80:11 95:14 Decker 1:19 denotes 76:12 87:1 95:16 80:10 116:9 117:8 creations 95:15 96:10 33:19 34:24 dense 83:4 detrimental discriminat... divesting 118:5 119:2 14:10 damned 58:13 62:6 Department 82:2 72:3,12 78:13 119:24 creative 94:13 97:18 41:1 59:1 develop 70:20 73:6 division 8:7 120:20 11:11 13:14 dangers 104:15 117:22 developed discussing 9:7,16 10:9 121:23 43:24 63:18 107:2 108:9 departments 78:11 84:11 49:6 10:16 28:19 122:21 119:14 Danihel 109:8 113:3,6 developers discussion documentat... 135:23 creativity 88:12,15 110:14 deposit 63:2,4 81:19 82:7 86:14 dumped 7:22 10:6 DARRELL 111:6 63:6 development dispense 6:7 doing 16:17 79:17 10:23 1:9 112:22 depository 22:7,8 displaced 25:4 26:4 dumping credit 26:20 dates 100:10 113:11 70:11 46:15,18 126:8 69:5 73:16 79:21 26:20 63:6 daughter 115:3 Derek 1:11 48:5,16 dispose 34:9 74:6 duty 89:13 132:12 79:14 80:1 123:11 36:19 70:5 84:5,7 49:23 dollars 62:24 90:21 credits 100:9 DAVID 1:14 decree 88:16 Derrickson 109:16 disposition 64:12 dwindling Creek 40:7 day 6:10,14 dedicated 8:10 113:5 98:24 Domb 1:10 80:8 crime 129:19 6:15 12:14 27:16 28:12 descent 75:4 123:22 disregard 15:15 19:13 Dylan 15:10 criminal 66:2 32:16 36:12 dedication deserve 26:19 124:4 125:24 36:18 53:7 15:11 17:23 critical 47:7 40:22 46:14 32:1 41:1 26:22 48:2 125:15,20 disrespect 53:8,11,21 18:15 19:4 48:14 54:2 48:22 75:7 117:22 84:5 86:22 125:21 125:4 105:5,6 19:22,24 crowned 7:18 116:2 deed 90:10 deserves 126:13 disrespectful 111:11,12 20:11,15 crushed 117:20 deep 16:21 15:23 16:1 134:17 72:4 113:16,17 124:8 129:8,10,11 20:16 design 70:19 135:5 distant 69:3 132:7,8 E CSA 90:3 129:13,14 default 69:15 designate Devereaux distinguished donate 14:21 E 44:23 56:18 CTR 58:18 129:16,18 defects 79:19 59:2 99:7 44:3 119:16 133:7 137:1 curblines 130:4,10,15 defend 76:24 designated device 61:20 distribution donated ear 22:1 102:5 days 53:3 77:9 89:16 88:22 61:21 109:14 132:20 earlier 96:23 72:15 early 32:23 Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 Earned electric 104:2 90:24 environment evolve 94:11 extraordina... farmers 64:6 110:17,18 132:11 104:3,6,9 enforcement 66:6 68:12 evolved 24:11 90:14 farmers' feet 101:21 earth 75:7 104:11 32:21 57:21 78:20 96:3 exactly 14:17 extremely 103:18,20 101:23 79:13 93:24 element 3:8 57:24 environmen...

