civus
Hearing video

ZBA Hearing - August 19, 2025

Philadelphia Zoning Board of Adjustment (ZBA)Aug 19, 20252h 38m

was renovated if it were if it was approved yes this is this is what it will look like when it's

Similar wording

renovated there were some other renderings though i believe that you had could you show those to the

Similar wording

board oh the before pictures you couldn't see them no no the there was some some drawings that

Similar wording

were done to show what the space would look like once it was all you know decorated and ready for

Similar wording

people to come in okay let me can you see this yes okay this is what it would

Similar wording

look like complete and could you talk about entrances and exits for us yes

Similar wording

there's if we can't see it back there all the way back where the stage is on

Similar wording

the right hand side would be an emergency exit door can you pull up any

Similar wording

of where the bathrooms would be that's a different part and then to the to the last row of seats

Similar wording

there would be an entrance door all from cedar street side

Similar wording

how many seats do you have there how many seats are in there yeah i'm this is just a drawing but

Similar wording

probably 50 50 or 60 seats right okay anything else you want to tell us about your update did

Similar wording

you go back to this to the rco can you go back to it did the rc the rco changed their vote

Similar wording

they're now in favor of it okay tell us tell us what happened there i honestly don't know when

Similar wording

when we went to the meeting with the neighborhood it was voted against right we came in front of the

Similar wording

board a few months ago and we went over everything explained everything it sound good and then the

Similar wording

board just said they would like pictures of what the inside would look like completed

Similar wording

so all we did was we went on the computer and computerized those

Similar wording

images of what it would look like to present to you guys

Similar wording

And did you see the provisos they've requested of you?

Similar wording

No.

Similar wording

Three-year temporary variance, hours of operation.

Similar wording

Three years temporary?

Similar wording

Temporary variance for three years, they said.

Similar wording

Hours of operation Sunday to Thursday.

Similar wording

Events end by 8 p.m.

Similar wording

Friday and Saturday events end at 11 p.m.

Similar wording

Okay. I mean, that would be good.

Similar wording

i don't have anything against doing that okay questions from the board

Similar wording

excuse me i quite we have a board's going to ask you some questions oh okay

Similar wording

i'll also say so do you have exterior photos of those um uh exits and entryways that you talked

Similar wording

about on the uh rendering not at this time i thought that was something that the board was

Similar wording

asking for like the actual photos of the exits and entry to the building we don't we don't have the

Similar wording

uh pictures of entrances and exits because there's only one exit in there as of now until zoning

Similar wording

approves us then we have to get a building permit to put another entrance in okay so do you have an

Similar wording

actual picture of where that that one exit is so that we can and maybe you can give us direction

Similar wording

that one exit is so that we can and maybe you can give us directional

Similar wording

guidance as to where you want to put the other egress i thought i saw outside there was a two

Similar wording

doors what was that oh no that was a that was the other side of the building we have a bunch of

Similar wording

pictures now if you if you look on this picture down at the two bathrooms there's a wall

Similar wording

there's a door to the left that actually an exterior picture of the door that's what i'm

Similar wording

saying do you have an exterior picture of the door to build an outside just take a picture

Similar wording

of where someone would yeah i have it from cedar street right yeah

Similar wording

that's that's far the corner that's fine is that it yeah yes

Similar wording

and then the other door you said you're going to have to cut into the wall

Similar wording

yes we'd have to cut a door in

Similar wording

and that's the right of the stage am I correct yes

Similar wording

any other questions and that and that that door Lee will lead to uh what uh cedar street

Similar wording

The pavement on Cedar Street. Both doors, the existing door, leads to Cedar Street, and the door that we will install will lead to Cedar Street.

Similar wording

The one that's there would basically become an emergency exit, and the new one we install would be a double door for the main entrance.

Similar wording

What are your proposed hours of operation? How many days a week do you plan to operate?

Similar wording

I mean, I would like to make it seven days a week, but depending on the venue.

Similar wording

Here's the proviso.

Similar wording

Sunday to Thursday, events end by 8 p.m.

Similar wording

Friday and Saturday, events end at 11 p.m.

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

Thank you.

Similar wording

Other questions?

Similar wording

I guess my question is, so people are just going to come in,

Similar wording

they're going to see the show and then they're going to leave is that it you're not serving food

Similar wording

you're not having um beverages you're not this is just a venue for people to come and see

Similar wording

whatever entertainment you're offering is that what's going to go on here and is that what you

Similar wording

told the community i'm i'm sorry but i could barely hear anything you're saying i said is this just a

Similar wording

venue where people come in they're going to see whatever entertainment that you're offering and

Similar wording

they're going to leave you're not offering food you're not offering beverages you are just this

Similar wording

entertainment yes okay your rendering shows a concession consists concession would be for like

Similar wording

not non-alcoholic drinks so it is drinks nothing alcoholic though we're not applying for a liquor

Similar wording

license my my my question didn't mention liquor my i asked you who are you going to be offering

Similar wording

um food and beverages okay as part of this oh yes just snacks okay all right and uh

Similar wording

how many how many people is this that you say you're gonna have in here you you you really don't

Similar wording

no is that is that what you're saying no i i would have to get a law for occupancy which

Similar wording

i can't obtain either until this is either approved or i don't know what the law for

Similar wording

occupancy would be for their they go by a square footage right what's the square footage of your

Similar wording

space it's roughly 5 000 square feet 5 000 square feet and depending on the size of your stage i

Similar wording

if you got fixed seats or non-fixed seats you're over 300 people that can technically be allowed

Similar wording

in this space it's just just a quick rule of thumb right so i don't have no i no plans on

Similar wording

having 300 people to me at 300 people being in there seeing how it's going to be set up

Similar wording

would really be way too many people have you have you run anything like this before

Similar wording

What's your background? What's your experience with running an establishment like this?