Council President Clarke

example 38:2 31:19 fastest 129:23 fell 18:24 ease 4:15,16 3:15 engage 68:10 68:1 78:9 126:16 father 15:9 fellow 93:16 15:3,4 Elementary 68:21 94:18 93:18 95:16 exceeds 82:18 F 17:22 18:4 felt 124:20 22:17,18 9:24 131:19 engagement environments excessively F 43:6 137:1 18:8 19:19 Fenerty 8:17 33:9,10 Eli 42:22 87:17 77:10 79:20 face 37:20 20:5,10 Ferry 78:4 east 11:12 118:17 engineering equal 38:1 excited 45:16 46:14 66:13 21:5,7,21 fervent 93:23 63:17 83:21 Elizabeth 7:23 20:3 equality excluded 66:16 89:24 79:23 Festival 85:23 86:4 94:14 English 79:3 38:13 94:1 100:15 faces 66:10 131:13 42:24 96:12 Ellis 76:9 engrossed equipment excuse 93:7 facilities father's 19:17 118:19 108:16 94:15 11:23 20:13 64:13 94:17 124:12 fathers 129:9 fewer 12:13 easterly email 46:6 29:17 equitable excused fact 6:12 favor 5:8 51:3 fiduciary 101:19 emergency enhanceme... 76:3 96:24 46:12 70:1 60:11 71:12 89:13 ebb 124:3 17:14 78:23 48:17,18 eradication execute 34:18 135:6 94:15 108:1 field 82:15,19 economic emissions enjoyed 27:19 41:17 failing 63:13 109:1 110:4 84:20 66:19,22 63:19 74:2 132:2 Erie 133:3,16 executives fairly 48:10 115:18 Fields 71:14 67:24 71:11 78:6 enjoying especially 4:4 69:4 Fairment 116:12 Fifth 126:19 107:15 Emma 8:7 132:3 37:17 exempt 41:20 117:11 fight 24:19 125:20 emotional enjoys 19:23 essentials 110:17,24 Fairmount 118:8 119:5 48:21 76:3 126:7 14:2 54:5 20:4 64:14 Exemptions 34:20 120:3 122:2 76:22 77:4 economy emotionally ensure 32:17 establish 46:22 fake 71:19 122:24 90:22 94:1 64:17,24 18:6 46:17 47:20 38:14 52:5 existence families 20:24 136:4 fighting Ed 15:11 employees enter 101:1,6 94:20 107:5 28:14 86:8 49:2 129:21 favorite 71:11 educates 18:5 31:4,24 130:9 121:7 existing 51:17 130:7,17 13:12,13,22 fights 77:6 educating 33:1 72:17 entire 27:24 established 52:7 121:9 132:15,22 14:4,9 filed 132:23 18:9 Empower 64:18 77:2 62:2 65:3 134:8,11 family 21:9 favors 120:23 film 42:24 education 67:22 entitled 45:3 103:7 exists 3:10,11 74:5 79:23 Fe 69:9,22 43:1 118:19 20:2 32:21 EMT 17:5 48:1 55:20 establishing expanding famous 7:19 fearful 47:9 118:19 95:2 en 18:19 55:22 56:3 44:20 51:15 26:20 54:7 9:8 fearing 48:16 final 35:18 educational enable 65:4 56:5,9,11 103:11 experience famously February 39:4 44:11 84:4 81:1 58:15,18,19 estate 107:7 32:5 72:22 76:18 17:24 18:13 50:14 51:9 effect 84:12 enables 74:6 58:22,24 Estelle experiences fan 11:2 20:12 52:12 53:5 effected 78:5 encompassi... 97:20 98:3 127:10 71:21 fan-powered Feby 15:10 58:2 59:9 effective 31:8 51:16 52:6 98:10,16,18 Estesa 75:1 exploiting 9:12 15:11 17:24 59:14,21 effectiveness 107:6 121:8 98:19 99:12 ethical 94:22 95:1 fantastic 26:5 18:15 19:22 60:22 61:3 27:23 encounter 99:19 100:1 European exploring far 66:3 20:11 61:15 97:14 efficiency 78:2 100:7,9,11 75:4 66:9 69:22 75:16 81:22 federal 29:7 106:24 27:23 encourages 100:13,17 evening 15:19 expressed Fargo 62:18 62:23 66:11 110:11 efficient 31:8 28:1 100:24 event 45:12 80:20 63:14,22 90:7 95:21 123:8 134:1 effort 33:2 encouraging 101:5,10,12 eventual 38:7 Expressway 65:20,22 96:1 134:4 efforts 29:2,5 8:1 95:10 101:16 everybody 55:17 66:2 68:6 Federation Finalists 7:19 94:5 encroachm... 102:1,8,12 15:20 23:8 Expressway... 71:18,21,23 127:22 finally 104:17 Egrede 74:17 104:4 102:16,20 23:11 25:24 98:8 72:18 73:13 128:5,23 111:5 74:20,21 encroachm... 103:1,6,10 evicted expropriati...