Similar wording

Well, I manage four buildings for the same person that owns this building.

Similar wording

So in our buildings, we have event halls. We have a gym. We had a boxing gym.

Similar wording

And the other one, we have a, if you ever heard of stateside, Vaca, they're in one of our buildings.

Similar wording

and the other one we have

Similar wording

a

Similar wording

if you ever heard a state

Similar wording

Okay.

Similar wording

So your experience is in managing properties where there are events and things.

Similar wording

Yes.

Similar wording

Is that, okay.

Similar wording

and so does that include the scheduling the you know the advertising the all of that that goes

Similar wording

along with this yes sometimes sometimes it involves that okay all right and then of course

Similar wording

my question is always about um fire and safety so what are your plans for um the hardwired

Similar wording

smoke detection well the building this building's already hardwired in we're monitored by

Similar wording

who is that alert one we're monitored by alert one we have a sprinkler system in the the entire

Similar wording

building and it is zoned okay and you have that but at as of this point you don't have the two

Similar wording

means of ingress and egress right now we only have one if it's approved we'll install the other one

Similar wording

And then Alert 1 is on board to come put pull stations in any new doorways or any entrances or exits.

Similar wording

Any emergency lighting?

Similar wording

They have to add all that.

Similar wording

Right now, this is basically a warehouse.

Similar wording

So you don't have to have as much if we change the zoning to what we want.

Similar wording

Obviously, we're going to have to add some fire things, pull stations.

Similar wording

but the sprinkler system is already in the building the only thing we would have to add

Similar wording

that i was told is when we turn in our plans to redo the area we'd have to be up the code with

Similar wording

pull stations strobe lights things like that but again we are already monitored the entire building

Similar wording

by alert one who monitors the system for the whole building if there's a low pressure if

Similar wording

anything goes off if there's a fire alarm they alert me and i come right down all right thank

Similar wording

you thank you questions from the board questions or comments from our attorney hillary emerson

Similar wording

not at this time mr chair questions or comments from their virtual audience

Similar wording

i see no gains at this time chairman planning commission good morning chairman david effecto

Similar wording

f-e-c-t-e-a-u with the city planning commission do you swear or affirm to tell the truth the

Similar wording

whole truth and nothing but the truth yes sir i do please proceed thank you sir thank you sir

Similar wording

chairman and board members the comprehensive plan recommends a change in zoning at this location

Similar wording

from i2 general industry to icmx industrial and commercial mixed use assembly and entertainment

Similar wording

would be allowed in the proposed icmx zoning the city planning commission recommends the board

Similar wording

grant a proposed use variance for assembly and entertainment thank you mi 2025 0004 2848 chatham

Similar wording

street i vote yes with the following proviso three-year temporary variance that would expire

Similar wording

8 20 28 hours of operation sunday to thursday events end by 8 pm friday to saturday events end

Similar wording

at 3 11 pm also use limited to area 3 and a certificate of occupancy to be obtained

Similar wording

michael johns my vote is yes with provisos cheryl gaston my vote is no

Similar wording

tennetta graham my vote is yes with provisos

Similar wording

brian mcadams my vote is yes with provisos thank you sir

Similar wording

we're going to go to number one mi 2204 002 293 6201 north 15th street

Similar wording

jermaine harris is the attorney this is a resumptive hearing

Similar wording

Jermaine Harris will be rejoining

Similar wording

as a panelist.

Similar wording

mr harris yes good morning good morning sir yes good morning here you go please stay

Similar wording

yes good morning good morning sir yes good morning there you go please state your name and spell

Similar wording

for this yeah sure jermaine harris and i am uh counsel for appellant russian basely uh my name

Similar wording

is spelled j-e-r-m-a-i-n-e h-a-r-r-i-s do you swear or firm to tell the truth the whole truth

Similar wording

nothing but the truth i do so mr harris we're going to this is a resumptive hearing and it is

Similar wording

there'll be a presentation by you of updated information yes questions from the board

Similar wording

will be public testimony or updated information only and and planning commission will make a

Similar wording

recommendation my my remembrance of this case is that uh the rco was not in favor and no the rco

Similar wording

was in favor it was in favor yes how about the council person the council person uh was not in

Similar wording

favor okay the rco was in favor okay um please proceed with your update sure let me share my

Similar wording

screen can i can i go back james harvey committee person in the 17th ward testified in opposition

Similar wording

is that correct? I don't know what his I don't know what his position I don't know what his

Similar wording

position was but we had a community meeting uh all right we had a community meeting with who

Similar wording

who was this hold on so why don't you start your why don't you give us the whole update of where

Similar wording

you stand with this? Yeah, sure. Yeah, we had a community meeting with Oak Lane Worcester and

Similar wording

Community Coalition, and that was on January 28th, and there was support for this project.