Council President Clarke

planter 39:15 101:18 6:23 7:15 53:23 54:10 131:22 products 136:1 129:11 platform 102:3 15:8 22:23 54:15,17,20 132:5,9 72:19 properties 131:18 81:21 108:13 87:13 54:23 55:4 133:3,13,20 professional 25:16,19 Philadelphi... play 54:3 portions 112:20 55:6,10,11 134:2 81:23 101:7 27:22 28:22 32:18 playing 19:24 83:21 102:4 115:1 57:7,14,17 135:12,14 profits 69:1 34:10,13 Philadelphi... 82:15,19 Portland presentation 58:1,5,6 135:20,24 73:3,4 45:7 47:17 32:3 66:4 84:20 69:21 15:21 59:7,15,17 136:6,9 74:14 49:24 50:3 75:18 85:11 plead 80:9 possible presentations 60:6,13,16 pride 7:15 profusely 51:17 52:7 88:6 93:16 please 2:14 35:23 48:11 86:14 60:24 61:8 22:8 119:1 17:12 121:9 Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 property 12:22 16:19 question 82:1 86:10 87:4 73:12 52:23 54:2 registered 21:17 30:15 25:21 40:12 31:3 40:12 104:16 RCOs 81:1,7 recipient 44:1 62:16 115:5 83:20 85:22 61:24 62:3 45:19,22 40:12,13 111:5 81:9,19,23 119:15 116:2 regressive remediating 46:23 47:9 61:10,12 113:10 84:6,24 reciprocal 117:18 37:21 26:1 47:15 48:4 65:8 66:9 questions 87:12,18 76:16 118:16 regular 6:8 remedy 88:18 72:13 88:20 66:17,20 71:1 84:15 134:9,11,14 Reclaim 120:10 60:21 97:14 89:1,22 89:4 90:13 67:5,8 68:3 quick 17:1,15 134:16 65:18 122:10 106:24 90:15 94:20 98:23 68:20 69:10 17:15 28:12 RDA 88:20 recognition recommend... regulating remember 110:19,22 70:2,5,13 78:21 reached 19:9 15:24 42:24 86:17 102:17 25:3,8 116:20 70:18,23 quickly 17:6 reactionary 118:18 reconstruct... regulation 128:15 124:14 74:13 88:21 Quinones-S... 37:20 recognize 64:10 44:21 103:7 remind 125:15 90:20 93:1 1:15 2:13 read 33:19 3:14 11:17 record 82:8 103:11 127:16 proposed 93:4,17 2:22 44:13 44:17 57:8 29:2 129:14 82:12 93:13 regulatory 134:22 86:20 87:1 94:20 96:18 45:9,10 58:13 60:10 131:18 97:4 134:10 96:1,9 reminded prosecute 116:20,21 57:16 106:2 78:21 79:7 recognized 134:15 Reinstate 94:10 90:9 116:21 106:3 112:8 97:8,9,16 35:22 44:16 recorded 97:1 58:16 reminder prospect 134:6 112:9 104:15 recognizes recording reinvests 64:6 130:15 134:7 137:12 114:13,14 107:2 109:8 2:9 4:22 110:18 reject 65:21 remnants protect 47:3,5 publicly 70:9 120:14,16 134:19 5:17,24 Recreation 96:13 24:3 76:23 94:24 70:9 120:17 reading 36:1 6:22 12:9 34:15 41:15 related 73:4 removal 96:2 publicly-ow... quite 16:16 58:14 59:9 15:7 21:16 red 62:1 78:23 82:23 28:12 59:4 protectors 68:17,18 quo 88:17 59:14,21 22:22 30:15 redevelopm...

Council President Clarke

system 69:14 57:1,5 slips 63:3 13:19 37:11 stance 93:20 stepmother 33:2 85:13 127:19 systems 70:22 101:15 small 63:21 61:22 stand 5:7 79:24 88:8 supervision 102:15 64:7,15 speakers 93:1 75:11,21 stepparents stronger 64:3 137:19 T sidewalks 87:2 speaks 79:2 131:21,22 100:14 64:3 Supplemen... T 137:1,1 46:4,10 smaller 45:20 special 135:21 steps 70:4 structure 100:18 table 61:17 Sidney 8:17 Smith 93:7 133:22 136:2 85:10 128:3 supplied 28:7 Tables 58:20 13:21,21 93:11,14,15 speeches standards Steve 36:21 struggle 38:1 supplies take 2:5 3:18 Sigma 52:24 social 53:1 123:13,14 45:6 58:21 stock 64:21 student 14:16 64:13 70:4 74:10 122:11 54:4 68:1 135:16 70:20 stood 134:6 14:20 supply 64:14 93:19 sign 12:3 93:18 spending standing stop 17:17 128:18 support 126:16 signed 12:5 122:12 129:16 12:23 31:1 19:5 76:19 students 7:1 32:21 46:22 taken 6:9 48:23 137:6 Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 takes 72:8 teams 9:7 20:19 21:13 127:1,2,5 79:14 83:23 86:5 111:2 turn 37:22 91:2 14:12 28:11 22:14,16,19 129:1,2,5 thrilled 13:2 91:15,15,24 transferred turns 61:21 talk 73:23 28:12 23:11 27:2 131:4,5,8 thriving 94:7 96:18 34:12 50:2 61:23,24 132:9 technical 30:11,11,16 132:4,5,6,8 Thursday 1:6 123:12,24 transfers TV 16:7 26:8 talked 45:16 50:17 56:13 30:19 31:24 133:11,11 4:21 5:2,6 127:17 100:14 two 3:4,18 4:8 123:23,24 133:23 32:24 33:6 133:13,17 18:13 131:13 112:24 16:3,11,24 132:10 technology 33:11,12 133:19,22 135:22 today's 50:16 transform 20:5,20 134:7 7:23 35:2,11,20 135:12,13 136:2 50:24 97:6 94:5 21:22 22:2 talking 6:21 Tejano 77:24 36:2,3,15 135:14,20 tide 126:23 told 17:13 Transform... 32:7 39:21 45:13 71:22 television 37:14,15 135:24 tides 126:22 22:5 72:1 24:1 27:9 41:7,7 Tanksley 40:14 38:24 39:2 136:10 time 3:18 6:7 82:14 126:3 32:14 44:16 70:7 85:17,20,21 116:23 39:8,11,20 thanks 5:22 6:10,19,22 135:10 transforming 78:11 91:14 Taubenber... tell 15:22 39:23 41:6 6:5 30:21 13:5,7 15:7 tolerate 66:1 32:16 104:16 1:17 15:16 21:7 42:2 41:11 42:4 theft 90:10 22:9,21 Tom 23:2 transportat... S 130:1 48:2 64:17 64:11 59:17 60:6 20:23 77:1 104:10 Tourism treaties 95:21 Ultimate 10:6 65:2 100:16 tenure 30:1 60:23 61:8 91:14 124:2,15 50:19 treatment 10:22 107:7 term 28:15 62:4,12 think 3:24 125:11 Tournament 72:3,12 ultimately 110:24 68:16 65:13 67:13 8:2 22:2 times 24:6 9:5 10:7 Treaty 95:22 63:23 111:2 terms 34:21 68:7 70:24 26:11,17,18 37:19 38:21 tourniquet Tree 34:18 unallowable 132:11 59:6 104:12 71:3 75:13 91:16 94:9 130:2 17:8 trees 26:16 63:13 taxable 107:6 territories 77:15 78:13 130:10,13 tired 134:21 Tower 42:14 Treetop uncompro... taxation 45:7 38:8 76:14 80:12,17 132:13 tires 56:7 Township 41:18 94:3 taxes 45:22 95:24 96:8 83:11 84:22 thinking title 12:13 86:2 tremendous uncompro... 100:13 territory 76:1 85:3,14 13:13 69:20 45:3 55:19 toxic 74:1 81:21 94:2 taxi 9:10 testify 62:4 87:16,22 Thirty-Fou... 56:2 97:8,9 78:6 79:16 trial 89:19 undercover taxpayers 71:12 78:22 88:10 92:1 102:6 98:17 trade 13:23 Tribe 76:10 26:8,9,13 96:6 126:7 134:6 92:2,3,15 thirty-six 100:12 tradition 18:7 95:9 undermine 132:23 testifying 92:15,17,20 101:23 107:2 109:8 traditional trick 3:20,22 67:3 teach 97:9 61:14 62:14 92:21 93:3 Thompson 109:11,12 128:2 tricks 3:21 understand teacher 10:1 testimony 93:23 96:14 102:19 titles 97:16 traffic 102:18 Trine 93:14 23:18 80:24 128:14 71:13 80:21 96:16,21 thought today 2:12 train-of-tho... trip 13:1 83:5 87:3 teachers 92:22 94:14 97:3,4 86:13 5:21 17:19 11:2 truck 44:21 93:21 64:12 96:17 127:8 104:14 124:18 17:22 21:23 trans 32:11 103:7,11 125:19 127:14,23 127:12 107:19 134:2 23:10 24:4 transaction true 48:3 understand... 128:1,5,8 thank 2:6,17 108:19 thoughts 4:14 31:2 32:4 100:15 truly 28:24 82:4 128:11,13 2:21 4:13 109:19 threats 66:11 38:2 39:21 transactions 29:8 31:4 understated 128:23 4:17,23 5:4 115:13 66:14,16 47:4 50:15 111:1 31:21 63:3 63:5 team 8:3,7 5:18 6:1,9 116:7 three 25:18 53:12 55:10 transcript truth 3:13,16 unemploym...