Similar wording

And if you may recall, this is requesting for a variance for the use of property at 6201

Similar wording

north uh 15th street uh for a daycare it's on the first floor uh also concurrent with the approval

Similar wording

my client got a petition signatures of 50 uh of 50 signatures of nearby neighbors which was also

Similar wording

uh submitted and is also attached here but let's go back to the project itself so

Similar wording

my client is the tenant of the owner and she wishes to use this property uh for daycare this

Similar wording

is a posting of the today's resumptive hearing this is the least evidencing that

Similar wording

and this is the photo of what the front would be this has the gate of it but this is the front of

Similar wording

the building there's another vantage picture of the front this is another picture of the front

Similar wording

a different angle. This is the side of the building. This is the side of the building.

Similar wording

Another picture of the front. This is the driveway which would be used for people when

Similar wording

they would be dropping off uh for dropping off the children this is a backyard and then this is

Similar wording

the interior now the interior it's actually two separate playrooms so to speak we're talking

Similar wording

about 2 000 square feet and so we have

Similar wording

one open area right here which is open area one we'll call it open area one that's where you walk

Similar wording

in through the main door the main double doors that we uh just saw pictures of from the street

Similar wording

so you walk in and this is the area right here and that's where the larger uh that's where the

Similar wording

larger children would be at and then we have exiting from there we have a smaller room

Similar wording

which is uh right here which is behind that the larger room is 879 square feet

Similar wording

The larger room is 879 square feet.

Similar wording

The smaller room, which is for the smaller children, is 608 square feet.

Similar wording

Now, this building, it does have, although it has a capacity of 49 people, my client doesn't plan on having that many people there.

Similar wording

I believe, and she can testify to this, but I believe that she was talking about 20, but ultimately the state is going to make a determination as to what would be acceptable to them based on the accommodations and the square footage of this.

Similar wording

there's also fire alarm system with this uh as reflected on the as reflected on the plan

Similar wording

the plans here again it's about 2 000 square feet that we're talking about

Similar wording

this is the larger of the interior room this is the smaller this is the smaller room

Similar wording

Minus the furniture, of course. So, this is a hallway.

Similar wording

and again we have uh we have the art we have the rco the summary meeting the meeting summary

Similar wording

from oak lane which evidence is that this was take uh that this community meeting took place

Similar wording

on january 27th and there was support along with the signatures i know uh also there's tax

Similar wording

clearance also of this and then this is the notice of refusal would have the I would have

Similar wording

the board know that this space has been used for years as a commercial space it has it was used

Similar wording

first as a looks like a pharmacy then it was used as a plumbing heating office back in 1980

Similar wording

uh looks like a ladies looks like a clothing store back in 87 so what we are asking for

Similar wording

is we are asking for this variance to be approved and we would open it up for any questions

Similar wording

that this board may have

Similar wording

do you want to have your testimony adopted sure uh may i have uh miss rashaun bailey could you

Similar wording

please raise your hand so you can be promoted as a panelist

Similar wording

rashaun basically has been promoted to panelist

Similar wording

okay miss basely can you hear me yes hi okay wait wait wait wait one minute

Similar wording

hi please state your name is spelled for the stenographer yes my name is rashaun basely my

Similar wording

the spelling of it is r-a-s-h-i-a-n last name b-a-s-l-e-y you swear or affirm to tell the

Similar wording

truth the whole truth nothing but the truth yes please proceed counsel okay so miss basely did

Similar wording

you hear the testimony that i gave to the board for the past 10 minutes yes okay and

Similar wording

do you agree with the testimony that i have given to the board yes and you don't necessarily have

Similar wording

to but is there anything you would like to add to the testimony that I've given to the that I've

Similar wording

given to this board no not at this time okay and so we would have open it up for any questions if

Similar wording

anyone has regarding this particular project questions from the board uh yes um at the last

Similar wording

hearing here I had asked about the rear area here is that where the children will be

Similar wording

entering or playing there's an adjacent business from what I understand maybe oh okay so through

Similar wording

the back entrance we will not be playing back there but you we will allow if we need to far

Similar wording

as the parking in that area you will be able to come through the front and also through the back

Similar wording

for drop off and pick up we're going to have indoor play for the children it won't be outside

Similar wording

All right. And we, I think the concern was, again, a better idea of the exterior area here.

Similar wording

all right and uh we

Similar wording

Now you've shown the front, but the back is where, where will the children be entering?

Similar wording

Through the front door. Through the front door. Yes.

Similar wording

ones with the pull down yes correct okay and there's a door there and there's windows yes

Similar wording

it's a door there and there's two large windows right there actually three i'm sorry three large

Similar wording