Council President Clarke

9:16 10:9 6:17,21 118:24 32:8 38:9 58:10 61:4 137:8,16 94:3,4 69:14 10:16 11:18 7:11,13 120:17 62:4,22 61:10 62:14 transfer try 3:24 unfortunat... 12:1 19:20 12:11,15 121:20 72:1 86:12 66:7 67:21 90:11 95:20 125:23 134:5 23:12,13 13:10 14:24 122:18 133:1 135:2 70:4 71:12 100:16 126:17 unidentified 25:23 30:18 15:2,5,6 123:10,17 three-year-... 78:24 79:8 110:24 trying 9:9 18:20 union 124:11 Stated Meeting May 11, 2017 127:15 various 75:5 walking 11:4 26:23 whacking working 11:1 year 11:7 90:3 uniquely 102:22 16:14,15 weed 26:14 26:14 26:2,4 12:24,24 1,349 128:10 66:18 103:3 Wall 65:7 week 37:7 Whitman 28:17,19 23:16 27:5 1:01 136:12 United 11:9 vehicle 58:21 94:17,18 50:18 54:16 12:18 29:7 30:23 27:20 28:6 10 40:17 19:15 38:10 104:2,3,6,9 Walnut 42:12 88:19 129:7 wholly 34:19 32:5 47:3 29:15 30:22 117:2 74:24 104:11 42:13 129:7 134:1 wholly-own... 2 132:24 8th 9:17,18 88:13 170449 61:5 36:11 40:21 400 1:5 9:19,22,23 110:14 88:13 108:9 44:1 94:16 42 89:4,24 97:24 170264 60:2 109:7 113:1 116:2 90:12 102:12 18 36:11 117:19 4300 133:5 9 170265 59:24 95:17 119:15 43rd 103:21 9-200 103:15 99:4 109:12 135:22 44 75:3 9-213 103:17 170281 60:3 116:2 136:3 4400-4500 9th 56:22 102:16 135:22 20th 99:23 44:22 97:24 170283 60:3 136:3 215 71:10 45 3:1 102:20 1818 39:16 74:23 4th 57:6 170284 60:3 1868 95:22 130:20 103:1 19 100:12 21st 75:17 5 170286 60:3 19-1400 2246 108:15 5 34:2 75:4 103:6 110:23 22nd 99:24 76:12 170289 58:22 19-1703 23 90:13 500 28:6 2381 90:2 5021-23 36:6

Permits on this parcel